Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 18:44

Summary of arguments for the existence of “trans inclusive feminism” so far:

Some dubious postmodernist academics say it’s a thing

trans women are women and because of that they’re not any threat to women at all, that’s men

”gender” is the root of women’s oppression, not “biosex”

some people on Facebook don’t like mumsnet

you’re bigots, so there

Shon Faye says so too

the patriarchy is the root of oppression and it has nothing to do with sex

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 18:38

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:29

Huh?
Saying it requires feminism does not = it’s women who need to do the advocacy

So who would be doing the advocacy then? If it’s men, why would they need feminism? They’re big boys ,they can do it themselves

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 18:38

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

Nice soundbite, except (1) it is hurting someone else and (2) TW are men, it's the main prerequisite for being one

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 18:37

Do people really only give this five seconds’ thought? What is a “trans woman”, how are they like a woman and how are they different to a man, exactly?

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 18:31

Can men stop being a threat by identifying as women?

Is the assumption that something in the process of identifying stops any threat

Or that no man who is a threat would identify as a woman?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 18:29

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

It’s entirely my business that naive, thoughtless women are telling entitled men that women will be ok with them in our spaces, hope that helps.

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:29

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 18:09

So where are the men’s groups advocating for Women’s mental health? Or is it just women that are supposed to advocate for men?

Huh?
Saying it requires feminism does not = it’s women who need to do the advocacy

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 18:26

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

In what sense aren’t transwomen men?

xye · 07/10/2026 18:25

@raisinglittlepeople12 “The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.”

Trans women are men, so they are definitely a threat to women.

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 18:22

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 17:47

I think any group of people can be a feminist group, provided nothing they fight for or work towards diminishes the rights or equality of women.

I don't see why men can't be feminists working alongside women to improve women's rights and equality.

The male only group would set their agenda and work towards their goals.

But how is that feminism? When is a male only group who decide what women need and how it is to be achieved, feminism and when it is the patriarchy?

'Trans inclusion' has been designed by such groups, hasnt it?

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 18:14

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

But “transwomen” are men. The only criteria to be. TW is to be a man first. So yes, the threat to women has always been men, even those claiming to be women. You are right.

solerolover · 07/10/2026 18:13

@Naunet

Sounds like a set of privilaged, luxury beliefs to me.

Absolutely, I couldn't have put it better myself.

The refusal to acknowledge the physical and social reality of the female half of the planet, to divorce that from womanhood, and state that, no actually, womanhood is contained in the minds of male people, the historical oppressor class of female people, in the form of some metaphysical concept known as a "gender identity" and you want to call that feminism?😳Maybe it's because my family are from a global South nation, so-called feminists who champion this ideology are extremely amusing and just silly to me.

I mean, no "transwoman" has ever:

had to face female genital mutilation, had to face the horrors being cut as a child, sometimes being sewn together, only to be "opened" up by his future husband on his wedding night, because his genitalia and sexuality are inherently dirty things that must be controlled

been killed as a newborn for the sin of being the wrong sex, the female sex that is considered a burden

been voiceless and veiled and treated lower than dogshit in Afghanistan

faced the sack for being married or having kids

has been denied the right to education, while his brothers are free to go to school

been ignored and overlooked for being female, but listened to when his husband is around

been denied the vote because he was a woman

been married off and sold like cattle to a man three times his age because girls are just another mouth to feed

experienced period poverty or the shame of being relegated to a menstrual hut

had his reproductive rights and literally every aspect of his material being policed, because that's what society does to women

...the list goes on.

But yeah, TWAW right? Spinny skirts away!

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

WaterThyme · 07/10/2026 18:12

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:35

Because there is no legitimate association demonstrable in reality. Age requires chronological associations. Gender only requires sociological associations that trans women possess.

Female is a sexed term btw. Woman is both a sex & gendered term. Trans women aren't claiming to be natal females they are claiming to be sociological women.

Gender only requires sociological associations that trans women possess.

So apparently I, a natal woman, am not wholly a woman because I never played with dolls never wore makeup, even though I suffered and fought all the restrictions of education, work and sexual harassment that women do.

Studied maths and went into computing - so am I not womanly? Can’t stand browsing for clothes - am I not womanly?

The logic that trans identifying men are somehow sociologically women because they do some things women are expected to do implies that women like me aren’t women in all senses. We absolutely are, we are fighting society’s gendered expectations in order to open up more prospects for women.

Trans identifying men, on the other hand, are not women. They are just reinforcing those gender stereotypes.

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 18:09

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 16:30

Men's mental health is absolutely a feminist issue. Feminism is about identifying and calling out the patriarchy, and the patriarchy plays a huge role in causing mens mental health struggle , it's mostly feminists who even recognise the patriarchy as a thing in the first place.

I never said it was the issue or that it should overshadow the ones that directly affect women. But the comment I replied to said anything to do with men isn't feminism, and that's just not correct.

So where are the men’s groups advocating for Women’s mental health? Or is it just women that are supposed to advocate for men?

SmallandSpanish · 07/10/2026 18:03

No.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 17:57

theilltemperedmonster · 07/10/2026 17:07

Women shouldn't read books because they might find out that the next village along doesn't marry off girls to middle-aged men at puberty.

Women shouldn't ride bikes because they might cycle to the next village, cuckold you, and land you with another man's child.

Women shouldn't rule the world because they might prioritise women and children and expect men to take responsibility instead of the most powerful men having the pick of the women.

It's all about competing for breeding opportunities and paternity guarding, whether consciously or not.

It's reproductive biology, all day long.

This. Do you see this point now @totino?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 17:56

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 17:13

Feminism isnt just theory. Its a doing word - women working to achieve better outcomes for women.

If men are included, it stops being that. At best its men helping to organising, or worse men deciding on the priorities, how they are achieved. Feminism is in danger of being by men, for men.

How many men can be included in Feminism before it loses focus of 'for women by women'? Can a group of trans identifying men be seen as a feminist group?

Precisely, feminism needs to be about women and girls. Men can call their gender analytical movement something else.

xye · 07/10/2026 17:53

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:49

but you also misread my innitail comment that said men should be included and conflated that with me saying men should be the focus

Men are always the focus!! They can’t seem to leave women alone!

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:49

xye · 07/10/2026 17:46

That is how I read it too.

but you also misread my innitail comment that said men should be included and conflated that with me saying men should be the focus

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 17:47

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 17:13

Feminism isnt just theory. Its a doing word - women working to achieve better outcomes for women.

If men are included, it stops being that. At best its men helping to organising, or worse men deciding on the priorities, how they are achieved. Feminism is in danger of being by men, for men.

How many men can be included in Feminism before it loses focus of 'for women by women'? Can a group of trans identifying men be seen as a feminist group?

I think any group of people can be a feminist group, provided nothing they fight for or work towards diminishes the rights or equality of women.

I don't see why men can't be feminists working alongside women to improve women's rights and equality.

OP posts:
xye · 07/10/2026 17:46

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 17:38

Okay, I see that xye said Why do men need feminism to focus on men?
and you said To identify patriarchy and its impact on these things
so the sentence flow reads as if you're saying it should focus on men in order to identify patriarchy
I accept that's not what you meant

That is how I read it too.

ReTerf · 07/10/2026 17:39

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:37

Very clearly not what I was saying??

Gender has EVERYTHING to do with feminism, what are you on about?
If the patriarchy hadn't created gendered roles, biases and stereotypes in the first place, there'd be no need for feminism. Women weren't kept out of work, politics and money because of their chromosomes, they were kept out because of what society decided women were for. That's gender
Very clearly, that is what you said—society, not chromosomes.

Edited to say, if it weren’t for the chromosomes, there would be no biological differences and no women to force into gender roles.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 17:38

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:21

Please, read back my posts you have misread. I haven’t once said feminism needs to focus on men?
I responded to a post that made a blanket statement that things pertaining to men have nothing to do with feminism, which is incorrect. I do not think that should be the main feminist focus , especially for women feminists to address, but they can be acknowledged as issues for feminism and that not take away from it predominantly being a women’s rights movement.

not assuming men can’t do it by themselves . Im saying that they need feminism to do it. Feminism is a school of thought that recognises the patriarchy. The positive male organisations your citing are no doubt promoting ideas like it’s okay for men to show emotions/ cry etc which is only necessary because patriarchy has constructed otherwise. Needing feminism and needing women is not the same thing, there are male feminists.

Dismantling the patriarchy requires a wholistic approach, and yes , that includes men and boys too.

Okay, I see that xye said Why do men need feminism to focus on men?
and you said To identify patriarchy and its impact on these things
so the sentence flow reads as if you're saying it should focus on men in order to identify patriarchy
I accept that's not what you meant

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:37

ReTerf · 07/10/2026 17:04

Ah, I see!!!
So are you saying—it was SOCIETY that decided women were destined to bear children and feed them from their own bodies, and deal with all the physiological and physical constraints that result from that, not chromosomes! ?

Thanks so much for pointing that out.

I disagree.

Edited

Very clearly not what I was saying??