Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The constant use of Groomer against TRAs is doing the GC cause harm

586 replies

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 18:59

Just seen this posted by Glinner
https://x.com/Glinner/status/2106504469651579047
Text
Russell T Davies says I called him "a paedophile and a groomer" in this. It's a lie. I did call him a groomer, because he used Doctor Who to push gender ideology, in which no child would believe unless an adult had planted it in his or her head.

And I just find it disingenuous from him. It's no secret I don't love his decent into more, let's call it, aggressive strategies on social media, but they are now coming home to roost and won't be good for any of us.

The word Groomer has a very specific history when it comes to CSA so to use it as often as he (and other) do and then claim you don't mean it in the very well accepted way is always meant just doesn't sit right with me.

Is there a term we can use that isn't sp precariously close to slandering someone as a Child sex abuser?

Here is the article he is referring to in the tweet

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

‘One person turned up at my house’: Russell T Davies on fierce fandom, finding love after grief - and the fear that drives him to keep a knife by the door

He’s the titan of TV who revived a flatlined Doctor Who and turned British queer life into jaw-dropping drama. But the screenwriter’s groundbreaking writing has sometimes made him a target of hate – from homophobes and Whovians alike

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:47

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 06:39

But you said gender roles were innate in humans So what the poster is asking ,and you deliberately misunderstanding, is what gender roles are unique to females and which are unique to males, or is there an overlap and you are talking bollocks again
@Helleofabore sorry for jumping in

No I did not. Its gendered behaviour that's partly biological. Gender roles are social constructs/human categorisations.

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:43

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 06:39

But you said gender roles were innate in humans So what the poster is asking ,and you deliberately misunderstanding, is what gender roles are unique to females and which are unique to males, or is there an overlap and you are talking bollocks again
@Helleofabore sorry for jumping in

Go for it!

Toodarktooearly · 07/10/2026 06:43

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 19:11

But the vast, VAST majority is. Do you think RTD is guilty of grooming children?

Yes he's part of the problem and should apologise

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:43

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:37

One paper does not make ‘scientific consensus’ even if it brought together other papers.

When sex categorisation matters, a persons gender identity is irrelevant. Hence, when regulations exclude all male people, that is legitimate sex discrimination.

So you now concede you have nothing to eliminate biological influences given your refusal to provide it with obfuscation.

Thankyou.

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 06:39

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:36

I don't know what you are blabbering on about to avoid accountability. My comments regarding behaviour pertain to gender categories not sex categories.

Now where's your evidence?

But you said gender roles were innate in humans So what the poster is asking ,and you deliberately misunderstanding, is what gender roles are unique to females and which are unique to males, or is there an overlap and you are talking bollocks again
@Helleofabore sorry for jumping in

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:38

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:36

I don't know what you are blabbering on about to avoid accountability. My comments regarding behaviour pertain to gender categories not sex categories.

Now where's your evidence?

Super feminine of you.

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:37

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:26

Says the person that claims that sex categories of humans can be categorised by behavioural traits.

I have said no such thing. Its gender categories & that's not my opinion but a sociological fact that gender categories are a socially constructed set of roles, behaviours, expressions and norms that a culture associates with being a boy or a man a girl or a woman. In fact the gender critical movement agrees with this otherwise how would they square their belief in gender stereotyping?

But nice attempt at diverting with false representation to avoid your accountability to provide evidence of your anti science claim that human behaviour is purely environmentally influenced.

That you can't bring yourself to at least acknowledge the scientific consensus on the matter can only be deduced as an effort to deny female agency.

Edited

One paper does not make ‘scientific consensus’ even if it brought together other papers.

When sex categorisation matters, a persons gender identity is irrelevant. Hence, when regulations exclude all male people, that is legitimate sex discrimination.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:36

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:31

At least we have moved from seeing that link to the self reported personality traits. A very good example of why those self descriptions fail would be how some people might describe themselves as super feminine on the personality questionnaire, yet in real life might show many more masculine traits and none of those super feminine traits in their everyday interaction with others. And this can be seen regularly on self published content, particularly videos, across social media platforms.

Any research that uses self reported personality traits as a basis for categorising sex categories, or even just a snap shot of time and how people behave, is going to only be able to claim very broad conclusions. It will also be why there is no resource tool created yet that will be able to be used to define sex category from personality / behaviourial traits.

Did we even get a list of what behaviourial / personality traits are associated with female vs male humans?

Or is this theory still at its concept stage with no usable tools coming from it?

I don't know what you are blabbering on about to avoid accountability. My comments regarding behaviour pertain to gender categories not sex categories.

Now where's your evidence?

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:31

At least we have moved from seeing that link to the self reported personality traits. A very good example of why those self descriptions fail would be how some people might describe themselves as super feminine on the personality questionnaire, yet in real life might show many more masculine traits and none of those super feminine traits in their everyday interaction with others. And this can be seen regularly on self published content, particularly videos, across social media platforms.

Any research that uses self reported personality traits as a basis for categorising sex categories, or even just a snap shot of time and how people behave, is going to only be able to claim very broad conclusions. It will also be why there is no resource tool created yet that will be able to be used to define sex category from personality / behaviourial traits.

Did we even get a list of what behaviourial / personality traits are associated with female vs male humans?

Or is this theory still at its concept stage with no usable tools coming from it?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 06:26

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:15

Says the person that claims that sex categories of humans can be categorised by behavioural traits.

As many of us on many threads have pointed out, there may be some behaviourial traits that may more aligned with one sex category of human than the other. Although they are not exclusive to one sex category. Therefore, behaviourial traits are an unreliable category definition of human sex category.

Because there are many humans who will not have the behaviourial traits that may be associated with their sex category and have those associated with the opposite sex category, and this does not change or negate the sex category that their body was formed around.

It is you who has attempted over many months, threads and user names to tell other posters that behaviourial / personality traits are a sex distinguishable trait. Some posters have pointed out that because many relevant points such as overlap between sex categories, lack of definition and changebility over time, behaviourial / personality traits are not reliable categorisation tools for human sex categories and that just because a male person may have some behaviourial traits categorised as being more associated with female people, he is not a female person.

Says the person that claims that sex categories of humans can be categorised by behavioural traits.

I have said no such thing. Its gender categories & that's not my opinion but a sociological fact that gender categories are a socially constructed set of roles, behaviours, expressions and norms that a culture associates with being a boy or a man a girl or a woman. In fact the gender critical movement agrees with this otherwise how would they square their belief in gender stereotyping?

But nice attempt at diverting with false representation to avoid your accountability to provide evidence of your anti science claim that human behaviour is purely environmentally influenced.

That you can't bring yourself to at least acknowledge the scientific consensus on the matter can only be deduced as an effort to deny female agency.

Helleofabore · 07/10/2026 06:15

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 06/10/2026 23:34

What you don't seem to comprehend is whether the research proves a smoking gun is irrelevant. All it has to do is point to credible possibilities supported by evidence that can't be ruled out. And that's essentially the problem with the blank slatists argument….it can't rule out biological influences. Hence you being unable to show how they are ruled out & clinging to tenuous obtuse argument.

Says the person that claims that sex categories of humans can be categorised by behavioural traits.

As many of us on many threads have pointed out, there may be some behaviourial traits that may more aligned with one sex category of human than the other. Although they are not exclusive to one sex category. Therefore, behaviourial traits are an unreliable category definition of human sex category.

Because there are many humans who will not have the behaviourial traits that may be associated with their sex category and have those associated with the opposite sex category, and this does not change or negate the sex category that their body was formed around.

It is you who has attempted over many months, threads and user names to tell other posters that behaviourial / personality traits are a sex distinguishable trait. Some posters have pointed out that because many relevant points such as overlap between sex categories, lack of definition and changebility over time, behaviourial / personality traits are not reliable categorisation tools for human sex categories and that just because a male person may have some behaviourial traits categorised as being more associated with female people, he is not a female person.

Rollingpinofdoom · 07/10/2026 05:35

Helleofabore · 06/10/2026 15:15

Indeed.

I would love to know how the paper is going to be proved in this modern era. I suspect it cannot because controlling for other influences cannot be done.

It is as weak as the self reported questionnaire that asked people about their personality traits. Apparently that was supposed to be convincing too.

But… apparently, this ‘evidence’ is strong enough to support that behavioural traits of the sexes are clearly defined enough to use as a basis for sex categorisation……

Yeah. If gender norms innate but also are unique depending on hormones and genes,as some posters claim then gender roles are meaningless and cannot be proven to be innate. Unless we monitor and record every hormone and gene on a baby at birth, then monitor each behaviour growing up, then compare each person to every other person to see what they do, we will never know. It has been proven that children pick up behaviours and language from a very early age however. This is proven. Therefore there seems to be more evidence that gender roles are learned and not innate

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 06/10/2026 23:34

Helleofabore · 06/10/2026 15:15

Indeed.

I would love to know how the paper is going to be proved in this modern era. I suspect it cannot because controlling for other influences cannot be done.

It is as weak as the self reported questionnaire that asked people about their personality traits. Apparently that was supposed to be convincing too.

But… apparently, this ‘evidence’ is strong enough to support that behavioural traits of the sexes are clearly defined enough to use as a basis for sex categorisation……

What you don't seem to comprehend is whether the research proves a smoking gun is irrelevant. All it has to do is point to credible possibilities supported by evidence that can't be ruled out. And that's essentially the problem with the blank slatists argument….it can't rule out biological influences. Hence you being unable to show how they are ruled out & clinging to tenuous obtuse argument.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 06/10/2026 23:25

DeanElderberry · 06/10/2026 09:25

Has anyone done that?

Nature exists. Nurture exists.

Gender is an artificial social construct, very culture specific, developed in different ways in different societies in different eras.

Correlation is not causation. You have no evidence that gender is exclusively a social construct. Your own defence disproves your argument.The fact that cultures differ in expression of gender can also be a result of cultural pressures. Women in Afghanistan aren't sporting mini skirts & high heals for a reason….they aren’t at liberty to. That's why when measuring gendered cultural differences in egalitarian countries like in Sweden are more accurate which research has shown to have even broader differences in gendered behaviour particularly in employment choices.

Helleofabore · 06/10/2026 15:15

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 06/10/2026 13:23

Yes; many theories look reasonable for a while but they can simply be shown eventually to be incorrect. As with phlogiston. Or the geocentric theory, which accumulated more and more extra theories to explain the movement of the planets through the heavens, since they too must revolve round the earth. Or the notion that illnesses sink through the body and eventually out through the feet; the discovery of the circulation of the blood did for that one, I think.

Theories that turn out on further examination (which that paper calls for) not to be accurate are called "exploded", as far as I know.

Some theories start with a new discovery or insight, such as that of a Ptolomy or an Archimedes or a Galileo or an Einstein, around which older theories have to be adjusted. Some theories seem to start from "here is a nice hypothesis: I wonder if it can be shown to work?" Perhaps the problem is when what is actually a hypothesis gets referred to as a theory?

Indeed.

I would love to know how the paper is going to be proved in this modern era. I suspect it cannot because controlling for other influences cannot be done.

It is as weak as the self reported questionnaire that asked people about their personality traits. Apparently that was supposed to be convincing too.

But… apparently, this ‘evidence’ is strong enough to support that behavioural traits of the sexes are clearly defined enough to use as a basis for sex categorisation……

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 06/10/2026 13:23

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 09:44

That really isn't how scientific theories work. They are ideas which are demonstrably supported by existing evidence. Alternative theories may be developed that better explain the evidence or new evidence discovered that requires a change in theory. But they aren't just ideas without any backing whatever.

Yes; many theories look reasonable for a while but they can simply be shown eventually to be incorrect. As with phlogiston. Or the geocentric theory, which accumulated more and more extra theories to explain the movement of the planets through the heavens, since they too must revolve round the earth. Or the notion that illnesses sink through the body and eventually out through the feet; the discovery of the circulation of the blood did for that one, I think.

Theories that turn out on further examination (which that paper calls for) not to be accurate are called "exploded", as far as I know.

Some theories start with a new discovery or insight, such as that of a Ptolomy or an Archimedes or a Galileo or an Einstein, around which older theories have to be adjusted. Some theories seem to start from "here is a nice hypothesis: I wonder if it can be shown to work?" Perhaps the problem is when what is actually a hypothesis gets referred to as a theory?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 06/10/2026 13:18

Only a sinking ship, @Boiledbeetle

Boiledbeetle · 06/10/2026 12:43

Just catching up.

Hyperbole with this one strong.

Is there something in the water at the moment?

May The Fourth Be With You Star Wars GIF
Helleofabore · 06/10/2026 12:43

PollyNomial · 06/10/2026 09:44

That really isn't how scientific theories work. They are ideas which are demonstrably supported by existing evidence. Alternative theories may be developed that better explain the evidence or new evidence discovered that requires a change in theory. But they aren't just ideas without any backing whatever.

Sure.

Anyone can develop a ‘scientific theory’.

However, if a team of academics wish their theory to be considered strong, they need to support it with strong evidence. Do you think the paper linked provided strong evidence that means that the environment was well controlled so that a conclusion could be drawn? Did you even bother to read the conclusion the paper drew before jumping in ?

HousePlantEmergency · 06/10/2026 12:18

Sexually reproducing creatures without a nervous system can tell the difference between male and female.

No gendered behaviours required.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/10/2026 10:47

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 06/10/2026 08:50

Oh look. Someone can quote bollocks whilst they mansplain that gender is innate and all women like pink and makeup.

& all the while to my intense irritation he keeps using the bloody Greengrocer's Apostrophe.

Edited

As I’ve mentioned before sometimes people online adopt little writing tics because they have another posting identity, to throw people off that so they don’t get identified. Not suggesting this is the case, but it’s a thing.

Shedmistress · 06/10/2026 10:09

Wishesandhorses · 06/10/2026 09:52

Yes, knew a similar one. Used to get absolutely plastered and then hang himself around the shoulder of anyone silly enough to make eye contact, put his face to theirs and sob 'are you saved?'

And that was your evening gone, he'd drain you dry on that one.

I found many that would hang off the side of a quiz machine and call out wrong answers and if you pressed the right answer would claim credit anyway.

Wishesandhorses · 06/10/2026 09:52

Shedmistress · 06/10/2026 09:49

There used to be a chap in the pub, most pubs, that would bang on and on about incomprehensibe nonsense and take the lack of 'resounding argument' as evidence of their 'I'm right'ness.

Most people just avoided him like the plague. For reasons he may never quite comprehend.

Yes, knew a similar one. Used to get absolutely plastered and then hang himself around the shoulder of anyone silly enough to make eye contact, put his face to theirs and sob 'are you saved?'

And that was your evening gone, he'd drain you dry on that one.

DeanElderberry · 06/10/2026 09:52

Do schools still teach reading comprehension?

I keep remembering teaching a BA evening class tutorial group ca 45 years ago where one bloke was being very repetitive and very resistant to learning anything about the subject, and it gradually became clear that be was well infused with wacky backy.

Mentioned it to a mutual acquaintance and was told yes, his job was customs official and he'd had a 'good' day.

Shedmistress · 06/10/2026 09:49

There used to be a chap in the pub, most pubs, that would bang on and on about incomprehensibe nonsense and take the lack of 'resounding argument' as evidence of their 'I'm right'ness.

Most people just avoided him like the plague. For reasons he may never quite comprehend.