Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The constant use of Groomer against TRAs is doing the GC cause harm

586 replies

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 18:59

Just seen this posted by Glinner
https://x.com/Glinner/status/2106504469651579047
Text
Russell T Davies says I called him "a paedophile and a groomer" in this. It's a lie. I did call him a groomer, because he used Doctor Who to push gender ideology, in which no child would believe unless an adult had planted it in his or her head.

And I just find it disingenuous from him. It's no secret I don't love his decent into more, let's call it, aggressive strategies on social media, but they are now coming home to roost and won't be good for any of us.

The word Groomer has a very specific history when it comes to CSA so to use it as often as he (and other) do and then claim you don't mean it in the very well accepted way is always meant just doesn't sit right with me.

Is there a term we can use that isn't sp precariously close to slandering someone as a Child sex abuser?

Here is the article he is referring to in the tweet

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

‘One person turned up at my house’: Russell T Davies on fierce fandom, finding love after grief - and the fear that drives him to keep a knife by the door

He’s the titan of TV who revived a flatlined Doctor Who and turned British queer life into jaw-dropping drama. But the screenwriter’s groundbreaking writing has sometimes made him a target of hate – from homophobes and Whovians alike

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:11

The “GC but”-ness of it all

Pingponghavoc · 05/10/2026 00:11

In at least one episode of Doctor Who, a male character was described being born a boy but is now a women.

Its dangerous telling children than a grown man is a woman.

Its basic safeguarding that we know age and sex. Females are girls and women. Males are boys and men. Its important that children understand this.

Its not just RTD fault, the bbc let it happen. But RTD did try to confuse children for the sake of it. Doctor who didnt need to introduce such a concept.

Hoardasurass · 05/10/2026 00:10

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 04/10/2026 23:51

p.s. As ever, apologies for typos - 'see' not 'are' etc.

I want to say something about the myth which is 'transing'.

No one is doing this. Not parents, teachers or any other adult. There is no gang of Big Pharma execs forcing children to be trans.

Every trans child will tell you that being out is both liberating and terrifying. Anti-trans violence is real.

Some basic points:

  • No parent craves having a trans child. They know how much danger trans kids face.

Being out at school massively affects academic performance too. It's days off school because the child is either worn out or too scared to attend. The modern curriculum is so tough that losing even a few weeks of school will likely drop a child's grades - and many trans kids stop going in for months, or at all. Non-attendance also risks parents being fined, and having to cope with endless meetings with teachers.

  • No parent thinks the life of a trans child is easier than that of a gay cis child. You can hide being gay, but not being trans.

And think about it. Which would parents accept more readily: a child being gay or a child being trans?

  • No, parents who support their trans children aren't suffering from factitious disorder imposed on another (used to be called Munchausen by proxy). No parent gains from having a trans child. There is no attention, no financial reward (often a major driver of FDIOA), and no constant medical procedures.

Surgery for under-18s is banned almost everywhere.

Gender-affirming care is almost impossible to access unless you have a lot of spare cash.

Parents with FDIOA want endless medical procedures performed on their children, and to make them ill. The child being oblivious to this deception - and believing they are sick - is critical to the FDIOA parent's success.

A trans child not permanently ill or attending hospital.

My son changed his name, hair and pronouns. Still wore the exact same uniform as before. I hated all the constant school contact. GCs still call me 'Munchausen' and accuse me of 'transing' him on a weekly basis. Oh and of being a groomer too, because of course.

  • Parents who manage to find the money for gender-affirming care are not doing it because they desperately want to 'trans' their child.

It's to save their life. Living with both dysphoria and anti-trans violence - while failing school - makes trans children feel they have no future.

The myth that adults are advocating for and directly 'transing' children is leading to vigilantism.

That's why RTD is scared.

Everyone who claims people like him (a gay man with a very full life) are 'transing' gay children and actively preying on them, are directly encouraging cranks to target them.

The myth of 'transing' exists because:

a) anti-trans people don't want to accept that they're doing great harm to trans children, so prefer to believe their existence is a conspiracy. The origin myths are quite breaktaking in their unreality. (Silliest of all is the 'trans the gay away' myth. Sexuality isn't gender, and trans people are straight, gay, ace etc. My son is a trans gay man, for example. I know an ace trans woman.) 'Transing' is a far-right creation, used to justify violence against trans people.

b) to reinforce the claim that no one is actually trans.

'Transing' doesn't happen.

Learning about being trans/nb doesn't create trans children either. Trans kids are still few and far between, usually a couple per school.

'Transing' is a variation on homophobic lies about why gay people exist, designed to stamp on the rights of minorities by saying who they are isn't real.

I'll end here (I know, finally 😁) by saying: being trans is not easy. In fact, it's a life of discrimination and violence.

Please stop encouraging vigilantism. Please.

Edited

Suzzy green admitted transitioning her gay son because her husband was homophobic.
The running ironic "joke" at the Tavistock clinic was that their would be no gay children left.
Jazz jennings parents made a fortune from him
Look at all the insta parents getting fame and adulation from transitioning their kids.
We've had parents on here so desperate for a trans child that they claimed a non verbal 9 month old waving their hand over a picture book proved they were trans.
We had that American nut job behind the satanic panic claim that baby girls pulling out ribbons and hair clips made them transmen and that baby boys who unpoppering their onesies mean that they are transwomen.
Everything that you have posted is provably false

MidnightMeltdown · 05/10/2026 00:09

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 19:11

But the vast, VAST majority is. Do you think RTD is guilty of grooming children?

I don’t think you understand what the term grooming means OP. It is not synonymous with sexual abuse.

Grooming behaviours can lead to sexual abuse, but not necessarily. Also, anyone can be groomed, not just children.

NotBadConsidering · 05/10/2026 00:05

Of course, lots of people participate in grooming without realising it. They facilitate the grooming for others. They are unwitting participants.

You see this when people demonstrate their lack of understanding of safeguarding. The teachers who don’t see a problem with other staff members being alone with children. The gymnastics organisations who let young athletes see a doctor unchecked.

This is pervasive in gender ideology. The teachers told it’s okay to keep children’s secrets from parents. The doctors implementing WPATH’s guidelines. The charities that employ people with questionable backgrounds and hold secret discussions online. The parents dealing with it at home while their child spends time on grooming forums like Reddit and Discord, where young girls are told “you look awesome Dude!” and and “you totally pass Bro!”

It’s not the teachers, the doctors, the good-intentioned charity workers, or the parents doing the grooming. They have been groomed themselves into thinking it’s all acceptable or just what you “have to do”.

ScrollingLeaves · 05/10/2026 00:02

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:36

Its a far right catch call that has its historical roots as a device to demonise groups that particularly gained a claim to fame by the Nazi's about Jews, homosexuals, socialists etc & their alleged cultural spreading of 'degeneracy'.

The idea is non conformity/'degeneracy' isn't an autonomous innate expression but rather a taught 'groomed' one. It's problematic to anyone who understands an aversion/'disgust' of non conformity & self determination is socially harmful.

Nonsense faux academic chop and glue.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/10/2026 23:58

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:44

A movement that uses the same rhetoric & frames their philosophy is the same ideas as the far right only has themselves to blame if they come to be associated to them.

What nonsense.

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:55

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 23:51

It's not a smear to point out the links. In fact calling out the far right using women's rights to further their own agenda would be a pretty good way of dispelling the claims that Nazis are welcomed by GC people. If you're not willing to call them out then you're part of the problem frankly.

I could point out myriad ways in which trans activists behave like far right goons, you know? Do you call them out? And I mean, most people, far right or not argue against trans bullshit because it is bullshit. They believe in material reality like the next person, I won’t call them out for that, but I will call them out for racism, for example.

Do you call out the transpeople, some of them on this very board, who issue rape threats to women? If not, why not?

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 23:51

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:37

What bullshit. I’m sick of these attempts to smear people who care about women’s rights as far-right.

It's not a smear to point out the links. In fact calling out the far right using women's rights to further their own agenda would be a pretty good way of dispelling the claims that Nazis are welcomed by GC people. If you're not willing to call them out then you're part of the problem frankly.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 04/10/2026 23:51

p.s. As ever, apologies for typos - 'see' not 'are' etc.

I want to say something about the myth which is 'transing'.

No one is doing this. Not parents, teachers or any other adult. There is no gang of Big Pharma execs forcing children to be trans.

Every trans child will tell you that being out is both liberating and terrifying. Anti-trans violence is real.

Some basic points:

  • No parent craves having a trans child. They know how much danger trans kids face.

Being out at school massively affects academic performance too. It's days off school because the child is either worn out or too scared to attend. The modern curriculum is so tough that losing even a few weeks of school will likely drop a child's grades - and many trans kids stop going in for months, or at all. Non-attendance also risks parents being fined, and having to cope with endless meetings with teachers.

