Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 08:46

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:29

Let's not forget that disadvantage is not enough for a special exemption as it must also:

(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

Do the circumstances you describe meet this condition? We don't know yet for sure because these cases haven't been tested in court but they seem to be more about personal discomfort.

So I'll ask again why you believe that the rights of a tiny number of men who identify as women trump the rights of those women who would be disadvantaged.

Because that's how rights balancing works. Numbers don't come into & if they did if its only a tiny number of men then its only a tiny inconvenience.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.

Um, this is a discussion forum not the floor of parliament….get over yourself.

Do the circumstances you describe meet this condition? We don't know yet for sure because these cases haven't been tested in court

Why?

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:44

FlirtswithRhinos posted a great post on another thread:

"Yes absolutely draw a difference.
A long time ago, but probably in the depths of FWR somewhere, I noted that danger of taking on someone else's cause for them is that you can fight for them, you can amplify their voice, you can hold the line for them, but you cannot compromise for them because it's not your fight to say what they can or can't accept in the interests of finding a solution. So, allies tend to be more extreme that the people for whom they are fighting.
And in a movement like Genderism, where you have I guess at least 1000 allies shouting about trans rights for each actual trans person, that becomes a big deal. Because most of the people driving this on the Genderist side now are only empowered to fight, not to compromise.
And then if they have also put a heavy slug of their own identity into being "a person who is compassionate / sophisticated enough to truly believe that TWAW / TMAM"... well. Those people have every reason to dig in and no reason in the world to soften."

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:43

@Choppingwoodcarryingwater

Because that's how rights balancing works. Numbers don't come into & if they did if its only a tiny number of men then its only a tiny inconvenience.

Numbers don't come into it? Of course they do. I don't understand how you can live in a modern society and not see that. But it's a convenient way of failing to answer the question, I'll give you that.

It isn't only a tiny inconvenience. The legal right of any one man who may go into one changing room once a year affects every woman in every town who doesn't want a man there every time she wants to use single sex facilities with a guarantee there will be no man in there.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:41

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:35

I have no trans family members. I simply enjoy discussion & debate about current affairs.

Mmm hmmm. You’d think you would be better at it in that case.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:39

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:36

the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

Is used to justify why single sex provision is needed.

If it isn't the service has to be mixed sex.

You seem to be saying that the provider need to justify why it should be single sex, then justify why trans identifying men should be excluded? But you acknowledge that these men are male?

You seem to believe that these men are male, but sometimes dont count as male for single sex spaces?

I think Chopping has an old copy of EHRC guidelines because that’s very much what the line was in the past. Not now though, the SC judgment clarified that.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:37

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 07:23

It is quite interesting to see some extreme transgender rights supporters talk about male people with transgender identities as ‘identifying with’.

we have seen on this thread that some transpeople might describe their identifying as the opposite sex as the brain mapping the body differently. We have posters using terminology like ‘identifying with associations to social categories’, we had one male poster in the past as telling us he simply ‘was’ and that somehow he was passive in the experience where people identified him as a woman while ignoring all the effort he took to present as female.

What all of these types of soundbites explanations miss is that those male people who claim to be female are using their person perceptions and their personal interpretation of what they believe female people to be. The logic can only ever be that they are overlaying their personal expectations of being female over their experience and they decided that they match.

But they only ever match to their interpretation of what it is to be female never what materially it is to be female. So, they do indeed ‘identify with’ and I think that these soundbites highlight the dissonance.

Great post.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:36

the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

Is used to justify why single sex provision is needed.

If it isn't the service has to be mixed sex.

You seem to be saying that the provider need to justify why it should be single sex, then justify why trans identifying men should be excluded? But you acknowledge that these men are male?

You seem to believe that these men are male, but sometimes dont count as male for single sex spaces?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:35

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:33

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.
Um, this is a discussion forum not the floor of parliament….get over yourself.

That would be a "no" then.

Can you answer my question about whether you have trans family members, it's your right not to of course, but it's often relevant in these discussions?

I have no trans family members. I simply enjoy discussion & debate about current affairs.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:33

Another question that @Choppingwoodcarryingwater has never answered is - what are women supposed to have in common with ‘transwomen’ (but not other men) that makes us coherent category?

Much less a category so important that it supersedes sex?

Because I can’t think of a single thing

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:33

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:21

You should replace the word discomfort with anxiety.

It has the same range but at the higher end it becomes a clinically recognised disadvantage.

Anxiety, sometimes extreme anxiety, is what men who identify as women are causing women by using female only spaces.

Edited

Some people experience extreme anxiety being around people in general. Are you suggesting society is responsible to cater for their privacy everywhere?

As I said before, the GC movement doesn’t understand how principles work.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:33

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:29

Let's not forget that disadvantage is not enough for a special exemption as it must also:

(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

Do the circumstances you describe meet this condition? We don't know yet for sure because these cases haven't been tested in court but they seem to be more about personal discomfort.

So I'll ask again why you believe that the rights of a tiny number of men who identify as women trump the rights of those women who would be disadvantaged.

