Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 19:37

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:36

It’s just pure waffly speculation to reverse engineer an explanation of how a man can have a lady brain.

No becuase they have said there isn’t a lady brain

just a feeling inside the brain / body

CreativeGreen · 07/10/2026 19:37

How does this boy know that’s “not what he is”?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:37

Poster believes men can be women, so poster has made up an explanation that they think is plausible

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 19:37

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:24

These discussions: “well it’s interesting that you have your established facts, risk profiling and logic and lived experience of your biological sex, but I think my incoherent, stereotype-based quasi-religious belief where I can’t quite explain how men are in any way like women but they totally are, and so you should give up your safety, privacy and dignity for this ideological concept” - so frustrating

It blows my mind that people think we should go along with such scientifically illiterate, ill thought through garbage.

I mean, why would we?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:36

It’s just pure waffly speculation to reverse engineer an explanation of how a man can have a lady brain.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 19:35

totino · 07/10/2026 19:27

I don't think the reproductive system should be the deciding factor. It will be true for most people, but not all.

I believe in most cases it's quite direct. Being addressed as a boy and becoming alienated because that's not what you are. Being referred to as a daughter and thinking that's not right. A consistent experience of alienation that can be alleviated by transition.

So another version of ‘sex should be defined as something other than sex’ then.

Well no, because that’s ridiculous. It’s also makes women’s rights impossible to defend,

There is no right way to be a boy or a girl and we should never encourage anyone to believe that. Men and women can express themselves as they want, wear what they want.

If people can’t bear their sex to be acknowledged, they need therapy, not the definition of words that have existed since the dawn of civilisation to be changed

totino · 07/10/2026 19:35

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 19:25

And where does it leave their female former partners. If they believed themselves to be straight, do they now have to accept they are bisexual?

It's a taxing thing to go through! I think some do and some don't. There's couples who bridge that gap, and yes, I might call the wife bisexual, but ultimately she was in love with a person and not a penis. However often enough it doesn't work out, and it's really sad, but I'd say it's the same as when someone comes out as a lesbian or as gay after many years. It can't really be helped.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 19:34

totino · 07/10/2026 19:27

I don't think the reproductive system should be the deciding factor. It will be true for most people, but not all.

I believe in most cases it's quite direct. Being addressed as a boy and becoming alienated because that's not what you are. Being referred to as a daughter and thinking that's not right. A consistent experience of alienation that can be alleviated by transition.

A feeling of alienation

its just a feeling?

a feeling that relies on you being the sex you are or you couldn’t feel it ?

this is so laughable twisted

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 19:31

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:52

I totally agree that men are impacted by patriarchy too.

However it’s not feminism's job to address this

Feminism is the only thing that actually identifies patriarchy in the first place. Take feminism away and nobody's naming those structures at all, because other ways of looking at the world either don't see it or deny it exists. So if men are being harmed by patriarchy, feminism is the lens that spots it and calls it out.
If you mean it's not women's job to fix it, then yes, I agree with you. But that's not the same as it not being feminism's job. The person doing the advocating or being on the front line doesn't have to be a woman.

Not saying every feminist has to take it on either. Just that it sits within feminism, not outside it.

Hoardasurass · 07/10/2026 19:30

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

We keep them out because they are men and yes its legal sex discrimination.
All men are a physical threat even if they've chopped their penis off because he can still strangle you to death with 1 hand or beat you to death.
Also we keep men out because we want privacy and dignity aswell as safety.
And that is why we keep winning.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:30

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 19:25

And where does it leave their female former partners. If they believed themselves to be straight, do they now have to accept they are bisexual?

Indeed.

CreativeGreen · 07/10/2026 19:28

totino · 07/10/2026 19:27

I don't think the reproductive system should be the deciding factor. It will be true for most people, but not all.

I believe in most cases it's quite direct. Being addressed as a boy and becoming alienated because that's not what you are. Being referred to as a daughter and thinking that's not right. A consistent experience of alienation that can be alleviated by transition.

So just thinking you don’t like being the sex you are, then?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:28

luy · 07/10/2026 19:26

this should be pinned up top as it sums up everything better than anything I’ve ever read!

