Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
popery · 08/10/2026 23:31

but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that

Anything a male person is sensing is, by definition, not something that is unique to being female. It is something that both sexes experience (or possibly only male people).

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 23:24

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 22:01

It's weird because they always say they would know who the liars are and who really really means it and is truly really and wholeheartedly pretending to be the opposite sex. Unlike us thickos who just can't work it out properly.

You’d think that if they knew, they’d let everyone else know so that we could make sure the fraudulent ones couldn’t keep ruining everything for the true transes.

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 22:23

I wonder how the ‘sense of female/always women’ people explain the documented cases of older people with dementia identifying back as their birth sex?

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 22:01

It's weird because they always say they would know who the liars are and who really really means it and is truly really and wholeheartedly pretending to be the opposite sex. Unlike us thickos who just can't work it out properly.

PrancingPanda · 08/10/2026 21:59

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 18:54

I think it’s a lot more than sad. The blitheness with which this poster is waving away women’s rights and basic safety precautions is shocking me to my core. It’s revolting

Agree wholeheartedly
Mouldy, lexi and now totino (who I think might be a youngster)
Have I missed cupboards and Lack? Howse that happen I wonder?

The usual patronising, condescending diatribe from them is so predictable, it's boring. I cannot bothered reading such rubbish in any great detail.
And as for posters talking of 'genuine' or was it 'sincere'? TW and non genuine: wow possibly sounds a little transphobic.

Again- why are these posters wanting to allow men into womens' spaces?
Do they hate women too?

Feminism cannot centre men. Or it wouldn't have been 'invented' ☺️

nutmeg7 · 08/10/2026 21:35

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

Being female is nothing to do with a “sense” of being female.

It’s our chromosomes, in every cell of our body, it’s having a body geared towards producing eggs, it is having a body that is never going to produce sperm.

Being male or female is not a feeling or a sense. Male and female are used all across the animal and plant kingdoms to mean the two distinct variations of a species that reproduces sexually.

Male and female are words that have quite clear and objective meanings in science, in medicine, in the natural world, outside the circles of true believers in gender ideology.

Catiette · 08/10/2026 21:27

Menier · 08/10/2026 21:20

What do you define as a proper academic circle- and are you part of one?
If not how do you 'know' nobody in these circles thinks like this?

I think the phrases "proper academic circle" and "nobody thinks like this" are probably mutually exclusive.

Biting my lip and going with the cringy sixth-form "proper", no "proper academic circle" worth its salt would respect the idea that thinking in any particular way is beyond the pale. Speaking some stuff, maybe. Thinking it through first, though, before perhaps discounting speaking it on the basis of that thought? No.

Being theoretically open to thinking through anything and everything is what makes them "proper".

Edited for typos and to add... I recognise the apparent paradox of Lexible arguing that academic crircles would never think in what Lexible sees as a close-minded way and me saying, Yeah, actually, they would! But what Lexible's saying seems to be that this debate about what defines feminism lacks validity, on the basis that Lexible themself sees the GC side as reductive and extreme. And I'm saying that that claim in itself is worthy of debate. Especially in a context in which there have been "proper academic circles" who've shut it down because they see it as anathema and to hell with truth (Stock, Bindel etc.) That word "proper" reflects exactly the same right/wrong, black/white attitude, with a smattering of decorum floating around the connotative edges (it's just not proper). Now that's anti-intellectual.

nutmeg7 · 08/10/2026 21:21

xye · 08/10/2026 18:15

@totino “Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally”

In what universe do some women have a penis? Bruce Jenner fathered his children. He didn’t carry and give birth to them.

Excellent point. The whole belief system is a childish, simplistic fantasy.

Menier · 08/10/2026 21:20

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 08:55

Yes of course.

Trans inclusive and exclusive feminism are just types of feminism. Like there are different types of socialism. Feminism just means that you believe that structural and societal power is unequally held by men and steps should be taken to address that. Different types of feminists have different approaches and ideas about the best ways to do that.

It doesn't matter how much someone who is trans inclusive tries to say that someone trans exclusive isnt a feminist or vice versa, the fact remains the same.

People often mistake their disagreement with a type of feminism for that school of thought not being feminism at all. People think this about other socio-political movements, too.

You'll find in proper academic circles with respected scholars, nobody thinks like this. It's only on the internet where you have the masses bashing away at their keyboards that you bump into this amateur school of thought.

What do you define as a proper academic circle- and are you part of one?
If not how do you 'know' nobody in these circles thinks like this?

Catiette · 08/10/2026 21:15

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 21:06

There's three attitudes working at once. One where vulnerable men need the protection of 'safe spaces'. Not only the physical space but the protections given by individual women and feminism as a movement.

Another seems to be that these men are an asset to women and feminism. They chose it, therefore must be more committed.

Lastly, that anything exclusive with boundaries is wrong, including limiting feminism to females. Its why theres no limited to what is trans, too.

I'd actually question the last point. I think one of the striking things about this ideology is that this "exclusivity" isn't just promoted but celebrated in a wide range of other contexts. A world in which a Mexican sombrero at a house party could get you cancelled but Ru Paul's a primetime moneymaker is a sexist world indeed. Whatever you think of these examples, the enormity of the bloody great gulf between the reception of each is pretty a damning "tell".

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 21:14

The logic about protecting vulnerable male people also doesn’t stand up to analysis.

There are numerous groups of male people who are similarly vulnerable. Yet they never get the protection of using female single sex provisions.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 08/10/2026 21:11

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 08:35

Well if you mean including men in your feminism, then no. Feminism is about focusing on women’s needs.

Interesting, I always thought it
was about equality and focusing on women as we are currently the oppressed

Keepgettingolder81 · 08/10/2026 21:11

No

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 21:10

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 20:05

FWIW, I've found slight soft men can be just as problematic if not more so than brick shithouses. (MASSMALT, obviously)

Sadly just because a man happens to be a loser in the Patriachy stakes, it doesn't necessarily make them any nicer or more sympathetic to women. Sometimes, it just means they feel justified in or masculinised by punching down.

Young women especially are not always aware of this.

I get that FWR. I'm a physically large, older and psychologically assertive female. I get that others would have more of a problem than me. I found short men the worst at work!

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 21:10

As I’ve said before, there’s a disconnect. Vulnerable doesn’t mean harmless. Many incredibly abusive people qualify as vulnerable due to psychological issues.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 21:06

There's three attitudes working at once. One where vulnerable men need the protection of 'safe spaces'. Not only the physical space but the protections given by individual women and feminism as a movement.

Another seems to be that these men are an asset to women and feminism. They chose it, therefore must be more committed.

Lastly, that anything exclusive with boundaries is wrong, including limiting feminism to females. Its why theres no limited to what is trans, too.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 20:57

I think the whole movement and most of its supporters are pretty immature by nature.

Catiette · 08/10/2026 20:54

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 19:07

If men can be women then how can 'we' rule?

If everyone can rule then nobody rules.

It's like walking into a bloody toddler's party where far too much pink cake and sweeties have been eaten.

Yes. There's an immaturity to it I find quite frightening.

Pink-icing feminism, in more way than one: gendered, neatly packaged and happily celebrated as women's rights burn.

Oh, apologies, let me try that again...

I meant cis women's rights.

Gah, shocking omission, very sorry, er... Cis women and trans men's rights.

(Oops. And non-binary people.

The female ones, that is).

Oh yeah - so, better phrasing: female rights.

But, really specifically, adult human females.

Yeah. Yeah, that does it.

Yeah.

Yeah!

That group, that nameless group, they "rule", too.

(Or they would, if they'd been left the language to have a pithy battle cry).

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 20:49

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 20:05

FWIW, I've found slight soft men can be just as problematic if not more so than brick shithouses. (MASSMALT, obviously)

Sadly just because a man happens to be a loser in the Patriachy stakes, it doesn't necessarily make them any nicer or more sympathetic to women. Sometimes, it just means they feel justified in or masculinised by punching down.

Young women especially are not always aware of this.

This.

Catiette · 08/10/2026 20:39

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

Who's the "we" here, Totino?

As yours is the "inclusive" version of feminism, you must be confident that there's now a fairly universal understanding that "woman" means gender identity, not body.

Could you just explain how this works in a bit more detail?

Like, when Amnesty referred to Afghani women as oppressed because of their "identity", was this in response to surveys in that country confirming this fit their perception of themselves and their status? If so, it would be useful to know how trans men are treated in contrast. Or was Amnesty risking misgendering by generalising, for simplicity? Or was it rather that they felt that this enlightened concept is the ethical descriptor regardless of what people in the developing world may currently understand or think?

Given these uncertainties, what word should I use if I want to accurately refer to the half of Afghanistan imprisoned in their homes?

Or are they not worth a noun of their own?

After all, We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference.

Datun · 08/10/2026 20:05

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

The difference between you and a transwoman is you're a completely different sex.

The similarity between you and other women is you are the same sex.

Cant believe I'm having to say it tbh.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 20:05

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 19:28

Happy to start another when it's full!

I didn't, when I started this thread, expect to find anyone able to come up with an argument that would persuade me that someone could be a feminist and also support biological males being in female spaces.

That expectation has not been disappointed.

I am, though, gobsmacked that multiple people declaring that they were born female claim to be feminist while being perfectly prepared to support things that without doubt upset/hurt/harm/disadvantage other women.

I am truly shocked by those women. They certainly don't fit into my definition of a feminist.

I write this as a female who personally would have no problem with sharing spaces with post-surgery males of female stature but who realises two things;

  • that I have no right to give that permission on behalf of other women, and would not dream of doing that
  • that allowing the slight, fine looking man who has been very feminine his whole life into my changing room means I can't keep out the brick shithouse who used to play male rugby and decided in his 40s he's female, and him I really do have a problem with.

Lastly, this thread hasn't yet really talked about what trans inclusive means. I am truly trans inclusive in so far as it reflects the rights of anyone to live presenting however they want to.

That inclusivity for me is total with the sole exceptions of women only spaces, women only shortlists, women's quotas, women only organisations and women's sport. (Children's activities will, I think, vary by context.)

Thank you everyone who joined in with this discussion in good faith and with respect.

Edited

FWIW, I've found slight soft men can be just as problematic if not more so than brick shithouses. (MASSMALT, obviously)

Sadly just because a man happens to be a loser in the Patriachy stakes, it doesn't necessarily make them any nicer or more sympathetic to women. Sometimes, it just means they feel justified in or masculinised by punching down.

Young women especially are not always aware of this.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 19:43

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 19:28

Happy to start another when it's full!

I didn't, when I started this thread, expect to find anyone able to come up with an argument that would persuade me that someone could be a feminist and also support biological males being in female spaces.

That expectation has not been disappointed.

I am, though, gobsmacked that multiple people declaring that they were born female claim to be feminist while being perfectly prepared to support things that without doubt upset/hurt/harm/disadvantage other women.

I am truly shocked by those women. They certainly don't fit into my definition of a feminist.

I write this as a female who personally would have no problem with sharing spaces with post-surgery males of female stature but who realises two things;

  • that I have no right to give that permission on behalf of other women, and would not dream of doing that
  • that allowing the slight, fine looking man who has been very feminine his whole life into my changing room means I can't keep out the brick shithouse who used to play male rugby and decided in his 40s he's female, and him I really do have a problem with.

Lastly, this thread hasn't yet really talked about what trans inclusive means. I am truly trans inclusive in so far as it reflects the rights of anyone to live presenting however they want to.

That inclusivity for me is total with the sole exceptions of women only spaces, women only shortlists, women's quotas, women only organisations and women's sport. (Children's activities will, I think, vary by context.)

Thank you everyone who joined in with this discussion in good faith and with respect.

Edited

Lastly, this thread hasn't yet really talked about what trans inclusive means. I am truly trans inclusive in so far as it reflects the rights of anyone to live presenting however they want to.

Whereas some people on this thread seem to have a far more limited idea of what 'trans' means and I think are less 'trans inclusive' than the people who are just concerned about women's rights.

Heggettypeg · 08/10/2026 19:30

murasaki · 08/10/2026 16:52

And pregnancy is a universal women's issue, whether it's trying not to be pregnant, wanting to be pregnant, being pregnant, having been pregnant, or not being pregnant and wondering why and finding out. Find me a woman who hasn't experienced one of those.

You can add to that: being one of those people who might get pregnant and want maternity leave some time in the future.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 19:28

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 19:07

Oh. Come on people!! Don’t use up the thread .. the revelation about how to test for genuine male people with transgender identities is coming !!!

At last! I am sure that the world health organisations are going to be very happy to have that test too!

Happy to start another when it's full!

I didn't, when I started this thread, expect to find anyone able to come up with an argument that would persuade me that someone could be a feminist and also support biological males being in female spaces.

That expectation has not been disappointed.

I am, though, gobsmacked that multiple people declaring that they were born female claim to be feminist while being perfectly prepared to support things that without doubt upset/hurt/harm/disadvantage other women.

I am truly shocked by those women. They certainly don't fit into my definition of a feminist.

I write this as a female who personally would have no problem with sharing spaces with post-surgery males of female stature but who realises two things;

  • that I have no right to give that permission on behalf of other women, and would not dream of doing that
  • that allowing the slight, fine looking man who has been very feminine his whole life into my changing room means I can't keep out the brick shithouse who used to play male rugby and decided in his 40s he's female, and him I really do have a problem with.

Lastly, this thread hasn't yet really talked about what trans inclusive means. I am truly trans inclusive in so far as it reflects the rights of anyone to live presenting however they want to.

That inclusivity for me is total with the sole exceptions of women only spaces, women only shortlists, women's quotas, women only organisations and women's sport. (Children's activities will, I think, vary by context.)

Thank you everyone who joined in with this discussion in good faith and with respect.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread