Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:05

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 07:50

Correct. Women have a number of sex based rights enshrined on law in this country. Men who believe they can change into women are campaigning to share those hard won rights. It's your right to campaign in that way. I sincerely hope you never win because by doing so you would remove the existing rights of women to have single sex spaces, single sex shortlists, single sex clubs and single sex sport, all of which were granted because of circumstances that made them right and circumstances which have not changed.

Firstly, I not a man. I'm a cis woman.

Secondly, that you assume disagreement can be only sex based is what's called internalised misogyny…& that's hardly feminist.

Thirdly, explaining how rights are apportioned which you finally acknowledge isn't a repudiation of current law or anti feminist. On the contrary its feminist to believe in sexual equality not sexual superiority when it comes to how rights are apportioned.

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim.
Indeed you have repeatedly where you have assumed biology decides rights when in fact it's disadvantage that does.

Jesus yes, sorry, I forgot you were actually a woman.

Do you have trans relatives? Women with the strength of conviction that a man can turn into the sex you are generally seem to.

Secondly, that you assume disagreement can be only sex based is what's called internalised misogyny…& that's hardly feminist.

Again, not a term I have ever used.

Thirdly, explaining how rights are apportioned which you finally acknowledge isn't a repudiation of current law or anti feminist. On the contrary its feminist to believe in sexual equality not sexual superiority when it comes to how rights are apportioned.

Believing that some sex based rights need protecting is not a belief in sexual superiority. That's a bizarre clam to make when it's for in physical inferiority and vulnerability.

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim.
Indeed you have repeatedly where you have assumed biology decides rights when in fact it's disadvantage that does.

That is tautological nonsense when it is biological sex that creates the disadvantage which require additional rights to be enshrined in law.

OP posts:
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:01

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:48

You keep banging on and on about proportionality.

In what way is it proportional to demand that the very, very many women who do not want to share (or cannot for religious or personal reasons) changing spaces with people with a male physique or who went through male puberty should be forced to do so because of the wishes of a tiny number of female identified men?

Rights balancing (proportionality) requires a disadvantage. While some may consider discomfort a justified disadvantage, discomfort works both ways as in trans women may feel discomfort in mens toilets. It's also a very subjective term because individuals have different perspectives on discomfort. I personally feel discomfort as many do changing in front of any strangers regardless of sex. Does this common view entitle us to private cubicles? How does that work practically.

Discomfort being so subjective makes it a logistical nightmare impossible to cater for so as a standard/principle its not practical that gender critical feminists don't seem to understand the consequences of in that once a principle is established it also needs to apply broadly.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:59

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:52

'Woman' is a biological & sociological concept. In other words, its got both social & biological associations whether you agree with that or not. So trans women are categorised as a sub group of women based on their social association to the concept of woman. Again, when it comes to structuring society that doesn't mean they get treated the same as natal women because by virtue of not being exactly the same creates differences in priorities. At this point, rights balancing occurs to ensure fairness.

Another example is adults & minors. Whilst they are both categorically human they don't get treated the same because of rights balancing.

So trans women are categorised as a sub group of women based on their social association to the concept of woman.

Only in your world. The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

Women are not a construct.

Women are a biological group with two X chromosomes.

A man cannot know if he feels like a woman, because he isn't one.

OP posts:
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 07:50

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:39

You don't understand the argument or don't want to understand it because if you did you would explain how it falls apart….but you can't so that's why you are pivoting to the juvenile retort of 'but biology'.

You have some lack of self awareness there calling me use of the fact of human biology "juvenile".

Again, sex isn't an automatic entitlement to rights because rights are circumstance dependant.

Correct. Women have a number of sex based rights enshrined on law in this country. Men who believe they can change into women are campaigning to share those hard won rights. It's your right to campaign in that way. I sincerely hope you never win because by doing so you would remove the existing rights of women to have single sex spaces, single sex shortlists, single sex clubs and single sex sport, all of which were granted because of circumstances that made them right and circumstances which have not changed.

If you actually believed what you claim that the female sex trumps all 'cause male violence/advantage GC's would be demanding separate spaces where all instances of potential male violence & disadvantage might occur but they don't AND can't because competing rights management underpins our social structure

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim. You claim that we are unreasonable and then demonstrate that we are not unreasonable by describing the demands that we could make but we don't make because they would be unreasonable.

And then you have the nerve to call my level of argument incoherent.

You begin to sound more and more like a group of little boys stamping their feet and crying "it's not fair!" because you can't get what you want.

Correct. Women have a number of sex based rights enshrined on law in this country. Men who believe they can change into women are campaigning to share those hard won rights. It's your right to campaign in that way. I sincerely hope you never win because by doing so you would remove the existing rights of women to have single sex spaces, single sex shortlists, single sex clubs and single sex sport, all of which were granted because of circumstances that made them right and circumstances which have not changed.

Firstly, I not a man. I'm a cis woman.

Secondly, that you assume disagreement can be only sex based is what's called internalised misogyny…& that's hardly feminist.

Thirdly, explaining how rights are apportioned which you finally acknowledge isn't a repudiation of current law or anti feminist. On the contrary its feminist to believe in sexual equality not sexual superiority when it comes to how rights are apportioned.

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim.
Indeed you have repeatedly where you have assumed biology decides rights when in fact it's disadvantage that does.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:48

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:37

You think proportionality law is wrong? As in this? Why?

27
(1)
A person does not contravene section 29, so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing a service only to persons of one sex if—
(a)
any of the conditions in sub-paragraphs (2) to (7) is satisfied, and
(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
(2)
The condition is that only persons of that sex have need of the service.
(3)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is also provided jointly for persons of both sexes, and
(b)
the service would be insufficiently effective were it only to be provided jointly.
(4)
The condition is that—
(a)
a joint service for persons of both sexes would be less effective, and
(b)
the extent to which the service is required by persons of each sex makes it not reasonably practicable to provide separate services.
(5)
The condition is that the service is provided at a place which is, or is part of—
(a)
a hospital, or
(b)
another establishment for persons requiring special care, supervision or attention.
(6)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is provided for, or is likely to be used by, two or more persons at the same time, and
(b)
the circumstances are such that a person of one sex might reasonably object to the presence of a person of the opposite sex.
(7)
The condition is that—
(a)
there is likely to be physical contact between a person (A) to whom the service is provided and another person (B), and
(b)
B might reasonably object if A were not of the same sex as B.
(8)
This paragraph applies to a person exercising a public function in relation to the provision of a service as it applies to the person providing the service.

You keep banging on and on about proportionality.

In what way is it proportional to demand that the very, very many women who do not want to share (or cannot for religious or personal reasons) changing spaces with people with a male physique or who went through male puberty should be forced to do so because of the wishes of a tiny number of female identified men?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:39

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:17

You don't understand the argument or don't want to understand it because if you did you would explain how it falls apart….but you can't so that's why you are pivoting to the juvenile retort of 'but biology'.

Again, sex isn't an automatic entitlement to rights because rights are circumstance dependant.

If you actually believed what you claim that the female sex trumps all 'cause male violence/advantage GC's would be demanding separate spaces where all instances of potential male violence & disadvantage might occur but they don't AND can't because competing rights management underpins our social structure.

Your argument is incoherent at best.

You don't understand the argument or don't want to understand it because if you did you would explain how it falls apart….but you can't so that's why you are pivoting to the juvenile retort of 'but biology'.

You have some lack of self awareness there calling me use of the fact of human biology "juvenile".

Again, sex isn't an automatic entitlement to rights because rights are circumstance dependant.

Correct. Women have a number of sex based rights enshrined on law in this country. Men who believe they can change into women are campaigning to share those hard won rights. It's your right to campaign in that way. I sincerely hope you never win because by doing so you would remove the existing rights of women to have single sex spaces, single sex shortlists, single sex clubs and single sex sport, all of which were granted because of circumstances that made them right and circumstances which have not changed.

If you actually believed what you claim that the female sex trumps all 'cause male violence/advantage GC's would be demanding separate spaces where all instances of potential male violence & disadvantage might occur but they don't AND can't because competing rights management underpins our social structure

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim. You claim that we are unreasonable and then demonstrate that we are not unreasonable by describing the demands that we could make but we don't make because they would be unreasonable.

And then you have the nerve to call my level of argument incoherent.

You begin to sound more and more like a group of little boys stamping their feet and crying "it's not fair!" because you can't get what you want.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 07:28

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 07:11

With phantom limbs, the limb once existed.

How is that relevant to this scenarios where the body has never been the opposite sex?

It is another appropriation of language and terminology to attempt give a concept that is impossible, credibility and that gives it power.

No male person ever can know that what they perceive as being ‘female’ is anything like what is materially experienced by any female person. They just want it to be so, and some people will believe it even when it is impossible.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 07:23

It is quite interesting to see some extreme transgender rights supporters talk about male people with transgender identities as ‘identifying with’.

we have seen on this thread that some transpeople might describe their identifying as the opposite sex as the brain mapping the body differently. We have posters using terminology like ‘identifying with associations to social categories’, we had one male poster in the past as telling us he simply ‘was’ and that somehow he was passive in the experience where people identified him as a woman while ignoring all the effort he took to present as female.

What all of these types of soundbites explanations miss is that those male people who claim to be female are using their person perceptions and their personal interpretation of what they believe female people to be. The logic can only ever be that they are overlaying their personal expectations of being female over their experience and they decided that they match.

But they only ever match to their interpretation of what it is to be female never what materially it is to be female. So, they do indeed ‘identify with’ and I think that these soundbites highlight the dissonance.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 07:11

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/10/2026 01:25

I think he's talking about brain mapping. Thing is, the brain maps the body you have not some imaginary body you think you should have. That's how we get phantom limbs in amputees. The map the brain holds of the body is remarkably stable and accurate so it KNOWS that limb should be there. It doesn't get it wrong and scan for body parts that never existed though. The body builds the map in the brain, not the other way around.

Edited

With phantom limbs, the limb once existed.

How is that relevant to this scenarios where the body has never been the opposite sex?

Chersfrozenface · 08/10/2026 06:50

Which gender roles are important? Which ones make you a woman or a man?

Are cooking, sewing and knitting female gender roles? Does that mean that when my husband cooks our evening meal, he is a woman? Is Kaffe Fassett a woman? Or the army officer who was a finalist on the Great British Sewing Bee? Or a tailor in Savile Row or Eton?

Or to take some examples from among my acquaintances, is the woman who does plumbing work in our area a man? Or the one who bashes people with a (blunt) sword in medieval re-enactments? Or the one who is an aircraft mechanic in the RAF or the other one who does the same job in an airline maintenance facility?

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 05:15

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:16

But its gender critical proponents that claim the commonalities are socially constructed stereotypes. So you already know what those are.

Noooo. Because if you’re waffling about ‘gender roles”, which are socially constructed, then they are not commonalities.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 05:13

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 22:50

Getting back to the point of this thread:

After 21 pages I remain of the view that you cannot be a feminist while you support biological men in female only spaces.

You don't seem to understand how this contradicts the fundamental principle feminism was predicated on which was equality in individual liberty that enables self determination. In other words individual liberty applies to all as in sexual equality not sexual superiority. Sex only comes into it if there is a disadvantage as a result of competing rights whereby rights are balanced according to the disadvantage that is circumstance dependant.

And this principle applies broadly as in all groups are equal but disadvantages in individual circumstances dictate how rights are apportioned.

Agreeing that trans women are women isn't a negation of rights balancing rather an acknowledgement that they are socially categorised as women. But social categorisation isn't an automatic entitlement to be treated the same as natal women…this is where rights balancing is relevant to adjudicating rights disputes.

But if you are saying TIM are only women in some circumstances…. You are saying they are not women. What do an adult human female and a male claiming to be a woman have uncommon thst make both of them women?

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/10/2026 01:25

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 18:54

The brain knows whether you are a man or a woman?

What does this even mean?

How does the brain ‘know’ something in total opposition to the reproductive system?

I think he's talking about brain mapping. Thing is, the brain maps the body you have not some imaginary body you think you should have. That's how we get phantom limbs in amputees. The map the brain holds of the body is remarkably stable and accurate so it KNOWS that limb should be there. It doesn't get it wrong and scan for body parts that never existed though. The body builds the map in the brain, not the other way around.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 00:49

But then, I’m always posting for the lurkers.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 00:49

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:48

The context is access to public spaces/resources not personal spaces.

Nice dodge 👍

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:48

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 00:45

How about when Ted Bundy pretended to have a broken arm? If he’d said he was also a woman, would that make him safe? “Disadvantaged” is in the eye of the beholder, no?

The context is access to public spaces/resources not personal spaces.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 00:45

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:35

Can you specify a situation?

How about when Ted Bundy pretended to have a broken arm? If he’d said he was also a woman, would that make him safe? “Disadvantaged” is in the eye of the beholder, no?

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 00:40

Ive been talking to trans identifying people for years now, all of them make a more compelling argument than choppy. And they mostly say 'because I want to!'

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 00:36

It’s all such nonsense.

newrubylane · 08/10/2026 00:35

StandingDeskDisco · 07/10/2026 10:40

men hold more structural and societal power and that has led to ongoing oppression.

I find it interesting that you didn't identify the object of the oppression in that sentence. Who is it that is being oppressed?

Looking at it through a trad-left lens, I would add a 'some' at the beginning:
'Some men hold more structural and societal power...'
And they oppress everyone else - both male and female.

If your concern is mainly with who is doing the oppressing, and dismantling the tools and mechanisms they use to oppress others, it might be easy to lose sight of the importance of analysing who are the people being oppressed, and how and why is each group being oppressed.
I think some modern ways of thinking tend to do this, by lumping all oppressed people together, be it black, disabled, mentally ill, women, trans, gay, or whatever. From there it is just a small step to oppression being something you can identify into.

Traditional schools of feminism are concerned with exactly one class of people who are being oppressed: biological women.
Within this, there can be more or less concern with intersecting factors of oppression such as race and disability, but it is still about biological females.

I wonder one of the roots of the idea that 'feminism' can be about anyone who is being oppressed by structurally dominant males, is that we as a society have lost sight of the traditional leftist analysis of social class and the way power operates within capitalism.
If you are a man feeling oppressed and have no notion of trad-left analysis, you may latch on to 'feminism' as the thing that you use to fight male power.

I was going to pose the question in answer to the same post - define 'man', and explain how and why they hold more structural and societal power'?

But actually, your point is really interesting. Some idea that feeling oppressed by men is what makes you a woman?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:35

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 00:27

When men are disadvantaged they should be treated as if they are women?

Can you specify a situation?

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 00:27

When men are disadvantaged they should be treated as if they are women?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:18

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 00:15

The idea of 'sociology' men and women is just different language for trans identifying people, rather than being a concept men and women experience.

We dont treat women who arent trans as sociologically men, regardless of what they look like or their behaviour. They are women.

You are basically saying there are biological women and men, and trans identifying people. But that doesnt explain why you think the trans identifying people should be treated as the opposite sex.

There isnt a real category of sociological women which included both males and females.

But that doesnt explain why you think the trans identifying people should be treated as the opposite sex.

I already explained repeatedly that's dependant on disadvantage in a particular circumstance. Disadvantage is the determining factor for treatment not sex.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:16

murasaki · 08/10/2026 00:12

I didn't use the word stereotype at all, I just asked what I have in common with TW that I don't with all men. You are yet to answer.

But its gender critical proponents that claim the commonalities are socially constructed stereotypes. So you already know what those are.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 00:15

The idea of 'sociology' men and women is just different language for trans identifying people, rather than being a concept men and women experience.

We dont treat women who arent trans as sociologically men, regardless of what they look like or their behaviour. They are women.

You are basically saying there are biological women and men, and trans identifying people. But that doesnt explain why you think the trans identifying people should be treated as the opposite sex.

There isnt a real category of sociological women which included both males and females.