Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anyone else seeing LWD Director Viv Pointon’s posts about Sonia Sodha?

223 replies

IWantToMakeTea · 04/10/2026 09:07

Did anyone catch the comments LWD director Viv Pointon made about Sonia Sodha? She’s getting massive backlash online for explicitly targeting Sonia’s heritage and ethnicity.

Just to be 100% clear, I am and remain completely gender-critical— but I did end up leaving the LWD and WRN groups a while ago simply because of how some people, like Viv, were behaving behind the scenes.

The group chats just felt incredibly messy, bitchy, and unmoderated. Instead of being a supportive or organised space, they were frequently filled with general nastiness towards each other, a bizarre amount of hate directed at former Labour MP Rosie Duffield, and some shocking antisemitic comments. Viv herself was often a central part of that unpleasant atmosphere. A lot of the time, it was just constant chatty bullshit rather than anything actually relevant to GC campaign work. There were some bitchy LWD messages that got leaked to a newspaper a few months back. These are grown women behaving like playground bullies. I was going to go to the conference and attend the fringe group, but I decided not to go, though I might watch the videos on YouTube later.

Being in those groups was really eye-opening because it showed me the GC movement isn't 'love all around'. Maybe I was just a bit naive! Even though the core beliefs are massively important, seeing a director behave like that online to Sonia Sodha just reminds me that some people in the movement can end up doing more harm than good with their behaviour.

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Justnot · 04/10/2026 12:54

So if the UK broke up what would those who aren’t ‘ethnically’ English be allowed to call themselves? Would it still be British?

anyway, no one has ever told me I’m not English despite having Irish born parents probably because I am white.

I do find it interesting, the waves of different peoples who came to the British Isles, sometimes completely displacing the local populations.

just had a quick google so take with a cup of salt, in 10th century the genetic makeup of England was 76% Anglo Saxon, Jutes etc and the rest was Celtic or Romano/British (that’s my DNA)

How far do we go back to say we have English ethnicity? What are the rules for inclusion? Nationality is the only thing that really makes sense - we can still have roots elsewhere or roots that go along way back here.

I am from London and went to school 50 years ago with a big mix of 2nd generation immigrants from at least 10 different nationalities who now have children and grandchildren, how can their kids and grandkids not be English?

I do think you can be two things at once - I am English and Irish as far as I am concerned, my teen is English though they like to refer to their Irish & Essex roots. If/when they have a kid how can it be anything but English?

My DP (from Essex) just said anyone after 1066 is a foreigner, I think he was joking, but if we draw the line there a lot of people will be getting their coats.

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 12:46

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 11:25

Not entirely social constructs, as with biological sex 'race' characteristics and ethniciity ( to an extent) are also genetically coded.

Could you describe to me the biological differences between a black person and a white person? How about if we throw brown people into the mix? Or Jewish or Romany?

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 04/10/2026 12:26

Perhaps it's a matter of the past, this country, all the parts of it, do have a culture, it grew organically over many centuries. Through fits and starts, through wars and reconciliations, maybe it's down to how much your ancestors contributed to making the culture what it is or suffered because of what it was that makes you a native.
Human rights are a Western construct, it came about because of the people in the west learned from the horrors they inflected on themselves, it was a cultural awakening, as was the determination not to let it happen again.
Racism is also a Western construct, there is no other ethnicity, race, culture, country outside the west that even recognises racism in the way we understand it.
Perhaps those who come to this country, or were born in this country to parents who were immigrants, who have embraced the concepts of human rights and racism can be considered British, but only those who's ancestors played a role in developing the culture that led to human rights etc can be one of the native tribes.
You can't belong to two places at once, if you have loyalty to a foreign land as well as the one you live in, you aren't a native too either land.

Heggettypeg · 04/10/2026 12:05

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:52

But what IS English ‘culture’ though?

Is the problem with defining "culture", or "English culture', would you say? What about French or American culture, for example?

OldCrone · 04/10/2026 12:02

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

What turn?

Are you surprised that Reform have strong views about nationality and ethnicity? I assume that's who you're referring to as the " movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists", as it was Suella Braverman who made the original comment about ethnicity which Viv Pointon supported and Sonia Sodha challenged.

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:59

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:51

Until there’s a common agreement on what is meant by the terms ‘race’, ‘ethnicity’ or ‘nationality’, everyone will be talking at cross purposes and likely be offended by each other’s posts.

Nationality is the only one that has a clear definition.

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:58

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:52

But what IS English ‘culture’ though?

Cricket?

weegielass1 · 04/10/2026 11:56

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 11:15

Sure, discuss what you like. Just do it with an awareness of the ‘naive’ OP’s intentions.

I think the OP was simply starting a discussion? It seems to have hit a particular nerve with you though?

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:52

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:44

Shared culture, language, history and set of traditions relating to place maybe?

However, that is obviously fraught when a group has been forced to move from a place.

Welsh people were discouraged from speaking Welsh within living memory, so I can understand why they would need a word to describe the thing they are trying to protect.

However, the odd thing about telling e.g. Rishi Sunak that he can't self describe as English is that Rishi Sunak's parents demonstrably valued English culture. (Not saying anyone on this thread is arguing this - just trying to think through what ethnicity is).

But what IS English ‘culture’ though?

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:51

Until there’s a common agreement on what is meant by the terms ‘race’, ‘ethnicity’ or ‘nationality’, everyone will be talking at cross purposes and likely be offended by each other’s posts.

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2026 11:49

PollyNomial · 04/10/2026 11:00

Who could possibly imagine that a movement generously supported by far right "Christian" nationalists would encourage people to take this turn?

Don’t be daft 🤣🤣🤣

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:44

JustSpeculation · 04/10/2026 11:29

The CED definition is a description of use rather than a prescriptive or principled definition.

"shared culture, language, history and set of traditions"

That definition could equally appply to the local gardening society or the House of Commons, but it would be ludicrous to claim that those were ethnicities. Perhaps it's better to look at ethnicities, gardening socieities and the House of Commens as being members of the set of groups which "share culture, language, history and set of traditions"

I'm not sure that "Nation" has a clear and uncontested meaning either. Actually, I'm sure it doesn't.

But, yes, I agree that Sonia Sodha is clearly English, for the reasons I wrote in my previous post.

Shared culture, language, history and set of traditions relating to place maybe?

However, that is obviously fraught when a group has been forced to move from a place.

Welsh people were discouraged from speaking Welsh within living memory, so I can understand why they would need a word to describe the thing they are trying to protect.

However, the odd thing about telling e.g. Rishi Sunak that he can't self describe as English is that Rishi Sunak's parents demonstrably valued English culture. (Not saying anyone on this thread is arguing this - just trying to think through what ethnicity is).

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:35

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 11:25

Not entirely social constructs, as with biological sex 'race' characteristics and ethniciity ( to an extent) are also genetically coded.

'Race' just refers to groups of people who share traits because their ancestors lived in the same geographical area for a while, and characteristics change as people move and meet different people.

However, sex remains constant.

JustSpeculation · 04/10/2026 11:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 11:22

A lot of this seems like people talking past each other to me.

Well, obvs. How are we supposed to know what we mean until we've seen it written in a post? And there's more than one discussion going on, I think.

More seriously, there's actually a lot of food for thought here and I'm going to go away and think about it.

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 11:31

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 11:21

Seeing as race and ethnicity are both social constructs we could discuss how that mirrors gender identity but I’m not sure this forum has the energy to pursue both those discussions! We could just acknowledge that all humans evolved as being naturally xenophobic and leave it at that. There’s more than a few posters on here who would be happy to accrue any so called “evidence “ that GC’s are all right wing Christian racists rather than the highly diverse political ,cultural and religious/ non religious individuals that GC’s are.

There’s some scope to discuss constructed identities vs material reality. I think arguing that either race or ethnicity are as robust, materially real categories as ‘sex’ is fraught with difficulty though.

JustSpeculation · 04/10/2026 11:29

RoyalCorgi · 04/10/2026 11:11

"Ethnicity" is a very broad term, is it not? I'd assumed that it included some genetic element - normally when you think of an ethnic group (the Yoruba, say), they have a shared language and history, but also a geographical connection that means they share some genetic features.

According to the Cambridge English Dictionary, however, an ethnic group is a group of people with a "shared culture, language, history and set of traditions". So no genetic element at all.

Before I read that, I'd have argued that English is a nationality rather than an ethnic group, given that the English are descended from a range of people who have invaded the country over the years - the Angles, the Saxons, the Vikings and the Normans. But if we go with the CED definition, then English is an ethnicity too.

On that basis, I don't see anything that would bar Sonia Sodha from claiming an English identity.

The CED definition is a description of use rather than a prescriptive or principled definition.

"shared culture, language, history and set of traditions"

That definition could equally appply to the local gardening society or the House of Commons, but it would be ludicrous to claim that those were ethnicities. Perhaps it's better to look at ethnicities, gardening socieities and the House of Commens as being members of the set of groups which "share culture, language, history and set of traditions"

I'm not sure that "Nation" has a clear and uncontested meaning either. Actually, I'm sure it doesn't.

But, yes, I agree that Sonia Sodha is clearly English, for the reasons I wrote in my previous post.

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 11:27

TheignT · 04/10/2026 11:06

I went to school in the50s, many of my classmates had Polish parents. Most of the fathers fought in WW2. Their grandchildren seem to qualify as English. My late fil was black, he fought In WW2. His GC don't seem to qualify as English. The only difference seems to be skin colour.

In a similar vein, I have an old friend who has a Black grandparent. She has a lot of siblings. She has straight blonde hair some of her siblings have dark curlier hair. They are all pretty light skinned until it’s summer. Only some of them have ever had their ‘Englishness’ questioned.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 11:25

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 11:21

Seeing as race and ethnicity are both social constructs we could discuss how that mirrors gender identity but I’m not sure this forum has the energy to pursue both those discussions! We could just acknowledge that all humans evolved as being naturally xenophobic and leave it at that. There’s more than a few posters on here who would be happy to accrue any so called “evidence “ that GC’s are all right wing Christian racists rather than the highly diverse political ,cultural and religious/ non religious individuals that GC’s are.

Not entirely social constructs, as with biological sex 'race' characteristics and ethniciity ( to an extent) are also genetically coded.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 11:22

A lot of this seems like people talking past each other to me.

B9b9b9 · 04/10/2026 11:21

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 11:08

Isn't it MORE important to discuss this then to dispel myths than to ban or shame people from talking about it?

Seeing as race and ethnicity are both social constructs we could discuss how that mirrors gender identity but I’m not sure this forum has the energy to pursue both those discussions! We could just acknowledge that all humans evolved as being naturally xenophobic and leave it at that. There’s more than a few posters on here who would be happy to accrue any so called “evidence “ that GC’s are all right wing Christian racists rather than the highly diverse political ,cultural and religious/ non religious individuals that GC’s are.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 11:19

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 11:15

Sure, discuss what you like. Just do it with an awareness of the ‘naive’ OP’s intentions.

I think her intentions were clear, it is just that the discussion that was sparked has led off somewhere else.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/10/2026 11:15

nicepotoftea · 04/10/2026 11:07

It seems to me that we can't cherrypick and have some groups of the ancestral sort being "ethnicised" and some not, without any logical basis other than whether it's politically expedient or not.

To be honest, I don't actually understand the point of ethnicising groups, particularly in England which has a far larger population than NI/Wales/Scotland and where e.g. people from Yorkshire and Cornwall have a strong sense of identity that is distinct from just being English.

I feel British and I have have a strong connection to the place in England where I grew up, but my family come from all over the UK, and I don't why I would be expected to feel more affiliated to somebody in Liverpool than somebody in Glasgow.

However, I understand that other people do feel English, and if they live in England and are British, I don't see why they shouldn't feel English.

There has always been a big thing in Liverpool ( which i personally don't like) of saying 'Scouse not English'; of seeing themselves as separate from England. This is down to a history of large scale Irish migration to the city during the famine and again during the industrial revolution. Though Liverpool also saw widespread Welsh migration, and Scottish too. It was a boom city and attracted people from all over.

There were also migrant sailors coming into the port from all over the world and staying and marrying locally......though they and their children, grandchildren etc still tend to refer to themselves as of dual nationality/ethnicity.

BackToLurk · 04/10/2026 11:15

Shedmistress · 04/10/2026 11:08

Isn't it MORE important to discuss this then to dispel myths than to ban or shame people from talking about it?

Sure, discuss what you like. Just do it with an awareness of the ‘naive’ OP’s intentions.

RoyalCorgi · 04/10/2026 11:11

"Ethnicity" is a very broad term, is it not? I'd assumed that it included some genetic element - normally when you think of an ethnic group (the Yoruba, say), they have a shared language and history, but also a geographical connection that means they share some genetic features.

According to the Cambridge English Dictionary, however, an ethnic group is a group of people with a "shared culture, language, history and set of traditions". So no genetic element at all.

Before I read that, I'd have argued that English is a nationality rather than an ethnic group, given that the English are descended from a range of people who have invaded the country over the years - the Angles, the Saxons, the Vikings and the Normans. But if we go with the CED definition, then English is an ethnicity too.

On that basis, I don't see anything that would bar Sonia Sodha from claiming an English identity.

JustSpeculation · 04/10/2026 11:10

Interesting discussion. So what makes you English? Not "you" - I mean "one" but didin't want to sound like the old Queen.

I've been thinking about this for over half a century and the only conclusion I can come to is that people see terms like nation and ethinicity differently. Maybe they can't be clearly defined. I know people who see the Union Flag as a symbol of an hegemonising elite trying to homogenise all the different people in Britain (and now the UK), and claim that the only flag for English people is the cross of St George. Such people often see anti-Englishness as a class issue. Some of these people are even still angry about the Norman conquest, which they see as the source of all evil. I know people who think that if you are English you can't be anything else. I also know people who are incandescent at the idea that they can't be English and, oh, Jewish for example. I know people who describe themselves as English and Greek. Not half English, half Greek, but completely English and completely Greek. As far as I'm concerened they're all right, because I can't see any coherent principles at work.

I don't agree with the idea of "civic" Englishness, as that would imply that your Englishness was officially recognised, but there is no document you can get to establish your Englishness as far as I know. I have a document saying I'm British (a passport) but nothing saying I'm Englilsh. Is it an ethnicity? I have a golden years travel pass ("Freedom pass") which is some kind of official recognition that I'm a Londoner, but nothing which says I'm English.

But I am English, of German, Scottish and English descent. I like being English, and I see no problem in celebrating Englishness. The Director OP mentions seems more to be annoyed at the idea that we shouldn't celebrate being English than anything else. I doubt she's actively racist in any meaningful sense. Also, Sonia Sodha (and Shabana Mahmood and Rishi Sunak) was born here, grew up here and say they're English. That's good enough for me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread