Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The constant use of Groomer against TRAs is doing the GC cause harm

586 replies

RobynMiller · 04/10/2026 18:59

Just seen this posted by Glinner
https://x.com/Glinner/status/2106504469651579047
Text
Russell T Davies says I called him "a paedophile and a groomer" in this. It's a lie. I did call him a groomer, because he used Doctor Who to push gender ideology, in which no child would believe unless an adult had planted it in his or her head.

And I just find it disingenuous from him. It's no secret I don't love his decent into more, let's call it, aggressive strategies on social media, but they are now coming home to roost and won't be good for any of us.

The word Groomer has a very specific history when it comes to CSA so to use it as often as he (and other) do and then claim you don't mean it in the very well accepted way is always meant just doesn't sit right with me.

Is there a term we can use that isn't sp precariously close to slandering someone as a Child sex abuser?

Here is the article he is referring to in the tweet

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

‘One person turned up at my house’: Russell T Davies on fierce fandom, finding love after grief - and the fear that drives him to keep a knife by the door

He’s the titan of TV who revived a flatlined Doctor Who and turned British queer life into jaw-dropping drama. But the screenwriter’s groundbreaking writing has sometimes made him a target of hate – from homophobes and Whovians alike

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/03/russell-t-davies-interview-doctor-who-fierce-fandom-love-grief

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 11/10/2026 16:24

Procrastinating! Thank you! That was the word I was groping for.

There's a character in The Phantom Tollbooth who is like that, only I can't for the moment think who it is. So now I shall have to re-read it; oh dear, how I do suffer.

lcakethereforeIam · 11/10/2026 15:44

I've just been talking to a friend about craft kits. That there are two hobbies, buying the kits is one, actually doing anything with them is the other. I think that fits with that interpretation 😊. Procrastinating and achieving nothing.

I've always interpreted it as people doing stuff with the best of intentions ('be kind') who end up causing harm. I can think of a bunch of stuff; thalidomide, vaginally mesh, lots of other stuff.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 11/10/2026 15:33

I have always thought that means people not actually getting round to doing good things and assuming that their intention to do good things is enough. That a good intention isn't enough to keep you from the road to hell if you don't follow through on it, as it were.

lcakethereforeIam · 11/10/2026 15:25

The saying is, 'The road to hell is paved with good intentions'.

Datun · 11/10/2026 13:39

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 11/10/2026 12:50

I think the question might be "is it possible to groom and not be a groomer?"

If that is possible, then calling someone who grooms a groomer may be inaccurate.

If that isn't possible, then a groomer is what that person is whether or not they intend to be. And doing something in ignorance that what you are doing is wrong is still doing that thing, and it is still wrong; that's why ignorance of the law is no excuse, after all.

Yes, I was thinking about that same thing.

RTD may not intend to harm children. But the ideology does harm children. It also harms women and girls, separately. His total lack of comprehension that it might, is a harm in itself.

Safeguarding of women, possibly children, are absolutely nowhere on his radar. Perpetuating that is harmful.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 11/10/2026 12:50

I think the question might be "is it possible to groom and not be a groomer?"

If that is possible, then calling someone who grooms a groomer may be inaccurate.

If that isn't possible, then a groomer is what that person is whether or not they intend to be. And doing something in ignorance that what you are doing is wrong is still doing that thing, and it is still wrong; that's why ignorance of the law is no excuse, after all.

Pingponghavoc · 11/10/2026 12:44

Maybe think of it in terms of the child.

A man directly grooming a child into harmful behaviour.

A man indirectly grooming children into harmful behaviour.

In the first scenario, an individual child has been targeted. In the second, the man has cast a net and any child could be targeted. The bigger the audience for the indirect grooming, the more children could be harmed.

In either case, the man may or may not intend or even see harm. But in both cases children are harmed.

Shedmistress · 11/10/2026 11:11

RobynMiller · 11/10/2026 00:16

Yes, for child predators. That was my whole point to begin with.

But if we're expanding the word out to cover all manner of society then everything is grooming and the word loses all meaning. All societal norms are instilled purposefully from our very first days. From the monarchy, church, school, tv, film, literature etc. but we don't go around calling everyone Groomers. We reserve that specific name for specific purposes otherwise why have it at all?

Mermaids used to go to PRIDE with puppies and lollipops. Specifically to target kids.

Mermaids has been highly promoted by the mainstream media for at least a decade.

