Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Shabana Mahmood claims most women coming on small boats have been raped.

194 replies

Signalbox · 05/10/2026 15:59

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/04/women-small-boats-raped-shabana-mahmood-asylum-migration

Sadly, I’m not at all surprised by this story. It’s strangely worded though.

“You can almost guarantee that every woman that’s in the north of France has probably been raped along the journey.”

Nearly all women arriving on small boats have been raped, says Shabana Mahmood

Home secretary warns people traffickers will exploit asylum seekers because they decide who comes to the UK

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/04/women-small-boats-raped-shabana-mahmood-asylum-migration

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 13:08

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 13:07

Stop with this colonial/oppressor narrative. it is so one dimensional and as a result has no flexibility to actually consider reality. "Others" do exactly the same. All nations have boundaries and rules. If they don't they cease to exist. Every country, tribe or clan enforces its membership criteria and regulates behaviour in its territory.

Edited

It’s extremely simplistic, and it’s not a viable way to manage these issues.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 13:08

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 13:03

There have, in fact, been many instances in which the actual sex of the offender is not reported. It is disguised using 'pronouns'. If people were actually aware of the number of sexual crimes being committed by men with trans identities they would be quite shocked. That the narratives about " harmless" " victimised" " most oppressed" don't bear much resemblance to much of the reality on the ground.

As we know, a comparison of the census figures with the number of trans identified males in prison for sex offences shows that trans identified males are statistically more likely to be in prison due to being convicted of a sex offence than other men.

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 13:07

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 13:03

I'm saying it's extraordinarily arrogant to think we can behave in a way and not expect others to do the same.

Others go even further and suggest that as we stole huge amounts of wealth from other countries, we have an obligation to their survivors.

Stop with this colonial/oppressor narrative. it is so one dimensional and as a result has no flexibility to actually consider reality. "Others" do exactly the same. All nations have boundaries and rules. If they don't they cease to exist. Every country, tribe or clan enforces its membership criteria and regulates behaviour in its territory.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 13:04

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 13:03

I'm saying it's extraordinarily arrogant to think we can behave in a way and not expect others to do the same.

Others go even further and suggest that as we stole huge amounts of wealth from other countries, we have an obligation to their survivors.

What would you like to see happen? How many people should we take to make up for the past?

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 13:03

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 13:00

The BBC report the names of almost all criminals that they write items about with pictures of the offender's. They don't explicitly state the sex of almost all those criminals simply because they aren't trans.

There are a few they don't identify, almost always because of their age and only because of their age.

It's not a conspiracy of silence, there just aren't that many trans people and a minority of them (like the rest of the population) commit crimes.

There have, in fact, been many instances in which the actual sex of the offender is not reported. It is disguised using 'pronouns'. If people were actually aware of the number of sexual crimes being committed by men with trans identities they would be quite shocked. That the narratives about " harmless" " victimised" " most oppressed" don't bear much resemblance to much of the reality on the ground.

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 13:03

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:57

I'm not exactly sure what you are trying to say?

I'm not sure what Brexit has to do with anything. Many countries around the world are experienced this same issue....uncontrolled and illegal migration. It is a major issue everywhere. Also as various tribal and religious conflicts and wars rage on around the world there are also mass movements of displaced people - on every continent.

Once again, illegal migration and/or displacement due to war is not the same thing as legal immigration in which a country chooses who can enter and who can stay, and on what terms and conditions.

Edited

I'm saying it's extraordinarily arrogant to think we can behave in a way and not expect others to do the same.

Others go even further and suggest that as we stole huge amounts of wealth from other countries, we have an obligation to their survivors.

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 13:00

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:52

How can you assume it is a myth though?

It could just as easily be becaue they don't want to inflame violence by revealing the actual statistics. The same way, maybe, that the BBC and most mainstream media don't reveal the actual sex ( male) of a lot of criminals who have been arrested for sexual and crimes of violence, if they identify as 'women'. Because the facts don't support the 'be kind' narratives.

Edited

The BBC report the names of almost all criminals that they write items about with pictures of the offender's. They don't explicitly state the sex of almost all those criminals simply because they aren't trans.

There are a few they don't identify, almost always because of their age and only because of their age.

It's not a conspiracy of silence, there just aren't that many trans people and a minority of them (like the rest of the population) commit crimes.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 12:58

BrambleyHedgeAutumn · 06/10/2026 12:44

How do you know whether refugees are more, less or equally likely to commit rape? The government refuse to release that information, which is strange, as it would surely be a great way to debunk this right wing myth?

Mouldemort doesn’t have a clue but it sounds like the right sort of thing. Unsurprising given the poster’s other anti-woman stances.

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:57

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 12:52

Exceptionalism that bequeathed us brexit isn't shared by the rest of the world. You can wish for only us to have the privilege of being immigrants but it will remain exactly that. A wish.

I'm not exactly sure what you are trying to say?

I'm not sure what Brexit has to do with anything. Many countries around the world are experienced this same issue....uncontrolled and illegal migration. It is a major issue everywhere. Also as various tribal and religious conflicts and wars rage on around the world there are also mass movements of displaced people - on every continent.

Once again, illegal migration and/or displacement due to war is not the same thing as legal immigration in which a country chooses who can enter and who can stay, and on what terms and conditions.

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 12:56

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 06/10/2026 12:08

Really? Most of the world is a misogynistic hell hole for women and in many countries they are treated as slaves, I'd much rather UK sovereignty on women's rights issues. Both the EU and the UN have written documents erasing the very concept of two sexes and thereby women's rights. The UN has allowed nations that kill women for showing their hair to chair committees on human rights.

UN aid agencies have agreed to expel pretty much all female HCPs from Afghanistan at the Taliban's request, which is implicitly supporting the Taliban's denial of any healthcare to females.

Opting out of treaties we don't like will do wonders for our ability to trade when other countries see we won't respect our obligations to something we signed up to. This is "somewhat important" because we've not been self-sufficient in food or goods for in the lifetime of anyone you've met and we've damaged our reputation enough in the last few years.

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:52

BrambleyHedgeAutumn · 06/10/2026 12:44

How do you know whether refugees are more, less or equally likely to commit rape? The government refuse to release that information, which is strange, as it would surely be a great way to debunk this right wing myth?

How can you assume it is a myth though?

It could just as easily be becaue they don't want to inflame violence by revealing the actual statistics. The same way, maybe, that the BBC and most mainstream media don't reveal the actual sex ( male) of a lot of criminals who have been arrested for sexual and crimes of violence, if they identify as 'women'. Because the facts don't support the 'be kind' narratives.

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 12:52

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:08

That is what all countries do when they have wars and move in on each other's territory. There have been population 'swaps' and migrations all across the world within the last century as new countries have been formed and/or their boundaries re-drawn.

Just because Britain used to have an empire it doesn't mean it now has to accept unbounded, uncontrolled and/or illegal migration.

Edited

Exceptionalism that bequeathed us brexit isn't shared by the rest of the world. You can wish for only us to have the privilege of being immigrants but it will remain exactly that. A wish.

BrambleyHedgeAutumn · 06/10/2026 12:44

Mouldemort · 06/10/2026 09:41

It isn't about acknowledge the general level of risk women face, it's about misdirecting the blame for this to their fellow travellers rather than the traffickers.

The implication of the anti-refugee position is that refugees are more likely to commit rape, which is not true - in fact the men are likely to have been sexually abused, too.

Safe and legal routes reduce the risk to women.

And well done for shoehorning some transphobia in there to spice up the bigotry.

How do you know whether refugees are more, less or equally likely to commit rape? The government refuse to release that information, which is strange, as it would surely be a great way to debunk this right wing myth?

Bringemout · 06/10/2026 12:27

Given that women seem to somehow mysteriously die on some of these boats yeah we should be looking at the passengers. I remember that story of a man who raped a teenager and killed her in-front of her own mum whilst the boat was sinking, horrifying. Oh and that Afghan found with a Turkish girl he had kidnapped from a Belgium asylum centre.

I’m done, the men can take care of themselves somewhere else. I’m fine with accepting female refugees but no chain migration.

Shortshriftandlethal · 06/10/2026 12:08

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 10:10

Our colonisation was the imposition of illegal immigration by us on those countries is the point.

That is what all countries do when they have wars and move in on each other's territory. There have been population 'swaps' and migrations all across the world within the last century as new countries have been formed and/or their boundaries re-drawn.

Just because Britain used to have an empire it doesn't mean it now has to accept unbounded, uncontrolled and/or illegal migration.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 06/10/2026 12:08

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 10:18

Opting out of international laws is never a good step

Really? Most of the world is a misogynistic hell hole for women and in many countries they are treated as slaves, I'd much rather UK sovereignty on women's rights issues. Both the EU and the UN have written documents erasing the very concept of two sexes and thereby women's rights. The UN has allowed nations that kill women for showing their hair to chair committees on human rights.

UN aid agencies have agreed to expel pretty much all female HCPs from Afghanistan at the Taliban's request, which is implicitly supporting the Taliban's denial of any healthcare to females.

Hedgerowmanager · 06/10/2026 11:30

PollyNomial · 05/10/2026 21:47

We bombed/conquered/pillaged over there, that's why. And why cutting spending on aid is a remarkably idiotic thing to do if you pretend to want to curb immigration.

History is full of pillaging and invading.

England is not an exception here. Everyone has done it at some point.

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 06/10/2026 11:24

Lots of European men saw all those Ukrainian women and children having to flee their country as a fantastic opportunity for sexual exploitation. That’s a big reason most countries put schemes into place to welcome and protect them.

Cheese55 · 06/10/2026 11:24

Mouldemort · 06/10/2026 10:07

It's the exact opposite. You don't need a visa to get refugee status. What used to happen is that anyone could apply for asylum in any British embassy or consulate.

Under the refugee treaty, breaking civil law to enter a country, by whatever means, is not a bar to claiming refugee status. So you can either encourage illegal routes and harm to asylum seekers by blocking these paths, or reopen them. So safe and legal routes are literally the answer.

It also means that you don't get as many asylum seekers waiting for any answer in the UK - they stay in the country where they applied to the embassy while awaiting the result.

The reason there are small boats is simply because they think that providing sage and legal routes will increase the number of claims by making it hard for asylum seekers to claim. The prevalence rape, risk of drowning and the expense are what the system does for this purpose. It's inhuman.

The vast majority are likely economic migrants so would not be eligible for asylum unless they actively arrive here and then claim asylum

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 10:30

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 10:28

You still think after all the evidence of failure since 2016 that anything Farage says about international "treaties" be trusted? I do hope someone has warned you about wallet inspectors...

I don’t really care what he says but if you want safe controlled routes those are three options below -

If you say no to all of them it’s chaos, deaths at sea and sexual violence on the way.

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 10:28

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 10:22

If that’s not wanted then it’s keep international laws and use the Australian system.

Or Bardella gets in and his party are convinced to take people crossing back.

You still think after all the evidence of failure since 2016 that anything Farage says about international "treaties" be trusted? I do hope someone has warned you about wallet inspectors...

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 10:28

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 10:25

I’m not sure how anyone can be that certain when the crimes are usually not recorded in the country of origin, nor shared. And they certainly aren’t on the way through various countries.

And we see crimes when here too. There’s very little vetting, if any at all.

The reason they’re certain is that they don’t care whether they’re right. They’re only interested in pushing the agenda.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 10:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 10:23

I see the suggestion here that the refugee men travelling can’t possibly be a danger to anyone, and some sweeping, unfounded claims that they’re far more likely to be victims than perpetrators. And it’s apparently wrong to call that out as agenda driven, or mention that all men are a risk to women. Too bad.

I’m not sure how anyone can be that certain when the crimes are usually not recorded in the country of origin, nor shared. And they certainly aren’t on the way through various countries.

And we see crimes when here too. There’s very little vetting, if any at all.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 10:23

I see the suggestion here that the refugee men travelling can’t possibly be a danger to anyone, and some sweeping, unfounded claims that they’re far more likely to be victims than perpetrators. And it’s apparently wrong to call that out as agenda driven, or mention that all men are a risk to women. Too bad.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2026 10:22

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 10:18

Opting out of international laws is never a good step

If that’s not wanted then it’s keep international laws and use the Australian system.

Or Bardella gets in and his party are convinced to take people crossing back.