Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 21:22

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 07/10/2026 20:40

Yes, obviously.

Misogyny affects all women. Trans women experience sexual harassment, discrimination and the violent attention of cis men.

Cis men have no idea about any of that. They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack. Trans women absolutely do.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience. Depressing but true.

So yes, I believe feminism should be trans-inclusive. Mine is.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience.

The sole uniting female experience is being born of the female sex.

What you are doing is finding a something woman can experience, and then saying men who experience it are women, too.

If both men and women can experience something, it cannot be used as a proof one sex.

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:18

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:00

Is the point of the thread to discuss whether we individually believe TWAW or to discuss whether trans inclusive feminism exists? Shall we go back to the OP?

Feminism that is inclusive of transwomen - ie men - is not feminism.

MarieDeGournay · 07/10/2026 20:52

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 19:40

We do not make laws and organise society on ‘feelings’ when we have objective, verifiable, scientific evidence at our disposal.

I think this is a very important point, and to take it further, the organisation of a society doesn't rest entirely on laws, it also depends on people accepting laws even when they are not being watched, and are not in fear of punishment.

'Manners are more important than laws. Upon them, in great measure, the laws depend' [Edmund Burke]

Most people will not set fire to the contents of a postbox, although there is an opening which could easily accommodate a lit paraffin-soaked rag, and no-one is watching [I hope I haven't given anyone any ideas😏]

Another example is men respecting women-only spaces, without having to be physically restrained from entering them, 'the good men stay out so the bad men stand out' up to very recently held true in almost all cases.

It's also accepted that laws do not bend to accommodate everybody's feelings - if there is a 60mph speed limit, it applies to all drivers, even the ones who know they are such fantastic drivers that they can safely do 80, or the ones who identify as Max Verstappen. Or even actual Max Verstappen.

Where it is necessary to identify whether a person belongs to the group 'men' or the group 'women' - and so far I think almost everybody here has agreed that there are some circumstances where that is the case - the pragmatic, workable approach is to use the scientific evidence, not act on how individuals feel about the scientific evidence, or allow them to identify out of the scientific evidence.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/10/2026 20:50

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 07/10/2026 20:40

Yes, obviously.

Misogyny affects all women. Trans women experience sexual harassment, discrimination and the violent attention of cis men.

Cis men have no idea about any of that. They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack. Trans women absolutely do.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience. Depressing but true.

So yes, I believe feminism should be trans-inclusive. Mine is.

They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack.

If you believe that, it tells me that you know very few men indeed. Ask some gen-X and older gay men how much of their young adulthood involved being constantly vigilant to attack. Fuck it, ask some scrawny straight ones, or some who just had the wrong accent in the wrong town.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 20:49

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 20:45

A lot of ‘trans-inclusive’ feminists look ‘trans-prioritising’ tbh.

Don’t they.

xye · 07/10/2026 20:49

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 07/10/2026 20:40

Yes, obviously.

Misogyny affects all women. Trans women experience sexual harassment, discrimination and the violent attention of cis men.

Cis men have no idea about any of that. They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack. Trans women absolutely do.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience. Depressing but true.

So yes, I believe feminism should be trans-inclusive. Mine is.

Just to be clear:

’Trans women’ are men
’Cis’ men are men

Heggettypeg · 07/10/2026 20:49

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 20:46

I would also think that many gay men know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack.

Yes, and it's also arguable that homophobia has its roots in misogyny - contempt for the feminine and for those who play the "female" role in sex. By that logic, "feminism" should include gay men.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 20:48

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 07/10/2026 20:40

Yes, obviously.

Misogyny affects all women. Trans women experience sexual harassment, discrimination and the violent attention of cis men.

Cis men have no idea about any of that. They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack. Trans women absolutely do.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience. Depressing but true.

So yes, I believe feminism should be trans-inclusive. Mine is.

Men who identify as women are not seen as actual women by most people, because most people know women are female. For the most part they are seen as psychologically fragile and volatile men. Vulnerable but not welcome in women’s spaces. The majority of straight men and lesbians don’t see them as part of their dating pool.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/10/2026 20:46

@totino

All you are doing is defining a new way to group people and calling it "women" or "men".

I'm not saying your new groups are not valid in their own right, but they are not really relevent to the groups of people who were known as "women" and "men" ie the two human sexes.

Nor does the sexism the female half of humanity suffered and still suffers stop being a thing just because you decided you don't want to call us "women" any more (because you think you have a better use for the word.)

I understand that you may not have thought about it this way, because boring everyday people can get taken for granted where there are exotic marginalised identities around, but you do need to consider that when a male person says he is a "woman", or a female person "a man" they aren't just describing themselves, they are claiming a similarity of mind/character with other people. But those other people may not in fact see themselves that way.

This is the problem your type of definition runs into.

Because you are only thinking about the trans people, you can say things like "people know who they are better than you do", and miss that to make trans women women and trans men men, the second part of this has to be "and they know who you are better than you do as well!" - because otherwise it just doesn't work.

So at the end of the day your "inclusive" type of womanhood and feminism pushes out at least as many female people as it includes male, because many female people simply don't identify with this new type of mental womanhood, nor with a "Feminism" that tells us that the sexism we face is because other people can somehow sense our inner gender alignment rather than simply because they see we are female and therefore apply sexist shite.

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 20:46

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 20:43

But all men - transgender or not experience sexual harressment discrimination and violence at the hands of other men

so you say that feminism should centre men ?

really pathetic

I would also think that many gay men know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack.

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 20:45

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 20:43

But all men - transgender or not experience sexual harressment discrimination and violence at the hands of other men

so you say that feminism should centre men ?

really pathetic

A lot of ‘trans-inclusive’ feminists look ‘trans-prioritising’ tbh.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 20:43

But all men - transgender or not experience sexual harressment discrimination and violence at the hands of other men

so you say that feminism should centre men ?

really pathetic

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 07/10/2026 20:40

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

Yes, obviously.

Misogyny affects all women. Trans women experience sexual harassment, discrimination and the violent attention of cis men.

Cis men have no idea about any of that. They don't know how it feels to constantly be vigilant to attack. Trans women absolutely do.

Misogyny is the sole uniting female experience. Depressing but true.

So yes, I believe feminism should be trans-inclusive. Mine is.

Heggettypeg · 07/10/2026 20:37

Outside the (relatively recent) Western model of transgender, there are a number of societies that have traditionally accommodated men who wish to live in the manner of a woman.

They seem to have done this by having a category in its own right for these men, with its own name. Not by appropriating the name "woman".

It is that appropriation which has led to the coercive farce that everyone has to pretend there is no difference between women and feminine- identifying men, or none that matters. And has led to the absurdity of a "feminism" which includes a select subset of men, calls them women, and prioritises them over women when there is a conflict.

So a desire to colonise women's identity and space is supported by linguistic gerrymandering which aims to makes the colonisation sound reasonable and inevitable. It isn't. There are other approaches to gender nonconformity.

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 20:26

totino · 07/10/2026 20:05

No but they do think a woman's defining factor is the ability to bear children.

Interesting because from my traditional Marxist background. Engles said exactly that. It is the root source of women's oppression, and the subsequent development of the patriarchy.

Women in the miners strike were heavily analysed, nay criticised for holding up the patriarchy by their defence of their own family unit and their children.

Terfdom holds all of the opinions be left or right they do not criticise women for being mothers, the struggles of liberty versus motherdom, we love all of it and all our disparate struggles.

it is truely back to the begining back to reality back to all that is woman.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 20:26

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 20:20

If both men and women can be men or women, and we group by self selection, what's the point?

Both groups will be the same, and we cant talk about sex as a class.

All that's happened is a group of people who want to conceal their sex have managed to stop anyond talking about sex. Sex hasnt disappeared, only our ability to talk about it clearly.

Rather than saying women should go for smear and menopause tests, we say people with cervix should. People with a cervix or uterus, not women. We start seeing ourselves as a series of disconnected parts, not our sex as a whole.

Feminism does have to step back and look at female as a class. Not all women give birth, but only women give birth. No women has made another women pregnant. Every women has common biology that men cannot share. And that cannot be ignored.

Edited

This is an absolutely key point.

Sex is material reality. I cannot be erased. The thing that TRAs and @totinowant to erase is our ability to talk about sex.

Whose interests does that serve? The women who have been fighting for their rights for millennia or the men who don't want to acknowledge these rights?

It doesn’t take a genius to figure that one out.,

xye · 07/10/2026 20:25

@Pingponghavoc “No women has made another women pregnant.”

Just like no man has made a ‘trans woman’ pregnant.

Pingponghavoc · 07/10/2026 20:20

If both men and women can be men or women, and we group by self selection, what's the point?

Both groups will be the same, and we cant talk about sex as a class.

All that's happened is a group of people who want to conceal their sex have managed to stop anyond talking about sex. Sex hasnt disappeared, only our ability to talk about it clearly.

Rather than saying women should go for smear and menopause tests, we say people with cervix should. People with a cervix or uterus, not women. We start seeing ourselves as a series of disconnected parts, not our sex as a whole.

Feminism does have to step back and look at female as a class. Not all women give birth, but only women give birth. No women has made another women pregnant. Every women has common biology that men cannot share. And that cannot be ignored.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 20:19

I love that some people reach for any old unconvincing guff just to avoid telling men that women and girls are female and have rights to privacy and dignity.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 20:15

I think they are continently called a mistake or reasonable collateral damage

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 20:14

totino · 07/10/2026 20:10

Of course they do, and that's a very difficult thing to go through. However, if you give a treatment to 100 people, and 2 end up regretting it, but 98 are helped by it, it's not right to deny the other 98 people. Of course diagnostic should be improved. And the best way to learn more is actually to let more people who want to, transition. Especially socially transition, because the ones who really don't feel it will dip out.

Worth mentioning that what detransitioners feel is what trans people feel when they don't transition. Being stuck in a body that's wrong for you.

But they were always the sex they transitioned to according to you. So what are they once they detransition,

spannasaurus · 07/10/2026 20:14

totino · 07/10/2026 20:10

Of course they do, and that's a very difficult thing to go through. However, if you give a treatment to 100 people, and 2 end up regretting it, but 98 are helped by it, it's not right to deny the other 98 people. Of course diagnostic should be improved. And the best way to learn more is actually to let more people who want to, transition. Especially socially transition, because the ones who really don't feel it will dip out.

Worth mentioning that what detransitioners feel is what trans people feel when they don't transition. Being stuck in a body that's wrong for you.

Worth mentioning that what detransitioners feel is what trans people feel when they don't transition. Being stuck in a body that's wrong for you.

What they feel is medically harmed. Its offensive to say that someone like Richie Herron who now has to live with no penis and a host of medical problems is stuck in a body that's wrong for him.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 20:13

If you give treatment to 100 people and 98 were helped ? Helped relieve some mental issues whilst giving them physical problems? Because the transgender treatment for females is associated with weak bones, dementia and heart failure so not something to be done lightly

what do you think happened in the past when treatment wasn’t available ?

spoiler alert
the women got over it, and didn’t suffer form weak bones, dementia or heart failure - win win !
and the men wore dresses and called themselves transvestites

theilltemperedmonster · 07/10/2026 20:13

@totino

When the aliens land, and they pick on you to explain the existence and purpose of human 'men' and 'women', what, exactly, are you going to tell them?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 20:12

totino · 07/10/2026 20:10

Of course they do, and that's a very difficult thing to go through. However, if you give a treatment to 100 people, and 2 end up regretting it, but 98 are helped by it, it's not right to deny the other 98 people. Of course diagnostic should be improved. And the best way to learn more is actually to let more people who want to, transition. Especially socially transition, because the ones who really don't feel it will dip out.

Worth mentioning that what detransitioners feel is what trans people feel when they don't transition. Being stuck in a body that's wrong for you.

But in your ideology aren’t “trans women” always women, never men? So if a man “transitions” has he always been a woman, and then if he detransitions was he a man all along even when he was always a woman?

Swipe left for the next trending thread