I do not think that these things are unrelated. It is all part of the melting pot of grooming kids. From teachers to publishers to TV to libraries to shops to toys to clothes manufacturers to even the spate of the BBC having pink and blue lighting in almost every bloody programme for years. It is a constant barrage that kids have real problems unpicking.

NotBadConsidering · 11/10/2026 11:09

RobynMiller · 11/10/2026 10:23

Oh don't be so condescending. If you read the whole thread you'll see this was talked about early on and I still disagree that ALL manipulation to ensure societal norms is grooming.

My whole original point is that grooming is used to refer to nefarious purposes AND that it mostly happens on an individual level with direct contact with the victim of said grooming.

I made the point above because so many people were claiming that there were all these non-nefarious ways people are groomed so therefore calling someone a Groomer could mean all sorts and if someone thinks it's an accusation of child abuse then that's their problem.

To call someone a Groomer in public is to accuse them of directly trying to hurt the subject in question. My whole argument is that throwing that accusation around where no actual contact or crime has happened makes our side look hysterical and is borderline a call for violence. Most people would take Groomer to mean child sexual abuser and at least where I'm from, many would say those should be shot in the street.

My whole original point is that grooming is used to refer to nefarious purposes AND that it mostly happens on an individual level with direct contact with the victim of said grooming.

Yes. And you’re wrong.

My whole argument is that throwing that accusation around where no actual contact or crime has happened makes our side look hysterical and is borderline a call for violence.

Don't you think it’s bit ironic you use the term “hysterical” for “our” side and then claim it’s a “borderline call for violence” and think it might lead to people saying they should be “shot in the street”?

I wouldn’t use the word “hysterical” to describe this view of yours but it’s hyperbolic to describe people making others aware of the widespread nature of grooming behaviour as some form of call to arms.

lcakethereforeIam · 11/10/2026 11:04

RobynMiller · 11/10/2026 00:16

Yes, for child predators. That was my whole point to begin with.

But if we're expanding the word out to cover all manner of society then everything is grooming and the word loses all meaning. All societal norms are instilled purposefully from our very first days. From the monarchy, church, school, tv, film, literature etc. but we don't go around calling everyone Groomers. We reserve that specific name for specific purposes otherwise why have it at all?

I think I get what you're getting at. It's arguable that RTD has no nefarious intent but that he has been influenced, groomed if you like, by progressives into the beliefs that caused him to put these ideas into his show. The show with these ideas was approved and paid for by 'groomed' execs at the Beeb. And so on. It's groomers all the way down. Gender ideology is currently systemic.

Putting it that way, I can see your point but I can't argue that Glinner is wrong to use the word. However kind and progressive RTD thinks he is being, he may have no nefarious intent, he is doing the 'groomer's' work for them. Perhaps it'll be the dash of cold water that will wake his up to what he is complicit in? I, personally, don't think so. RTD is firmly in his bubble.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2026 10:39

“To call someone a Groomer in public is to accuse them of directly trying to hurt the subject in question.”

I don’t believe that it matters whether harm was intended or not. If someone is doing something that non-intentionally causes harm via a grooming dynamic, it should be highlighted.

“My whole argument is that throwing that accusation around where no actual contact or crime has happened makes our side look hysterical and is borderline a call for violence.”

Ok. And people have disputed the premises you have used for your argument. I would also dispute that it makes “our side” look hysterical and calling for violence in any degree.

What I can see is that numerous people who have attempted to shame feminists have often attempted to use this tactic. Feminists are not responsible for male people’s actions. Just because some male people or even female people agree broadly with the outcomes that feminists campaign for, doesn’t mean that feminists are responsible for what they do or say.

If someone’s support of female single sex provisions and better medical care for children is based on whether a small group of other people with similar goals uses the right words for highlighting issues or not, that really is up to them to make their own decisions. “Our side”? Sounds more like tribalism in political opinion than a discussion about the issues.

RobynMiller · 11/10/2026 10:23

NotBadConsidering · 11/10/2026 00:46

Congratulations OP, you are finally waking up to the idea that grooming happens in all walks of life, not just sexual predation.

No, it is not grooming to teach people the societal norms. Teaching people the societal norms of how to act is not grooming.

It is grooming to teach people to ignore societal norms: ignore that it’s not possible to change sex, ignore that parents should be involved in their children’s care, education and identity development, ignore the harms and realities of medical transition, ignore the transgression of boundaries trans activism promotes, ignore the medicalisation of homosexuality. The grooming is all of this said with a smile and a hand wave at silly people who see safeguarding concerns and are told to ignore their instincts.

Oh don't be so condescending. If you read the whole thread you'll see this was talked about early on and I still disagree that ALL manipulation to ensure societal norms is grooming.

My whole original point is that grooming is used to refer to nefarious purposes AND that it mostly happens on an individual level with direct contact with the victim of said grooming.

I made the point above because so many people were claiming that there were all these non-nefarious ways people are groomed so therefore calling someone a Groomer could mean all sorts and if someone thinks it's an accusation of child abuse then that's their problem.

To call someone a Groomer in public is to accuse them of directly trying to hurt the subject in question. My whole argument is that throwing that accusation around where no actual contact or crime has happened makes our side look hysterical and is borderline a call for violence. Most people would take Groomer to mean child sexual abuser and at least where I'm from, many would say those should be shot in the street.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 11/10/2026 00:46

Congratulations OP, you are finally waking up to the idea that grooming happens in all walks of life, not just sexual predation.

No, it is not grooming to teach people the societal norms. Teaching people the societal norms of how to act is not grooming.

It is grooming to teach people to ignore societal norms: ignore that it’s not possible to change sex, ignore that parents should be involved in their children’s care, education and identity development, ignore the harms and realities of medical transition, ignore the transgression of boundaries trans activism promotes, ignore the medicalisation of homosexuality. The grooming is all of this said with a smile and a hand wave at silly people who see safeguarding concerns and are told to ignore their instincts.

RobynMiller · 11/10/2026 00:16

lcakethereforeIam · 10/10/2026 23:55

Grooming the parents to get to the kids is also a thing.

Yes, for child predators. That was my whole point to begin with.

But if we're expanding the word out to cover all manner of society then everything is grooming and the word loses all meaning. All societal norms are instilled purposefully from our very first days. From the monarchy, church, school, tv, film, literature etc. but we don't go around calling everyone Groomers. We reserve that specific name for specific purposes otherwise why have it at all?

OP posts:
lcakethereforeIam · 10/10/2026 23:55

Grooming the parents to get to the kids is also a thing.

RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 23:53

ScrollingLeaves · 10/10/2026 23:36

Because they’ve already been told as a ‘fact’ in school PSHE or a school library book that some people have a gender different from the sex they were born. Because they may have been taken to drag queens [trans] grooming hour in the past. Because they may be autistic.

Well if they have the kind of parents that are taking them to Drag shows and encouraging it I really don't think Dr. Who is changing their mind in either direction. That being said, I also wouldn't go so far as to say their parents were grooming them, just parenting in a way I disagree with.

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 10/10/2026 23:36

RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 21:11

Well considering the suggested viewing age for Dr Who is 10+ I actually think they are capable of knowing what is and isn't real. They understand Santa Clause isn't real, why would this be any different?

Because they’ve already been told as a ‘fact’ in school PSHE or a school library book that some people have a gender different from the sex they were born. Because they may have been taken to drag queens [trans] grooming hour in the past. Because they may be autistic.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 10/10/2026 22:16

RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 21:11

Well considering the suggested viewing age for Dr Who is 10+ I actually think they are capable of knowing what is and isn't real. They understand Santa Clause isn't real, why would this be any different?

That's a very naive take.

Older children and adults can tell that fantasy isn't real, yes, but they can also tell the difference between the fantasy narrative and the real world setting in which the fantasy happens. Of course a propagandist can tell their "this is how the world is/should morally be" story as part of the real world elements within a fantasy story.

Kids and teen stories have done this forever after all - give kids heroes that exhibit the character and behaviour adults want those kids to emulate, give them a setting where society acts like we wish it did with values we want them to believe in not like it actually does.

Any story with a strong moral heart, which Dr Who clearly is, with its immortal god-in-a-blue-box hero saving the day against various threats, is a perfect place to embed character/value building messages through the simple mechanism of having the hero exhibit whatever value or quality you want to promote.

I have been wondering whether Propaganda is a better fit than grooming, or indeed if there is even a difference.

Then I thought about what grooming - not the consensual "grooming the next CEO" type but the malevolent "grooming someone to act in my interests believing they act in their own" is, and I think at heart it is teaching someone that what you want from them is something they want to give you, either because "everyone does it" or because "they are special".

