Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
totino · 07/10/2026 16:03

Ok chipping in as another trans-inclusive feminist who usually stays out of this, it's not true that women's oppression is or was entirely centered on biosex. They used to say women shouldn't read books because their tiny little brains get overstimulated. They said women shouldn't ride bikes because their wombs would bounce around. They say women can't be world leaders because their hormones make them emotional. None of this has anything to do with how the body works. That's not biology, it's "biology".

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:59

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:56

Okay, I think the dominant oppressive concept of "woman" sprang from man brain.

I never said it had nothing to do with biological sex at all in origin. Women's bodies, and their differnces from men particularly, were the excuse. Pregnancy, periods, being physically smaller on average: all of that got used to justify keeping women out of work, money and power. But the oppression itself didn't come from biology, it came from what patriarchy decided that biology meant.

That’s semantics. At base, it came from the fact that biologically men and women are different. We basically agree here, just because people don’t lionise the concept of “gender” and think it’s basically dependent on sex, doesn’t mean they support the patriarchal system.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:59

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:57

Can you link this group? I could do with a laugh. I’m also intrigued by their definition of “GC” which I suspect isn’t that simple.

I bet they're a right laugh

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:57

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 15:26

So they deny you are a feminist by calling you a Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist (TERF)? Sounds likely.

It doesnt matter who wants to try and deny it, trans inclusionary and exclusionary feminism are legitimate models of feminism. That's just a fact. Either side that deny that just look stupid and it is why nobody with serious credentials will ever listen to you.

There's a GC group on Facebook who talk about the anti intellectualism in here and how it hurts their cause. They don't want any association with MN or the staff here because they say it's all AI bots and questionable men.

Can you link this group? I could do with a laugh. I’m also intrigued by their definition of “GC” which I suspect isn’t that simple.

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:56

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:27

Can you answer the question? How is it not to do with biology? Gender is just a framework for biological sex, no? What else is it for?

Okay, I think the dominant oppressive concept of "woman" sprang from man brain.

I never said it had nothing to do with biological sex at all in origin. Women's bodies, and their differnces from men particularly, were the excuse. Pregnancy, periods, being physically smaller on average: all of that got used to justify keeping women out of work, money and power. But the oppression itself didn't come from biology, it came from what patriarchy decided that biology meant.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 15:55

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 13:42

Of course you don't think it's a good analogy, because that would make you a bigot.

Bigotry is bigotry. There are plenty of people who think their bigotry isn't bigotry because they can't possible be bigots - after all, they support other people's rights. Carving out an exception for their own brand of hatred inevitably leads to unpleasant alliances. Just think of who your allies are, the far-right, Trump Republicans and Christian fundamentalists. They absolutely can't get enough of gender critical patsies.

It is possible for very bad people to have some correct views. Hitler and I both supported a ban on fox hunting with hounds. I don't support invading other countries or people I don't like.

There are plenty of people who think their bigotry isn't bigotry because they can't possible be bigots - after all, they support other people's rights.

Oh the delicious irony in a discussion about feminists supporting male trans people's rights.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 15:45

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:17

Gender has EVERYTHING to do with feminism, what are you on about?

If the patriarchy hadn't created gendered roles, biases and stereotypes in the first place, there'd be no need for feminism. Women weren't kept out of work, politics and money because of their chromosomes, they were kept out because of what society decided women were for. That's gender.

But at the time that happened that "gender"was entirely synonymous with "sex". The gender differences were based on sex. Feminism is about sex, not gender, otherwise it includes all men who have adopted a female gendered presentation and of course it doesn't because they are men.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:42

Hehheh!!!
I love that stripy jacket

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 15:38

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:31

Posts like this amuse me so much. "Somebody said they didn't like you"
I couldn't care less if it hurts their cause, whatever that might be. I don't even know who they are.

I was a particular fan of "A group on Facebook" says.

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?
TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 15:37

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:36

I’m amusing myself by ordering my list of whose opinion I care about least as offered on this thread. A random Facebook group who hate read MN has to be near the top, but it’s a crowded field, in this Ambassador’s reception of a thread.

This thread has been 100% worth it for ‘ham is sociological kale’.

A little touch of genius there

😂

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:36

I’m amusing myself by ordering my list of whose opinion I care about least as offered on this thread. A random Facebook group who hate read MN has to be near the top, but it’s a crowded field, in this Ambassador’s reception of a thread.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 15:36

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 12:09

Most feminists are trans-inclusive, apart from a small group of almost universally white privileged people with a disproportionate influence. They align with neo-cons, incels and Christian nationalists in their obsessive hatred of transgender people.

The shift in language from anti-trans to pro-women, and from trans-exclusionary to sex-based rights is straight from the old-school bigotry used against black people and gay people forever.

www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09589236.2025.2468805#abstract

Just a teeny weeny bit ignorant, that post.

Disproportionate influence? The women who don't want men in their changing rooms?

😂🤣😂🤣😂

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:34

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 15:33

I mean some randomers on Facebook?

Who cares? 😂😂😂

But we are supposed to be A HIVE MIND and agree on everything

You lot are really letting the side down

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 15:33

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:31

Posts like this amuse me so much. "Somebody said they didn't like you"
I couldn't care less if it hurts their cause, whatever that might be. I don't even know who they are.

I mean some randomers on Facebook?

