Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Do intersex people's views on pronoun use count in sex and gender discussions?

54 replies

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 18:05

I want to raise a pronoun-related issue which I think has been largely ignored (if it hasn't, I'd be very interested to see where it's been discussed).

I belong to the "I" in the alphabet soup, although given that "Intersex" (i.e. DSDs) is neither an identity nor a sexuality (it is an umbrella term for a range of congenital medical disorders) I don't think it should be included. But that is another matter.

Anyway, given that I am included in the alphabet, I assume I'm allowed a say in how I feel about pronoun usage. (And if not, why not?)

My condition means that I have male chromosomes but am phenotypically female. I do not look (or act) remotely male. If someone were to ask me my pronouns - i.e. imply that it's not fucking obvious by taking one glance at me - I would be both offended and hurt.

So my question is: do the opinions of the other "letters" count on this issue, or is it only the "T" that matters?

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 04/10/2026 19:24

I get rather irritated by people that try to forcibly team up people with DSDs with trans. Totally different situations. (I don’t know if I’m allowed an opinion either, but I’m the A in the alphabet soup)

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 19:32

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 19:05

Any time you want to play single sex sports.
You have a y chromosome and as such cant compeat in women's sports and most have brought back sex screening so it will come up

My understanding is that they test for the SRY gene and therefore people with my condition could still compete.

OP posts:
46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 19:33

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 19:14

My question would be how many of those who call themselves intersex actually have a dsd.
I say this because some of tge loudest people online who claim to be intersex have been proven not to have any DSDs

Yes, I have wondered this as well.

OP posts:
FiveEightNine · 04/10/2026 19:34

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 19:05

Any time you want to play single sex sports.
You have a y chromosome and as such cant compeat in women's sports and most have brought back sex screening so it will come up

Afaik it depends on the exact diagnosis.
The first test js SRY test, not XX/XY. And individuals with SRY positivr test, but CAIS (and maybe a few other conditions) can prove it and be eligible for female sport category, at least the tennis rules seems so

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 19:45

backformoreofthesame · 04/10/2026 19:16

Oh I think it is the question

taking the post at face value however

i mean the norm is that you should follow medical advice and work with your medical team

and how you appear and choose to present and the pronouns that are used as a result are not for anyone else to worry about

unless OP is saying that they would have to tell people what pronouns to use - then it’s forced speech

OP had a very rare DSD

The question is that if the opinion of the T is the direct opposite of the opinion of the I, who takes precedence?

There is nothing internally or externally male about me; I don't even have ovaries producing testosterone, unlike typical women.

OP posts:
FiveEightNine · 04/10/2026 19:54

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 19:45

The question is that if the opinion of the T is the direct opposite of the opinion of the I, who takes precedence?

There is nothing internally or externally male about me; I don't even have ovaries producing testosterone, unlike typical women.

In this forum, we are (mostly) rooting for you in this question.

If I understand your condition correctly, your body is actually build about production of big gametes (though probably unable to actually produce them).

It is not fair that T crowd is abusing your kind of condition for their agenda.

How I see it, the DSD people didn't have a problem (in the social aspect, of course understanding your condition and finding health care able to deal with your condition in an informed way was probably as hard as for any other rare condition), before the T created one for you.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/10/2026 20:02

I have never asked anyone for his or her pronouns; my experience has been that anyone who gives a tuppenny one about other people "getting them right" when they are completely at odds with observed reality will have broadcast the information, and quite possibly wear a badge saying "My pronouns are fo/fum" just to make sure everyone knows.

So I'd assume that if you look female and are not making an attention-grabbing fuss about it, you probably want to be referred to by female pronouns, and that is what I'd do.

Peregrina · 04/10/2026 20:05

I would imagine that the vast majority of us wouldn't know whether we had ever met someone with this condition because they look female and were socialised as such.

Unlike trans identifying men, who still look like men, but and were socialised as men, and can only try to act a part as a woman.

EntirelyUnnecessary · 04/10/2026 20:31

I am pretty sure that the LGBT+ lobby only want the I because they want to pretend that sex is not a real and binary category, and therefore that gender identity must prevail.

But it's nonsense. People with DSDs are not some halfway point between the sexes. They are still men and women.

And even if they were it still wouldn't make gender identity to make sense. To take an analogy, if 99.999% of the world can be split into, say, blue and yellow but the remaining 0.001% are green, does that mean that A) blue and yellow are still useful categories and we should treat the few green people sensitively and try to accommodate them with dignity? Or B) Everyone can just decide if they are blue or yellow, and if you have any doubts about a yellow person claiming to be blue you are a massive bigot.

But it does seem to work on some people who don't think it through 🤷🏻‍♀️

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 21:07

FiveEightNine · 04/10/2026 19:54

In this forum, we are (mostly) rooting for you in this question.

If I understand your condition correctly, your body is actually build about production of big gametes (though probably unable to actually produce them).

It is not fair that T crowd is abusing your kind of condition for their agenda.

How I see it, the DSD people didn't have a problem (in the social aspect, of course understanding your condition and finding health care able to deal with your condition in an informed way was probably as hard as for any other rare condition), before the T created one for you.

I agree with all of this, and you're correct about the medical side of things.

OP posts:
46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 21:08

Peregrina · 04/10/2026 20:05

I would imagine that the vast majority of us wouldn't know whether we had ever met someone with this condition because they look female and were socialised as such.

Unlike trans identifying men, who still look like men, but and were socialised as men, and can only try to act a part as a woman.

Yes, agreed.

OP posts:
singthing · 04/10/2026 21:31

You are of no use nor interest to trans activism until and unless your medical status can be shoehorned in and/or used to their advantage regarding their spurious identity claims.

You can of course say what you want whenever you want, but unless it aligns with their viewpoint, you will be ignored (at best) or cast out (more likely) or actively and potentially violently cancelled in as many ways as necessary to shut you up (also not unlikely).

Women on the other hand will be fine with you speaking and thinking what you like, but most of them don't give a fuck about pronouns. There's probably far more interesting things about you to talk about anyway.

EdithStourton · 04/10/2026 21:40

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 19:14

My question would be how many of those who call themselves intersex actually have a dsd.
I say this because some of tge loudest people online who claim to be intersex have been proven not to have any DSDs

DIdn't the genderists, a few years ago, declare that some sizeable proportion of the population was 'intersex', by dint of including all women with PCOS, men with hypospadias etc etc?

46XYDSD · 04/10/2026 21:47

EdithStourton · 04/10/2026 21:40

DIdn't the genderists, a few years ago, declare that some sizeable proportion of the population was 'intersex', by dint of including all women with PCOS, men with hypospadias etc etc?

They love to quote the (debunked) statistic that 1.7% of people are intersex and that it's as common as people having read hair. (As Helen Joyce says, as common as having red hair where? In Northern Ireland, or in North Korea?)

In my opinion, if your chromosomes match your phenotype and you're fertile then you're really stretching the definition of "intersex". However "Disorder of Sexual Development" might still be an appropriate definition for something like hypospadias.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 04/10/2026 21:57

EdithStourton · 04/10/2026 21:40

DIdn't the genderists, a few years ago, declare that some sizeable proportion of the population was 'intersex', by dint of including all women with PCOS, men with hypospadias etc etc?

yep. I believe Anne Fausto- Sterling popularised that stat.

LEONARD SAX REBUTTAL OF 1.7% ‘INTERSEX’ STATISTIC FROM FAUSTO - STERLING

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12476264/

How common is intersex? a response to Anne Fausto-Sterling

Leonard Sax, August 2002

Abstract
Anne Fausto-Sterling s suggestion that the prevalence of intersex might be as high as 1.7% has attracted wide attention in both the scholarly press and the popular media. Many reviewers are not aware that this figure includes conditions which most clinicians do not recognize as intersex, such as Klinefelter syndrome, Turner syndrome, and late-onset adrenal hyperplasia. If the term intersex is to retain any meaning, the term should be restricted to those conditions in which chromosomal sex is inconsistent with phenotypic sex, or in which the phenotype is not classifiable as either male or female. Applying this more precise definition, the true prevalence of intersex is seen to be about 0.018%, almost 100 times lower than Fausto-Sterling s estimate of 1.7%.

TL/DR

the true prevalence of intersex is seen to be about 0.018%, almost 100 times lower than Fausto-Sterling s estimate of 1.7%.

It is also discussed here in this article :
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/intersex-is-not-as-common-as-red

Intersex Is Not as Common as Red Hair

The claim that intersex people comprise 1.7% of the population is wildly inaccurate.

https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/intersex-is-not-as-common-as-red

Hoardasurass · 04/10/2026 22:13

EdithStourton · 04/10/2026 21:40

DIdn't the genderists, a few years ago, declare that some sizeable proportion of the population was 'intersex', by dint of including all women with PCOS, men with hypospadias etc etc?

Yep they say its 1.7% of the population ie as common as being redheaded which is completely nonsensical as possible is a female disease/disorder rather than a DSD

Datun · 05/10/2026 08:20

As far as I remember it was the transactivist group GIRES who initially went after the members of the Intersex Society. Bernard and Terry Reed. A physiotherapist and a businessman. They had a trans child.

Loosely, their motivation was that because some people with disorders of sexual development have to have operations, they wanted to get them to align themselves with trans ideology and promote operations together.

The Intersex Society refused, but GIRES badgered and badgered them. In the end the Society posted a public letter basically telling them to fuck off.

It clearly didn't deter them.

Scout2016 · 05/10/2026 08:35

DSDs are used to argue sex is a spectrum. It isn't, but even if it were the argument falls down because DSDs can be qualified by evidence, just as height is a spectrum which can be measured, it's not an undefinable feeling. I think it's also used to argue they all need "healthcare" by which they mean whatever treatment they say they want, even if not medically necessary. Sexuality can be evidenced too.

For some of those who have faced infertility and medical treatment due to DSDs, having a middle aged man who has fathered kids and is just revelling in wearing his wife's clothes and playing the victim say the two are in any way compatible must be incredibly offensive and hurtful.

titchy · 05/10/2026 08:41

How on earth is hypospadias a DSD? Theres not odd genetic makeup. Boys born with it have completely normal XY.

ErrolTheDragon · 05/10/2026 08:51

titchy · 05/10/2026 08:41

How on earth is hypospadias a DSD? Theres not odd genetic makeup. Boys born with it have completely normal XY.

Because it literally is a disorder of sex development - they’re not all down to X/Y chromosome differences and this is included. It’s one of the many DSDs where there’s no ambiguity whatsoever about a person’s sex.
https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/differences-in-sex-development/

nhs.uk

Differences in sex development

Find out about differences in sex development (DSDs), a group of rare conditions where the reproductive organs and genitals don't develop as expected. Some people prefer to use the term intersex.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/differences-in-sex-development/

DinoLil · 05/10/2026 08:53

What now???
Geez I must be old...

MarieDeGournay · 05/10/2026 09:21

I'm in the 'whatever 46XYDSD is comfortable with' camp - it's a rare DSD, not a choice. It doesn't set any precedent to refer to 46XYDSD using female pronouns.

Only a sneaky ill-intentioned point-scorer would say 'Well if you refer to 46XYDSD as 'she', you have to do that or all trans-IDing men as'.
Fortunately sneaky ill-intentioned point-scorers are vanishingly rare...😏

On the subject of sportspeople with DSDs - the Taiwanese boxer Lin Yu-Ting, who was 'mentioned in despatches' with Imane Khelif at the Paris Olympics, has been cleared by the IOC to box, on the basis that..her? their? DSD does not involve 'androgenization' [IOC'sword] and is therefore clear to box in the female category.

Good luck to Khelif's camp if they want to claim that his DSD does not involve 'androgenization'! As far as I know he has not taken the IOC tests.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 05/10/2026 12:21

backformoreofthesame · 04/10/2026 19:16

Oh I think it is the question

taking the post at face value however

i mean the norm is that you should follow medical advice and work with your medical team

and how you appear and choose to present and the pronouns that are used as a result are not for anyone else to worry about

unless OP is saying that they would have to tell people what pronouns to use - then it’s forced speech

OP had a very rare DSD

So my question is: do the opinions of the other "letters" count on this issue, or is it only the "T" that matters?

THIS was the question.

46XYDSD · 05/10/2026 13:25

Datun · 05/10/2026 08:20

As far as I remember it was the transactivist group GIRES who initially went after the members of the Intersex Society. Bernard and Terry Reed. A physiotherapist and a businessman. They had a trans child.

Loosely, their motivation was that because some people with disorders of sexual development have to have operations, they wanted to get them to align themselves with trans ideology and promote operations together.

The Intersex Society refused, but GIRES badgered and badgered them. In the end the Society posted a public letter basically telling them to fuck off.

It clearly didn't deter them.

I didn't know this - very interesting.

No, clearly it didn't!

OP posts:
AlexandraLeaving · 05/10/2026 13:52

On the subject of whose views trump whose, obviously what SHOULD happen is different from what DOES happen in practice (where T view trump everything else). There was a very depressing thread on AIBU the other day about an autistic child of 5 with a developmental age of 3 who had been told off at school for referring to a 5yo boy in a dress as 'a boy' because he wanted to be referred to as a girl. The number of posters that were happy to see the neurodivergent girl's needs and views set aside to prioritise the boy's was very depressing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread