Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 11:27

It’s just nonsense burble to manufacture engagement.

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 11:25

JanesLittleGirl · 08/10/2026 11:21

Wait what! Gender critical feminism serves to undermine egalitarianism. Please explain your understanding of 'gender critical feminism' that causes you to make that statement?

Or indeed egalitarianism.

JanesLittleGirl · 08/10/2026 11:21

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:52

Both. I believe in egalitarianism & the principles that underpin it. As a woman, a child of immigrants & poverty Im very grateful for them & believe in defending them particularly against gender critical feminism which serves to essentially undermine it & enable authoritarianism.

Edited

Wait what! Gender critical feminism serves to undermine egalitarianism. Please explain your understanding of 'gender critical feminism' that causes you to make that statement?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 11:13

ScarlettSunset · 07/10/2026 13:26

Yes. I strongly believe that those men who insist they must be granted access to female spaces are absolutely at the front of the list of those that should stay out.

And that really is the heart of the matter for me. Decent men don’t make women uncomfortable or violate their boundaries. Men who don’t care or even worse, get pleasure from it, do.

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 11:11

The question is really "can you be a partially male inclusive feminist?".

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 11:01

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 23:03

yes in a brief glance I did actually, it’s late, I’m tired - does that make any big point to you ?

It does make a point, yes. The mistake is neither here nor there, we all make mistakes. The problem isn’t that you assumed they were social media platforms; it’s that you declared they were echo chambers. So you were willing to make a judgement about social media platforms that you’ve never been on because they don’t exist. That marks you out as somewhat dishonest. (Or at the very least, unwilling to check evidence and resources before making a declaration about something. That would make me take the rest of your posts with a pinch of salt).

JustSpeculation · 08/10/2026 10:49

Well, I've read most of this thread, and I think for a bunch of amateurs rather than proper respected academics (yes, I know. I'm just being facetious) in proper institutions (Lexibletheflexible, this thread page 1) there's been some bloody good argumenting going on here.

@FlirtsWithRhinos , thanks for the point that allies can't compromise. That's a really useful insight that's going straight into the toolbox.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:44

Oh, back to the OP and my post on perspectives, I forgot to include this one:

Principle vs Immateriality. For some women, they don't really think TWAW but assume there are only a few TW and that their behaviour will be respectful towards actual women, so in practice they just ignore that TW are taking the piss a bit with their idea of what being a woman is because there are better uses of women's time than making it a big deal. Kind of like the rules that allow for trace contaminants in food before it counts as contaminated.

While on the other hand, you have women who think if you make it acceptable for even one male person to count as a "woman" because of how they think, feel, or act, you have fundamentally underminded the core Feminist point which is that women do not all feel, or act in certain ways and it's reducing our agency and possibilities to treat us or make decisions about us as if we do.

Portmore · 08/10/2026 10:35

I strongly support Trans rights.

As in rights to be Trans & right to not face discrimination or be at a disadvantage. There should be very harsh penalties for hate crimes against trans people. Bullying or threats by men against trans women in toilets etc should be treated very harshly.

I just don't accept that trans women are women. Trans identified males shouldn't be treated any less than women or men but also shouldn't cause women to be at a disadvantage. It's not a hate crime to stand up for women's rights & women's safety. You can support Trans rights &at the same time support women's rights to female only spaces.

Apparently that makes me a TERF, bigot, homophobic & responsible for suicides.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 08/10/2026 10:31

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 23:45

Technically there are no 'women's rights' or 'men rights'. All there is anti discrimination law based on sex where special exemptions exist that are reliant on a disadvantage which is context determined.

False.

Women’s rights are different from men’s rights in areas where the difference of sex is a factor that makes risks different, or where the situation (like maternity) is only possible for members of one sex.

This has been enshrined in law since at least 1823.

You really know very little & seem to resist learning - and yet you are constantly raising the subject.

Why?

Why not master the basics before you start?

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 10:30

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:22

Shouldn't need saying but probably does...

A person who is oppressed (or in HowseSpeak suffering from the imposition of another's "authoritarianism" limiting what they want to be allowed to do) may in another context be the person who is oppressing (imposing "authoritarianism" upon others).

An analysis which becomes impossible if all axis of oppression, exploitation and marginalisation are munged into one blob.

Very good point that I had not thought of.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:28

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 10:21

The idea that its authoritarian not to have an undefined category of social women is an interesting take.

I suspect that its not possible to define the category, because in doing so, itll be forcing women into an arbitrary category they dont consent to.

Wear a dress - become a social woman, wear a tie, they become a social man.

Exactly.

Plenty of authoritarianism is apparently totally fine when it comes the suggestion that female people be allowed to say for ourselves when our sex matters, or whether we consent to being redefined by some amorphous constellation of unsayable but nevertheless very important, of course you know what they are, so why would I need to say? social commonalities.

When it comes to the significance of sex, suddenly we don't get a say at all.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 10:28

I do find it odd that none of these “trans-inclusive feminists” are happy that the SC judgement gave TIF clarity on their rights to abortion, maternity and healthcare, and the right to access female only RCC. Or is their “”feminism” only concerned with the rights of TIM?
none of them have answered the question, in a scenario where a vulnerable woman needs a single sex space, but a TIM also wants to access the space, whose wishes and needs should be met?

JanesLittleGirl · 08/10/2026 10:24

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 21:30

They agree with you that transgender people are inauthentic and you are absolutely united in wanting to curtail their rights.

Gender Critical Feminism and I have no opinion on the authenticity or otherwise of transgender people. Our concern is with social construct of Gender and how it is used to deny women our full role in society. I, and other gender critical feminists have no desire to curtail the sex-based rights of transgender people but don't accept that gender-based rights should be a thing because of our view of gender itself.

On the other hand, both genderists and your bogeymen believe that gender is not a social construct but is innate, part of the natural order and very important.

BTW, we are not small children to be frightened into line by the threat of monsters under the bed.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:22

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 09:44

This is an example of what I talked about in my post yesterday:

If your concern is mainly with who is doing the oppressing, and dismantling the tools and mechanisms they use to oppress others, it might be easy to lose sight of the importance of analysing who are the people being oppressed, and how and why is each group being oppressed.
I think some modern ways of thinking tend to do this, by lumping all oppressed people together, be it black, disabled, mentally ill, women, trans, gay, or whatever.

@Choppingwoodcarryingwater you are lumping together being an immigrant, being a woman, and being poor, labelling the lump as being about egalitarianism, and contrasting that against authoritarianism.

What feminism does is separate out the strands of that lump and concern itself only with the 'woman' part.
There are other analyses, other schools of critical thought, other "isms", that are concerned with immigration and (separately) with poverty. And more that look at disability rights, racial issues, etc. etc.

Egalitarianism is the belief that everyone is equal and should have equal rights. But is does very little to analyse why some groups of people don't have equal rights in practice. For that you need to separate out the groups of people being oppressed and look at each one, not lump them all together and just 'fight authoritarianism'.

Shouldn't need saying but probably does...

A person who is oppressed (or in HowseSpeak suffering from the imposition of another's "authoritarianism" limiting what they want to be allowed to do) may in another context be the person who is oppressing (imposing "authoritarianism" upon others).

An analysis which becomes impossible if all axis of oppression, exploitation and marginalisation are munged into one blob.

MarieDeGournay · 08/10/2026 10:22

Choppingwoodcarryingwater
Discomfort being so subjective makes it a logistical nightmare impossible to cater for so as a standard/principle its not practical that gender critical feminists don't seem to understand the consequences of in that once a principle is established it also needs to apply broadly.

You may have been tired when you wrote that, it took a few reads, but I think this is the meaning - I'm open to correction, sorry if I've got it wrong -
catering for a subjective concept like 'discomfort' is a logistical nightmare, and broad principles need to be implied instead.

Have I got that right?
If so, I think it sums up very well the pragmatic, pro-social approach I take - yes, individuals have all sorts of subjective feelings, but if it is decided that the safe speed at that point is 60mph, individual feelings about it are irrelevant, the principle is applied not just broadly but universally; even Max Verstappen has to respect the limit.

Similarly, where facilities are separated on the basis of sex, it would result in a 'logistical nightmare' if individual feelings about whether sex means 'biological sex' or 'sociological sex' or feelings of 'discomfort' at having to use the facilities designated for one's biological result in a logistical nightmare were taken into account.