Who cares? 😂😂😂

CreativeGreen · 07/10/2026 15:32

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 15:26

So they deny you are a feminist by calling you a Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist (TERF)? Sounds likely.

It doesnt matter who wants to try and deny it, trans inclusionary and exclusionary feminism are legitimate models of feminism. That's just a fact. Either side that deny that just look stupid and it is why nobody with serious credentials will ever listen to you.

There's a GC group on Facebook who talk about the anti intellectualism in here and how it hurts their cause. They don't want any association with MN or the staff here because they say it's all AI bots and questionable men.

Oh no, not a Facebook group that doesn't agree with me! Whatever shall I do!

I think you're aiming for sarcasm there but I've seen a very recent example of the line 'TERFs aren't feminists' from an 'academic'.

You don't know my 'credentials' but I will say that in an argument where I was trying to position myself as one familiar with academic discourse, its rules and its tone, I wouldn't use phrases like 'that's just a fact' about something which is eminently open to question.

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 15:32

Gender is applied differently to men and women.

A man cannot opt into women's gender and claim oppression. Being able to jump in and out of gender isnt how gender works for women.

A women might not get a promotion because her employer thinks she will have a child and become a carer and lose focus at work. A man might get the promotion after having a child because he is now seen a breadwinner and provider. She is seen as less reliable, him more.

It doesnt matter if they both wear suits or summer dresses.

How can a man opt into women's gender in this scenario?

If gender was really about the superficial things we can change - like clothes and make up and the size of breasts, women would have become men years ago.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:31

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 15:26

So they deny you are a feminist by calling you a Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist (TERF)? Sounds likely.

It doesnt matter who wants to try and deny it, trans inclusionary and exclusionary feminism are legitimate models of feminism. That's just a fact. Either side that deny that just look stupid and it is why nobody with serious credentials will ever listen to you.

There's a GC group on Facebook who talk about the anti intellectualism in here and how it hurts their cause. They don't want any association with MN or the staff here because they say it's all AI bots and questionable men.

Posts like this amuse me so much. "Somebody said they didn't like you"
I couldn't care less if it hurts their cause, whatever that might be. I don't even know who they are.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:27

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:25

I was arguing against the assertion that it doesn't have anthing to to with gender, which is factually incorrect and remains so. Don't be so patronising

Can you answer the question? How is it not to do with biology? Gender is just a framework for biological sex, no? What else is it for?

StandingDeskDisco · 07/10/2026 15:27

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 13:42

Of course you don't think it's a good analogy, because that would make you a bigot.

Bigotry is bigotry. There are plenty of people who think their bigotry isn't bigotry because they can't possible be bigots - after all, they support other people's rights. Carving out an exception for their own brand of hatred inevitably leads to unpleasant alliances. Just think of who your allies are, the far-right, Trump Republicans and Christian fundamentalists. They absolutely can't get enough of gender critical patsies.

I am an atheist Marxist.
TWAM.
Hope that helps.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 15:26

So they deny you are a feminist by calling you a Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist (TERF)? Sounds likely.

It doesnt matter who wants to try and deny it, trans inclusionary and exclusionary feminism are legitimate models of feminism. That's just a fact. Either side that deny that just look stupid and it is why nobody with serious credentials will ever listen to you.

There's a GC group on Facebook who talk about the anti intellectualism in here and how it hurts their cause. They don't want any association with MN or the staff here because they say it's all AI bots and questionable men.

Naunet · 07/10/2026 15:25

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:17

Gender has EVERYTHING to do with feminism, what are you on about?

If the patriarchy hadn't created gendered roles, biases and stereotypes in the first place, there'd be no need for feminism. Women weren't kept out of work, politics and money because of their chromosomes, they were kept out because of what society decided women were for. That's gender.

Women weren't kept out of work, politics and money because of their chromosomes

And how did they know which humans the women were? Was it based on who wore dresses? Who had long hair? No, it was based on biology, gender was just the weapon they used to oppress us with

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 15:25

A boy without a winkle is a girl, @solerolover

(Nursie on Blackadder, should any TRAs think I'm being serious)

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 15:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 15:20

But it was, essentially, based on their biological sex ie their chromosomes. Or do you think the concept of “woman” sprang fully formed from the lady brain?

I was arguing against the assertion that it doesn't have anthing to to with gender, which is factually incorrect and remains so. Don't be so patronising

solerolover · 07/10/2026 15:21

I also don't understand the cowardly framing of "trans women are women, but only sometimes", that some so-called feminists indulge in either. For example, I think the argument that only male people who have had their penises inverted to create a facsimile of a vulva, should be allowed to be in spaces where women and girls are in a state of undress or performing private bodily functions, is absolutely illogical, and the more I think about it, actually insane, because women are not dickless men! Should a male person who has lost his penis through injury or illness be allowed to enter female only spaces? Why or why not? Why should access to female spaces be predicated upon the thoughts of a male person, simply because he declares himself to be a woman?

Naunet · 07/10/2026 15:20

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 14:48

Are there any situations whatsoever, where you believe a transwoman shouldnt be treated as women? For example, if a rape victim requested a female nurse or doctor for an intimate examination, because she has PTSD, would you be happy to send a transwoman to perform this?
Or if a man rapes a woman and then before hes sent to prison, claims hes trans, would you put him in a womans prison?

At what point does the man become a woman, in your mind? As soon as he says it?