Because that's how rights balancing works. Numbers don't come into & if they did if its only a tiny number of men then its only a tiny inconvenience.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.

Um, this is a discussion forum not the floor of parliament….get over yourself.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.
Um, this is a discussion forum not the floor of parliament….get over yourself.

That would be a "no" then.

Can you answer my question about whether you have trans family members, it's your right not to of course, but it's often relevant in these discussions?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:31

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:09

You are confusing 'female' with 'woman'. Female is a sex category. Woman is both a sociological & sex category because of social associations.

The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

But they don't really on the whole because if they did they wouldn't continue to perpetuate them by expressing sex typical behaviours & most men & women do this to some degree. That you are in denial of this reality doesn't do your credibility much justice particularly given its a centrepiece of gender critical feminism. Do you even understand your own ideology?

I didn't even use the word female.

Female is also an adjective and "feminine", female-ness, is very much a social construct.

Woman is a biological fact of carrying two X chromosomes and no Y.

You define "woman" as a set of behaviours and feelings, that not all women will share.

I can assure you that the lack of understanding is not on my side of this discussion.

OP posts:
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:29

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:17

Let's forget discomfort for the moment because it's impossible to define.

There are Jewish women and Moslem women, and no doubt others, who are prohibited by their faith or culture from being semi clothed in areas where there are men. To access sporting facilities, these women need women only changing rooms and women only swim sessions.

There are rape victims who have clinically observable PTSD who require the same thing. They also have a requirement for rape support centres where they know they will not meet male people.

By sticking to the current law, that males should use male or gender neutral facilities, nobody is prevented from those activities.

By allowing males into those places women are disadvantaged.

So I'll ask again why you believe that the rights of a tiny number of men who identify as women trump the rights of those women who would be disadvantaged.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.

Edited

Let's not forget that disadvantage is not enough for a special exemption as it must also:

(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

Do the circumstances you describe meet this condition? We don't know yet for sure because these cases haven't been tested in court but they seem to be more about personal discomfort.

So I'll ask again why you believe that the rights of a tiny number of men who identify as women trump the rights of those women who would be disadvantaged.

Because that's how rights balancing works. Numbers don't come into & if they did if its only a tiny number of men then its only a tiny inconvenience.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.

Um, this is a discussion forum not the floor of parliament….get over yourself.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:29

In the Equality Act, the act used to allow many single sex spaces, a woman is defined as a female of any age. The SC clarified that sex means biological sex, not sex acquired via a GRC.

So the idea that female and women means different things is not true.

You may not understand it, but you are attempting to create a new class of people - social man and women.

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 08:23

Chersfrozenface · 08/10/2026 06:50

Which gender roles are important? Which ones make you a woman or a man?

Are cooking, sewing and knitting female gender roles? Does that mean that when my husband cooks our evening meal, he is a woman? Is Kaffe Fassett a woman? Or the army officer who was a finalist on the Great British Sewing Bee? Or a tailor in Savile Row or Eton?

Or to take some examples from among my acquaintances, is the woman who does plumbing work in our area a man? Or the one who bashes people with a (blunt) sword in medieval re-enactments? Or the one who is an aircraft mechanic in the RAF or the other one who does the same job in an airline maintenance facility?

He never says, he tells us it has been explained repeatedly presumably to engage in some people going back through the bazillions of his posts to try and work out what the fuck he is talking about but he never ever manages to type out any that he means

Presumably because his brain hurtz?

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:21

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:17

That's not how rights balancing works. Women don't 'own spaces' disadvantage does & discomfort doesn't qualify as one.

You should replace the word discomfort with anxiety.

It has the same range but at the higher end it becomes a clinically recognised disadvantage.

Anxiety, sometimes extreme anxiety, is what men who identify as women are causing women by using female only spaces.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:19

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:17

That's not how rights balancing works. Women don't 'own spaces' disadvantage does & discomfort doesn't qualify as one.

There’s absolutely no need to ‘rughts balance’ here.

No one has ever had the ‘right’ to use facilities for the opposite sex.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:18

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:15

Single sex services are justified and designed on the bases of sex.

You acknowledge that trans identifying men are not female.

So what are you talking about?

If you want to lobby for spaces to be justified and designed base on 'social women/social men' go for it. But you will need to define the term, justify why people would need to be segregated, and design the spaces knowing they are mixed sex.

But you dont seem to be able even to define the term.

@Choppingwoodcarryingwaterwants us to redefine sex to mean something other than sex so that she can sell women’s rights down the river

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:17

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:01

Rights balancing (proportionality) requires a disadvantage. While some may consider discomfort a justified disadvantage, discomfort works both ways as in trans women may feel discomfort in mens toilets. It's also a very subjective term because individuals have different perspectives on discomfort. I personally feel discomfort as many do changing in front of any strangers regardless of sex. Does this common view entitle us to private cubicles? How does that work practically.

Discomfort being so subjective makes it a logistical nightmare impossible to cater for so as a standard/principle its not practical that gender critical feminists don't seem to understand the consequences of in that once a principle is established it also needs to apply broadly.

Let's forget discomfort for the moment because it's impossible to define.

There are Jewish women and Moslem women, and no doubt others, who are prohibited by their faith or culture from being semi clothed in areas where there are men. To access sporting facilities, these women need women only changing rooms and women only swim sessions.

There are rape victims who have clinically observable PTSD who require the same thing. They also have a requirement for rape support centres where they know they will not meet male people.

By sticking to the current law, that males should use male or gender neutral facilities, nobody is prevented from those activities.

By allowing males into those places women are disadvantaged.

So I'll ask again why you believe that the rights of a tiny number of men who identify as women trump the rights of those women who would be disadvantaged.

I hope you are putting as much effort into campaigning for gender neutral facilities as you are into trying to push women into agreeing to give up existing hard won rights.

OP posts:
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:17

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:12

If transwomen feel discomfort in the bathroom provided for their own sex, there is zero requirement for women to give up their rights to single sex spaces to accommodate them.

Either you educate men to treat all men with respect in male spaces or you campaign for third spaces.

Lesve women out of it. We are not some lesser beings who only exist to accommodate men 🙄

That's not how rights balancing works. Women don't 'own spaces' disadvantage does & discomfort doesn't qualify as one.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:15

Single sex services are justified and designed on the bases of sex.

You acknowledge that trans identifying men are not female.

So what are you talking about?

If you want to lobby for spaces to be justified and designed base on 'social women/social men' go for it. But you will need to define the term, justify why people would need to be segregated, and design the spaces knowing they are mixed sex.

But you dont seem to be able even to define the term.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:15

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:05

Jesus yes, sorry, I forgot you were actually a woman.

Do you have trans relatives? Women with the strength of conviction that a man can turn into the sex you are generally seem to.

Secondly, that you assume disagreement can be only sex based is what's called internalised misogyny…& that's hardly feminist.

Again, not a term I have ever used.

Thirdly, explaining how rights are apportioned which you finally acknowledge isn't a repudiation of current law or anti feminist. On the contrary its feminist to believe in sexual equality not sexual superiority when it comes to how rights are apportioned.

Believing that some sex based rights need protecting is not a belief in sexual superiority. That's a bizarre clam to make when it's for in physical inferiority and vulnerability.

I've never made that claim. I don't know anyone who has ever made that claim.
Indeed you have repeatedly where you have assumed biology decides rights when in fact it's disadvantage that does.

That is tautological nonsense when it is biological sex that creates the disadvantage which require additional rights to be enshrined in law.

Believing that some sex based rights need protecting is not a belief in sexual superiority. That's a bizarre clam to make when it's for in physical inferiority and vulnerability.

Shifting the goal posts now? You alleged sex determines rights repeatedly & as I have demonstrated repeatedly they do not because they are subject to context.

That is tautological nonsense when it is biological sex that creates the disadvantage which require additional rights to be enshrined in law.

Not always which is the point you are spectacularly missing.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:14

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:09

You are confusing 'female' with 'woman'. Female is a sex category. Woman is both a sociological & sex category because of social associations.

The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

But they don't really on the whole because if they did they wouldn't continue to perpetuate them by expressing sex typical behaviours & most men & women do this to some degree. That you are in denial of this reality doesn't do your credibility much justice particularly given its a centrepiece of gender critical feminism. Do you even understand your own ideology?

No women is not a ‘sociological category’ 🙄

Do we need to remind you of the post about non veggies larping as veggies trying to make the point that ‘ham is sociological kale’

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:12

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:01

Rights balancing (proportionality) requires a disadvantage. While some may consider discomfort a justified disadvantage, discomfort works both ways as in trans women may feel discomfort in mens toilets. It's also a very subjective term because individuals have different perspectives on discomfort. I personally feel discomfort as many do changing in front of any strangers regardless of sex. Does this common view entitle us to private cubicles? How does that work practically.

Discomfort being so subjective makes it a logistical nightmare impossible to cater for so as a standard/principle its not practical that gender critical feminists don't seem to understand the consequences of in that once a principle is established it also needs to apply broadly.

If transwomen feel discomfort in the bathroom provided for their own sex, there is zero requirement for women to give up their rights to single sex spaces to accommodate them.

Either you educate men to treat all men with respect in male spaces or you campaign for third spaces.

Lesve women out of it. We are not some lesser beings who only exist to accommodate men 🙄

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:09

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 07:59

So trans women are categorised as a sub group of women based on their social association to the concept of woman.

Only in your world. The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

Women are not a construct.

Women are a biological group with two X chromosomes.

A man cannot know if he feels like a woman, because he isn't one.

You are confusing 'female' with 'woman'. Female is a sex category. Woman is both a sociological & sex category because of social associations.

The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

But they don't really on the whole because if they did they wouldn't continue to perpetuate them by expressing sex typical behaviours & most men & women do this to some degree. That you are in denial of this reality doesn't do your credibility much justice particularly given its a centrepiece of gender critical feminism. Do you even understand your own ideology?