Thank you! Years of hard experience of being tired of explaining reality.

totino · 07/10/2026 19:27

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:54

The brain knows whether you are a man or a woman?

What does this even mean?

How does the brain ‘know’ something in total opposition to the reproductive system?

I don't think the reproductive system should be the deciding factor. It will be true for most people, but not all.

I believe in most cases it's quite direct. Being addressed as a boy and becoming alienated because that's not what you are. Being referred to as a daughter and thinking that's not right. A consistent experience of alienation that can be alleviated by transition.

luy · 07/10/2026 19:26

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:24

These discussions: “well it’s interesting that you have your established facts, risk profiling and logic and lived experience of your biological sex, but I think my incoherent, stereotype-based quasi-religious belief where I can’t quite explain how men are in any way like women but they totally are, and so you should give up your safety, privacy and dignity for this ideological concept” - so frustrating

this should be pinned up top as it sums up everything better than anything I’ve ever read!

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 19:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:12

@totino if a “trans woman” is “never” a man, does that mean that if Donald Trump announced he was a woman tomorrow, he’s always been one? Would you accept his identity? Or would you gatekeep?

because the claims to be women of many of the men you are caping for are easily just as ludicrous as that. I suspect you do gatekeep, don’t you?

Edited

And where does it leave their female former partners. If they believed themselves to be straight, do they now have to accept they are bisexual?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 19:24

Pallisers · 07/10/2026 19:22

Me too. Also when you come up with the definition could you send it on to Afghanistan - I'm sure it will make a huge difference to the women of that country.

@totino will give us the answer

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:24

These discussions: “well it’s interesting that you have your established facts, risk profiling and logic and lived experience of your biological sex, but I think my incoherent, stereotype-based quasi-religious belief where I can’t quite explain how men are in any way like women but they totally are, and so you should give up your safety, privacy and dignity for this ideological concept” - so frustrating

MarieDeGournay · 07/10/2026 19:23

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

Thank you for replying.
I only mentioned wombs because you mentioned wombs.

The fact of being male or female is not just in our reproductive systems, is it?
Our biological sex is encoded in every cell in our body - which, usefully. makes a quick cheek swab just as effective as the often-mentioned 'genital inspections'.

Apart from rare DSDs, the XX/XY things is a straightforward, provable, workable, pretty much universal way to define 'man' and 'women', and I don't see the point in pursuing less convincing alternatives. Except of course in angels-on-head-of-pins-type speculation, which is fair enough, but not very practical.

Wishesandhorses · 07/10/2026 19:23

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

Yes, I'm sure that's all lovely.

What do we do with the women who are quite certain of their sex and need single sex spaces for access and equality?

Pallisers · 07/10/2026 19:22

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 19:12

I am interested in this too

Me too. Also when you come up with the definition could you send it on to Afghanistan - I'm sure it will make a huge difference to the women of that country.

GrumpyPanda · 07/10/2026 19:15

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:29

The thing with self determination means its upto individuals to decide what they believe that's why self identification exists. Identity is a personal determination that people are entitled to regardless of how illogical or impractical or unhelpful others may find it just like atheists don't get to dictate their beliefs onto theists.

Does the same right apply to Rachel Dolezal? If not, why not?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 07/10/2026 19:14

If you have to put trans in front of anything then you aren’t what you say you are. Isn’t that what it boils down to. If you were a woman you’d just be a woman? Not a trans woman. Why are grown adults debating this?

Am I a trans millionaire? My bank says no, but my
expensive clothes, tastes, restaurants and holiday
resorts say otherwise. Who is responsible for this discrimination?

That’s before I get onto age. 44 you say? I don’t feel it…

The game is up. If it isn't seek help.

CreativeGreen · 07/10/2026 19:14

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

So what other things help define whether someone is male or female?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 19:12

@totino if a “trans woman” is “never” a man, does that mean that if Donald Trump announced he was a woman tomorrow, he’s always been one? Would you accept his identity? Or would you gatekeep?

because the claims to be women of many of the men you are caping for are easily just as ludicrous as that. I suspect you do gatekeep, don’t you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread