Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 22:15

PremierInnShafter · 07/10/2026 22:01

No, you can't centre males and claim to be a feminist.
Nor can men be feminists.

And my feminism includes all females, whatever their race, their religion, their shoe size, the nasty ones, the nice ones, the funny ones, the weird ones, fat, thin, short, tall, women wearing trousers or a floaty frock.
It encompasses the ones who want to be included & the ones who hate feminists. The trad wives, the single women, the mums and the women in polyamourous communes.
It includes all the women on this thread shilling for transwomen, and it encompasses the women who want to cut their healthy bodies to simluate a male body.

But it doesn't include one single man. Ever.

And this is a hill I will die on.

Me too 👏

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 22:12

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:49

Because they need feminism/ feminist ideology to recognise that their issues are intertwined with misogyny and caused by and large, patriarchy

Edited

So you’re saying men are too thick to know about the patriarchy so they’ll listen to women telling them why they need it? If they will listen tho women about their, why won’t they listen when women tell them to stop raping and killing us?

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 22:08

totino · 07/10/2026 18:57

A rape victim in need should never be left hanging so yes, obviously. If he wants to go. Perhaps he would prefer a service for men, but there are very few, so yes. But I also think the same of a trans woman. If there is a situation where another survivor absolutely cannot be in the same space as a trans woman she also should be accommodated. More funding for rape crisis services would be helpful, but everyone knows that's not coming.

So again, as a feminist, do you prioritise the needs of the woman or the wants of the man. If there are no men’s rape groups, why have men not set them up? If a woman is traumatised by a male presence so has to self exclude from a group that includes men who claim to be women, do you think that is ok? I notice your answer was about the man…. Not very feminist there

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 22:06

PremierInnShafter · 07/10/2026 22:01

No, you can't centre males and claim to be a feminist.
Nor can men be feminists.

And my feminism includes all females, whatever their race, their religion, their shoe size, the nasty ones, the nice ones, the funny ones, the weird ones, fat, thin, short, tall, women wearing trousers or a floaty frock.
It encompasses the ones who want to be included & the ones who hate feminists. The trad wives, the single women, the mums and the women in polyamourous communes.
It includes all the women on this thread shilling for transwomen, and it encompasses the women who want to cut their healthy bodies to simluate a male body.

But it doesn't include one single man. Ever.

And this is a hill I will die on.

I mostly like your post apart from including the reprobates who are trans inclusive, they can and they will die in their own pit of collusion.

PremierInnShafter · 07/10/2026 22:01

No, you can't centre males and claim to be a feminist.
Nor can men be feminists.

And my feminism includes all females, whatever their race, their religion, their shoe size, the nasty ones, the nice ones, the funny ones, the weird ones, fat, thin, short, tall, women wearing trousers or a floaty frock.
It encompasses the ones who want to be included & the ones who hate feminists. The trad wives, the single women, the mums and the women in polyamourous communes.
It includes all the women on this thread shilling for transwomen, and it encompasses the women who want to cut their healthy bodies to simluate a male body.

But it doesn't include one single man. Ever.

And this is a hill I will die on.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 22:00

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 21:59

Oh one more

Men want it to exist so could you really be arsed arguing with them?

Ah yes. And yes, I can be arsed.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:59

Perhaps they could call it femininism instead.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 21:59

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:44

Time to add some updates

gender critical feminists are united with republicans and the far right in wanting to curtail mysterious “rights” that are never quite articulated

we judge whether people are men or women on appearance so there’s no point relying on sex to segregate spaces

gender critical feminists are a bit like the taliban

I believe my made up idea of why men can actually be women and always have been is morally and rationally superior to respecting women’s boundaries around men and their privacy and dignity

Oh one more

Men want it to exist so could you really be arsed arguing with them?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/10/2026 21:57

Going back to the OP...

There's a few perspectives to consider.

  1. principles vs practical. A woman whose focus is on practical support of women may say TWAW. Taken to its logical endpoint (womanhood is a mental feature, being female is not necessary) I think this is incompatible with Feminism unless one changes Feminism in a fundamental way to the detriment of the people for whom it was originally conceived (see point 2). If she was inundated with TW to the point it disrupted her support of women she might have to rethink, but while the actual TW using her support number zero to one she's going to accept the odd TW. I would still recognise her support of women is an act of practical Feminism even if I think her position on TW taken to its logical endpoint is not compatible with Feminism.
  2. Female vs Feminine. Some people want to change the definition of woman to people of either sex who exhibit, or feel aligned with, character traits culturally seen as pertaining to women. Whether this is a reasonable concept in its own right or not, it doesn't take away the reality of sex, it just takes away its name to plonk it onto something else. So if you condider that Feminsm follows the word woman, then sure, you have trans inclusive Feminism. But it's not really anything to do with what was previously known as Feminism. The irony of course is that having a worldview that encompasses both the constructs of feminity, the reality of sex, and the tensions between them is absolutely a Feminist perspective. But it's a perspective that you can only have if you recognise the validity of women's existence as female people separate from "femininity"
  3. Feminist Analysis vs Feminism. Feminist analysis absolutely has to consider men. We can't make sense of the position and construction and exploitatation and marginalisation women in patriarchy without considering the mirror of that, the position and construction and expectations and social enforcement of men's roles. But Feminism, while shining a light and offering a way forward for men, is ultimately about freeing women. We can't solve their roles for them, they have to work it out for themselves. Otherwise we are just playing out the same old "women's job is to make it ok for men" trope.
  4. A label vs a thing.Whether you call it "Feminism" or not, a movement to answer the oppression and exploitation of the female half of humanity is justified. Arguing about whether it's "Feminism" or not is fetishing the word over the people. If you remember which people you are focusing on, there is no confusion, no complication.
Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:47

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:42

lol not you the one you quoted

I’ve just realised after reading your other replies 🤣🤣

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:46

totino · 07/10/2026 20:10

Of course they do, and that's a very difficult thing to go through. However, if you give a treatment to 100 people, and 2 end up regretting it, but 98 are helped by it, it's not right to deny the other 98 people. Of course diagnostic should be improved. And the best way to learn more is actually to let more people who want to, transition. Especially socially transition, because the ones who really don't feel it will dip out.

Worth mentioning that what detransitioners feel is what trans people feel when they don't transition. Being stuck in a body that's wrong for you.

The thing is, those 98 people aren’t being ‘helped’ by ‘treatment’ because there’s no treatment that can extract a female from a male body or vice versa. So the treatment fails.

Treatment that allows the people who mistakenly believe they’re in the wrong body to understand and accept that it’s physically impossible to be in any body other than the one they’ve got is the only treatment that should be on offer.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:44

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 18:44

Summary of arguments for the existence of “trans inclusive feminism” so far:

Some dubious postmodernist academics say it’s a thing

trans women are women and because of that they’re not any threat to women at all, that’s men

”gender” is the root of women’s oppression, not “biosex”

some people on Facebook don’t like mumsnet

you’re bigots, so there

Shon Faye says so too

the patriarchy is the root of oppression and it has nothing to do with sex

Time to add some updates

gender critical feminists are united with republicans and the far right in wanting to curtail mysterious “rights” that are never quite articulated

we judge whether people are men or women on appearance so there’s no point relying on sex to segregate spaces

gender critical feminists are a bit like the taliban

I believe my made up idea of why men can actually be women and always have been is morally and rationally superior to respecting women’s boundaries around men and their privacy and dignity

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:42

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:41

I’m not a man. Female through and through.

lol not you the one you quoted

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:41

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:38

Said by a man

I’m not a man. Female through and through.

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:38

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:35

Oooh, you’re so edgy!

Said by a man

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:35

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 21:29

Mhmm you sure? Feels like that's a losing battle and tbh, I have no issue with calling someone a man or woman if they have the 'wrong' genitals because those words have always been applied based on appearances anyway. So, I can also suspend disbelief if someone isn't quite passing, for the sake of kindness. And it looks like that's what society is deciding, even while some drag their feet over it.

So.. focus on hardcore, inarguable facts only. Those genitals (and strength etc) only really matter when we're talking about private, unsupervised spaces. And then they really matter. And if I walk into one more fecking public bathroom, about to floss my teeth, pull my knickers out my ass or get changed or do a full-body mirror check, only to stop when I spot cameras installed because these are now penis&vagina bathrooms, I will go fecking ape shit.

Oooh, you’re so edgy!

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 21:35

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 21:30

They agree with you that transgender people are inauthentic and you are absolutely united in wanting to curtail their rights.

What rights are being curtailed?

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 21:34

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 21:29

Mhmm you sure? Feels like that's a losing battle and tbh, I have no issue with calling someone a man or woman if they have the 'wrong' genitals because those words have always been applied based on appearances anyway. So, I can also suspend disbelief if someone isn't quite passing, for the sake of kindness. And it looks like that's what society is deciding, even while some drag their feet over it.

So.. focus on hardcore, inarguable facts only. Those genitals (and strength etc) only really matter when we're talking about private, unsupervised spaces. And then they really matter. And if I walk into one more fecking public bathroom, about to floss my teeth, pull my knickers out my ass or get changed or do a full-body mirror check, only to stop when I spot cameras installed because these are now penis&vagina bathrooms, I will go fecking ape shit.

I’m not going to just roll over and give in to a group of men who want to dismantle woman’s spaces and services.

You do what you want 🙄

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:33

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:41

And if you don't understand that trans inclusive feminists don't see trans women as men, then you aren't really part of the conversation.

Aaah… the ‘shut up pesky woman’ comment. Got it. Anyone who doesn’t see a transwoman as a man is not worth listening to. If they deny such a basic fact, what else do they deny - the earth is round, water is wet, gravity?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:33

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:31

Can you tell me what curtailing their rights actually looks like in practical terms.

Yes, which “rights” would those be?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:33

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 21:29

Mhmm you sure? Feels like that's a losing battle and tbh, I have no issue with calling someone a man or woman if they have the 'wrong' genitals because those words have always been applied based on appearances anyway. So, I can also suspend disbelief if someone isn't quite passing, for the sake of kindness. And it looks like that's what society is deciding, even while some drag their feet over it.

So.. focus on hardcore, inarguable facts only. Those genitals (and strength etc) only really matter when we're talking about private, unsupervised spaces. And then they really matter. And if I walk into one more fecking public bathroom, about to floss my teeth, pull my knickers out my ass or get changed or do a full-body mirror check, only to stop when I spot cameras installed because these are now penis&vagina bathrooms, I will go fecking ape shit.

You do you.

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:31

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 21:30

They agree with you that transgender people are inauthentic and you are absolutely united in wanting to curtail their rights.

Can you tell me what curtailing their rights actually looks like in practical terms.

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 21:30

JanesLittleGirl · 07/10/2026 15:04

The far-right, Trump Republicans and Christian fundamentalists are not my allies. I am gender critical. They are not. They have far more in common with the genderists than they do with me.

They agree with you that transgender people are inauthentic and you are absolutely united in wanting to curtail their rights.

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 21:29

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:59

No we don’t. When nonsense is being spouted, we have to push back on it firmly and reiterate the actual meaning of words.

We do not have to change our vocabulary because a small group of scientifically illiterate men want us to.

Mhmm you sure? Feels like that's a losing battle and tbh, I have no issue with calling someone a man or woman if they have the 'wrong' genitals because those words have always been applied based on appearances anyway. So, I can also suspend disbelief if someone isn't quite passing, for the sake of kindness. And it looks like that's what society is deciding, even while some drag their feet over it.

So.. focus on hardcore, inarguable facts only. Those genitals (and strength etc) only really matter when we're talking about private, unsupervised spaces. And then they really matter. And if I walk into one more fecking public bathroom, about to floss my teeth, pull my knickers out my ass or get changed or do a full-body mirror check, only to stop when I spot cameras installed because these are now penis&vagina bathrooms, I will go fecking ape shit.

Soontobe60 · 07/10/2026 21:25

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Hahahaha!