Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anyone else seeing LWD Director Viv Pointon’s posts about Sonia Sodha?

223 replies

IWantToMakeTea · 04/10/2026 09:07

Did anyone catch the comments LWD director Viv Pointon made about Sonia Sodha? She’s getting massive backlash online for explicitly targeting Sonia’s heritage and ethnicity.

Just to be 100% clear, I am and remain completely gender-critical— but I did end up leaving the LWD and WRN groups a while ago simply because of how some people, like Viv, were behaving behind the scenes.

The group chats just felt incredibly messy, bitchy, and unmoderated. Instead of being a supportive or organised space, they were frequently filled with general nastiness towards each other, a bizarre amount of hate directed at former Labour MP Rosie Duffield, and some shocking antisemitic comments. Viv herself was often a central part of that unpleasant atmosphere. A lot of the time, it was just constant chatty bullshit rather than anything actually relevant to GC campaign work. There were some bitchy LWD messages that got leaked to a newspaper a few months back. These are grown women behaving like playground bullies. I was going to go to the conference and attend the fringe group, but I decided not to go, though I might watch the videos on YouTube later.

Being in those groups was really eye-opening because it showed me the GC movement isn't 'love all around'. Maybe I was just a bit naive! Even though the core beliefs are massively important, seeing a director behave like that online to Sonia Sodha just reminds me that some people in the movement can end up doing more harm than good with their behaviour.

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:09

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

Left wing union leaders?

Your main problem with this argument is that Christian Nationalists love the concept of gender identity.

JimBobsWife · 04/10/2026 11:09

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 10:51

People have always moved around within the British Isles because that is how you survive. I grew up with stories of my family living in a particular part of the UK, but that was just the part of the family that people thought was worth remembering. I have plenty of great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great grandparents. There is no clear genetic distinction between people who live at either end of the M4.

I'm sure that if Wales/Scotland left the UK a very large proportion of the now 'English' would be able to claim dual nationality. Ironically the people more likely to only have a family connection to a small part of England are the children of more recent migrants.

But if we are talking about recent ancestry, is Armando Ianucci allowed to call himself Scottish? Hugo Rifkind?

Yes, if they want to. See my earlier post on the matter.

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 11:08

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 10:34

Congratulations to the OP who has managed to engineer a first post that has pivoted away from discussing whether people who call themselves GC have different views (well d’ur) to getting people to argue about English ethnicity with little reference to feminism.

As it happens I think it would help to both read Sonia’s piece and also to consider the wider context. The wider context being that the people who question whether some of my friends are ‘English’ but wouldn’t question whether I am, do so on the basis of their skin colour. That despite the fact one half of my family has no ‘ethnic’ link to England whatsoever, and the majority of my friends’ families have been in England for generations.

Isn't it MORE important to discuss this then to dispel myths than to ban or shame people from talking about it?

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:07

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:28

Go back far enough, and we're all related; go through history, and most groups have been in contact and mixed with other groups to some degree, so is "ethnicity" a thing? If so, why, if not, why not?

It seems to me that we can't cherrypick and have some groups of the ancestral sort being "ethnicised" and some not, without any logical basis other than whether it's politically expedient or not.

It seems to me that we can't cherrypick and have some groups of the ancestral sort being "ethnicised" and some not, without any logical basis other than whether it's politically expedient or not.

To be honest, I don't actually understand the point of ethnicising groups, particularly in England which has a far larger population than NI/Wales/Scotland and where e.g. people from Yorkshire and Cornwall have a strong sense of identity that is distinct from just being English.

I feel British and I have have a strong connection to the place in England where I grew up, but my family come from all over the UK, and I don't why I would be expected to feel more affiliated to somebody in Liverpool than somebody in Glasgow.

However, I understand that other people do feel English, and if they live in England and are British, I don't see why they shouldn't feel English.

TheignT · 04/10/2026 11:06

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 10:34

Congratulations to the OP who has managed to engineer a first post that has pivoted away from discussing whether people who call themselves GC have different views (well d’ur) to getting people to argue about English ethnicity with little reference to feminism.

As it happens I think it would help to both read Sonia’s piece and also to consider the wider context. The wider context being that the people who question whether some of my friends are ‘English’ but wouldn’t question whether I am, do so on the basis of their skin colour. That despite the fact one half of my family has no ‘ethnic’ link to England whatsoever, and the majority of my friends’ families have been in England for generations.

I went to school in the50s, many of my classmates had Polish parents. Most of the fathers fought in WW2. Their grandchildren seem to qualify as English. My late fil was black, he fought In WW2. His GC don't seem to qualify as English. The only difference seems to be skin colour.

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 11:04

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

What movement?

What turn?

A discussion about ourselves? What is wrong with that exactly?

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 11:04

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

What turn is that?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 11:04

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

LOL, nice try

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 11:02

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:50

Borders aren't necessarily driven by ethnicity. Some are, but some are connected with collective interest binding a varied bunch of people and some are determined by conquest from outside.

And taxes.

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 10:58

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 10:51

People have always moved around within the British Isles because that is how you survive. I grew up with stories of my family living in a particular part of the UK, but that was just the part of the family that people thought was worth remembering. I have plenty of great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great grandparents. There is no clear genetic distinction between people who live at either end of the M4.

I'm sure that if Wales/Scotland left the UK a very large proportion of the now 'English' would be able to claim dual nationality. Ironically the people more likely to only have a family connection to a small part of England are the children of more recent migrants.

But if we are talking about recent ancestry, is Armando Ianucci allowed to call himself Scottish? Hugo Rifkind?

I reckon he would identify himself as Italian -Scottish, and Rifkind as Scottish -Jewish.

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 10:51

JimBobsWife · 04/10/2026 10:19

I don't think we need to. Until migration as we now recognise it started after the second world war, the British Isles were overwhelmingly white and many of these people could trace their families back generations. People didn't move around much, often never leaving the UK. Yes, there were migrants coming and going, mainly into cities but the numbers were small.

These sorts of arguments are modern ones, caused by an increasingly global world and movements of people. It doesn't mean English isn't an ethnicity and it's not racist to say that it is, and that those will people will be white. That's just facts.

People have always moved around within the British Isles because that is how you survive. I grew up with stories of my family living in a particular part of the UK, but that was just the part of the family that people thought was worth remembering. I have plenty of great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great grandparents. There is no clear genetic distinction between people who live at either end of the M4.

I'm sure that if Wales/Scotland left the UK a very large proportion of the now 'English' would be able to claim dual nationality. Ironically the people more likely to only have a family connection to a small part of England are the children of more recent migrants.

But if we are talking about recent ancestry, is Armando Ianucci allowed to call himself Scottish? Hugo Rifkind?

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:50

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 10:32

If we go back far enough all humans descended from one woman so why even have borders?

Borders aren't necessarily driven by ethnicity. Some are, but some are connected with collective interest binding a varied bunch of people and some are determined by conquest from outside.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 10:43

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 04/10/2026 10:24

Are you an English TIM excelling at football, and consider yourself a female, you have the possibility of playing in the England Ladies team.

My father's side of the family is predominantly of Scottish ancestry, though he and i were born in England. My two sons were both born in Scotland and this is on their birth certificate, but in Scotland they would be considered English. ( presumably not eligible to play for Scotland)

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:43

I think if you think any group of people is going to be "love all round" you are being naive, unfortunately. Human beings are only human.

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 10:38

@IWantToMakeTea i think you have hit the nail on the head with your original statement of "Being in those groups was really eye-opening because it showed me the GC movement isn't 'love all around'. Maybe I was just a bit naive!" Even Mother Teresa was considered racist with a white saviour complex in some quarters so there we go!

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 10:37

Bacha1910 · 04/10/2026 10:15

Not everyone in the UK has a mix of ancestors from all over the UK. People in cities often do because of migration for work, around the Industrial Revolution particularly, but there are people all over the country whose ancestry is much more specific to one particular area.

True! Most of my family ancestry comes from people who migrated to Liverpool for work ( from elsewhere in the British Isles) during the industrial revolution.

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 10:34

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 10:28

Welcome to Mumsnet OP.

A rather unusual issue for your first post. What are you hoping to achieve from it I wonder?

Glad someone else noticed.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 10:34

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 04/10/2026 10:19

And how consistent and homogenous ethnically has that line been in the last 1000 years?

Very, I'd say. I know my DNA is entirely British Isles ( but include very small percentages of French ( normans/Breton), Dutch and Danish. I've predominantly Scottish and Irish type DNA - though also some that originates in East Anglia/Essex. Though If your family orginates in East Anglia the chances are you'll also have some N.W European too - from cross North sea traders .

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 10:34

Congratulations to the OP who has managed to engineer a first post that has pivoted away from discussing whether people who call themselves GC have different views (well d’ur) to getting people to argue about English ethnicity with little reference to feminism.

As it happens I think it would help to both read Sonia’s piece and also to consider the wider context. The wider context being that the people who question whether some of my friends are ‘English’ but wouldn’t question whether I am, do so on the basis of their skin colour. That despite the fact one half of my family has no ‘ethnic’ link to England whatsoever, and the majority of my friends’ families have been in England for generations.

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 10:32

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:28

Go back far enough, and we're all related; go through history, and most groups have been in contact and mixed with other groups to some degree, so is "ethnicity" a thing? If so, why, if not, why not?

It seems to me that we can't cherrypick and have some groups of the ancestral sort being "ethnicised" and some not, without any logical basis other than whether it's politically expedient or not.

If we go back far enough all humans descended from one woman so why even have borders?

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 10:28

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 10:12

How far are we going back to determine who is genetically English? Go back 1,000 years and everyone with European ancestors is related. Is there a sweet spot about 500 years ago? Nigel Farage's name is supposed to be Huguenot, so is he on the right side of the line?

Go back far enough, and we're all related; go through history, and most groups have been in contact and mixed with other groups to some degree, so is "ethnicity" a thing? If so, why, if not, why not?

It seems to me that we can't cherrypick and have some groups of the ancestral sort being "ethnicised" and some not, without any logical basis other than whether it's politically expedient or not.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/10/2026 10:28

Welcome to Mumsnet OP.

A rather unusual issue for your first post. What are you hoping to achieve from it I wonder?

Jiddles · 04/10/2026 10:27

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 10:22

Are you British but unable to vote in the NI, Scottish or Welsh elections?

No - then from a legal point of view you are English.

Would you be eligible to play for England?

Yes - then you are definitely English.

Should your 'No' be 'Yes'? It doesn’t make sense the way you’ve written it - "No, I’m not unable to vote in those elections therefore I’m English"…

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 10:26

Jiddles · 04/10/2026 10:16

Genuine question: how many generations do you think it takes before the descendants of immigrants should reasonably be able to classify themselves as English? (Or is the answer 'never'?)

Nationally English or Ethically English?

Being born in a country as I've already said, makes your Nationality either the country you were born in or the country your parents were born in, hence the dual passport system.

Ethnically is about your ancestry which would definitely need to be multigenerational and more difficult to parse. But if your family was multigenerational in a country that went back several hundred years then you have much more 'claim' to be ethnically from that country than people whose parents arrived 50 years ago.

Swipe left for the next trending thread