Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
Helleofabore · 11/10/2026 07:49

So totino didn’t come back with the links of how to assess whether a male person “is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation”.

I can only assume that the test doesn’t exist and never has.

At this point, I also assume that some posters do only read superficially and/or do believe pseudoscience over proven and established science because it allows them to stay comfortably in the image they have of themselves. They then feel they can dismiss proven science as being ‘just an opinion‘ and that all opinions should be welcome and misinformation should be considered valid.

The concepts around gender identities have been building for decades. Since even before girls and women, female people, were being called ‘gennies’ by men who claimed to be women. It has taken generations, and a fuck ton of forced teaming for building credibility, but some people believe that a male person can be female if he claims he is.

Yet, there is no evidence despite decades of work to show how this is possible. Instead, we have a group of believers repeating the same soundbites and making emotionally reasoned and faith or spiritualist type statements to defend the concept.

The use of ‘cis’ is just an example of how flawed this acquisition of credibility via misusing existing language has been. In taking a prefix from other areas of science and applying it to human biology, they then showed just how meaningless the word is for that purpose because it never worked in theory and it is a disaster in application because people don’t even understand what it means. They just keep repeating it because someone else reassures them the word works. Without providing logic or evidence that it does work.

I think some people must never look beyond their group’s vague assurances that it all works together to see there is no foundational support that is evidenced at all.

No totino, there is no way at all for you or any person in authority to arbitrate who “is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation”. There are many types of harm that comes from allowing any male person above about 8 years old to access female single sex provisions. It is not limited to rape risk but that is one risk of many.

Segregation exists based on sex category not on philosophical belief about gender. No one has to be living in any closet. Stop acquiring language cues from oppresssd groups to misuse to support your personal unevidenced belief.

What people cannot do, is expect any other person to act as if they believe an impossible statement and treat a male person as if they are female based on that male person’s claim.

Grammarnut · 10/10/2026 17:58

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

In the UK only men can rape - it requires a penis. I actually deprecate male prison warders in women's prisons and vice versa, this seems terminally stupid and dangerous (and is why Elizabeth Fry in the 1820s said women should be looked after by women warders). But transwomen have committed rape and sexual assault and it would appear at a greater rate than men who are not TiMs. They have no place in the women's estate and need to be housed in special units of men's prisons.

Grammarnut · 10/10/2026 17:52

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 11:03

Who gets to decide that being a feminist means transwomen are allowed in segregated spaces? I am a feminist and I support the inclusion of transwomen - where appropriate.

We would help ourselves so much by labelling things properly. That's the problem with language. Labelling vagina-only spaces as "women" has led to unreasonable and ridiculous conclusions when it comes to trans inclusion.

Anything purely identity-related can include transwomen. Because anything truly identity-related doesn't matter at all. "Women vs men" on a quiz, for example. Who cares if a transwoman is included? She is more than welcome.

People with penises (and extra strength) in a space with no supervision or cameras - of course transwomen cannot be there because that has nothing to do with identity and never bloody did!!!! Use language properly ffs!!! Stop calling those spaces "women" and you fix all your problems.

We're separating penises and vaginas. We're protecting from violence and rape. Not separating "people who like makeup and wearing heels from people who don't". FFS!!!!

Get the labels right and this shit disappears instantly.

Also: this is fuelled by insidious forces trying to justify installing surveillance everywhere. I have already seen cameras in women's vagina-only bathrooms and open bathrooms visible to the rest of the bar, precisely because we're allowing men penises in vagina-only spaces but we know that we cannot have penises in vagina-only spaces!!!!! Obviously!! Omg sick of even hearing about this.

And an absurd situation arises because transwomen are at equal risk of violence / rape if actual men are allowed in these vagina-only spaces. So who benefits?? The insidious forces trying to justify surveillance in every corner of the country.

Anyone reasonably thought to possibly have a penis needs to be questioned / stopped and if they insist, then staff either need to escort them inside the bathroom or ask them to use the disabled toilet. Business owner choice on which. And say no to surveillance in private spaces: both penis and vagina-only private spaces. Thanks.

Oh and if you have a penis and insist on using vagina-only spaces: please sit down to urinate. Thank you.

It's much simpler to say men and women. Since men can't be women this covers all eventualities. Men in the men's bog, women in the ladies'.

helderste · 09/10/2026 19:23

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 09/10/2026 18:30

“Trans” means ‘the opposite sex from the one stated in the noun”. So “trans woman” means “not a woman (& therefore a man)”

There’s no need for a word adding another “not”.

We are women, not “not not women”.

Yes, exactly

Pingponghavoc · 09/10/2026 18:37

It is the same passive action that we saw from the male poster who kept telling us that everyone treated him as a woman so therefore he was.

Men demand preferred pronouns, then say everyone sees them as women because they are referred to as she/her.

Its like a child telling everyone that spiderman is here, then running back in a costume and being happy when their parents say 'hello spiderman '.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 09/10/2026 18:30

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

“Trans” means ‘the opposite sex from the one stated in the noun”. So “trans woman” means “not a woman (& therefore a man)”

There’s no need for a word adding another “not”.

We are women, not “not not women”.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 09/10/2026 18:25

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

Experiences we don’t remember absolutely do shape us.

Child development 101.

theilltemperedmonster · 09/10/2026 11:03

They're the same annoying types who accuse us of not being gender critical because we supposedly hold people to exacting gender standards.

Like they can't tell the difference between insisting on the wearing/not wearing of a dress and lipstick, and noting whether someone has a gross male phenotype shaped by androgenisation in the perinatal and pubertal phases.

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 10:42

“I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’.“

It is the same passive action that we saw from the male poster who kept telling us that everyone treated him as a woman so therefore he was.

They obviously all read the same philosophical theory texts.

It is really concerning though that there are women who actually accept these male people’s philosophising as being material reality that must be affirmed. And usually with a breezily dismissive ‘live and let live.

Or that terminally cyclical, they know themselves so we must listen to them.

Or the equally terminal clique (and hypocrisy) is we cannot know what they experience so who are we to judge.

Or the ludicrous gaslighting that is someone declaring that a male person demanding female language has no negative impact on any female person at all. Which is completely illogical but yet, some posters will again dismiss it as being just ‘opinion’!

Pingponghavoc · 09/10/2026 10:29

The definition of women is far too complicated to put to paper, but society instinctively recognises that a man is a woman?

We cant describe them, but we know a woman when we see one.

I think half of them what to be us, the other half want women to disappear as a word.

Chersfrozenface · 09/10/2026 09:48

I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’.

The very epitome of wishful thinking.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/10/2026 09:35

I’m a tad Jimmy Hill that “society places him in the category of a woman”. Do we know who he is? Would love to see a photo.

StandingDeskDisco · 09/10/2026 09:34

From the article

As a trans woman, [...] It is a label [...] that I find restrictive and inadequate.

Nothing will ever be enough. Everything will always be restrictive and inadequate. There is no freedom and peace and satisfaction to be had by going down the 'trans rabbit hole', because no matter how much you mangle the language, no matter how many female spaces you invade, no matter how much you impose yourself on society around you, deep deep down you know that you are a man, male, and always will be. You cannot fix yourself by changing the world around you.

I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’.

You are 'choosing' to be a transwoman. Society would not place you in that category if you didn't insist upon it. Society does not pick upon some random effeminate men and decide that they are transwomen. It is something the individual chooses.

Imdunfer · 09/10/2026 09:11

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:47

here is part of the letter from this link

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

-start-

Women’s – Belonging to, relating to, or intended for women.

Now, fighting for an end to the systematic oppression of women obviously relates to women, as does this publication. That fight is intended for women: both in terms of women obviously being interested in the end of their oppression, and women being the drivers of that fight. But that fight is also not intended for women alone…

FEMINISM – NOT JUST FOR WOMEN

While the majority of the work that goes into producing Women’s Fightback, and our feminist work more generally, is done by women (and other non-men oppressed as women), men do also contribute to Women’s Fightback, help to produce and propagate the publication, and read and fight for the demands that we publish. This is essential. Not least because, unlike general class struggle, women are not such a majority as the working class as whole.

That does not mean that we need men to ‘selflessly intervene’ to end women’s oppression, but rather that men need to be interested in ending misogyny and patriarchy – and there is plenty that should interest men towards that end, beyond simply caring for women.

Patriarchy and misogyny harm men. Patriarchy demands that there be clear demarcation between ‘men’ and ‘women’, which not only means that its enforcers must ensure that there are behaviours that women should not possess, and levels they cannot ‘rise’ to, but also means that, conversely, there are behaviours that men should not possess, and levels that they cannot ‘sink’ to. Men, obviously, use these misogynistic standards to threaten and coerce women into subservience, but they also use them to threaten and coerce more reluctant men into their intended role as fellow enforcers of patriarchy. After all, the less that patriarchy is enforced, the weaker it becomes. This results in bullying and violence between boys and men that often leaves lasting scars.

The men who present particular threats to patriarchy, are harmed particularly. The oppression of gay and bisexual men stems from this misogyny, and this is why the harshest punishment is reserved for those men who are most ‘overtly queer’ – to privately transgress what is ‘expected’ of a man is excuse enough for ridicule, but even more severe attacks are aimed at those who publicly challenge the default assumption of heterosexuality, and the expected form of family (and women’s place within that family) that follows from that assumption.

Even men who are relatively unimpacted by patriarchy and misogyny can benefit directly from women’s liberation. Contemporary feminist demands such as: free 24-7 childcare; expanded parental leave for both mothers and fathers; and reduction in working hours without a loss in pay, to increase the time parents can spend with children – all directly benefit men.
It is in the interests of men to fight back against women’s oppression, and so to that end, the fightback certainly relates to, and is intended for men, too.

While some women may respond to this by saying ‘Feminism should focus on women’s oppression, not men’s problems’, part of women’s oppression is directly caused by the harm that is done to men being passed from those men onto women. Men brutalise women, in part, to demonstrate to themselves or their peers that they are ‘domineering’ and ‘manly’; and when men’s misogynistic hazing of each other results in men with emotional deficits, it is primarily women expected to resolve that deficiency for the men in their lives.

As such, these struggles are not separate from the fight against women’s oppression, but integral to it.

WHAT IS A WOMAN?

In my attempt to define ‘Women’s’ above, I didn’t make an attempt to actually define the word ‘women’ – both because an adequate definition of a woman is too complicated to fit in this article, and because the relentless deluge of disingenuous ‘What is a woman?’ invocations, used as a stick to beat trans women for at least the past decade, have made the question rather tedious. But if we are using the word in the title of our publication, it’s worth reflecting on what it means.

One of the catalysts of our discussion on the name ‘Women’s Fightback’ was the experience of some of our comrades, who reported that, when selling copies, some people assumed it to be a transphobic ‘feminist’ (or so-called ‘gender-critical’) publication – which is why we began integrating the trans flag into the front-cover design.
Now, we should not allow transphobes’ transmisogynistic weaponisation of the word ‘woman’ make it a tainted word, but I think that part of the reason that defining a woman has become such a go-to part of the transphobic playbook is because we do a poor job of defining the word ourselves. That’s not necessarily a bad thing – after all, there are likely more possible definitions of the word ‘woman’ than there are women, but I think it may be cause for further reflection.

As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate. It is in some ways something I’ve used to signal who I am, but I also recognise that it is a social, not a personal, categorisation. I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’ (even when it insists that it does not). A more in-depth exploration of womanhood will have to wait for another time, but I hope this at least highlights the somewhat competing definitions that even a single person can hold simultaneously, and how it can be difficult to reconcile those definitions.

There are more urgent matters to focus on than how we define women, but transphobes have taken this space because we have, to some extent, left it open for them. I think that if we are to keep the name Women’s Fightback, we should be thinking about how we reclaim the word ‘woman’, rather than simply hoping that transphobes will eventually hand it back.

WOMEN’S FIGHTBACK?

Overall, I do feel that the name Women’s Fightback fails to fully capture the scope of the publication, and I think it risks not engaging men who assume our feminism to be none of their concern. If a better name comes along, I may well support it. But I also feel that feminists have already given ground that has allowed transphobes to weaponise the word woman, and that dropping the word woman from our title, without addressing the underlying issue that enabled transphobes to weaponise the word in the first place, only gives them further ground.

And more important than the name itself, is the discussion and explanation of our anxieties around keeping or changing the name, which may very well be a reflection of some disagreement in our underlying politics that we have yet to explore and reconcile. In any case, I believe that it’s worth taking this opportunity to become more conscious about what our feminism actually stands for, and what aspects of it we may be taking for granted and leaving underdeveloped.

-end-

“As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate”

So, a male person acquires the language of female people, and then of feminists, but then has decided that female language is not quite right for him. He chooses to then change the language to suit himself. And in doing so, cares not for any harm he has caused to female people. It is all about himself and his belonging.

It is certainly not a new dynamic. We have seen this over and over again.

These were some of the first published anecdotes

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5445899-break-it-down-for-me-2-general-break-it-down-archive-thread?reply=151123204&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share

OFFS!

Thank you HoaB, that is very eye opening. I did think we had a problem now with feminism as well as woman, I didn't realise it was so bad.

There is so much to object to in that article but I'll go straight to the root.

A more in-depth exploration of womanhood will have to wait for another time.

The whole argument is based on the definition of a woman.

Giving your conclusions without defining the core fact on which they are based is like a zoologist insisting that a duck billed platypus is a bird because it has a beak and lays eggs.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 09/10/2026 09:02

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/10/2026 08:59

Reminiscent of Shon Faye and his “shifting constellation”

Old Butters was keen on his constellation of data points too

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/10/2026 08:59

GreyskySexRealistsky · 09/10/2026 08:49

"an adequate definition of a woman is too complicated to fit in this article"

Er, no. No it's not.

Reminiscent of Shon Faye and his “shifting constellation”

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/10/2026 08:58

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:47

here is part of the letter from this link

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

-start-

Women’s – Belonging to, relating to, or intended for women.

Now, fighting for an end to the systematic oppression of women obviously relates to women, as does this publication. That fight is intended for women: both in terms of women obviously being interested in the end of their oppression, and women being the drivers of that fight. But that fight is also not intended for women alone…

FEMINISM – NOT JUST FOR WOMEN

While the majority of the work that goes into producing Women’s Fightback, and our feminist work more generally, is done by women (and other non-men oppressed as women), men do also contribute to Women’s Fightback, help to produce and propagate the publication, and read and fight for the demands that we publish. This is essential. Not least because, unlike general class struggle, women are not such a majority as the working class as whole.

That does not mean that we need men to ‘selflessly intervene’ to end women’s oppression, but rather that men need to be interested in ending misogyny and patriarchy – and there is plenty that should interest men towards that end, beyond simply caring for women.

Patriarchy and misogyny harm men. Patriarchy demands that there be clear demarcation between ‘men’ and ‘women’, which not only means that its enforcers must ensure that there are behaviours that women should not possess, and levels they cannot ‘rise’ to, but also means that, conversely, there are behaviours that men should not possess, and levels that they cannot ‘sink’ to. Men, obviously, use these misogynistic standards to threaten and coerce women into subservience, but they also use them to threaten and coerce more reluctant men into their intended role as fellow enforcers of patriarchy. After all, the less that patriarchy is enforced, the weaker it becomes. This results in bullying and violence between boys and men that often leaves lasting scars.

The men who present particular threats to patriarchy, are harmed particularly. The oppression of gay and bisexual men stems from this misogyny, and this is why the harshest punishment is reserved for those men who are most ‘overtly queer’ – to privately transgress what is ‘expected’ of a man is excuse enough for ridicule, but even more severe attacks are aimed at those who publicly challenge the default assumption of heterosexuality, and the expected form of family (and women’s place within that family) that follows from that assumption.

Even men who are relatively unimpacted by patriarchy and misogyny can benefit directly from women’s liberation. Contemporary feminist demands such as: free 24-7 childcare; expanded parental leave for both mothers and fathers; and reduction in working hours without a loss in pay, to increase the time parents can spend with children – all directly benefit men.
It is in the interests of men to fight back against women’s oppression, and so to that end, the fightback certainly relates to, and is intended for men, too.

While some women may respond to this by saying ‘Feminism should focus on women’s oppression, not men’s problems’, part of women’s oppression is directly caused by the harm that is done to men being passed from those men onto women. Men brutalise women, in part, to demonstrate to themselves or their peers that they are ‘domineering’ and ‘manly’; and when men’s misogynistic hazing of each other results in men with emotional deficits, it is primarily women expected to resolve that deficiency for the men in their lives.

As such, these struggles are not separate from the fight against women’s oppression, but integral to it.

WHAT IS A WOMAN?

In my attempt to define ‘Women’s’ above, I didn’t make an attempt to actually define the word ‘women’ – both because an adequate definition of a woman is too complicated to fit in this article, and because the relentless deluge of disingenuous ‘What is a woman?’ invocations, used as a stick to beat trans women for at least the past decade, have made the question rather tedious. But if we are using the word in the title of our publication, it’s worth reflecting on what it means.

One of the catalysts of our discussion on the name ‘Women’s Fightback’ was the experience of some of our comrades, who reported that, when selling copies, some people assumed it to be a transphobic ‘feminist’ (or so-called ‘gender-critical’) publication – which is why we began integrating the trans flag into the front-cover design.
Now, we should not allow transphobes’ transmisogynistic weaponisation of the word ‘woman’ make it a tainted word, but I think that part of the reason that defining a woman has become such a go-to part of the transphobic playbook is because we do a poor job of defining the word ourselves. That’s not necessarily a bad thing – after all, there are likely more possible definitions of the word ‘woman’ than there are women, but I think it may be cause for further reflection.

As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate. It is in some ways something I’ve used to signal who I am, but I also recognise that it is a social, not a personal, categorisation. I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’ (even when it insists that it does not). A more in-depth exploration of womanhood will have to wait for another time, but I hope this at least highlights the somewhat competing definitions that even a single person can hold simultaneously, and how it can be difficult to reconcile those definitions.

There are more urgent matters to focus on than how we define women, but transphobes have taken this space because we have, to some extent, left it open for them. I think that if we are to keep the name Women’s Fightback, we should be thinking about how we reclaim the word ‘woman’, rather than simply hoping that transphobes will eventually hand it back.

WOMEN’S FIGHTBACK?

Overall, I do feel that the name Women’s Fightback fails to fully capture the scope of the publication, and I think it risks not engaging men who assume our feminism to be none of their concern. If a better name comes along, I may well support it. But I also feel that feminists have already given ground that has allowed transphobes to weaponise the word woman, and that dropping the word woman from our title, without addressing the underlying issue that enabled transphobes to weaponise the word in the first place, only gives them further ground.

And more important than the name itself, is the discussion and explanation of our anxieties around keeping or changing the name, which may very well be a reflection of some disagreement in our underlying politics that we have yet to explore and reconcile. In any case, I believe that it’s worth taking this opportunity to become more conscious about what our feminism actually stands for, and what aspects of it we may be taking for granted and leaving underdeveloped.

-end-

“As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate”

So, a male person acquires the language of female people, and then of feminists, but then has decided that female language is not quite right for him. He chooses to then change the language to suit himself. And in doing so, cares not for any harm he has caused to female people. It is all about himself and his belonging.

It is certainly not a new dynamic. We have seen this over and over again.

These were some of the first published anecdotes

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5445899-break-it-down-for-me-2-general-break-it-down-archive-thread?reply=151123204&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share

Extraordinarily telling. We saw this kind of thing coming a mile off.

MagpiePi · 09/10/2026 08:49

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:04

"I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation."

Please provide this rigorous and accurate test.

Otherwise, you are spreading misinformation. Because if such a test existed, it would be in wide usage around the word.

Wouldn’t it save an awful lot of time and money if there was a simple test that could distinguish who was lying about anything!

All those lawyers, sentencing courts and appeal courts would be out of business. Nobody would ever be wrongly convicted or wrongly escape punishment.

Or is it only those who call themselves trans who are all sincerely and utterly truthful all of the time?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 09/10/2026 08:49

"an adequate definition of a woman is too complicated to fit in this article"

Er, no. No it's not.

nicepotoftea · 09/10/2026 07:20

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:55

The letter is a doozy.

It is rather illustrative from several different aspects.

Edited

I think it is enlightening. It frames women’s oppression as the oppression of femininity and so claims that feminism must include any man who is in any way considered effeminate.

However, I think women have challenged gender norms very successfully over the last 100 years. Men have been less successful, but that is their problem to solve.

In contrast, women can’t change the fact that being female has physical consequences and women will always need to fight for rights that men don’t need. I think it often takes time to acknowledge this, and it’s intrinsically ‘awkward’ because rights are in fact pie and men do give something up when women claim resources.

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:55

ReTerf · 09/10/2026 06:39

OMFG. They want to erase us.

Edited

The letter is a doozy.

It is rather illustrative from several different aspects.

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:47

here is part of the letter from this link

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

-start-

Women’s – Belonging to, relating to, or intended for women.

Now, fighting for an end to the systematic oppression of women obviously relates to women, as does this publication. That fight is intended for women: both in terms of women obviously being interested in the end of their oppression, and women being the drivers of that fight. But that fight is also not intended for women alone…

FEMINISM – NOT JUST FOR WOMEN

While the majority of the work that goes into producing Women’s Fightback, and our feminist work more generally, is done by women (and other non-men oppressed as women), men do also contribute to Women’s Fightback, help to produce and propagate the publication, and read and fight for the demands that we publish. This is essential. Not least because, unlike general class struggle, women are not such a majority as the working class as whole.

That does not mean that we need men to ‘selflessly intervene’ to end women’s oppression, but rather that men need to be interested in ending misogyny and patriarchy – and there is plenty that should interest men towards that end, beyond simply caring for women.

Patriarchy and misogyny harm men. Patriarchy demands that there be clear demarcation between ‘men’ and ‘women’, which not only means that its enforcers must ensure that there are behaviours that women should not possess, and levels they cannot ‘rise’ to, but also means that, conversely, there are behaviours that men should not possess, and levels that they cannot ‘sink’ to. Men, obviously, use these misogynistic standards to threaten and coerce women into subservience, but they also use them to threaten and coerce more reluctant men into their intended role as fellow enforcers of patriarchy. After all, the less that patriarchy is enforced, the weaker it becomes. This results in bullying and violence between boys and men that often leaves lasting scars.

The men who present particular threats to patriarchy, are harmed particularly. The oppression of gay and bisexual men stems from this misogyny, and this is why the harshest punishment is reserved for those men who are most ‘overtly queer’ – to privately transgress what is ‘expected’ of a man is excuse enough for ridicule, but even more severe attacks are aimed at those who publicly challenge the default assumption of heterosexuality, and the expected form of family (and women’s place within that family) that follows from that assumption.

Even men who are relatively unimpacted by patriarchy and misogyny can benefit directly from women’s liberation. Contemporary feminist demands such as: free 24-7 childcare; expanded parental leave for both mothers and fathers; and reduction in working hours without a loss in pay, to increase the time parents can spend with children – all directly benefit men.
It is in the interests of men to fight back against women’s oppression, and so to that end, the fightback certainly relates to, and is intended for men, too.

While some women may respond to this by saying ‘Feminism should focus on women’s oppression, not men’s problems’, part of women’s oppression is directly caused by the harm that is done to men being passed from those men onto women. Men brutalise women, in part, to demonstrate to themselves or their peers that they are ‘domineering’ and ‘manly’; and when men’s misogynistic hazing of each other results in men with emotional deficits, it is primarily women expected to resolve that deficiency for the men in their lives.

As such, these struggles are not separate from the fight against women’s oppression, but integral to it.

WHAT IS A WOMAN?

In my attempt to define ‘Women’s’ above, I didn’t make an attempt to actually define the word ‘women’ – both because an adequate definition of a woman is too complicated to fit in this article, and because the relentless deluge of disingenuous ‘What is a woman?’ invocations, used as a stick to beat trans women for at least the past decade, have made the question rather tedious. But if we are using the word in the title of our publication, it’s worth reflecting on what it means.

One of the catalysts of our discussion on the name ‘Women’s Fightback’ was the experience of some of our comrades, who reported that, when selling copies, some people assumed it to be a transphobic ‘feminist’ (or so-called ‘gender-critical’) publication – which is why we began integrating the trans flag into the front-cover design.
Now, we should not allow transphobes’ transmisogynistic weaponisation of the word ‘woman’ make it a tainted word, but I think that part of the reason that defining a woman has become such a go-to part of the transphobic playbook is because we do a poor job of defining the word ourselves. That’s not necessarily a bad thing – after all, there are likely more possible definitions of the word ‘woman’ than there are women, but I think it may be cause for further reflection.

As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate. It is in some ways something I’ve used to signal who I am, but I also recognise that it is a social, not a personal, categorisation. I am not a woman because I ‘choose to be a woman’, but because society places me into the category of ‘woman’ (even when it insists that it does not). A more in-depth exploration of womanhood will have to wait for another time, but I hope this at least highlights the somewhat competing definitions that even a single person can hold simultaneously, and how it can be difficult to reconcile those definitions.

There are more urgent matters to focus on than how we define women, but transphobes have taken this space because we have, to some extent, left it open for them. I think that if we are to keep the name Women’s Fightback, we should be thinking about how we reclaim the word ‘woman’, rather than simply hoping that transphobes will eventually hand it back.

WOMEN’S FIGHTBACK?

Overall, I do feel that the name Women’s Fightback fails to fully capture the scope of the publication, and I think it risks not engaging men who assume our feminism to be none of their concern. If a better name comes along, I may well support it. But I also feel that feminists have already given ground that has allowed transphobes to weaponise the word woman, and that dropping the word woman from our title, without addressing the underlying issue that enabled transphobes to weaponise the word in the first place, only gives them further ground.

And more important than the name itself, is the discussion and explanation of our anxieties around keeping or changing the name, which may very well be a reflection of some disagreement in our underlying politics that we have yet to explore and reconcile. In any case, I believe that it’s worth taking this opportunity to become more conscious about what our feminism actually stands for, and what aspects of it we may be taking for granted and leaving underdeveloped.

-end-

“As a trans woman, but also a gender abolitionist, my own relationship to my identity as a woman is complex. It is a label that I’ve had to fight to be granted to me, but also a label imposed onto me, that I find restrictive and inadequate”

So, a male person acquires the language of female people, and then of feminists, but then has decided that female language is not quite right for him. He chooses to then change the language to suit himself. And in doing so, cares not for any harm he has caused to female people. It is all about himself and his belonging.

It is certainly not a new dynamic. We have seen this over and over again.

These were some of the first published anecdotes

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5445899-break-it-down-for-me-2-general-break-it-down-archive-thread?reply=151123204&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share

women's fightback

Our name and our feminism

The more observant of our readers will have noticed that the name of this publication is ‘Women’s Fightback’. Internally, we’re having conversations about what that name means, what it should mean, and how well it fits. On its surface, it’s a discussio...

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

ReTerf · 09/10/2026 06:39

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:34

I just saw this on twitter imdunfer and thought of this thread.

https://x.com/runthinkwrite/status/2108208439809671619?s=46

from Jon Pike

-start-

“This is odd.
A handful of people in GC ranks learned some of their politics, decades ago, in @workersliberty. (Today it's sometimes difficult to know who is most embarassed about this - us or them)

Socialist Organiser - as it then was - differentiated itself from the Socialist Workers Party in many ways but one was in relation to sex and feminism. From 1972 the SWP had a special women's newspaper: Women's Voice, but closed it down in July 1982. Women's Voice had, apparently, gone off the rails politically and was not recruiting to the Party sufficently. It was too focussed on specifically women's politics and insufficiently on class politics. There was a long, and, for some, formative debate about the relationship between socialism and feminism.

People in Socialist Organiser, back in the early 80s learned that this decision was wrong. In particular, it was important to assert the 'right of women to organise autonomously.' To that end, SO maintained its own newspaper 'Women's Fightback' And, though it's a bit sporadic, the paper remains to this day.

But what's this? On their website the AWL have posted this weird article, by a trans-identifying male, which questions the name of the paper. The AWL are considering changing the name of their women's paper - by dropping the, er, woman bit.

They assert that 'Feminisim is not just for women' and express their dismay that the title 'Woman's Fightback' causes some alarm that its a GC publication.

The point of this post is to draw attention to this very strange article, but also to show how far the politics of the group have shifted - it is publicly abandoning what seemed to be a well rooted commitment to socialist feminism and to women's autonomy. (You might say that commitment went years ago, but this makes it pretty explicit).”

-end-

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

I will post the article in another post. It is an article written by a man who wants to remove the word woman from a women’s publication.

OMFG. They want to erase us.

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:34

I just saw this on twitter imdunfer and thought of this thread.

https://x.com/runthinkwrite/status/2108208439809671619?s=46

from Jon Pike

-start-

“This is odd.
A handful of people in GC ranks learned some of their politics, decades ago, in @workersliberty. (Today it's sometimes difficult to know who is most embarassed about this - us or them)

Socialist Organiser - as it then was - differentiated itself from the Socialist Workers Party in many ways but one was in relation to sex and feminism. From 1972 the SWP had a special women's newspaper: Women's Voice, but closed it down in July 1982. Women's Voice had, apparently, gone off the rails politically and was not recruiting to the Party sufficently. It was too focussed on specifically women's politics and insufficiently on class politics. There was a long, and, for some, formative debate about the relationship between socialism and feminism.

People in Socialist Organiser, back in the early 80s learned that this decision was wrong. In particular, it was important to assert the 'right of women to organise autonomously.' To that end, SO maintained its own newspaper 'Women's Fightback' And, though it's a bit sporadic, the paper remains to this day.

But what's this? On their website the AWL have posted this weird article, by a trans-identifying male, which questions the name of the paper. The AWL are considering changing the name of their women's paper - by dropping the, er, woman bit.

They assert that 'Feminisim is not just for women' and express their dismay that the title 'Woman's Fightback' causes some alarm that its a GC publication.

The point of this post is to draw attention to this very strange article, but also to show how far the politics of the group have shifted - it is publicly abandoning what seemed to be a well rooted commitment to socialist feminism and to women's autonomy. (You might say that commitment went years ago, but this makes it pretty explicit).”

-end-

https://www.workersliberty.org/story/2026-09-25/our-name-and-our-feminism

I will post the article in another post. It is an article written by a man who wants to remove the word woman from a women’s publication.

Jon Pike (@runthinkwrite) on X

This is odd. A handful of people in GC ranks learned some of their politics, decades ago, in @workersliberty. (Today it's sometimes difficult to know who is most embarassed about this - us or them) Socialist Organiser - as it then was - differen...

https://x.com/runthinkwrite/status/2108208439809671619?s=46

Helleofabore · 09/10/2026 06:17

totino · 08/10/2026 16:36

I laid out what my reasoning is in my replies, probably around page 12 to 15 or something. Not that you have read it, or like it, but we do explain ourselves on here. You don't like the arguments but it's the same vice versa

Are these the posts you were referring to?

-start-

totino · 07/10/2026 18:52

Was away from my desk, but I'll try to reply. I don't think trans woman are ever men. I don't think in general that there is "male" brain and "female" brain, but I think the brain knows whether you're a man or woman. It's been explained to me comparable to phantom pain, when you feel a limb that's missing. The brain scans for a body that should be a certain way but it's not, which is why gender dysphoria exists, and why people transition. I think that's completely authentic and I think it's probably always been around, like how we used to call depression "melancholia" and seizures "having visions", things like that.

I don't think all trans women are meek little lambs because women aren't all meek little lambs. But I don't believe in "trans women are a danger because males are a danger" because I don't believe men are born inherently more sexual, more violent, that they "can't help themselves". Men commit the most crimes, the most violence because they can, because they are the dominant group in society. There's a lot of toxicity around what "being a real man" is, and a lot of bonding rituals around harming and dominating women. A trans woman is neither welcome to this bonding nor does she want it, since she does not consider the men her peers. "Trans women" were once considered effeminate men and "real" men beat them. As they still do.

This is also why I don't think discussion between GCs and trans-inclusive feminists are very productive. They can be interesting, but ultimately we have all heard each other's arguments and we don't agree.

totino · 07/10/2026 19:05

Oh I have no doubt that the original categories of woman/man were based around the reproductive system, it's an easily observable thing. But observations can be incomplete, they can be expanded on, especially in such a long time and with all the things we learn about human nature. I think a definition of woman/man that centers on the reproductive system is incomplete. Most people are cis, so the observation that most women will fall under XX/ova and most men will fall under XY/testes is still correct, it's not the complete picture. You think that the reproductive element should be the deciding factor and I don't. I've written elsewhere about how I think it works psychologically.

totino · 07/10/2026 19:27

I don't think the reproductive system should be the deciding factor. It will be true for most people, but not all.
I believe in most cases it's quite direct. Being addressed as a boy and becoming alienated because that's not what you are. Being referred to as a daughter and thinking that's not right. A consistent experience of alienation that can be alleviated by transition.

-end-

Because there is nothing in these posts that provides any evidence or analytical thinking about why some male people are female when they say they are.

The concern is when statements such as the following are made:

“Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.”

It is concerning, because generally when people consider answers such as these, the question arises that if this is how those male people ended up being placed in female prisons.

Because some people who support that happening believe the soundbites they are told or they read. That they centre a group of male people to such a degree that when someone who repeats platitudes like ‘risk assessment will make sure no male inmates with transgender identities will harm female prison inmates’, those making such statements never drill further to understand how that is going to happen. How does risk assessment work? Where is the rigorously tested process to discover “ who is sincere” and* who is “someone who lies out of desperation.”*

It is all just so dismissive of the needs of female prison inmates. It fully centres the needs of those male people.

And why? Because if at the same time, a person believes that some male peopele have never been ‘male’ and always been ‘female’ then of course it is completely acceptable to repeat the fallacies of ‘it is only male staff abusing female inmates’ and the ‘women do it too!’ fallacy.

Is it because some people don’t want to know the truth? That despite all the reports to the contrary, they maintain this line of ‘those in authority or who must reallly be knowledgable know what they are doing’? Which is an appeal to authority.

Or is this where people show ( I cannot believe that they ‘have’) no understanding that some opinions are not formed from even a shred of evidence and some opinions are formed fully on known and proven facts and science, but that to some people, an opinion is an opinion so all opinion should be treated as if they hold the same value?

Is this why we keep being told that it is all just a matter of opinion and differences of opinion?

Because opinions can be dismissed and therefore dismissing statements of established fact as opinion means that someone can comfortably believe that their position on an issue will not support harm to others. All I can see in these posts is the reproduction of soundbites coming from activist groups that have no foundation in evidence. One reason is because it is a comfortable position to simply believe that a group you are politically interested in is supporting an evidence based position and not one merely from from ideology or philosophical theory.

Yet, anything that people will point out will be dismissed as opinion. Meanwhile, female people are harmed in prison by male inmates who should never have been there