Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:32

How about Imane Khelif?

If there's a disadvantage rights balancing is required. Its a principle. Now go see if you can join the dots.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:33

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:31

You're almost there. Male puberty confers an advantage, so men have to be excluded, even if they pretend to be women.

So they are men.

I just said its circumstance dependant. Do you understand what that means?

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 07/10/2026 23:33

Coconutter24 · 07/10/2026 08:56

Why would transmen want to be included with women things? They want to live as a man so should go do that.

Unfortunately for that idea, “live as a man” (or “live as a woman”) is pretty meaningless.

In many aspects of life there’s no difference between a woman doing something & a man doing something. Men & women do not live so differently as all that. As Germaine Greer says somewhere, the only job a woman can’t do is sperm donor & the only job a man can’t do is wetnurse.

But when sex matters it really does matter, & women who claims to be trans & women who don’t claim to be trans are alike female.

Feminism is about analysing & addressing the oppression of the female sex as a class by reason of their sex, & works to liberate us from it.

Women who claim to be trans often do not want to be a part of that sex class, for many reasons.

I recall a TiF once telling me she had “identified into male privilege”: about the least feminist thing a woman could believe, besides being of course a fantasy (I think what she had actually done, or tried to do, was to identify into trans privilege, as part of the new sacred caste).

But when sex matters it will matter for them too, & while women may abandon feminism, feminism cannot abandon them.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:32

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:29

Your'e almost there. If in a particular context if there's a disadvantage proportionality as in rights balancing occurs.

An example would be sex segregation in elite sports. But that might not apply for sports for prepubescent children. See how sex isn't the the defining factor but evidence of a disadvantage is?

Edited

How about Imane Khelif?

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:31

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:29

Your'e almost there. If in a particular context if there's a disadvantage proportionality as in rights balancing occurs.

An example would be sex segregation in elite sports. But that might not apply for sports for prepubescent children. See how sex isn't the the defining factor but evidence of a disadvantage is?

Edited

You're almost there. Male puberty confers an advantage, so men have to be excluded, even if they pretend to be women.

So they are men.

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:30

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:28

Though not the most original.

Well no, and we do look forward to a new argument that might convince, but oddly it never comes. It's like Billy Bunter's postal order.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:29

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:25

So, if they're women, why is there a disadvantage occurring? There only is because they are men.

Come now, you know this.

Your'e almost there. If in a particular context if there's a disadvantage proportionality as in rights balancing occurs.

An example would be sex segregation in elite sports. But that might not apply for sports for prepubescent children. See how sex isn't the the defining factor but evidence of a disadvantage is?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:28

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:27

I actually think Chopping may be the funniest one we've had so far.

Though not the most original.

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:27

I actually think Chopping may be the funniest one we've had so far.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:27

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:25

So, if they're women, why is there a disadvantage occurring? There only is because they are men.

Come now, you know this.

She does.

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:25

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:24

By doing so, the acknowledgement is that TW are not women.

It does no such thing all it acknowledges is rights balancing where disadvantage occurs.

So, if they're women, why is there a disadvantage occurring? There only is because they are men.

Come now, you know this.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:23

What is self evidently false?

”it’s a negation of rights”

“If you lump them in with women”

”women have no right to spaces away from men”

”they are men”

?

I don't reply to nonsensical posts from the peanut gallery

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:24

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:22

Really? Actually that move towards sanity is because women were losing rights, the right to female sport and that needed to be rectified. By doing so, the acknowledgement is that TW are not women.

Rights had been lost, we're now getting our stuff back. Bit by bit.

By doing so, the acknowledgement is that TW are not women.

It does no such thing all it acknowledges is rights balancing where disadvantage occurs.

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:24

Has anyone got a wet paper bag for Chopping to fail to fight their way out of?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:23

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:19

That's self evidently false given the restructuring of sports & proportionality exemption law that is widespread in western nations.

What is self evidently false?

”it’s a negation of rights”

“If you lump them in with women”

”women have no right to spaces away from men”

”they are men”

?

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:22

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:19

That's self evidently false given the restructuring of sports & proportionality exemption law that is widespread in western nations.

Really? Actually that move towards sanity is because women were losing rights, the right to female sport and that needed to be rectified. By doing so, the acknowledgement is that TW are not women.

Rights had been lost, we're now getting our stuff back. Bit by bit.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:21

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 23:21

Oh dear me.
That's the cue for me to leave this echo chamber for tonight😴

Owwww my brain hurtz…..

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 23:21

Oh dear me.
That's the cue for me to leave this echo chamber for tonight😴

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:19

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:12

I think it is a negation of rights. As if you lump them in with women, women have no right to spaces away from men, and they are men.

That's self evidently false given the restructuring of sports & proportionality exemption law that is widespread in western nations.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:17

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 23:09

Agreeing that trans women are women isn't a negation of rights

No, it's biological illiteracy.

The rest of your argument falls apart at that point.

You want the right of a man who identifies as a woman to be in women only spaces to override the legal rights of women who don't want him there..

That is not feminism.

Edited

You don't understand the argument or don't want to understand it because if you did you would explain how it falls apart….but you can't so that's why you are pivoting to the juvenile retort of 'but biology'.

Again, sex isn't an automatic entitlement to rights because rights are circumstance dependant.

If you actually believed what you claim that the female sex trumps all 'cause male violence/advantage GC's would be demanding separate spaces where all instances of potential male violence & disadvantage might occur but they don't AND can't because competing rights management underpins our social structure.

Your argument is incoherent at best.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 23:15

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 23:06

I often quote my credentials as a women’s right activist in terms of where i come from, all over this shop, but just want to say i walk amongst giants, and and am grateful for you all holding the line, whilst i and others slept.

I'm interested in your mining community background but it's a conversation for another time so as not to derail this thread.
Also we have to bear in mind the AI bot scrapers

Tears0fTheMushroom · 07/10/2026 23:15

Naunet · 07/10/2026 15:20

Are there any situations whatsoever, where you believe a transwoman shouldnt be treated as women? For example, if a rape victim requested a female nurse or doctor for an intimate examination, because she has PTSD, would you be happy to send a transwoman to perform this?
Or if a man rapes a woman and then before hes sent to prison, claims hes trans, would you put him in a womans prison?

At what point does the man become a woman, in your mind? As soon as he says it?

That would be never. Ole Mouldy doesn't believe it any more than we do.

Heggettypeg · 07/10/2026 23:14

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 22:49

yes, they are also echo chambers

An echo chamber is a place where you hear no voice that disagrees with you. This forum is not one. There is constant argument, and you don't get banned for arguing per se, though you can for personal abuse.

I believe there are forums on Reddit and other places where you can get banned for posting anything, however politely, that doesn't follow an approved line on certain topics. That would fit the definition of an echo chamber.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 23:12

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:12

I think it is a negation of rights. As if you lump them in with women, women have no right to spaces away from men, and they are men.

Exactly.

murasaki · 07/10/2026 23:12

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 23:09

Agreeing that trans women are women isn't a negation of rights

No, it's biological illiteracy.

The rest of your argument falls apart at that point.

You want the right of a man who identifies as a woman to be in women only spaces to override the legal rights of women who don't want him there..

That is not feminism.

Edited

I think it is a negation of rights. As if you lump them in with women, women have no right to spaces away from men, and they are men.

Swipe left for the next trending thread