Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The constant use of Groomer against TRAs is doing the GC cause harm

586 replies

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 18:59

Just seen this posted by Glinner
https://x.com/Glinner/status/2106504469651579047
Text
Russell T Davies says I called him "a paedophile and a groomer" in this. It's a lie. I did call him a groomer, because he used Doctor Who to push gender ideology, in which no child would believe unless an adult had planted it in his or her head.

And I just find it disingenuous from him. It's no secret I don't love his decent into more, let's call it, aggressive strategies on social media, but they are now coming home to roost and won't be good for any of us.

The word Groomer has a very specific history when it comes to CSA so to use it as often as he (and other) do and then claim you don't mean it in the very well accepted way is always meant just doesn't sit right with me.

Is there a term we can use that isn't sp precariously close to slandering someone as a Child sex abuser?

Here is the article he is referring to in the tweet

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

‘One person turned up at my house’: Russell T Davies on fierce fandom, finding love after grief - and the fear that drives him to keep a knife by the door

He’s the titan of TV who revived a flatlined Doctor Who and turned British queer life into jaw-dropping drama. But the screenwriter’s groundbreaking writing has sometimes made him a target of hate – from homophobes and Whovians alike

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 07:16

NotBadConsidering · 05/10/2026 07:07

“Detransitioners aren’t trans, so it doesn’t matter that they were groomed to believe they were and made irreversible changes to their bodies.”

The point you are spectacularly missing is detransitioners don't prove that 'grooming' is causal to trans identification in general.

BackToLurk · 05/10/2026 07:11

Datun · 05/10/2026 07:06

Detransitioners aren't trans people by definition though so they don't count

😄

And even if they did there aren’t very many of them. The comedy cherry on the inane cake.

DeanElderberry · 05/10/2026 07:10

Disclaimer: I have not read the whole (f) thread.

But from the OP and following discussion it seems to be about a man I have barely heard of (RTD) and another man I'm slightly more familiar with (GL) and they online disagreements. I have never watched any of Davies' cultural offerings, I've heard some of Linehan's early radio work, years ago. Ultimately, they are both blokes. Neither of them can ever understand feminist motivation.

I'm a woman, a feminist, my experience of a lifetime living in a female body, growing into adulthood at a time when many of my choices were constrained because I was female, makes me find men debating any aspect of feminism so ridiculous that I really can't be arsed.

I'm appalled that some girls find puberty so distressing that they starve their bodies of cut their bodies, or latterly drug and mutilate and deny their bodies. I wish it wasn't so. Anyone who encourages young women to harm their bodies to avoid adulthood is cruel and cynical.

Enabling male predation on women by using 'gender' to remove the protections afforded to the female sex is also cruel and cynical.

Men having disputes about women's issues in cyberspace is wanky.

NotBadConsidering · 05/10/2026 07:07

“Detransitioners aren’t trans, so it doesn’t matter that they were groomed to believe they were and made irreversible changes to their bodies.”

Datun · 05/10/2026 07:06

Detransitioners aren't trans people by definition though so they don't count

😄

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 07:03

Soontobe60 · 05/10/2026 06:54

You’re working really hard here to present RTD is a favourable light - I wonder why? If you listen to what detransitioners have to say, you may well change your opinion on whether they have been groomed or not. When they have been bombarded with messages - overt or otherwise- about how much happier they’d be if only they were trans then you’d accept that they have been groomed. Those messages come from media, direct from famous people, (Ellen Page for instance) internet chat rooms, TV, youth leaders, politicians, even religious leaders! The whole principle of gender ideology is based on grooming. That’s why things like drag Queen story time was so prevalent- get to the kids as young as possible…
When you look at the history of the rise in GI, you’ll see that ultimately it’s a men’s movement designed to encourage young boys to remain childlike for nefarious reasons. Pretending otherwise is just ignorant.

Detransitioners aren't trans people by definition though so they don't count not to mention their minuscule numbers aren't reflective of the norm.

Datun · 05/10/2026 06:55

God yes, Jeffrey Marsh. Going out of his way to separate children from their caregivers.

Soontobe60 · 05/10/2026 06:54

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 20:06

As I clarified above direct contact can also be online messaging.

I also said I would call RTD a propagandist which is a much better word for what he does instead of groomer.

You’re working really hard here to present RTD is a favourable light - I wonder why? If you listen to what detransitioners have to say, you may well change your opinion on whether they have been groomed or not. When they have been bombarded with messages - overt or otherwise- about how much happier they’d be if only they were trans then you’d accept that they have been groomed. Those messages come from media, direct from famous people, (Ellen Page for instance) internet chat rooms, TV, youth leaders, politicians, even religious leaders! The whole principle of gender ideology is based on grooming. That’s why things like drag Queen story time was so prevalent- get to the kids as young as possible…
When you look at the history of the rise in GI, you’ll see that ultimately it’s a men’s movement designed to encourage young boys to remain childlike for nefarious reasons. Pretending otherwise is just ignorant.

Shedmistress · 05/10/2026 05:56

The use of groomer tended to be when the TRA was directly addressing children with 'ill be your new family' style approaches. As the TRA community were completely unable to call out their own on this it became obvious it was acceptable to the TRA community to use any tactics available to them, including now pretending to be shocked that anyone would call anyone a 'groomer' for people trying to separate children from their families.

Then it became apparent that there are no boundaries for the TRA community, that anyone expressing any opinions not in line with their agenda was to be brought down and then more and more people started to realise what had been going on under their noses. So the vitriol and accusations ramped up the more that the agenda was becoming clear.

It isn't just kids groomed into thinking they are 'in the wrong body' it is adults that have been groomed into not using words to describe reality lest they be accused of being literally Hitler.

It isn't the word 'groomer' that is the issue it is the behaviour of a whole network of TRAs that manipulate and propagandise and terrorise people into behaving in ways that they would not normally even consider.

Grooming is probably the very nicest way of referring to the behaviour we have seen over the last decade. And yet, they still aren't happy. Sheesh. Who'd a thought it?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 05:11

NotBadConsidering · 05/10/2026 04:51

That sanitation persists to this day. It’s remarkable how everyone like the Guardian questions the ethics of chemical castration for sex offenders without realising they are the exact same drugs given to gender distressed children as part of medical transition.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/aug/22/chemical-suppression-why-the-uk-is-exploring-libido-control-drugs-to-treat-sex-offenders

Because there is institutional grooming too with language. Pronouns. Euphemisms like “top surgery”. “Gender affirming care” for children meaning sterilisation and causing infertility. This links to the “how did trans ideology get so embedded” thread.

But describing or supporting a phenomena doesn’t prove a causal link to it occurring in the first place. This is where 'groomer mentality' falls apart. Its an assumption without any causal scientific basis. Its as silly as saying more gay people will exist if society is supportive of them.

NotBadConsidering · 05/10/2026 04:51

That sanitation persists to this day. It’s remarkable how everyone like the Guardian questions the ethics of chemical castration for sex offenders without realising they are the exact same drugs given to gender distressed children as part of medical transition.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/aug/22/chemical-suppression-why-the-uk-is-exploring-libido-control-drugs-to-treat-sex-offenders

Because there is institutional grooming too with language. Pronouns. Euphemisms like “top surgery”. “Gender affirming care” for children meaning sterilisation and causing infertility. This links to the “how did trans ideology get so embedded” thread.

Datun · 05/10/2026 03:58

I can remember when Suzy Green went off alarming because KJK used the word castration and Green said it had sex offender connotations.

The push to sanitise the ideology and its effects on children isn't exactly a secret.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 02:41

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:31

How would that change my advice to report it to the police? Will they not investigate because these rape threats were posted elsewhere?

I wasn’t criticising your advice to report to the police, that wasn’t remotely what I was disagreeing with.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 01:56

Trans identification absolutely at its essence challenges gender norms in the act of natal males & natal females expressing gender non conformity to what is socially commonly associated to men & women. That they use 'trans man/woman' is simply a shorthand description of this phenomena not a prescriptivist idea on what qualifies as a man or woman for everyone.

The point gender critical critique of gender stereotypes fails to comprehend is socially constructed categorical roles, behaviours expressions, and identities of girls, women, boys, men, and gender-diverse people exist independently of trans people. Its reality right or wrong so trans people are simply pointing to which social category they identify with not sex. That's not the same as saying men or women typically behave a certain way so they should be sexually categorised as such.

And the idea that the gender critical movement is opposed to sex stereotypes is patently false give the particular derision they reserve for trans women (not trans men interestingly) expressing gender non conformity as in the vicious mocking of them as 'men in dresses' 'woman face' 'cross dressers' & 'AGP' thereby modelling a distinct internalised misogyny that aligns with misogynistic views of patriarchal values where the demeaning of feminine expression AKA femmephobia has a long history rooted in the systemic devaluation of traits, behaviours and aesthetics associated with women and femininity. Historically, patriarchal structures have positioned masculinity as the universal human standard leaving femininity to be viewed as inferior, superficial, or manipulative.

Describing feminine traits, behaviours and aesthetics as purely a 'stereotype' is simply another form of femmephobia. Just because patriarchal & social expectations exist regarding feminine expression doesn't mean that's the only cause of them. In fact gendered traits are considered as both a nature/nurture phenomenon with genes, hormones & evolutionary survival & mating pressures influencing their expression.

Heggettypeg · 05/10/2026 00:46

What a peculiar idea, that trans ideology challenges social norms.

The whole thing is parasitical on the notion that femininity and masculinity are sharply differentiated and socially recognisable. You can't be a male- bodied person "living as a woman" if living as a woman is indistinguishable from living as a man because there are numerous members of both sexes who do/ wear / behave / name themselves in every possible way, such that nothing can be socially man- or woman- coded . You can't even be ostentatiously "non- binary" if non- binary behaviour is the social norm. Nothing is left but pronouns, an untruthful M or F in official documents, and attempts to breach spaces where sex, not gender, is the rationale.

Under those circumstances gender becomes meaningless and pointless. You can do what you like without having to " identify" as anything. (Sex, however, does not become meaningless. It exists, matters in the situations where it matters, and that's all.)

Trousers are a good microcosm of this. Women have adopted them in such large numbers that putting on a pair of trousers no longer genders a person.

Dresses, to date, haven't achieved the same status. If men can wear them while still being recognised and accepted as men, that's another social convention busted, like the trouser convention. If men who wear them are read as, and consider themselves to be, women, then convention is still king.

It's just occurred to me that the reason TRAs in the west have become so hell bent on pronouns, gendered documentation and access to single sex spaces is precisely because feminism has had an effect and there are far fewer hard and fast - and therefore authoritative - social gender markers now. It's paradoxically easier (if riskier) to validate your transness in a conservative society with very strong gendered conventions.

GarlicEverything · 05/10/2026 00:35

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:30

You appear to be suggesting that trans people should develop the same tactics the suffragettes used to win their rights?

Well, if that's as far as your reading comprehension can take you - yes, it would be an improvement on their prolifically detailed rape and murder threats, widespread lying, piss protests and mass intimidation.

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:31

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:30

Read my post again.

How would that change my advice to report it to the police? Will they not investigate because these rape threats were posted elsewhere?

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:30

GarlicEverything · 05/10/2026 00:29

Harming the CG cause.

Absolutely! If only women's rights campaigners were more polite, moderate, inoffensive and chose our words more carefully, everyone would instantly rally to the cause and our rights be secured forever.

If only the Suffragettes had listened when they were repeatedly given the same advice: women would have votes now! If the titans of Women's Liberation had helped their cause by avoiding words that upset people, we might now have the right to our own money and to make our own decisions.

GC feminists should surely adopt the gentle, co-operative approach modelled by trans activists: as we have seen, they won hearts & minds everywhere with their kindly uncontroversial messaging. We should be careful not to challenge anything, except in the mildest terms.

🙄

You appear to be suggesting that trans people should develop the same tactics the suffragettes used to win their rights?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:30

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:29

"Do you call out the transpeople, some of them on this very board, who issue rape threats to women?"

Read my post again.

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:29

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:28

She didn’t say they issued them on this board. They have done so elsewhere though.

"Do you call out the transpeople, some of them on this very board, who issue rape threats to women?"

GarlicEverything · 05/10/2026 00:29

Harming the CG cause.

Absolutely! If only women's rights campaigners were more polite, moderate, inoffensive and chose our words more carefully, everyone would instantly rally to the cause and our rights be secured forever.

If only the Suffragettes had listened when they were repeatedly given the same advice: women would have votes now! If the titans of Women's Liberation had helped their cause by avoiding words that upset people, we might now have the right to our own money and to make our own decisions.

GC feminists should surely adopt the gentle, co-operative approach modelled by trans activists: as we have seen, they won hearts & minds everywhere with their kindly uncontroversial messaging. We should be careful not to challenge anything, except in the mildest terms.

🙄

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:28

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:24

I'd encourage you to do so. If you have evidence of rape threats on this board from trans people then I would suggest you report them to both Mumsnet and the police for action. That's absolutely disgusting.

She didn’t say they issued them on this board. They have done so elsewhere though.

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:25

Pingponghavoc · 05/10/2026 00:11

In at least one episode of Doctor Who, a male character was described being born a boy but is now a women.

Its dangerous telling children than a grown man is a woman.

Its basic safeguarding that we know age and sex. Females are girls and women. Males are boys and men. Its important that children understand this.

Its not just RTD fault, the bbc let it happen. But RTD did try to confuse children for the sake of it. Doctor who didnt need to introduce such a concept.

Trans people existing is not a safeguarding issue for crying out loud. It's post like these that make it harder and harder to make the argument that being gender critical is the sensible position.

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 00:24

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:55

I could point out myriad ways in which trans activists behave like far right goons, you know? Do you call them out? And I mean, most people, far right or not argue against trans bullshit because it is bullshit. They believe in material reality like the next person, I won’t call them out for that, but I will call them out for racism, for example.

Do you call out the transpeople, some of them on this very board, who issue rape threats to women? If not, why not?

Edited

I'd encourage you to do so. If you have evidence of rape threats on this board from trans people then I would suggest you report them to both Mumsnet and the police for action. That's absolutely disgusting.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 05/10/2026 00:21

WatchingWongAgain · 04/10/2026 23:55

I could point out myriad ways in which trans activists behave like far right goons, you know? Do you call them out? And I mean, most people, far right or not argue against trans bullshit because it is bullshit. They believe in material reality like the next person, I won’t call them out for that, but I will call them out for racism, for example.

Do you call out the transpeople, some of them on this very board, who issue rape threats to women? If not, why not?

Edited

Whilst there's certainly instances of TRA illiberal behaviour its not the same as it being ubiquitous in their movement which as we can see just from the behaviour & rationalisations on this thread it it is in the gender critical movement. They believe trans identification to be only the result of a contagion, perversion & mental illness that's 'learned'/groomed…just like the far right does about everything they don't agree with including feminism.