Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

First national independent legal advice service for rape victims to be led by Centre for Women's Justice

60 replies

Imnobody4 · 05/10/2026 23:41

A very welcome development
https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/centre-for-womens-justice-to-deliver-first-ever-national-independent-legal-advice-service-for-victim-survivors-of-rape-and-sexual-violencenbsp

Centre for Women’s Justice is excited to announce that it will be leading the delivery of a new national free Independent Legal Advice service for adult victim-survivors of rape and sexual assault. We will be supported by partners Rape Crisis England and Wales and Victim Support.

The service will provide specialist, independent legal advice to victim-survivors about their rights within the criminal justice process. It will support them in relation to issues such as excessive personal data requests, Victim’s Right to Review and police investigations that fall below expected standards. The scheme is designed to help those who decide to report to the police understand their options, make informed decisions, and access clear, wholly independent legal advice at key stages of the process. While we anticipate that the overwhelming majority of service users will be women, the service will also be available to male survivors.

Centre for Women’s Justice to deliver first ever national Independent Legal Advice service for victim-survivors of rape and sexual violence  — CWJ

Centre for Women’s Justice is excited to announce that it will be leading the delivery of a new national free Independent Legal Advice service for adult victim-survivors of rape and sexual assault. We will be supported by partners Rape Crisis England a...

https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/centre-for-womens-justice-to-deliver-first-ever-national-independent-legal-advice-service-for-victim-survivors-of-rape-and-sexual-violencenbsp

OP posts:
Wishesandhorses · 09/10/2026 08:51

alcovecupboards · 09/10/2026 00:32

So just to be clear - you are now actively campaigning against a service to provide specialist legal advice to rape survivors because it also provides that specialist legal advice to male survivors. There are no words.

Oh put your pearls away.

As usual ALL the rape services are running to pander first and foremost to the group you think are the most special humans in the world, they are not going to suffer by specific specialist services for women not being all about them too.

They will survive permitting women an inch of the bloody universe, they really will.

alcovecupboards · 09/10/2026 00:32

Hedgehogforshort · 09/10/2026 00:27

I have had a reply from a CWJ solicitor to my e mail which confirmed that they will be delivering direct services to male victims.

in the context of the e mail it sounded like they thought i was a male victim.

anyway i have now made a compliant as that are in breach of their own objectives.

I am not having any of it, female only services bending their own rules to meet with commissioning objectives that do not recognise sex based services is my issue.

This is what happened to Edingburgh RCC, and more besides.

So just to be clear - you are now actively campaigning against a service to provide specialist legal advice to rape survivors because it also provides that specialist legal advice to male survivors. There are no words.

Hedgehogforshort · 09/10/2026 00:27

I have had a reply from a CWJ solicitor to my e mail which confirmed that they will be delivering direct services to male victims.

in the context of the e mail it sounded like they thought i was a male victim.

anyway i have now made a compliant as that are in breach of their own objectives.

I am not having any of it, female only services bending their own rules to meet with commissioning objectives that do not recognise sex based services is my issue.

This is what happened to Edingburgh RCC, and more besides.

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 22:01

Centre for Women’s Justice is excited to announce that it will be leading the delivery of a new national free Independent Legal Advice service for adult victim-survivors of rape and sexual assault. We will be supported by partners Rape Crisis England and Wales and Victim Support.

Who do you think should be leading it instead of CWJ? They are the one's who designed and delivered the pilot. They are doing it as an independent project to keep it at arms length while they still pursue strategic litigation against the gov CPS etc.

OP posts:
Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 21:16

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 21:12

It's not really a single sex service though. It's part of the criminal justice system aimed at ensuring fair trials in rape cases.
The evaluation report of the original CWJ pilot recommended it was extended to all rape victims.
static1.squarespace.com/static/69ce2e0f6fcae1199cca3cec/t/6abe75266c90152504de3ca4/1790866726852/Legal+Advice+Evaluation+%28Final+Report%29.pdf

It should not be a single sex service. How it is delivered and by whom is the issue

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 21:12

It's not really a single sex service though. It's part of the criminal justice system aimed at ensuring fair trials in rape cases.
The evaluation report of the original CWJ pilot recommended it was extended to all rape victims.
static1.squarespace.com/static/69ce2e0f6fcae1199cca3cec/t/6abe75266c90152504de3ca4/1790866726852/Legal+Advice+Evaluation+%28Final+Report%29.pdf

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · 07/10/2026 17:41

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 13:53

This is a government service not a charitable one.
Government launches new national Legal Advisors service for rape victims and expands Operation Soteria into the courtroom - GOV.UK https://share.google/yzpv22jDsHe3DHBzd

The new Independent Legal Advisor service, backed by initial funding of £6 million over two years, will provide rape victims with specialist legal advice throughout investigations and prosecutions.
CWJ have been chosen to lead it because they developed and ran the pilot on which it is based.
I think a scheme which excluded male victims would have fallen foul of the EQ Act. 2 separate schemes would increase costs.
Should CWJ have refused their expertise?
Personally I think it's a necessity and in the best interest of women.

I agree although I posted yesterday that as it is Government funded there would be strings attached, but from the announcement it says

These measures form part of the Government’s wider plan to halve violence against women and girls within a decade, ensuring victims receive the justice and protection they deserve.

So on these basis of this initial statement it implies it is part of acknowledging that women in particular are the main victims of sexual violence.

So wonder at which point those applying the funding were told (informally) they are more likely to get money it they aren't just a single sex service, or at which point the groups who came together thought they would go against their own existing practice of single sex services. ie RCEW & CWJ are already doing this (with I think WGN)

Also interesting to note that this concept is as a result of campaigning by RCEW and after lobbying adopted by Labour (under Starmer)

After years of campaigning by RCEW and the wider sexual violence and abuse sector, the promise of a national Independent Legal Advice service was included in the 2024 Labour Party manifesto and forms part of the Government’s Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG) strategy.

Is this Labour saying of course we support single sex services (so long as men also benefit).

Hedgehogforshort · 07/10/2026 14:28

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 13:53

This is a government service not a charitable one.
Government launches new national Legal Advisors service for rape victims and expands Operation Soteria into the courtroom - GOV.UK https://share.google/yzpv22jDsHe3DHBzd

The new Independent Legal Advisor service, backed by initial funding of £6 million over two years, will provide rape victims with specialist legal advice throughout investigations and prosecutions.
CWJ have been chosen to lead it because they developed and ran the pilot on which it is based.
I think a scheme which excluded male victims would have fallen foul of the EQ Act. 2 separate schemes would increase costs.
Should CWJ have refused their expertise?
Personally I think it's a necessity and in the best interest of women.

If CEJ accept the funding stream at it is they who lead it, just with any other funding stream that a charity accepts it is an activity governed by charity law, and must be within the scope of their objectives.

From the link you have shared (thanks), the project that the CEJ is undertaken is part of a bigger project running across multiple, public and charitable sector partners.

All good. Since the CEJ are lawyers i am going to assume that they will function, only within their objectives, but want to satisfy myself that this is the case.

i am just wary as well that the word hypocrites could be thrown at us.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 14:15

Well that's totally different framing from the original article. That implied it was a charity-run service with some government backing, not a government-run and -funded service.

The CEJ statement about not having 'previously applied' for government funding implied that in this case they had applied for funding to run their own project - which would normally be partial funding, with the rest the resources coming from the main charity staff and funding streams.

If it is fully resourced by government, and the charity are simply supplying expertise (and being recompensed for their time) then it may well not breach their charitable objectives or be detrimental to their main service. If that's so, then great.

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2026 13:53

This is a government service not a charitable one.
Government launches new national Legal Advisors service for rape victims and expands Operation Soteria into the courtroom - GOV.UK https://share.google/yzpv22jDsHe3DHBzd

The new Independent Legal Advisor service, backed by initial funding of £6 million over two years, will provide rape victims with specialist legal advice throughout investigations and prosecutions.
CWJ have been chosen to lead it because they developed and ran the pilot on which it is based.
I think a scheme which excluded male victims would have fallen foul of the EQ Act. 2 separate schemes would increase costs.
Should CWJ have refused their expertise?
Personally I think it's a necessity and in the best interest of women.

OP posts:
MarieDeGournay · 07/10/2026 12:40

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 08:48

It doesn't matter whether it's front line or not. Money isn't infinite, lawyers' time isn't infinite. If £100 pounds, or a 6-minute block of time, is spent on a man, that's time and money not available for a woman.

Which isn't in itself a bad thing - men need help too - but if that money has been raised specifically for women then it should be spent on women.

I agree .Men who have experienced sexual abuse - whether as adults or, as is more common I think, as children - deserve care and support.

I just fail to see why it has to be provided by women, in centres organised by and for women.
Of course the helplines should be open to men, where they can be referred on to appropriate men's support services, but not the services themselves.

Perhaps men's rights groups could pay more attention to practical things like setting up men's crisis centres and refuges, etc., which would not only leave much-needed spaces for women, but would also provide services specifically tailored for male survivors.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 08:48

IwantToRetire · 07/10/2026 01:40

Women fought hard for rape crisis services. We know women's access to them has been eroded elsewhere. It's right to be vigilant.

On one level I agree. But this is not about front line services. This is providing legal advice to victims of rape trying to get their case to court, which in most instances rape victims cat afford.

So if this means women victims can access the funded legal advice from CFJ through WGN, and males through Victim support, it is a method.

I suspect the CWJ is basically saying, government money comes with rules, but in this instance giving legal advice indirectly through Victim Support doesn't compromise their aims and objectives.

Too late to read now, but need to understand what for CWJ is strategically important for their work, setting legal presidents. That is the main part of their work.

And through the 2 front line services, rape victims get legal advice they might not otherwise have got.

Just indicates the hoop's women's right have to jump through

It doesn't matter whether it's front line or not. Money isn't infinite, lawyers' time isn't infinite. If £100 pounds, or a 6-minute block of time, is spent on a man, that's time and money not available for a woman.

Which isn't in itself a bad thing - men need help too - but if that money has been raised specifically for women then it should be spent on women.

Wishesandhorses · 07/10/2026 07:46

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 01:16

It's not about the funding coming from government. It's about whether their charitable objectives are specifically to support women, not men; and whether funding intended for women is therefore being diverted to men (which is where the detriment lies).

If the answer to these questions is no, then great. If it's yes that doesn't mean the project is bad - it sounds an admirable and much needed service - but we should still be able to ask questions about the way it is being done.

Women fought hard for rape crisis services. We know women's access to them has been eroded elsewhere. It's right to be vigilant.

Quite.

It also reflects modern thinking which is weighted against women, that anything providing something solely for women is actually not ok, and that providing to both sexes (even when it's a women's charity) makes them 'better'.

Because at the bottom of it is the usual women are not enough/ should never be a focus/ unless it's doing something useful to men it's naughty and unjustified.

71Alex · 07/10/2026 06:49

I don’t think CWJ are the right people to provide legal advice, albeit indirectly, to male rape victims. Although the law is technically the same as for female victims, CWJ’s practical expertise with the law relates to women not men.

IwantToRetire · 07/10/2026 01:40

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 01:16

It's not about the funding coming from government. It's about whether their charitable objectives are specifically to support women, not men; and whether funding intended for women is therefore being diverted to men (which is where the detriment lies).

If the answer to these questions is no, then great. If it's yes that doesn't mean the project is bad - it sounds an admirable and much needed service - but we should still be able to ask questions about the way it is being done.

Women fought hard for rape crisis services. We know women's access to them has been eroded elsewhere. It's right to be vigilant.

Women fought hard for rape crisis services. We know women's access to them has been eroded elsewhere. It's right to be vigilant.

On one level I agree. But this is not about front line services. This is providing legal advice to victims of rape trying to get their case to court, which in most instances rape victims cat afford.

So if this means women victims can access the funded legal advice from CFJ through WGN, and males through Victim support, it is a method.

I suspect the CWJ is basically saying, government money comes with rules, but in this instance giving legal advice indirectly through Victim Support doesn't compromise their aims and objectives.

Too late to read now, but need to understand what for CWJ is strategically important for their work, setting legal presidents. That is the main part of their work.

And through the 2 front line services, rape victims get legal advice they might not otherwise have got.

Just indicates the hoop's women's right have to jump through

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/10/2026 01:16

Imnobody4 · 06/10/2026 14:02

As CWJ’s mission is, and remains, to hold the state accountable around VAWG, we have traditionally not applied for government funding, except indirectly through the legal aid scheme. We carefully considered the implications of this new departure, but are clear that we can deliver the Independent Legal Advice service as a distinct project that will not compromise our wider mission, independence, legal judgment or willingness to hold the state to account. We will continue to do so, including through strategic litigation, policy, advice and campaigning work.

It's not about the funding coming from government. It's about whether their charitable objectives are specifically to support women, not men; and whether funding intended for women is therefore being diverted to men (which is where the detriment lies).

If the answer to these questions is no, then great. If it's yes that doesn't mean the project is bad - it sounds an admirable and much needed service - but we should still be able to ask questions about the way it is being done.

Women fought hard for rape crisis services. We know women's access to them has been eroded elsewhere. It's right to be vigilant.

IwantToRetire · 06/10/2026 21:46

Unlike say Southall Black Sisters that is both a frontline single sex service but also campaigns on issues that aren't exclusively about women.

IwantToRetire · 06/10/2026 21:45

I think that as their aims are about taking on "strategic" cases they could argue that in providing legal support to male rape victims, if it illustrates the failure of legal support when reporting to the police.

Not saying it is right. But CWJ is not a frontline service and take on strategic cases.

IwantToRetire · 06/10/2026 21:34

RCEW, Centre for Women's Justice and Victim Support to deliver the first national Independent Legal Advice Service for survivors of sexual violence and abuse.

We are delighted to announce that Rape Crisis England & Wales (RCEW) will be working in partnership with Centre for Women's Justice and Victim Support to deliver the first ever national Independent Legal Advice (ILA) service for adult survivors of sexual violence and abuse.

About the ILA service

The service, funded by the Ministry of Justice, will provide specialist, independent legal advice to survivors about their rights within the criminal justice process. Legal advisors will support on issues such as excessive personal data requests, Victim’s Right to Review and police investigations that fall below expected standards.

The service will be modelled on the existing ILA model currently delivered in London by WGN with CWJ, who are the lead project partner. RCEW and Victim Support will work with CWJ as partners to support the mobilisation and delivery of the new national scheme.
Who the service is for

The scheme is designed to support those who decide to report to the police, to understand their options, make informed decisions, and access clear, wholly independent legal advice at key stages of the criminal justice process.

The first national service of its kind will be available to survivors across England and Wales who are aged 18+ and have reported the offence of rape or assault by penetration (sections 1 and 2 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003) to the police.

Continues at https://rapecrisis.org.uk/news/launch-of-national-independent-legal-advice-service-for-survivors-of-sexual-violence-and-abuse/

As the actual service will be provided by WGN who are (I think!) a single sex service, I imagine Victim Support will work with men (just a guess) and CWJ provide the legal advice. (?)

Launch of National Independent Legal Advice Service for survivors of sexual violence and abuse

We are delighted to announce that Rape Crisis England & Wales (RCEW) will be working in partnership with Centre for Women's Justice and Victim Support to deliver the first ever national Independent Legal Advice (ILA) service for adult survivors of sexu...

https://rapecrisis.org.uk/news/launch-of-national-independent-legal-advice-service-for-survivors-of-sexual-violence-and-abuse/

Hedgehogforshort · 06/10/2026 20:56

@Imnobody4 think my post you quote sufficiently explains my concern.

i have e mailed them.

Imnobody4 · 06/10/2026 20:39

Hedgehogforshort · 06/10/2026 20:23

I have come back after thinking about the issue I highlighted, as in acting outside the objectives of a charity for women.

my position is that we can not vetch and complain about the WI the girl guides, and Edinburgh Rape crisis services, wandering outside their brief unlawfully so.

and then on the other hand say oh well on this occasion it is okay.

it is not.

charities need to stand up to government and local authorities, when they look to the primarily women’s sector providers of services (where there is a lack of male specific services) to fill the gap.

or as I see it two different groups experience male violence from very different perspectives.

i speak as a person who was in a leadership role in the VAWG sector for many years.

This is a separate legal advice sevice for individual rape victims the majority of whom are women. In what way is including men a detriment to women?
It isn't strictly speaking part of the charoty but a stand alone project. I really don't get your concerns.

OP posts:
Hedgehogforshort · 06/10/2026 20:23

I have come back after thinking about the issue I highlighted, as in acting outside the objectives of a charity for women.

my position is that we can not vetch and complain about the WI the girl guides, and Edinburgh Rape crisis services, wandering outside their brief unlawfully so.

and then on the other hand say oh well on this occasion it is okay.

it is not.

charities need to stand up to government and local authorities, when they look to the primarily women’s sector providers of services (where there is a lack of male specific services) to fill the gap.

or as I see it two different groups experience male violence from very different perspectives.

i speak as a person who was in a leadership role in the VAWG sector for many years.

solerolover · 06/10/2026 15:11

This is really good news

MrsOvertonsWindow · 06/10/2026 14:13

Imnobody4 · 06/10/2026 14:02

As CWJ’s mission is, and remains, to hold the state accountable around VAWG, we have traditionally not applied for government funding, except indirectly through the legal aid scheme. We carefully considered the implications of this new departure, but are clear that we can deliver the Independent Legal Advice service as a distinct project that will not compromise our wider mission, independence, legal judgment or willingness to hold the state to account. We will continue to do so, including through strategic litigation, policy, advice and campaigning work.

Thank you.
While I understand that anyone can question initiatives from any group, given some of the vile threads and posts recently on here from grim posters using rape victims as an excuse to berate women, it may be I'm a bit sensitive to challenges like this.
Edited to clarify I'm not talking about anyone on this thread raising issues.

Imnobody4 · 06/10/2026 14:02

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 06/10/2026 13:33

It's not criticism to note the rules on charitable objectives. There are very strict limits on what a charity can do because donors have given funds for a specific purpose.

As CWJ’s mission is, and remains, to hold the state accountable around VAWG, we have traditionally not applied for government funding, except indirectly through the legal aid scheme. We carefully considered the implications of this new departure, but are clear that we can deliver the Independent Legal Advice service as a distinct project that will not compromise our wider mission, independence, legal judgment or willingness to hold the state to account. We will continue to do so, including through strategic litigation, policy, advice and campaigning work.

OP posts: