Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 19:12

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 19:07

How do you think we should decide who is a woman and who is a man if not based on sex?

I am interested in this too

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 19:08

xye · 07/10/2026 17:04

Women do not need men to identify patriarchy, as women experience its daily impacts, cultural norms, and structural inequalities firsthand.

On this point: yes. we do. Not because women are incapable of identifying patriarchy, obviously, but because if there is ever going to be any meaningful change, men have to recognise it too.

Misogyny and patriarchal norms are upheld by men, and the reality is that men are often far more likely to listen to other men about this than they are to listen to women telling them about their own experiences. So we absolutely need men who are willing to recognise the patriarchal underpinnings of women's subjugation, and to challenge other men on them. And that includes recognising the ways that patriarchy and misogyny harm men too. Things like toxic masculinity and the expectation that men shouldn't show vulnerability aren't somehow separate from misogyny. They are part of the same system, and recognising that gives men a reason to want to challenge it for their own sake as well as women's.
If we want to reduce things like violence against women, discrimination and sexual harassment, it isn't enough for women to understand the problem. Men have to understand it too, and men need to be challenging other men, so it's essential that they identify patriarchy

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:07

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

This is complete fanciful nonsense. The reason “trans inclusive feminism” isn’t actually a thing is that you are literally centring men over women and girls. That is not feminism. It is anti feminism.

I highly doubt you could make any rational argument as to how a “trans woman” has anything in common with a woman that isn’t also shared with other men, but I’m all ears.

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 19:07

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

How do you think we should decide who is a woman and who is a man if not based on sex?

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 19:06

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 19:05

I am nearly 65 i walked away from feminism when it went right up its own arse. I was a reader/subscriber of the Spare Rib collective. In a simplistic analysis feminism only subsequently existed in academia. It ceased to have any relationship with working class women and their actual life experiences tethered to their biology and reproductive destiny, lower wages, etc.

then i popped into mumsnet FWR and bugger me the the name TERF cropped up, and the various activities of the TERFY peeps.

i thought yeah, i can call myself a feminist again.

Why? Because TERF talks about all biological women, it centres Lesbians, and it centres class and race, and religious oppression. It takes no prisoners.

Some TERFS have earned some fiscal privilege and use that to promote our cause.

I love being a TERF.

We are not a branch of feminism we are the trunk, connected to the roots of activism,

to stretch an analogy further the weak branch of feminism that is inclusive of men is about to drop off.

And i will be there to fucking burn it.

Amazing post

xye · 07/10/2026 19:06

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 19:01

Phantom limb pain occurs after the amputation of a limb - it's the brain looking for something that was previously there.

A brain can't recognise being in the wrong body as its never been in an opposite sex body

This whole notion of ‘being in the wrong body’ is ludicrous!

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

MarieDeGournay · 07/10/2026 16:11

I see what you're saying with biology vs 'biology', there were some daft ideas in the past. There still are...😏

Two thoughts: what originally distinguished the group who said the other group's wombs would catch fire if they read books, or whatever, from the group whose wombs would allegedly catch fire?

And biology has come a long way from the inflammable womb theory - but it can still distinguish clearly between the group who have wombs as Standard Issue, and the group who don't.
In fact, it's never been easier - a simple cheek swab suffices.

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 19:05

I am nearly 65 i walked away from feminism when it went right up its own arse. I was a reader/subscriber of the Spare Rib collective. In a simplistic analysis feminism only subsequently existed in academia. It ceased to have any relationship with working class women and their actual life experiences tethered to their biology and reproductive destiny, lower wages, etc.

then i popped into mumsnet FWR and bugger me the the name TERF cropped up, and the various activities of the TERFY peeps.

i thought yeah, i can call myself a feminist again.

Why? Because TERF talks about all biological women, it centres Lesbians, and it centres class and race, and religious oppression. It takes no prisoners.

Some TERFS have earned some fiscal privilege and use that to promote our cause.

I love being a TERF.

We are not a branch of feminism we are the trunk, connected to the roots of activism,

to stretch an analogy further the weak branch of feminism that is inclusive of men is about to drop off.

And i will be there to fucking burn it.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 19:02

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 18:59

Are you saying that a woman who doesn't want a man in her rape therapy group should go elsewhere rather than the man

Which is the same as saying women can only have single sex spaces/services when men allow them to.

Wow, this is top notch feminism 🙄

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 19:01

Phantom limb pain occurs after the amputation of a limb - it's the brain looking for something that was previously there.

A brain can't recognise being in the wrong body as its never been in an opposite sex body

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 18:59

totino · 07/10/2026 18:57

A rape victim in need should never be left hanging so yes, obviously. If he wants to go. Perhaps he would prefer a service for men, but there are very few, so yes. But I also think the same of a trans woman. If there is a situation where another survivor absolutely cannot be in the same space as a trans woman she also should be accommodated. More funding for rape crisis services would be helpful, but everyone knows that's not coming.

Are you saying that a woman who doesn't want a man in her rape therapy group should go elsewhere rather than the man

Wishesandhorses · 07/10/2026 18:58

Absolutely no issues with men presenting any way they choose, mentally feeling any way they feel, having complex spiritual beliefs about souls, interesting alternative science interests and beliefs, and all the rest of it. Have a lovely time.

Just tolerate the existence of single sex spaces for women that choose and need them, and stop trying to get in there.

End of issue.

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 18:57

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

The idea that Bruce Jenner, Frank Maloney and Eddie Izzard were never men is frankly laughable. Sorry.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 18:57

There is no male or female brain or body but you just know ?

since the male and female brains and bodyies don’t exist you can’t know because there is nothing to know?

except I suspect you know who you fancy

totino · 07/10/2026 18:57

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 16:22

So if you include TIM in your feminism, I have a question. If there is a TIM who wants access to a women’s only rape crisis centre, but his presence will traumatise the women in that place, whose rights and needs should be met?

A rape victim in need should never be left hanging so yes, obviously. If he wants to go. Perhaps he would prefer a service for men, but there are very few, so yes. But I also think the same of a trans woman. If there is a situation where another survivor absolutely cannot be in the same space as a trans woman she also should be accommodated. More funding for rape crisis services would be helpful, but everyone knows that's not coming.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 18:55

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

I can't even

For the second time this evening

theilltemperedmonster · 07/10/2026 18:55

solerolover · 07/10/2026 18:13

@Naunet

Sounds like a set of privilaged, luxury beliefs to me.

Absolutely, I couldn't have put it better myself.

The refusal to acknowledge the physical and social reality of the female half of the planet, to divorce that from womanhood, and state that, no actually, womanhood is contained in the minds of male people, the historical oppressor class of female people, in the form of some metaphysical concept known as a "gender identity" and you want to call that feminism?😳Maybe it's because my family are from a global South nation, so-called feminists who champion this ideology are extremely amusing and just silly to me.

I mean, no "transwoman" has ever:

had to face female genital mutilation, had to face the horrors being cut as a child, sometimes being sewn together, only to be "opened" up by his future husband on his wedding night, because his genitalia and sexuality are inherently dirty things that must be controlled

been killed as a newborn for the sin of being the wrong sex, the female sex that is considered a burden

been voiceless and veiled and treated lower than dogshit in Afghanistan

faced the sack for being married or having kids

has been denied the right to education, while his brothers are free to go to school

been ignored and overlooked for being female, but listened to when his husband is around

been denied the vote because he was a woman

been married off and sold like cattle to a man three times his age because girls are just another mouth to feed

experienced period poverty or the shame of being relegated to a menstrual hut

had his reproductive rights and literally every aspect of his material being policed, because that's what society does to women

...the list goes on.

But yeah, TWAW right? Spinny skirts away!

Edited

Indeed. TW claim to be feminists, but I just don't see what use feminism is to them. Nothing in your post applies to them.

Sure, they might, if they pass, suffer from perceptive discrimination, but I think we've already got that covered, along with discrimination as to gender reassignment.

And they are at risk from other men, because all men are: men kill twice as many men as women.

But heterosexual TW are not at risk from their wives, and if attacked by another man have some chance of fighting him off (and don't risk pregnancy). What does this have to do with women?

I actually don't object to men being "socially women" (because what's the rationale for banning it?). I draw the line at them pretending to actually be women, for all the many reasons rehearsed supra.

Wishesandhorses · 07/10/2026 18:55

The threat to women has always been men, not trans women

Another mindless mantra passing from screen to mouth without making it through the brain on the way. Chanted with the aim of forcing non consenting women to have to undress and/or submit to intimate touch from men to gratify the man's inner self.

There's no point even bothering to unpack it, any more than there is debating 'pretty polly'.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:54

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

The brain knows whether you are a man or a woman?

What does this even mean?

How does the brain ‘know’ something in total opposition to the reproductive system?

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

murasaki · 07/10/2026 16:05

So please can you explain in what way biological men who think they are women are actually women and therefore should be included in feminism please?

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:52

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:49

Because they need feminism/ feminist ideology to recognise that their issues are intertwined with misogyny and caused by and large, patriarchy

Edited

I totally agree that men are impacted by patriarchy too.

However it’s not feminism's job to address this

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:51

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

What’s the difference between a man and a ‘transwoman’?

And dismantling women’s sex based rights IS hurting them. Are people incapable of thinking through basic consequences?

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 18:50

The threat to women has always been men not transwomen

thats false

first because to be a transwoman you have to be a man - so the statement reads “
the threat to women has always been men not men
“ which is clearly nonsense

second the prison data suggests that transwomen may even be more of a threat to women than none transgender men.

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:49

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 18:38

So who would be doing the advocacy then? If it’s men, why would they need feminism? They’re big boys ,they can do it themselves

Because they need feminism/ feminist ideology to recognise that their issues are intertwined with misogyny and caused by and large, patriarchy

Lhori · 07/10/2026 18:45

raisinglittlepeople12 · 07/10/2026 18:12

Yes. People have such a hard time minding their own business, but ultimately for me it’s a case of “do what you want as long as it’s legal and not hurting anyone else. The threat to women has always been men, not trans women.

Why would men who say they are women, or believe they should be women, be safer than other men? Based on crime statistics of prisoners, trans women are actually a bit less safe when it comes to sexual assaults.