  • No parent thinks the life of a trans child is easier than that of a gay cis child. You can hide being gay, but not being trans.

And think about it. Which would parents accept more readily: a child being gay or a child being trans?

  • No, parents who support their trans children aren't suffering from factitious disorder imposed on another (used to be called Munchausen by proxy). No parent gains from having a trans child. There is no attention, no financial reward (often a major driver of FDIOA), and no constant medical procedures.

Surgery for under-18s is banned almost everywhere.

Gender-affirming care is almost impossible to access unless you have a lot of spare cash.

Parents with FDIOA want endless medical procedures performed on their children, and to make them ill. The child being oblivious to this deception - and believing they are sick - is critical to the FDIOA parent's success.

A trans child not permanently ill or attending hospital.

My son changed his name, hair and pronouns. Still wore the exact same uniform as before. I hated all the constant school contact. GCs still call me 'Munchausen' and accuse me of 'transing' him on a weekly basis. Oh and of being a groomer too, because of course.

  • Parents who manage to find the money for gender-affirming care are not doing it because they desperately want to 'trans' their child.

It's to save their life. Living with both dysphoria and anti-trans violence - while failing school - makes trans children feel they have no future.

The myth that adults are advocating for and directly 'transing' children is leading to vigilantism.

That's why RTD is scared.

Everyone who claims people like him (a gay man with a very full life) are 'transing' gay children and actively preying on them, are directly encouraging cranks to target them.

The myth of 'transing' exists because:

a) anti-trans people don't want to accept that they're doing great harm to trans children, so prefer to believe their existence is a conspiracy. The origin myths are quite breaktaking in their unreality. (Silliest of all is the 'trans the gay away' myth. Sexuality isn't gender, and trans people are straight, gay, ace etc. My son is a trans gay man, for example. I know an ace trans woman.) 'Transing' is a far-right creation, used to justify violence against trans people.

b) to reinforce the claim that no one is actually trans.

'Transing' doesn't happen.

Learning about being trans/nb doesn't create trans children either. Trans kids are still few and far between, usually a couple per school.

'Transing' is a variation on homophobic lies about why gay people exist, designed to stamp on the rights of minorities by saying who they are isn't real.

I'll end here (I know, finally 😁) by saying: being trans is not easy. In fact, it's a life of discrimination and violence.

Please stop encouraging vigilantism. Please.

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:46

NotBadConsidering · 04/10/2026 23:46

Ignore HowseItChopping, just the usual nonsense, wait until the Wikipedia links start, then it’s really nonsensical.

Oh, it’s Howse is it? Enough said!

NotBadConsidering · 04/10/2026 23:46

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:37

What bullshit. I’m sick of these attempts to smear people who care about women’s rights as far-right.

Ignore HowseItChopping, just the usual nonsense, wait until the Wikipedia links start, then it’s really nonsensical.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:44

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:37

What bullshit. I’m sick of these attempts to smear people who care about women’s rights as far-right.

A movement that uses the same rhetoric & frames their philosophy is the same ideas as the far right only has themselves to blame if they come to be associated to them.

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:37

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:36

Its a far right catch call that has its historical roots as a device to demonise groups that particularly gained a claim to fame by the Nazi's about Jews, homosexuals, socialists etc & their alleged cultural spreading of 'degeneracy'.

The idea is non conformity/'degeneracy' isn't an autonomous innate expression but rather a taught 'groomed' one. It's problematic to anyone who understands an aversion/'disgust' of non conformity & self determination is socially harmful.

What bullshit. I’m sick of these attempts to smear people who care about women’s rights as far-right.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:36

Cattywillow · 04/10/2026 23:15

Grooming doesn’t mean just sexual. I think it’s a helpful term in a number of different contexts.

Its a far right catch call that has its historical roots as a device to demonise groups that particularly gained a claim to fame by the Nazi's about Jews, homosexuals, socialists etc & their alleged cultural spreading of 'degeneracy'.

The idea is non conformity/'degeneracy' isn't an autonomous innate expression but rather a taught 'groomed' one. It's problematic to anyone who understands an aversion/'disgust' of non conformity & self determination is socially harmful.

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 23:30

Canadanian · 04/10/2026 22:56

just one example - is somone like @Soontobe60 just saying they understand why someone might use the term groomers, or are they just saying they thinks people supporting trans rights are groomers, on their post on this thread? (It’s the latter)

Depends on what you mean by supporting trans rights.
If you mean anyone who is promoting gender ideology to children then yes they are all groomers.
If you mean people saying trans identifying males belong in women's spaces i think the terms misogynist, women haters and delusional would be more accurate
If you mean people saying that trans identifying people should be allowed to work, rent a home and not be abused then no

NotBadConsidering · 04/10/2026 23:20

Cattywillow · 04/10/2026 23:15

Grooming doesn’t mean just sexual. I think it’s a helpful term in a number of different contexts.

Exactly. The entire concept of Adolescence and the Tate brothers, incel culture etc involves the acceptance that young males are being groomed into these cultures.

It’s accepted that young Muslims can be groomed into Jihadist beliefs.

As a society, we now recognise grooming takes many forms, and that’s s good thing, it improves safeguarding.

And one of those forms is telling children it’s possible to change sex, it’s okay to keep their bodies in a prepubertal state, and it’s okay to keep secrets from their parents.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/10/2026 23:18

Canadanian · 04/10/2026 22:45

But you can see, like I can see, the posters ON THIS VERY THREAD, defending use of the term groomer, right? You don’t need to search Mumsnet archives - it’s happening today, in front of you?

They are explaining its meaning because you do not seem to understand it. It is a word with a context dependent meaning and the grooming in this context is clearly not ‘grooming for sex with a child’.

When people explain a meaning of a word it does not mean they themselves particularly favour using it. They may or may not.

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 23:17

Canadanian · 04/10/2026 22:56

just one example - is somone like @Soontobe60 just saying they understand why someone might use the term groomers, or are they just saying they thinks people supporting trans rights are groomers, on their post on this thread? (It’s the latter)

With respect, whether she thinks someone who “is party to misinforming children that it’s possible to change sex is guilty of grooming children” (which is slightly different from someone who supports trans rights) is neither here nor there. The accusation is calling someone a groomer damages the reputation of the ‘GC movement’ (whatever that is). Presumably because it is public. Unless you’re now policing what people think as well as what they say.

Cattywillow · 04/10/2026 23:15

Grooming doesn’t mean just sexual. I think it’s a helpful term in a number of different contexts.

RogueFemale · 04/10/2026 23:14

@RobynMiller You come across as deeply insincere and hoping to be manipulative (but failing).

Tears0fTheMushroom · 04/10/2026 23:12

It ain't what you say...

Music Video Dancing GIF
Dadalus · 04/10/2026 23:09

Canadanian · 04/10/2026 22:59

Right. If you think it’s a fine thing to say I don’t know why you’re so invested in claiming nobody DOES say it (despite of evidence to the contrary on this very thread)….

but I am getting used to the weird rabbit holes / circular arguments / imagined gotchas that characterise this forum 🤷‍♀️

It's pretty simple.
Someone claims a group constantly do action X and it is very harmful.

Members of the group respond pointing out that both elements of the original claim are exaggerated or inaccurate.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 23:07

Far right mimicry in the gender Critical movement is simply a natural conclusion of a movement that is essentially conservative coded in its resistance to change, preference for existing conditions, established institutions and traditional ways of doing things over modern innovations. Its essence is conforming in nature so its going to attract all that goes with that: good & bad.

Personally, I prefer encouraging far right proponents to let their freak wig fly as a community service. Its important for the general public to understand who these people actually are (& their actions point to that) so they can accurately assess where this train is actually going…& not anywhere good.

That's not to say the gender critical movement's intentions aren't societally helpful in terms of caution to harm, they clearly are, but that the far right historically has a way of exploiting & distorting caution into authoritarianism & bigotry that is anything but pro women's rights so important to allow them to show who they are.

If it it walks like a duck…

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:04

Canadanian · 04/10/2026 22:59

Right. If you think it’s a fine thing to say I don’t know why you’re so invested in claiming nobody DOES say it (despite of evidence to the contrary on this very thread)….

but I am getting used to the weird rabbit holes / circular arguments / imagined gotchas that characterise this forum 🤷‍♀️

Because by and large we don’t really say it on here so it’s weird you’re claiming we do. I’m just a bit sick of people mangling language and making out that perfectly normal usage of words is wrong or telling women off for words used by men.

I also wonder if you spend any time at all posting about pro trans posters and the vile language they often direct at women which is far more worse than using “groomer.”

Swipe left for the next trending thread