Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
NotBadConsidering · 08/10/2026 09:36

Lexibletheflexible · 08/10/2026 09:29

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism, just like trans exclusive feminism. It doesnt matter how much you snarl and fight about it, irrespective of your beliefs, both are feminist approaches and always will be.

That's why if you google "what are the types of feminism", both types will come up.

So it doesnt matter if you get to 1000 replies and 17 threads. Trans inclusive feminism will still be postmodern feminism. Or how many times you try and quote me, chase me around the site talking about my marriage or past, try and derail threads I am on, or circumvent MN sock troll detectors, transninclusive feminism will still be a type of feminism. It will still be listed in textbooks as a type of feminism by all academics.

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism

Trans women are a type of women

Trans men are a type of men

Non-binary is a type of identity

Flat earthism is a type of astronomy

When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less

backformoreofthesame · 08/10/2026 09:34

Google says both types exist - that’s proven then

I do think men can be feminists
I don’t think that anyone who can’t understand what a woman is can be a feminist
but of course they want to eliminate the meaning of useful words

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 09:33

Word salad is salad.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 08/10/2026 09:30

"snarl"

It's a discussion, Lexible.

Lexibletheflexible · 08/10/2026 09:29

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism, just like trans exclusive feminism. It doesnt matter how much you snarl and fight about it, irrespective of your beliefs, both are feminist approaches and always will be.

That's why if you google "what are the types of feminism", both types will come up.

So it doesnt matter if you get to 1000 replies and 17 threads. Trans inclusive feminism will still be postmodern feminism. Or how many times you try and quote me, chase me around the site talking about my marriage or past, try and derail threads I am on, or circumvent MN sock troll detectors, transninclusive feminism will still be a type of feminism. It will still be listed in textbooks as a type of feminism by all academics.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 08/10/2026 09:27

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:44

FlirtswithRhinos posted a great post on another thread:

"Yes absolutely draw a difference.
A long time ago, but probably in the depths of FWR somewhere, I noted that danger of taking on someone else's cause for them is that you can fight for them, you can amplify their voice, you can hold the line for them, but you cannot compromise for them because it's not your fight to say what they can or can't accept in the interests of finding a solution. So, allies tend to be more extreme that the people for whom they are fighting.
And in a movement like Genderism, where you have I guess at least 1000 allies shouting about trans rights for each actual trans person, that becomes a big deal. Because most of the people driving this on the Genderist side now are only empowered to fight, not to compromise.
And then if they have also put a heavy slug of their own identity into being "a person who is compassionate / sophisticated enough to truly believe that TWAW / TMAM"... well. Those people have every reason to dig in and no reason in the world to soften."

What an interesting post. Thanks for reposting it here.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 09:23

NotBadConsidering · 08/10/2026 09:18

This is the best they can send apparently.

Yes.

NotBadConsidering · 08/10/2026 09:18

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:41

Mmm hmmm. You’d think you would be better at it in that case.

This is the best they can send apparently.

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 09:14

newrubylane · 08/10/2026 00:35

I was going to pose the question in answer to the same post - define 'man', and explain how and why they hold more structural and societal power'?

But actually, your point is really interesting. Some idea that feeling oppressed by men is what makes you a woman?

No, not that being oppressed by powerful men is what makes you a woman.

My point is that some people (men and women) mistakenly think that if the issue is 'men doing oppressing', that must be a feminist issue. (Hence why transwomen can be included in feminism). They can't see anything else except feminism that is analysing and criticising 'men doing oppressing' - and mistakenly believe that feminism is about 'fighting men doing oppressing', instead of feminism being about 'women being oppressed'. A subtle but crucial distinction.

The exchange between @sosomewhereelse and @Rollingpinofdoom , finishing at 22:12 yesterday on page 21, illustrates this beautifully. (I also saw the mistake crop up on an earlier page of this thread but can't find that post now.)

The logic goes
A. Powerful men are oppressing other men, causing problems like e.g. men's mental health issues
B. Patriarchy is about 'men doing oppressing'
C. Therefore men oppressing men is a result of patriarchy
D. Feminism is about fighting patriarchy
C. Therefore men being oppressed by men is a feminist issue.

The flaw creeps in at step B - patriarchy is specifically about men oppressing women, not men oppressing other men.
Then the flaw continues in step C - because the word 'patriarchy' lost its definition in step B, and becomes expanded in step C to include men oppressing men.

This is where I bring in traditional leftist analysis of social class and capitalism. It is these that will help you understand men oppressing men, not feminism.

To be precise, it is not merely about social class and capitalism. These may be just further symptoms of men's need for hierarchy and tendency to oppress anyone they see as weaker.
I am not sure if there is a word for the analysis of this. Which may be why we resort to inaccurate words like 'feminism' or not-quite-accurate words like 'classism' or 'capitalism'.

It is admirable that people are concerned with men oppressing transwomen and want to fight this. But it is not a feminist issue. 'Men oppressing everyone else' needs another name.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 09:12

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/10/2026 08:53

Well it's not. @totino is making up their own/ borrowing someone else's pseudoscience nonsense based loosely on real science. It's a bit like "intersex means there are more than 2 sexes because chromosomes." Utter rubbish.

Genderists come up with this nonsense purely to justify why they want to prioritise men over women. Both women and men do this, with men it’s generally because they just don’t give a fuck about women and it doesn’t occur to them that women might have a say. Women do it in a more internalised way, we can see how they justify it on Mumsnet. “I’m a good person, I have empathy”, but they think women should put themselves second to these men. They’re as sexist as the men are.

backformoreofthesame · 08/10/2026 09:07

i guess “authoritarianism” is kind of like “bossy” when women are assertive ?

actually the phantom limb is interesting
would people take away the crutches of a one legged person because they claimed they could feel both legs ?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 09:03

Wishesandhorses · 08/10/2026 09:02

Ah, so same old same old.

Arguments that men are very very very important and feelings matter - but women's don't.
Framing the absolute naivety, ignorance and lack of care for women as 'its just a tiny inconvenience' to have men in women's spaces.

Sexism on crack. And a lot of enjoyment of seeing women run around giving attention and emotion in response to the provocation.

I sadly can't find a gif of the magic roundabout but the theme tune is about all I can hear in my head.

Indeed. People used to post a link to an episode on YouTube. Or the song “Let’s Go Round Again”.

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 09:03

'As a woman'

Do they not realise that thanks to the Gender Addler Grievance Gerbils this means NOTHING?

Wishesandhorses · 08/10/2026 09:02

Ah, so same old same old.

Arguments that men are very very very important and feelings matter - but women's don't.
Framing the absolute naivety, ignorance and lack of care for women as 'its just a tiny inconvenience' to have men in women's spaces.

Sexism on crack. And a lot of enjoyment of seeing women run around giving attention and emotion in response to the provocation.

I sadly can't find a gif of the magic roundabout but the theme tune is about all I can hear in my head.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:58

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:52

Both. I believe in egalitarianism & the principles that underpin it. As a woman, a child of immigrants & poverty Im very grateful for them & believe in defending them particularly against gender critical feminism which serves to essentially undermine it & enable authoritarianism.

Edited

Women wanting loos kept to their own sex enables authoritarianism?

The kind of authoritarianism that in other countries has put women through criminal courts and heavily fined lesbians for not wanting a man in their club and women for referring to someone born male as "he"?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:54

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/10/2026 08:53

Well it's not. @totino is making up their own/ borrowing someone else's pseudoscience nonsense based loosely on real science. It's a bit like "intersex means there are more than 2 sexes because chromosomes." Utter rubbish.

Yes, agreed

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:53

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:52

Both. I believe in egalitarianism & the principles that underpin it. As a woman, a child of immigrants & poverty Im very grateful for them & believe in defending them particularly against gender critical feminism which serves to essentially undermine it & enable authoritarianism.

Edited

More word salad 😂

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/10/2026 08:53

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 07:11

With phantom limbs, the limb once existed.

How is that relevant to this scenarios where the body has never been the opposite sex?

Well it's not. @totino is making up their own/ borrowing someone else's pseudoscience nonsense based loosely on real science. It's a bit like "intersex means there are more than 2 sexes because chromosomes." Utter rubbish.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:52

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:47

Are you simply enjoying the debate or do you actually believe what you are writing?

I find it almost inconceivable and fascinating and disappointing that there are women with no close association to trans people who are so prepared to disadvantage other women as your arguments would suggest that you are.

Both. I believe in egalitarianism & the principles that underpin it. As a woman, a child of immigrants & poverty Im very grateful for them & believe in defending them particularly against gender critical feminism which serves to essentially undermine it & enable authoritarianism.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:50

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:49

But choppy doesn't talk about the GRA or even a diagnosis, just social women.

I think they mean if we can't tell they are men, or can guess that they are trans, we treat them as women, but cant say that.

That would apply even if they weren’t “trans”. Hardly any man can truly pass as a woman.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 08:49

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:47

Are you simply enjoying the debate or do you actually believe what you are writing?

I find it almost inconceivable and fascinating and disappointing that there are women with no close association to trans people who are so prepared to disadvantage other women as your arguments would suggest that you are.

What I’ve learnt in the course of this debate is that misogyny (both externalised and internalised) runs very deep in our society.

Depressing beyond belief

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 08:49

Those 'tiny numbers' do make a hell of an impact don't they?

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 08:49

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:39

I think Chopping has an old copy of EHRC guidelines because that’s very much what the line was in the past. Not now though, the SC judgment clarified that.

But choppy doesn't talk about the GRA or even a diagnosis, just social women.

I think they mean if we can't tell they are men, or can guess that they are trans, we treat them as women, but cant say that.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 08:47

Yes, that’s an excellent point. The other thing that acts on allies is a lot of them are scared of saying the wrong thing. Of being called out as not sufficiently supportive. Of being accidentally “transphobic”. They have seen what happens when women say no to these men.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 08:47

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:35

I have no trans family members. I simply enjoy discussion & debate about current affairs.

Are you simply enjoying the debate or do you actually believe what you are writing?

I find it almost inconceivable and fascinating and disappointing that there are women with no close association to trans people who are so prepared to disadvantage other women as your arguments would suggest that you are.

OP posts: