Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions

259 replies

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:33

Stephen King was asked a simple question - are trans women women? - and when he said yes, one of the most wealthy writers in the world turned on him.

J.K. Rowling had just publicly showered him with praise. Within hours of his answer, she deleted it and, in King's words, "sorta blocked" him.

King is one of the most famous novelists alive, and he didn't walk it back or cast himself as the victim. He said plainly that nobody had cancelled Rowling - he just thought she was wrong. He turns 79 today, still saying it.

He could have kept the friend and stayed quiet. He said yes instead.

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GarlicEverything · 03/10/2026 23:29

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:29

Seriously, a deleted tweet is not a big deal. He's dealt with worse (and madder) stuff.

😂😂

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:29

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:27

The right to a belief. As in the right not to be discriminated against for your political or religious beliefs would be examples.

You can believe what you want.

You don’t have any rights to force others to collude with your beliefs when they have no factual basis

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:29

Seriously, a deleted tweet is not a big deal. He's dealt with worse (and madder) stuff.

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:28

alcovecupboards · 03/10/2026 23:26

She deleted praise of something for sticking up with her because she later discovered he didn't agree with her on one singular issue. But meanwhile she's spent years taking potshots at people for daring to disagree with her.

She deleted a tweet. That is allowed in this free world of ours. Move on

God so much barrel scraping tonight. wtf is wrong with people?

solerolover · 03/10/2026 23:27

Didn't JKR and King have some kind of playful back and forth banter last year or something like that?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:27

AstonCanKissMyArse · 03/10/2026 23:18

the right to identity (self identification)

Whenyou say this is a right, what do you mean?

People often seem to throw the word 'rights' about with little concept of what right, according to whom, for what purposes?

When people talk about their 'rights' it often seems to mean 'a thing that I think i should be allowed to do'.

Its almost as if its just a way to make their wants seem more legitimate.

There is no 'right' to pretend to be the opposite sex.

The right to a belief. As in the right not to be discriminated against for your political or religious beliefs would be examples.

alcovecupboards · 03/10/2026 23:26

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:22

How does it do that?

She deleted praise of something for sticking up with her because she later discovered he didn't agree with her on one singular issue. But meanwhile she's spent years taking potshots at people for daring to disagree with her.

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:26

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:23

No, that does not what legitimate aim means. You seem to be making it up as you go to suit your biases.

Nope. You don’t understand the law.

There is no situation where a legitimate aim would be answered by a group based on ‘gender identity.’

You can have single sex provision or unisex provision. Those are the options.

solerolover · 03/10/2026 23:25

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:14

Guess what @Choppingwoodcarryingwater

Humans STILL can’t change sex.

And no one is buying your attempts to change the definition of sex 🙄

I swear ChoppingGoodGretelNorthernBaileyHowseIcelandicnights has been making the same argument for the better part of a year now and it's still as nonsensical and incoherent as ever.

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:24

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:22

We've seen all these arguments before (anyone reminded of dear departed Howse?) and they are still weak and unconvincing.

I’ve seen a few ‘let’s get round this by defining sex as something other than sex’ arguments recently.

The barrel is truly being scraped.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 03/10/2026 23:23

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 22:58

The nuance is sex isn't just socially distinguished by reproductive traits but also set of roles, behaviours, expressions, and norms that societies consider appropriate for men, women and gender-diverse people.

Of course gender critical proponents would correctly categorise this as stereotyping but nevertheless that is the reality we live in as in those categories exist whether we agree with them or not.

Sex IS reproductive trait.

That’s literally what sex is.

I don’t know what your point has to do with the price of fish - or with the arguments that actually-existing trans activists have been making, or the orthodoxy current when King made his very silly intervention.

Or indeed with the actual statement he agreed with.

It was “trans women are women” - not “trans women are men who try to mimic stereotypical feminine behaviour as understood in a specific but not universal cultural context which may be subject to change over time” or even “trans women are men who believe they have feminine gender, whatever they mean by that”.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:23

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:17

If a legitimate aim is to be met, it will be met by segregation by sex.

Not segregation by ‘gender identity’, which there is no provision for in law

No, that does not what legitimate aim means. You seem to be making it up as you go to suit your biases.

alcovecupboards · 03/10/2026 23:23

Mapletree1985 · 03/10/2026 22:48

Did she? What praise exactly? Where was it published/posted? How did she delete it?

https://news.sky.com/story/jk-rowling-deletes-praise-for-stephen-king-after-he-voices-support-for-trans-women-12017534

GarlicEverything · 03/10/2026 23:22

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:18

Sex traits can change is the point. Whether you personally accept this as what qualifies as a woman is simply an opinion not a fact given 'woman' is a socially constructed category. In other words, it can mean whatever society deems it to mean.

Oh, for god's sake, woman is not a socially constructed category.

It's the word for a human of the female reproductive category (otherwise known as sex).

Same as hen, mare, ewe, doe, etc are the females of their species.

Been repeating this on here and twitter for the last 18 years. Where the fuck have you been?

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:22

alcovecupboards · 03/10/2026 23:21

It shows her hypocrisy.

How does it do that?

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:22

We've seen all these arguments before (anyone reminded of dear departed Howse?) and they are still weak and unconvincing.

alcovecupboards · 03/10/2026 23:21

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 22:23

In your opinion, why is it if any consequence that she deleted a tweet?

It shows her hypocrisy.

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:20

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:18

Sex traits can change is the point. Whether you personally accept this as what qualifies as a woman is simply an opinion not a fact given 'woman' is a socially constructed category. In other words, it can mean whatever society deems it to mean.

Fake boobs are just fake boobs @Choppingwoodcarryingwater

Humsms STILL cannot change sex

AstonCanKissMyArse · 03/10/2026 23:20

And yet, most adults seem to figure out how to breed.

Its astounding. What are the chances? itsalmost like you can tell, or something

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:19

You've read too much Harry Potter if you think that saying magic words or taking potions causes people to change sex.

SabrinaThwaite · 03/10/2026 23:19

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:11

Definitions aren't fixed though because they are reliant on public/cultural usage. And its self evident that trans woman has broadly understood accepted meaning. In other words, most people know what these words point to whether they agree on how the concept comes into being or not.

Nope. Definitions of male and female are fixed. And in the UK, as clarified in law, a woman is an adult human female.

And no, a significant proportion of the UK general public have no idea that a trans woman is a male.

The Telegraph in 2023: A third of Britons don’t know that transgender women were born male.

https://archive.ph/kg6QU

It’s almost like the language is designed to
obfuscate.

gamerchick · 03/10/2026 23:19

Why is this being brought up years later and the story changed? Annoyed all over again.

I loved his books, haven't bought a new one since he pulled that stunt. What a fucking bastard.

We remember dude. We'll always remember.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 03/10/2026 23:18

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 22:52

There are two different issues here that are often conflated here. One is the right to identity (self identification) & the other is how to manage competing priorities as a result of it. Just because competing priorities exist doesn't invalidate self identification nor is inclusion a right….that depends on rights balancing.

the right to identity (self identification)

Whenyou say this is a right, what do you mean?

People often seem to throw the word 'rights' about with little concept of what right, according to whom, for what purposes?

When people talk about their 'rights' it often seems to mean 'a thing that I think i should be allowed to do'.

Its almost as if its just a way to make their wants seem more legitimate.

There is no 'right' to pretend to be the opposite sex.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:18

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:14

Guess what @Choppingwoodcarryingwater

Humans STILL can’t change sex.

And no one is buying your attempts to change the definition of sex 🙄

Sex traits can change is the point. Whether you personally accept this as what qualifies as a woman is simply an opinion not a fact given 'woman' is a socially constructed category. In other words, it can mean whatever society deems it to mean.

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:17

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:14

Ah no that's not how proportionality works. Sex isn't a get out of jail free card. The individual circumstances matter as to whether a legitimate aim is met.

If a legitimate aim is to be met, it will be met by segregation by sex.

Not segregation by ‘gender identity’, which there is no provision for in law