So there's probably a spectrum between propaganda and social grooming, but looking at the two ends, the propagandist says "this is how the world should be, and these are your enemies who are trying to stop it", and the groomer says "this is how the world is, if you want to be normal/special/morally good you need to align with it, ignore those other people who want you to think differently"

I think RTD's Genderist proselytising probably sits somewhere in the middle.

All that said, and even though I think he's being a manipulative toad, the "transRose can solve this problem that neither Donna nor Doctor can because (s)he is beyond the binary..." did fold his propaganda into a nice plot.

RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 21:11

Pingponghavoc · 10/10/2026 20:57

Doctor Who isnt subtle at the best of times, and with its trans characters hammered home the idea that men could be women, characters could be non binary and anyone disagreeing are wrong. It wasnt characters that happened to be trans, trans was the character and point of the characters.

It was hours of TV introducing the concept of trans ideology to children and that a man could be a woman, and no one should question it.

Children can't separate out fiction from reality in a way that adults can. Its why daleks frightened a generation of children, whereas adults can see they are bonkers costumes.

As an adult, I can watch a programe knowing everything about it is fiction. I know the characters have been written to manipulate me, and I have the ability to enjoy it while knowing nothing about it is true. Children often dont see this.

RTD sees his role as a progressive story teller. He wanted to show trans ideology and trans characters positively. He wasnt concerned that its a contested ideology, the safeguarding risks and that children process fiction in different ways to adults. Or perhaps he did, and wrote it anyway.

The upshot is that some children will think that a character that was born a boy is now woman. They will take this into their real life and think its possible for them and anyone they meet.

How is the end result different if he told it directly to one child?

Well considering the suggested viewing age for Dr Who is 10+ I actually think they are capable of knowing what is and isn't real. They understand Santa Clause isn't real, why would this be any different?

OP posts:
RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 21:10

Shedmistress · 10/10/2026 20:58

What if it was in a reality show? Is it the 'it's a fantasty show' bit that you think makes it NOT grooming?

Well I think in a reality show like BB for instance, children shouldn't be watching to begin with. Can't really think of any reality show I would let my children watch come to think of it. I also don't think that trans identified people should be banned from appearing on television as though simply knowing the exist would convince someone to also act that way.

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 10/10/2026 21:05

Pingponghavoc · Today 20:57
What you describe is even more of a grooming set up than I had imagined from the OP.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 10/10/2026 21:01

I am waiting to see the evidence that anyone, with the possible exception of someone I don't read, constantly uses the word "groomer" as a pejorative against trans people.

I occasionally see the word used in Mumsnet in other places than this thread, where the word is being discussed and will therefore appear frequently.

Seriously: storm force 11 in sea area Teacup.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/10/2026 21:00

I cannot think that it does not sow the seed of an idea that they may be in the wrong skin, and that to be trans would offer a ‘queer’ and glamorous alternative to misery in certain young, vulnerable people’s minds.

Shedmistress · 10/10/2026 20:58

RobynMiller · 10/10/2026 19:44

As I've said multiple times now on this very thread, directly contacting a child and convincing them to be trans IS over the line into grooming.

What I don't agree with is that a trans identified character being in a fantasy tv show is of the level of grooming.

What if it was in a reality show? Is it the 'it's a fantasty show' bit that you think makes it NOT grooming?

Pingponghavoc · 10/10/2026 20:57

Doctor Who isnt subtle at the best of times, and with its trans characters hammered home the idea that men could be women, characters could be non binary and anyone disagreeing are wrong. It wasnt characters that happened to be trans, trans was the character and point of the characters.

It was hours of TV introducing the concept of trans ideology to children and that a man could be a woman, and no one should question it.

Children can't separate out fiction from reality in a way that adults can. Its why daleks frightened a generation of children, whereas adults can see they are bonkers costumes.

As an adult, I can watch a programe knowing everything about it is fiction. I know the characters have been written to manipulate me, and I have the ability to enjoy it while knowing nothing about it is true. Children often dont see this.

RTD sees his role as a progressive story teller. He wanted to show trans ideology and trans characters positively. He wasnt concerned that its a contested ideology, the safeguarding risks and that children process fiction in different ways to adults. Or perhaps he did, and wrote it anyway.

The upshot is that some children will think that a character that was born a boy is now woman. They will take this into their real life and think its possible for them and anyone they meet.

How is the end result different if he told it directly to one child?