Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

DD fed up of trans friend drama

66 replies

MTKWhite · 04/10/2026 12:25

Sharing mine and DDs experience of navigating this situation for anyone else going through it.

DD is 13 and in year 8. She has a group of friends, one of which "Frank" has come out as FtM trans.

This child has changed their name to "Frank" and uses he / him pronouns.

Frank is fully transitioned at school regarding name and pronouns. I'm not sure what happens about changing rooms. I was alarmed to hear that apparently Frank had transitioned at school without Frank's dad's knowledge. I thought the school had to inform parents?? The school is in Surrey. Can DM the school name.

Frank hasn't had the easiest time as Frank's parents are divorced and I gather that relationships with the mum are very difficult. Frank only recently "came out" to dad, a long time after being out at school. Frank is also autistic.

Now how this applies to my DD - Frank has become very angry at anyone who misgenders Frank. This is usually students or teachers who simply weren't aware Frank had transitioned or what the preferred pronouns were.

Frank goes off on rants calling these folks "transphobic" and dominates all conversation on this topic.

My DD is a very sensible chilled out girl who really can't be bothered with drama.

She and some other friends have distanced themselves from Frank because it just isn't enjoyable being friends with Frank any more.

I'm proud of DD for prioritising healthy friendships. Interested to hear others experiences

OP posts:
anonymoususer9876 · 04/10/2026 20:57

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 04/10/2026 17:56

Agreed, but they also shouldn’t be compounding the problem by agreeing with this distressed girl’s self diagnosis that she is ‘really a boy’ and encouraging her to make unreasonable demands on her friends (for pronouns, compelled belief etc), with a strong risk of alienation and further distress.

They should be following proper safeguarding procedures and speak to the parents.

There is no reason to think school are encouraging Frank to make unreasonable demands on their friends. Frank sounds like they are doing that all by themselves. School will be privy to the issues Frank is facing regarding home life and doing as much as they can to support. But school is not a replacement for counselling or other therapeutic support because teaching staff are just that. They are not trained to provide therapy and will refer on if safeguarding is an issue. Other professional bodies will decide from there. However, I imagine a child wanting to be called by their preferred gender pronouns will be very far down on the list.
The dad not being told will have been a judgement call by the school if they felt it would harm the child (emotionally) if dad was told, and I would hope that again would’ve been referred onto professional services.

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 20:09

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 19:12

You're not a parent are you mate?

Just a tip - reading the OP is always a good idea if you don't want to end up looking foolish

Am I not? Someone might want to come and get the two that insist on calling me mum then.

MissChanandlerBonng · 04/10/2026 20:01

Distancing yourself from this is really always the best solution. At the very least it’s monopolising attention.

IwantToRetire · 04/10/2026 19:44

Sorry - typo Blush

I can imagine any school siding with a child whose behaviour was oppressive and demanding of other pupils, by formalising their right to behave badly!

I cant imagine any school siding with a child whose behaviour was oppressive and demanding of other pupils, by formalising their right to behave badly!

IwantToRetire · 04/10/2026 19:42

I think by now most of us know those who are on FWR and are not gender critical.

So there really isn't any need to respond to them, as it is all just a wind up, in the hope that yet another thread on FWR will be another GroundHog Day.

Not only does it encourage them to come back over and over again, but it means that what used to be FWR strength, providing supportive and informative responses to those asking for help and advice, no longer, is starting to ebb away.

IwantToRetire · 04/10/2026 19:36

helpfulperson · 04/10/2026 16:06

It sounds like fairly typical teen drama that just happens to be trans related rather that particularly because they are trans. If your daughter is fed up of it she needs to just take a step back.

Edited

I can imagine any school siding with a child whose behaviour was oppressive and demanding of other pupils, by formalising their right to behave badly!

Its one thing having friendship groups where the dynamics often are shifting.

It is quite another thing to have the so called adults and ruling group, the teachers, "normalising" bad behaviour.

Livpool · 04/10/2026 19:16

SequinsandSlippers · 04/10/2026 12:50

My daughter's friend transitioned and they stayed good friends. No drama.
Just a friend whose name/presentation changed (they had testosterone and top surgery. They do "pass" but my daughter would have been friends regardless. There was no vocalising, transphobia comments, politics, ideology or stress involved. They got on with it, as did staff).

Do you mean a wholly unnecessary mastectomy when you say ‘top surgery’?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 19:12

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 18:03

Is this your first child? Because by about eight most parents have stopped being so over-involved in their child's friendship dramas. Just leave them to it.

You're not a parent are you mate?

Just a tip - reading the OP is always a good idea if you don't want to end up looking foolish

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 18:03

Is this your first child? Because by about eight most parents have stopped being so over-involved in their child's friendship dramas. Just leave them to it.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 04/10/2026 17:56

anonymoususer9876 · 04/10/2026 13:14

Schools can only do so much. Whilst some schools have counsellor services provided within the setting, others do not and refer on to CAMHS. And if the child is still going home to the same environment that may be behind the root cause, then that is out of schools hands.

OP hasn’t said what therapeutic support the child has had or continues to have and I’d be surprised if they knew the details unless the child or parent has chosen to share them.

Agreed, but they also shouldn’t be compounding the problem by agreeing with this distressed girl’s self diagnosis that she is ‘really a boy’ and encouraging her to make unreasonable demands on her friends (for pronouns, compelled belief etc), with a strong risk of alienation and further distress.

They should be following proper safeguarding procedures and speak to the parents.

LowlandLucky · 04/10/2026 16:07

Frank needs to understand that being transgender does not give you the right to be a rude obnoxious twunt. Your daughter has every right to tell Frank she doesn't want to be friends until all the drama and rudness stops.

helpfulperson · 04/10/2026 16:06

It sounds like fairly typical teen drama that just happens to be trans related rather that particularly because they are trans. If your daughter is fed up of it she needs to just take a step back.

SockPlant · 04/10/2026 16:01

viques · 04/10/2026 14:34

No drama? I think removing perfectly healthy body parts is pretty dramatic, as is taking medication that will cause long term and irreversible health issues, eg osteoporosis, vaginal atrophy, potential heart issues. Both actions pretty disturbing and a tad dramatic imo to fix an issue which is, statistically, more than likely to be linked to anxiety, autism and confusion about sexuality rather than issues about ‘gender’.

Horrifying implication that the staff ( school staff?) stood by and watched this unfold.

Edited

yes, i think there needs to be a lot more help from teachers and leadership in youth groups for young people - in how they interact with each other and learn to navigate a whole variety of social situations.

Of course, this needs to be done at home too, but we do need that village more than ever right now.

Helleofabore · 04/10/2026 15:15

SequinsandSlippers · 04/10/2026 12:50

My daughter's friend transitioned and they stayed good friends. No drama.
Just a friend whose name/presentation changed (they had testosterone and top surgery. They do "pass" but my daughter would have been friends regardless. There was no vocalising, transphobia comments, politics, ideology or stress involved. They got on with it, as did staff).

Did your daughter use male pronouns for her friend? In which case, there was 'drama' in that your daughter changed not just language for that moment or for future, but also then retconned her own historical recollections to fit her friend's identity.

I don't consider that to be 'no drama'. Your daughter may have done it willingly, but it was not a small thing to do.

viques · 04/10/2026 14:34

SequinsandSlippers · 04/10/2026 12:50

My daughter's friend transitioned and they stayed good friends. No drama.
Just a friend whose name/presentation changed (they had testosterone and top surgery. They do "pass" but my daughter would have been friends regardless. There was no vocalising, transphobia comments, politics, ideology or stress involved. They got on with it, as did staff).

No drama? I think removing perfectly healthy body parts is pretty dramatic, as is taking medication that will cause long term and irreversible health issues, eg osteoporosis, vaginal atrophy, potential heart issues. Both actions pretty disturbing and a tad dramatic imo to fix an issue which is, statistically, more than likely to be linked to anxiety, autism and confusion about sexuality rather than issues about ‘gender’.

Horrifying implication that the staff ( school staff?) stood by and watched this unfold.

BadSkiingMum · 04/10/2026 14:22

This is where I think formal debating can be quite useful. Because you get to see that a whole alternative set of beliefs can be held and equally perceived as 'true'. And that disagreement is not necessarily the same as attack.

Helleofabore · 04/10/2026 14:20

The need to control language and perception is key to some of the children's identities in my teen's friend group.

This is why any person who declares that there is no harm being done by children declaring that they are transgender is ignoring the harm that is immediately apparent in controlling other's language and behaviour. It is an immediate contradiction to declare there is no harm, while then demanding that people used demanded language.

But there has been a group who has fully believed that this group of people should have every right to expect others to support their personal choices around their philosophical belief about their identity. This sense of self righteousness and ownership of other's beliefs and language is considered progressive for now.

BadSkiingMum · 04/10/2026 14:19

I remember that about Y8 or Y9 was the first time that my peers and I became interested in 'issues', back in the late eighties. One girl brought in a load of leaflets (perhaps she had visited a PETA stand or similar?) about cosmetics testing on animals and the treatment of animals in the food industry. She would share petitions and there was a bit of social pressure to sign up and be seen to support the cause. I think a couple of girls went vegetarian. These were good causes by the way, but I am not sure that all the material was appropriate for 12-13 year old children!

The same girl had also been to 'The Body Shop' and brought back news about both their campaigns and their fruity products, so there was a lot of interest in that too!

To come to my point, I believe that there has been little change in the juvenile desire for attention, the desire to be seen as avant-garde in beliefs and the perceived necessity of having others unquestioningly adopt the same belief system. Unfortunately this particular set of beliefs has far more serious implications than signing a petition or annoying your mum by deciding to go vegetarian just before a family meal...

Helleofabore · 04/10/2026 14:15

OP

I had a child (maybe a year older at the time) who went through something similar with their group of friends. Only, within 18 months, out of the 7 of them, 5 had declared transgender identities.

I witnessed quite a few conversations where the group would express anger at any one, even the friends in the group, who misgendered them. After about 2 years of this, my own child decided there was so much constant focus on the individuals in the group's poor mental health, that my own teen decided to spend much less time with the group. My teen's mental health suffered during that time and partly because of the constant outrage at perceived phobia and hatred.

It can be very hard for children to navigate the situation that you find your daughter in.

Wishesandhorses · 04/10/2026 14:02

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 13:08

Controlling others (ceorcive control) is a major feature of transactivism and a dangerous lesson for children and young people to learn. They're not building healthy, respectful relationships and the long term result will often be their social isoloation as their peers start to recognise the unhealthy dynamics and remove themselves from their company (as your DD has done).

That's why some adults have failed so dismally by enabling these unhealthy attitudes to peers rather than fostering and modelling healthy, mutually respectful relationships

V good point.

Always striking in many articles written by FtM detransitioners how many of them describe, often very articulately, the driving need for control, and of sorting people into those who have agreed to be managed and those resisting.

But then in my time in secondary school the same behaviour (and probably the same demographic) were doing this mostly through anorexia as the means of the time. Vulnerable kids with unmet needs, making cries for things that feel like they meet needs and make sense of the whole situation. Which needs help from adults that does not make things worse or lock in any narratives, just gives space and time, and also doesn't require unhealthy/enabling behaviours from anyone else.

Can be helpful to rewatch Inside Out and look at the role of Disgust, who manages social harm risks as well as physical ones.

Floppyearedlab · 04/10/2026 13:39

MTKWhite · 04/10/2026 12:25

Sharing mine and DDs experience of navigating this situation for anyone else going through it.

DD is 13 and in year 8. She has a group of friends, one of which "Frank" has come out as FtM trans.

This child has changed their name to "Frank" and uses he / him pronouns.

Frank is fully transitioned at school regarding name and pronouns. I'm not sure what happens about changing rooms. I was alarmed to hear that apparently Frank had transitioned at school without Frank's dad's knowledge. I thought the school had to inform parents?? The school is in Surrey. Can DM the school name.

Frank hasn't had the easiest time as Frank's parents are divorced and I gather that relationships with the mum are very difficult. Frank only recently "came out" to dad, a long time after being out at school. Frank is also autistic.

Now how this applies to my DD - Frank has become very angry at anyone who misgenders Frank. This is usually students or teachers who simply weren't aware Frank had transitioned or what the preferred pronouns were.

Frank goes off on rants calling these folks "transphobic" and dominates all conversation on this topic.

My DD is a very sensible chilled out girl who really can't be bothered with drama.

She and some other friends have distanced themselves from Frank because it just isn't enjoyable being friends with Frank any more.

I'm proud of DD for prioritising healthy friendships. Interested to hear others experiences

Your daughter is quite right. This nonsense does not belong in schools

SockPlant · 04/10/2026 13:29

Frank needs a teacher to point out that shouting at your friends and accusing them of mean things (transphobia etc) alongside dominating all conversations and generally being a "me me me" will drive them away. As it has.

It is not so much to do with their transition - which i would worry about - but generally not being the kind of person who will attract friendship, sympathy and empathy.

This child clearly needs help.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 13:29

anonymoususer9876 · 04/10/2026 13:14

Schools can only do so much. Whilst some schools have counsellor services provided within the setting, others do not and refer on to CAMHS. And if the child is still going home to the same environment that may be behind the root cause, then that is out of schools hands.

OP hasn’t said what therapeutic support the child has had or continues to have and I’d be surprised if they knew the details unless the child or parent has chosen to share them.

That's an important point. And why schools should not be involved in promoting gender identity to children - the impact on the vulnerable could be catastrophic. And yes I know so much of this is online but it's only since September 2026 that schools have been advised to be cautious and not actively promote it. Until now, the DfE, unions and even shamefully, professional organisations like Education Psychologists have been funding and promoting trans ideology at children and schools.

Now the new guidance on SRE teaching tells schools they must not teach children that everyone has a gender identity and that it's a contested belief.

Another link that's useful for parents if they find schools inviting trans lobby groups into schools to promote GI to children

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/relationships-education-relationships-and-sex-education-rse-and-health-education

Relationships and sex education (RSE) and health education

Statutory guidance on relationships education, relationships and sex education (RSE) and health education.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/relationships-education-relationships-and-sex-education-rse-and-health-education

Mischance · 04/10/2026 13:26

This young person is in need of help, both with regard to their neuro-diversity and their gender confusion. I wonder who is on top of this.

It is such a shame that the whole issue has become a rights campaign and that those affected feel the need to be accusatory and unpleasant if someone makes a mistake in addressing them. It hampers normal human interaction.

I can understand that your DD wants to keep away and avoid the drama. Self protection is important. She needs to be able to go to school without feeling harassed by this person's strident responses. But of course it is very hard for the child involved as they need good social contacts more than ever.

I have a close young relative (also autistic) who is on the FtoM path but the difference is that they do not expect everyone to understand nor to always remember their preferred name/pronoun etc. They recognize that people will not always get it "right" and that good loving relationships are more important than blame. Just as well as I get it wrong all the time!! - but the overarching fact is that they know I love them.

Sadly people will stop loving/liking this troubled young pupil and this will compound their problems.

MTKWhite · 04/10/2026 13:16

anonymoususer9876 · 04/10/2026 13:14

Schools can only do so much. Whilst some schools have counsellor services provided within the setting, others do not and refer on to CAMHS. And if the child is still going home to the same environment that may be behind the root cause, then that is out of schools hands.

OP hasn’t said what therapeutic support the child has had or continues to have and I’d be surprised if they knew the details unless the child or parent has chosen to share them.

I don't know those details so can't comment but agree with your points

OP posts: