Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Silence on Cornell

241 replies

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:44

So… about J.K. Rowling. And the Cornell Seven, but we will get to that.

Here’s the thing: I liked Harry Potter growing up. It was the first and only chapter book my mom read to me, and I learned to read so I could read the second on my own after she refused to so so (for my own benefit).
Each year I was in school, there was a new book. I loved that they grew in depth as the characters aged. Yes, there were problems and problematic characters, but that’s a later subject.

I soured on Harry Potter when JKR kept adding things from the Pottermore website as canon: making Dumbledore gay was fine and easy to see in the book (see Grindelwald!), but the thing I hated was making Dumbledore in love with Harry
The greatest wizard of an age, hero and mentor to our protagonist… was revealed to be a pedophile in the post-script.
That’s shitty. My appreciation for the series soured after that, because suddenly the only “gay” representation is predatory and a heinous crime at that.

Fast forward a few years, and we see JKR’s anti-trans stance. Why? “Because she’s protecting real women!” She’s a TERF (derogatory) at best, but I think she’s actually much worse than that.

You see, she views those who support her works as synonymous with supporting her views, so to engage with her beloved franchise is to embolden her anti-trans and pro-billionaire crusade.

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

She wields real power in many ways, but what does she use it for? Oppression of the marginalized.

Now we come to the latest, and in many ways most concerning, activity or, rather, lack thereof; the Cornell 7.

Not once has she spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 (see attached image), a subject which would be *directly in support of women,” her alleged championed-cause.
She could speak out on this cause with ease, reaching millions. She could, at a stroke, fund all of Jane Doe's legal costs. But she doesn't. When there's actually a genuine case of harm of women but one that doesn't have the desired effect of harming marginalized communities she's as silent as the grave.

So no. I can’t in good faith engage with the franchise i used to love BECAUSE of the author, and JKR needs a real wake-up call before she does more harm.

“Talks on behalf of women” my ass. She’s almost as bad as Trumplestien.

Silence on Cornell
OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 05/10/2026 13:52

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 13:47

"‘Dehumanisation of trans people’ - get a grip"

Or, in other words, The Cult doesn't like anyone who speaks out against the worshipful deity of The Cult. You and your verifiable facts have no place in The Cult.

What "cult" would that be?

Be specific now.

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 13:47

Soontobe60 · 05/10/2026 13:23

‘Dehumanisation of trans people’ - get a grip 🤣🤣🤣

"‘Dehumanisation of trans people’ - get a grip"

Or, in other words, The Cult doesn't like anyone who speaks out against the worshipful deity of The Cult. You and your verifiable facts have no place in The Cult.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 05/10/2026 13:23

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 13:14

I'm no fan of JKR's demonisation & dehumanisation of trans people but I don't think its a betrayal of feminism not to comment on the Cornell 7 case yet until all the facts are known that won't be fully revealed until the court case comes to fruition. But what is certainly noteworthy is the misogynistic views both by women & men regarding the culpability of women's liberties & feminism for this issue.

I don't know any feminist worth their weight that isn't thoroughly disgusted & outraged by the misogynistic attitudes on full display on X at the moment. Its really grim so in that sense people particularly with powerful reach who claim to be supporters of women's rights should be calling it out.

In terms of rejecting JKR's work I would also caution against conflating the author with their work particularly since they are in contradiction to one another. As John Lithgow implied in not so many words, while the work has value to fight against bigotry it shouldn't be shunned.

‘Dehumanisation of trans people’ - get a grip 🤣🤣🤣

sohard · 05/10/2026 13:20

Thousands of women per hour are raped worldwide. Are we expecting JKR to speak about every single one?

Soontobe60 · 05/10/2026 13:19

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:59

I note that not a single responder so far has anything to say on JKR's shameful silence on the Cornell case.

It would appear her disciples are as silent as she is about topics that actually matter to women; unless, of course, those topics allow them to attack others whilst feigning support.

For shame.

You’re talking complete and utter nonsense. Unless you’ve been glued to a persons side 24/7 then you have absolutely NO idea what they have or haven’t said about any particular subject, especially allegations that have not been proven.
I feel quite sorry for you, your life must be very empty.

nutmeg7 · 05/10/2026 13:16

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:59

I note that not a single responder so far has anything to say on JKR's shameful silence on the Cornell case.

It would appear her disciples are as silent as she is about topics that actually matter to women; unless, of course, those topics allow them to attack others whilst feigning support.

For shame.

Oh feck off with your purity testing.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 13:14

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:44

So… about J.K. Rowling. And the Cornell Seven, but we will get to that.

Here’s the thing: I liked Harry Potter growing up. It was the first and only chapter book my mom read to me, and I learned to read so I could read the second on my own after she refused to so so (for my own benefit).
Each year I was in school, there was a new book. I loved that they grew in depth as the characters aged. Yes, there were problems and problematic characters, but that’s a later subject.

I soured on Harry Potter when JKR kept adding things from the Pottermore website as canon: making Dumbledore gay was fine and easy to see in the book (see Grindelwald!), but the thing I hated was making Dumbledore in love with Harry
The greatest wizard of an age, hero and mentor to our protagonist… was revealed to be a pedophile in the post-script.
That’s shitty. My appreciation for the series soured after that, because suddenly the only “gay” representation is predatory and a heinous crime at that.

Fast forward a few years, and we see JKR’s anti-trans stance. Why? “Because she’s protecting real women!” She’s a TERF (derogatory) at best, but I think she’s actually much worse than that.

You see, she views those who support her works as synonymous with supporting her views, so to engage with her beloved franchise is to embolden her anti-trans and pro-billionaire crusade.

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

She wields real power in many ways, but what does she use it for? Oppression of the marginalized.

Now we come to the latest, and in many ways most concerning, activity or, rather, lack thereof; the Cornell 7.

Not once has she spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 (see attached image), a subject which would be *directly in support of women,” her alleged championed-cause.
She could speak out on this cause with ease, reaching millions. She could, at a stroke, fund all of Jane Doe's legal costs. But she doesn't. When there's actually a genuine case of harm of women but one that doesn't have the desired effect of harming marginalized communities she's as silent as the grave.

So no. I can’t in good faith engage with the franchise i used to love BECAUSE of the author, and JKR needs a real wake-up call before she does more harm.

“Talks on behalf of women” my ass. She’s almost as bad as Trumplestien.

I'm no fan of JKR's demonisation & dehumanisation of trans people but I don't think its a betrayal of feminism not to comment on the Cornell 7 case yet until all the facts are known that won't be fully revealed until the court case comes to fruition. But what is certainly noteworthy is the misogynistic views both by women & men regarding the culpability of women's liberties & feminism for this issue.

I don't know any feminist worth their weight that isn't thoroughly disgusted & outraged by the misogynistic attitudes on full display on X at the moment. Its really grim so in that sense people particularly with powerful reach who claim to be supporters of women's rights should be calling it out.

In terms of rejecting JKR's work I would also caution against conflating the author with their work particularly since they are in contradiction to one another. As John Lithgow implied in not so many words, while the work has value to fight against bigotry it shouldn't be shunned.

Maaate · 05/10/2026 13:10

You could perhaps make a list of Tra types who have also not posted anything about the case, if that was in any way helpful?

We've had at least 2 threads started on here by TRAs using this horrendous case purely to have a pop at MN posters and now JKR.

No shock, anger or sympathy for Jane Doe. No actual discussion of the events, no condemnation of the vile men who perpetrated and enabled it to happen. No mention of the institutional response and cover up of what happened.

Just salivating over a chance to slag off other women

For shame OP. Disgusting

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 05/10/2026 13:08

My tap is wobbly. Almost certainly JKR's fault. I see she still hasn't commented on it, despite me living a long way away, or even said a few platitudes.

Bloody hell! As if entertaining me, getting my children to read (and inspiring their imagination) and doing loads of incredibly generous things with her money such as funding support for raped women, helping get Afghani women away from the Taliban and helping children all over the world over decades was gift enough for one mere human.

Obviously she's just unconscionable if she won't deign to ALSO FIX MY TAP and comment on every injustice the world over ever!

TL DR version:
Waaah! Mummy won't give in to my strop!

Igneococcus · 05/10/2026 12:59

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

We've had a gazillion threads about the Amnesty report. I assume this wasn't written specifically for MN.

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 05/10/2026 12:59

You’ve just decided that everything she does is wrong. So that’s that really.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 05/10/2026 12:44

SockPlant · 05/10/2026 12:42

We should start a list of people who haven't made a statement on this and pile on them. Cunts. All of them

Edited

I haven't seen ANY drag queens comment on this. Shocked.

OhBotherSaidPoo · 05/10/2026 12:44

She really does live rent free in your head. You should probably get a hobby.

SockPlant · 05/10/2026 12:42

We should start a list of people who haven't made a statement on this and pile on them. Cunts. All of them

Somnambule · 05/10/2026 12:34

I've just read the OP word for word posted by some dudebro on Facebook.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 05/10/2026 12:34

@ZanyAnt- from the spelling /phrasing of your OP, I’m assuming you are American, would I be right? And as such, I’m guessing this is a very big story in the US, something that pretty much all US based feminists and men’s rights activists have taken a stance on, discussed publicly. Have I got that right? Is it one of those big cases in your news cycle that everyone’s talking about and you have heard from pretty much everyone about it?

Thing is, while it has been reported on some news websites, it’s not a big story over here in the UK. It’s not had a great deal of coverage and very few UK based commentators (from either side of the discussion) have said anything.

However what you might have missed, being US and not UK based, is its party conference time. JKR has commented on the Green Party conference.

does Jane Doe need to raise funds for her legal costs and can’t find local donators? if she was looking to get her legal costs supported, that definitely hasn’t been reported in the UK so I’m not sure it’s fair to expect JKR to have known she might need financial help.

Impic · 05/10/2026 12:34

I've just seen this exact same post on Facebook.

Word for word.

What can JKR say about this case except platitudes that may or may not be welcomed by the victim?

I bet if she had said something TRAs would find a reason why she shouldn't have.

Whether or not JKR cares about this particular case is entirely irrelevant to trans issues. Do you think you saying, "look, she's a bad person" is going to make sex stop being a biological immutable fact?

tokennamechange · 05/10/2026 12:32

um, where on earth was it revealed that Dumbledore was in love with Harry? Any actual evidence for this please?

JKR does a lot to support women, including victims of rape, in her own country including literally setting up a rape support centre. Why on earth do you think she's under some sort of obligation to post about and pay for the victims of rape worldwide? Or is it just american exceptionalism?

Mapletree1985 · 05/10/2026 12:23

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:44

So… about J.K. Rowling. And the Cornell Seven, but we will get to that.

Here’s the thing: I liked Harry Potter growing up. It was the first and only chapter book my mom read to me, and I learned to read so I could read the second on my own after she refused to so so (for my own benefit).
Each year I was in school, there was a new book. I loved that they grew in depth as the characters aged. Yes, there were problems and problematic characters, but that’s a later subject.

I soured on Harry Potter when JKR kept adding things from the Pottermore website as canon: making Dumbledore gay was fine and easy to see in the book (see Grindelwald!), but the thing I hated was making Dumbledore in love with Harry
The greatest wizard of an age, hero and mentor to our protagonist… was revealed to be a pedophile in the post-script.
That’s shitty. My appreciation for the series soured after that, because suddenly the only “gay” representation is predatory and a heinous crime at that.

Fast forward a few years, and we see JKR’s anti-trans stance. Why? “Because she’s protecting real women!” She’s a TERF (derogatory) at best, but I think she’s actually much worse than that.

You see, she views those who support her works as synonymous with supporting her views, so to engage with her beloved franchise is to embolden her anti-trans and pro-billionaire crusade.

She recently bullied Amnesty International into apologizing to her for simply stating facts (look it up!)

She wields real power in many ways, but what does she use it for? Oppression of the marginalized.

Now we come to the latest, and in many ways most concerning, activity or, rather, lack thereof; the Cornell 7.

Not once has she spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 (see attached image), a subject which would be *directly in support of women,” her alleged championed-cause.
She could speak out on this cause with ease, reaching millions. She could, at a stroke, fund all of Jane Doe's legal costs. But she doesn't. When there's actually a genuine case of harm of women but one that doesn't have the desired effect of harming marginalized communities she's as silent as the grave.

So no. I can’t in good faith engage with the franchise i used to love BECAUSE of the author, and JKR needs a real wake-up call before she does more harm.

“Talks on behalf of women” my ass. She’s almost as bad as Trumplestien.

She's not American, she doesn't teach in the USA, Cornell is not in Scotland - I realize this is big news in the USA, but the UK has its own problems to deal with. And what is there to say about this case anyway? It's just men doing what men have always done. We all know it is reprehensible and to be condemned - except, apparently, the people in charge at Cornell and in the USA.

somekindofdoughnut · 05/10/2026 12:11

'So here's the thing' - OK, AI.

ProfessorRedshoeblueshoe · 05/10/2026 12:11

How long did the last thread like this last ? That one claimed the woman was raped due to transphobia.

QiBengong · 05/10/2026 12:11

It is possible to care about things without posting on X, it is possible to support and fund things privately, without announcing it.

Considering the money JKR donates to womens organisations and survivors of rape she probably does more practical good for rape victims than any number of performative posters on X. You could perhaps make a list of Tra types who have also not posted anything about the case, if that was in any way helpful?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 05/10/2026 12:09

Iainsninelives · 05/10/2026 12:04

Wait, you are saying you will no longer have anything to do with JKR because of something she didn't do? Now, I’m not her biggest fan, i am a trans ally (i know, frowned upon here, but i never join the conversations so) but even I can’t fault someone for not saying something. That’s utterly weird. Why do you think JKR is obligated to speak on this?

Why do you think JKR is obligated to speak on this?

Thank you for saying this.

Igmum · 05/10/2026 12:09

🙄🙄🙄

And the first rule of misogyny is…

As an aside interesting to see I’m now a disciple, I thought I was an alt-right/Christian funded something or other.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 05/10/2026 12:06

ZanyAnt · 05/10/2026 11:59

I note that not a single responder so far has anything to say on JKR's shameful silence on the Cornell case.

It would appear her disciples are as silent as she is about topics that actually matter to women; unless, of course, those topics allow them to attack others whilst feigning support.

For shame.

I must've missed Andy Burnham's statement on this case?
Zack Polanski?
Windy Willoughby? (I'm scraping the barrel now for TRA spokespeople)

Where have you, OP, spoken or tweeted about the Cornell 7 in a way that proves you actually care about the victim?

You're just yet another poster weaponizing this case and the victim's horrendous experience and real distress to score cheap points about something unrelated.

For shame.