The principle that single-sex facilities are in some circumstances required, and that 'sex' means biological sex, avoid the logistical nightmare you refer to.

Broadly applied, that means providing, where required, facilities reserved for biological males, and facilities reserved for biological females, and trusting people to respect them.
That's a configuration which worked well for the huge majority of people until very recently.

Men's/women's/accessible provision is pragmatic, economic, safe, fair for most of the population, based on provable distinctions between men and women, easy to implement, and pretty much universally respected until very recently.
It works fine unless
'Discomfort being so subjective'
is invoked by men demanding to use the women's facilities which
'makes it a logistical nightmare'
as organisations, companies and venues have been discovering to their cost.

edited to say that the para starting 'Similarly...' is pretty dense, sorry - must've been feeling tired all of a suddent😞

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 10:21

The idea that its authoritarian not to have an undefined category of social women is an interesting take.

I suspect that its not possible to define the category, because in doing so, itll be forcing women into an arbitrary category they dont consent to.

Wear a dress - become a social woman, wear a tie, they become a social man.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 10:19

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:17

Geocentrism is exactly what Genderism always makes me think of.

They have a fixed belief at the centre that is axiomic. Every observation has to be made to work with that.

But the world isn't like that. And reality keeps breaking through in ways that their model doesn't fit.

So they end up with more and more convoluted logic, more and more made up explanations to account for all the exceptions to their core assertion, more and more "have you considered that..."s and "I expect that science will eventually show that..."s, til what they have is the Genderist equivalent of all those supercomplicated calculations and "retrograde movement" medieval astronomers needed to try to predict the motion of the plants and the paths of the sun and moon in the sky in a way that aligned with their fixed belief that the earth was the thing they all moved round....

When the actual reality was simply that they had started from the wrong place, and once you start from the right place what looked impossibly complicated becomes far far simpler.

But even beyond this, the biggest irony for the Genderists, even more ironic than the story of the geocentrists and all the time spent on calculations to solve the wrong problem, is not simply that the Genderists are wrong but that even if they were right, even if all that effort was justified, they still aren't proving what they think they are.

Because the thing they actually need to prove isn't that this "Gender" thing is real, or even that it matters. The thing they actually need to prove to support their extremist demands is not that "Gender" is real but that sex is not.

They need to prove that sex isn't real, or that sex doesn't matter, or that the language and provisions set up for sex make more sense made over to "Gender" and nothing would be needed to replace them.

And these things is they can never prove, because reality belies them.

That is literally one of the best analogies of it that I’ve ever read 👏

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 10:17

Chersfrozenface · 08/10/2026 09:41

Flat earthism is a type of astronomy

As is geocentrism. You know, Galileo Galilei vs the Inquisition.

Geocentrism is exactly what Genderism always makes me think of.

They have a fixed belief at the centre that is axiomic. Every observation has to be made to work with that.

But the world isn't like that. And reality keeps breaking through in ways that their model doesn't fit.

So they end up with more and more convoluted logic, more and more made up explanations to account for all the exceptions to their core assertion, more and more "have you considered that..."s and "I expect that science will eventually show that..."s, til what they have is the Genderist equivalent of all those supercomplicated calculations and "retrograde movement" medieval astronomers needed to try to predict the motion of the plants and the paths of the sun and moon in the sky in a way that aligned with their fixed belief that the earth was the thing they all moved round....

When the actual reality was simply that they had started from the wrong place, and once you start from the right place what looked impossibly complicated becomes far far simpler.

But even beyond this, the biggest irony for the Genderists, even more ironic than the story of the geocentrists and all the time spent on calculations to solve the wrong problem, is not simply that the Genderists are wrong but that even if they were right, even if all that effort was justified, they still aren't proving what they think they are.

Because the thing they actually need to prove isn't that this "Gender" thing is real, or even that it matters. The thing they actually need to prove to support their extremist demands is not that "Gender" is real but that sex is not.

They need to prove that sex isn't real, or that sex doesn't matter, or that the language and provisions set up for sex make more sense made over to "Gender" and nothing would be needed to replace them.

And these things is they can never prove, because reality belies them.

throwawayimplantchat · 08/10/2026 10:05

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

If someone believes they have a missing limb when they actually don’t, should they be given a blue badge and PIP and other benefits they may be granted if they actually had a missing limb?

Should they be allowed to park in disabled spaces which are limited, at the expense of people who have a disability who then may not have enough parking?

These are genuine questions as I’m trying to work through your analogy logically.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 09:52

Lexibletheflexible · 08/10/2026 09:29

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism, just like trans exclusive feminism. It doesnt matter how much you snarl and fight about it, irrespective of your beliefs, both are feminist approaches and always will be.

That's why if you google "what are the types of feminism", both types will come up.

So it doesnt matter if you get to 1000 replies and 17 threads. Trans inclusive feminism will still be postmodern feminism. Or how many times you try and quote me, chase me around the site talking about my marriage or past, try and derail threads I am on, or circumvent MN sock troll detectors, transninclusive feminism will still be a type of feminism. It will still be listed in textbooks as a type of feminism by all academics.

You know if we googled “flat earth" we'd find societies dedicated to it?

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 09:51

Lexibletheflexible · 08/10/2026 09:29

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism, just like trans exclusive feminism. It doesnt matter how much you snarl and fight about it, irrespective of your beliefs, both are feminist approaches and always will be.

That's why if you google "what are the types of feminism", both types will come up.

So it doesnt matter if you get to 1000 replies and 17 threads. Trans inclusive feminism will still be postmodern feminism. Or how many times you try and quote me, chase me around the site talking about my marriage or past, try and derail threads I am on, or circumvent MN sock troll detectors, transninclusive feminism will still be a type of feminism. It will still be listed in textbooks as a type of feminism by all academics.

Pesco-Vegetarian is a term that will come up if you google. Most vegetarians don’t consider people who eat fish any type of vegetarian.

Heggettypeg · 08/10/2026 09:46

Lexibletheflexible · 08/10/2026 09:29

Trans inclusive feminism is a type of feminism, just like trans exclusive feminism. It doesnt matter how much you snarl and fight about it, irrespective of your beliefs, both are feminist approaches and always will be.

That's why if you google "what are the types of feminism", both types will come up.

So it doesnt matter if you get to 1000 replies and 17 threads. Trans inclusive feminism will still be postmodern feminism. Or how many times you try and quote me, chase me around the site talking about my marriage or past, try and derail threads I am on, or circumvent MN sock troll detectors, transninclusive feminism will still be a type of feminism. It will still be listed in textbooks as a type of feminism by all academics.

Until there are new textbooks and an update of Wikipedia which state that "trans-inclusive feminism" was a misstep, and not, in fact, a feminism at all.

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 09:44

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:52

Both. I believe in egalitarianism & the principles that underpin it. As a woman, a child of immigrants & poverty Im very grateful for them & believe in defending them particularly against gender critical feminism which serves to essentially undermine it & enable authoritarianism.

Edited

This is an example of what I talked about in my post yesterday:

If your concern is mainly with who is doing the oppressing, and dismantling the tools and mechanisms they use to oppress others, it might be easy to lose sight of the importance of analysing who are the people being oppressed, and how and why is each group being oppressed.
I think some modern ways of thinking tend to do this, by lumping all oppressed people together, be it black, disabled, mentally ill, women, trans, gay, or whatever.

@Choppingwoodcarryingwater you are lumping together being an immigrant, being a woman, and being poor, labelling the lump as being about egalitarianism, and contrasting that against authoritarianism.

What feminism does is separate out the strands of that lump and concern itself only with the 'woman' part.
There are other analyses, other schools of critical thought, other "isms", that are concerned with immigration and (separately) with poverty. And more that look at disability rights, racial issues, etc. etc.

Egalitarianism is the belief that everyone is equal and should have equal rights. But is does very little to analyse why some groups of people don't have equal rights in practice. For that you need to separate out the groups of people being oppressed and look at each one, not lump them all together and just 'fight authoritarianism'.

Chersfrozenface · 08/10/2026 09:41

Flat earthism is a type of astronomy

As is geocentrism. You know, Galileo Galilei vs the Inquisition.