Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Silence on Cornell

241 replies

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:44

So… about J.K. Rowling. And the Cornell Seven, but we will get to that.

Here’s the thing: I liked Harry Potter growing up. It was the first and only chapter book my mom read to me, and I learned to read so I could read the second on my own after she refused to so so (for my own benefit).
Each year I was in school, there was a new book. I loved that they grew in depth as the characters aged. Yes, there were problems and problematic characters, but that’s a later subject.

I soured on Harry Potter when JKR kept adding things from the Pottermore website as canon: making Dumbledore gay was fine and easy to see in the book (see Grindelwald!), but the thing I hated was making Dumbledore in love with Harry
The greatest wizard of an age, hero and mentor to our protagonist… was revealed to be a pedophile in the post-script.
That’s shitty. My appreciation for the series soured after that, because suddenly the only “gay” representation is predatory and a heinous crime at that.

Fast forward a few years, and we see JKR’s anti-trans stance. Why? “Because she’s protecting real women!” She’s a TERF (derogatory) at best, but I think she’s actually much worse than that.

You see, she views those who support her works as synonymous with supporting her views, so to engage with her beloved franchise is to embolden her anti-trans and pro-billionaire crusade.

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

She wields real power in many ways, but what does she use it for? Oppression of the marginalized.

Now we come to the latest, and in many ways most concerning, activity or, rather, lack thereof; the Cornell 7.

Not once has she spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 (see attached image), a subject which would be *directly in support of women,” her alleged championed-cause.
She could speak out on this cause with ease, reaching millions. She could, at a stroke, fund all of Jane Doe's legal costs. But she doesn't. When there's actually a genuine case of harm of women but one that doesn't have the desired effect of harming marginalized communities she's as silent as the grave.

So no. I can’t in good faith engage with the franchise i used to love BECAUSE of the author, and JKR needs a real wake-up call before she does more harm.

“Talks on behalf of women” my ass. She’s almost as bad as Trumplestien.

Silence on Cornell
OP posts:
JanesLittleGirl · 06/10/2026 20:14

murasaki · 06/10/2026 20:05

Yup, see also not posting ahead of Tribunal Tweets. It's become ingrained.

Does anyone else remember when TRAs were complaining about having to deal with Conspicuously Law Abiding Women?

murasaki · 06/10/2026 20:15

JanesLittleGirl · 06/10/2026 20:14

Does anyone else remember when TRAs were complaining about having to deal with Conspicuously Law Abiding Women?

Plus ca change...

JustSawJohnny · 07/10/2026 22:23

JanesLittleGirl · 06/10/2026 18:35

Wazzock should definitely make a comeback but, whenever possible, the full 'spawny eyed, parrot-faced wazzock' should be used.

A thing of true beauty 😂

potterypieces · 09/10/2026 19:15

I lost a button yesterday, that must be JK’s fault too.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 09/10/2026 19:22

I found one today, but I don't think it was yours.

callmeLoretta1 · 09/10/2026 21:25

Oh another one who mistakes being PRO-WOMEN as 'anti men' or 'anti trans'. Without admitting that being pro-trans = anti-women, please explain how defending the rights of women, little girls and RAPE SURVIVORS LIKE ME to have female only intimate single sex spaces for safety, privacy and dignity is 'anti trans' WITHOUT admitting that pro-trans therefore = anti-women.

This is about MALE vs FEMALE. Not 'trans'. Do you even know what she has said about trans people? Tell us here how funding a rape crisis centre for the female sex and saying the female sex needs privacy and dignity is 'anti-trans'? What you really want to say, don't you, is that she is anti-men. Misandrist. But you know how that will make you look.

Silence on Cornell
TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/10/2026 06:20

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:44

So… about J.K. Rowling. And the Cornell Seven, but we will get to that.

Here’s the thing: I liked Harry Potter growing up. It was the first and only chapter book my mom read to me, and I learned to read so I could read the second on my own after she refused to so so (for my own benefit).
Each year I was in school, there was a new book. I loved that they grew in depth as the characters aged. Yes, there were problems and problematic characters, but that’s a later subject.

I soured on Harry Potter when JKR kept adding things from the Pottermore website as canon: making Dumbledore gay was fine and easy to see in the book (see Grindelwald!), but the thing I hated was making Dumbledore in love with Harry
The greatest wizard of an age, hero and mentor to our protagonist… was revealed to be a pedophile in the post-script.
That’s shitty. My appreciation for the series soured after that, because suddenly the only “gay” representation is predatory and a heinous crime at that.

Fast forward a few years, and we see JKR’s anti-trans stance. Why? “Because she’s protecting real women!” She’s a TERF (derogatory) at best, but I think she’s actually much worse than that.

You see, she views those who support her works as synonymous with supporting her views, so to engage with her beloved franchise is to embolden her anti-trans and pro-billionaire crusade.

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

She wields real power in many ways, but what does she use it for? Oppression of the marginalized.

Now we come to the latest, and in many ways most concerning, activity or, rather, lack thereof; the Cornell 7.

Not once has she spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 (see attached image), a subject which would be *directly in support of women,” her alleged championed-cause.
She could speak out on this cause with ease, reaching millions. She could, at a stroke, fund all of Jane Doe's legal costs. But she doesn't. When there's actually a genuine case of harm of women but one that doesn't have the desired effect of harming marginalized communities she's as silent as the grave.

So no. I can’t in good faith engage with the franchise i used to love BECAUSE of the author, and JKR needs a real wake-up call before she does more harm.

“Talks on behalf of women” my ass. She’s almost as bad as Trumplestien.

Of course she hasn't. She consistently supports violent men (and hires them). And is probably aware that support for those evil rapists is strong among the kind of people who form her largest support base.

A lot of influential terfs are going to condemn Jane Doe, just watch - my guess is Rowling knows that, so is opting for cowardly silence.

She barely ever mentions actual women's issues unless they can be co-opted to support her cause, e.g. the cis man who chased his victim across the ground floor and into an inclusive locker room at Planet Fitness this week.

(If only it'd been a single-sex space huh - he would've had far too much respect for women to go in 🙄)

She hasn't ever apologised for hiring Depp.

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

No retracting of her words about Benjamin Cohen and his husband after they were cleared this week.

Nothing on Gaza, Congo, Sudan.

With great power comes great responsibility. She failed every kid (including mine) who ever looked up to her as a safe haven. Mocking, raging against and misgendering trans people - and perpetuating harmful myths about them - is not feminism.

I have so much contempt for how she failed in her duty to lonely, isolated children who thought she cared about them.

Rollingpinofdoom · 10/10/2026 07:04

JanesLittleGirl · 06/10/2026 18:35

Wazzock should definitely make a comeback but, whenever possible, the full 'spawny eyed, parrot-faced wazzock' should be used.

I learned a new word today… Wankerchief. For those people who wanker is too mild for. I think it definitely fits those posters who have nothing better to do with their lives thst rage at women for defending their sex based rights and get upset when people won’t affirm their batshit beliefs.

Rollingpinofdoom · 10/10/2026 07:05

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/10/2026 06:20

Of course she hasn't. She consistently supports violent men (and hires them). And is probably aware that support for those evil rapists is strong among the kind of people who form her largest support base.

A lot of influential terfs are going to condemn Jane Doe, just watch - my guess is Rowling knows that, so is opting for cowardly silence.

She barely ever mentions actual women's issues unless they can be co-opted to support her cause, e.g. the cis man who chased his victim across the ground floor and into an inclusive locker room at Planet Fitness this week.

(If only it'd been a single-sex space huh - he would've had far too much respect for women to go in 🙄)

She hasn't ever apologised for hiring Depp.

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

No retracting of her words about Benjamin Cohen and his husband after they were cleared this week.

Nothing on Gaza, Congo, Sudan.

With great power comes great responsibility. She failed every kid (including mine) who ever looked up to her as a safe haven. Mocking, raging against and misgendering trans people - and perpetuating harmful myths about them - is not feminism.

I have so much contempt for how she failed in her duty to lonely, isolated children who thought she cared about them.

I’m sure she is gutted and lying awake at night repenting of her sins against the genderborg.

Imdunfer · 10/10/2026 08:17

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

That would be the same Amnesty International who apologised for publishing a list including the name of a women only rape crisis centre as an anti rights organisation would it?

Imdunfer · 10/10/2026 08:29

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

She was also talking about Imane Khelif who is not cleared to fight again as he is genetically male with partial androgen insensitivity. His outer body looks female but he isn't.

Yu-ting is also male but his androgen insensitivity has been declared complete not partial . They have the same condition, AIS, but one is PAIS and the other judges to be PAIS. They are both genetically men.

This is a judgment call by medics, there is no hard and fast test which distinguishes partial from complete. Also androgens are not the only thing that confers male advantage.

There are many people who are unhappy that somebody born to have abnormal height (7 inches taller than an average Thai female, 2 inches taller than an average Thai male) and length of arms and legs by virtue of his male genes has been cleared to continue to batter women in a boxing ring.

Imdunfer · 10/10/2026 08:56

Imdunfer · 10/10/2026 08:29

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

She was also talking about Imane Khelif who is not cleared to fight again as he is genetically male with partial androgen insensitivity. His outer body looks female but he isn't.

Yu-ting is also male but his androgen insensitivity has been declared complete not partial . They have the same condition, AIS, but one is PAIS and the other judges to be PAIS. They are both genetically men.

This is a judgment call by medics, there is no hard and fast test which distinguishes partial from complete. Also androgens are not the only thing that confers male advantage.

There are many people who are unhappy that somebody born to have abnormal height (7 inches taller than an average Thai female, 2 inches taller than an average Thai male) and length of arms and legs by virtue of his male genes has been cleared to continue to batter women in a boxing ring.

Edited

This post was in response to @TransParentlyAnnoyed , the quote didn't work.

The second PAIS should be CAIS

Helleofabore · 10/10/2026 09:24

What is noticable is that someone listing JK Rowling‘s sins hasn’t quite realised that not only did Benjamin Cohen exploit at least one woman’s body and an infant to be delivered of a child on demand, but that Cohen’s publication can be said to have targeted Rowling with many accusations and articles that if she ever chose to take to court would have a good chance of resulting in serious issues for that publication.

Yet apparently, Rowling responding about Cohen and James’s support of and use of surrogacy is worthy of vilification. It is remarkable

FrippEnos · 10/10/2026 10:32

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/10/2026 06:20

Of course she hasn't. She consistently supports violent men (and hires them). And is probably aware that support for those evil rapists is strong among the kind of people who form her largest support base.

A lot of influential terfs are going to condemn Jane Doe, just watch - my guess is Rowling knows that, so is opting for cowardly silence.

She barely ever mentions actual women's issues unless they can be co-opted to support her cause, e.g. the cis man who chased his victim across the ground floor and into an inclusive locker room at Planet Fitness this week.

(If only it'd been a single-sex space huh - he would've had far too much respect for women to go in 🙄)

She hasn't ever apologised for hiring Depp.

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

No retracting of her words about Benjamin Cohen and his husband after they were cleared this week.

Nothing on Gaza, Congo, Sudan.

With great power comes great responsibility. She failed every kid (including mine) who ever looked up to her as a safe haven. Mocking, raging against and misgendering trans people - and perpetuating harmful myths about them - is not feminism.

I have so much contempt for how she failed in her duty to lonely, isolated children who thought she cared about them.

So what you are saying is that you hate JKR because she hasn't done as you think she should and she won't stay in her lane, and is vocal about the causes that she supports but they are not the ones that you want her to?

That is the most Trans lobby/TRA reasoning that I have ever seen, full of #bekind, do as you are told and some made up BS for good measure.

BackToLurk · 10/10/2026 11:08

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/10/2026 06:20

Of course she hasn't. She consistently supports violent men (and hires them). And is probably aware that support for those evil rapists is strong among the kind of people who form her largest support base.

A lot of influential terfs are going to condemn Jane Doe, just watch - my guess is Rowling knows that, so is opting for cowardly silence.

She barely ever mentions actual women's issues unless they can be co-opted to support her cause, e.g. the cis man who chased his victim across the ground floor and into an inclusive locker room at Planet Fitness this week.

(If only it'd been a single-sex space huh - he would've had far too much respect for women to go in 🙄)

She hasn't ever apologised for hiring Depp.

Nothing when Lin Yu-ting passed new sex testing and was officially cleared to fight. Even though she set the whole internet after her, accusing her of being a man who likes hitting women.

No retracting of her words about Benjamin Cohen and his husband after they were cleared this week.

Nothing on Gaza, Congo, Sudan.

With great power comes great responsibility. She failed every kid (including mine) who ever looked up to her as a safe haven. Mocking, raging against and misgendering trans people - and perpetuating harmful myths about them - is not feminism.

I have so much contempt for how she failed in her duty to lonely, isolated children who thought she cared about them.

She barely ever mentions actual women's issues unless they can be co-opted to support her cause, e.g. the cis man who chased his victim across the ground floor and into an inclusive locker room at Planet Fitness this week.

Excellent. Given your confidence that the suspect is a ‘cis man’, you’re obviously just the person to help with a question that has been asked many times. Just how do we distinguish the transwomen from the ‘cis’ men? This suspect is 40. We all know of many, often high-profile, transwomen who’ve come out well after that age. Some of them have assaulted women before they came out. You’ve previously claimed that every one of them was always a woman, so how can you spot that this suspect is a ‘cis man’. It would be really helpful to know as no one else seems to be able to quite put their finger on it.

(There won’t be an answer).

PrancingPanda · 10/10/2026 11:30

I can't stand the phrase " Here's the thing..."
So patronising

TPA drawing from their barrel of vitriol again. Why so full of hate? Can't be healthy

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread