Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions

259 replies

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:33

Stephen King was asked a simple question - are trans women women? - and when he said yes, one of the most wealthy writers in the world turned on him.

J.K. Rowling had just publicly showered him with praise. Within hours of his answer, she deleted it and, in King's words, "sorta blocked" him.

King is one of the most famous novelists alive, and he didn't walk it back or cast himself as the victim. He said plainly that nobody had cancelled Rowling - he just thought she was wrong. He turns 79 today, still saying it.

He could have kept the friend and stayed quiet. He said yes instead.

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CassOle · 04/10/2026 00:51

Is a replacement bus service a trans-train or a cis-train, then?

PachacutisBadAuntie · 04/10/2026 00:46

ErrolTheDragon · 04/10/2026 00:10

Some trains which identify as ‘transpennine’ are surely cispennine Confused

If 'cis' means frequently delayed or cancelled and the compo comes by cheque, they surely are. Words can apparently mean whatever we want them to mean...

GrumpyPanda · 04/10/2026 00:45

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:24

I’ve seen a few ‘let’s get round this by defining sex as something other than sex’ arguments recently.

The barrel is truly being scraped.

It's usually part of the "sex is a spectrum" nonsense. Because certain sex traits, such as height, are bimodal and overlapping, they claim that so is sex itself. Neatly overlooking not only the difference between sex and sex traits, but also the fact that the two separate bimodal curves are.... male and female.

maxslice · 04/10/2026 00:42

She has her opinion, he has his. Mature people are able to disagree and remain friends. Especially about issues that do not directly affect them. And people can also not give a toss about famous writers’ views on topics that have nothing to do with writing.

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 00:38

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:33

Stephen King was asked a simple question - are trans women women? - and when he said yes, one of the most wealthy writers in the world turned on him.

J.K. Rowling had just publicly showered him with praise. Within hours of his answer, she deleted it and, in King's words, "sorta blocked" him.

King is one of the most famous novelists alive, and he didn't walk it back or cast himself as the victim. He said plainly that nobody had cancelled Rowling - he just thought she was wrong. He turns 79 today, still saying it.

He could have kept the friend and stayed quiet. He said yes instead.

I want to ask something. It's a genuine question. Why does a transgender woman want to claim female space. Some transgender eomen I presume have nice lives and and are living the life they want, so why is there the need to claim female space. I'm not being facetious. Why not have spaces for them.i cant see why there wouldnt be enough power in claiming a space for themselves. Why dont they want to be accepted as themselves and equal in their own space. Why isnt it enough to be who they actually are.

lcakethereforeIam · 04/10/2026 00:26

Has King ever written a trans character? Or an NB one? I suppose it's possible some of his female characters were actually trans identifying men but either passed so perfectly the other characters didn't notice (he does mostly write fiction) or were too polite/woke to say anything. An NB character would be they/themming so it would be more noticeable. I'm asking because I honestly don't know. It's would be strange if he whole heartedly supported people who claimed some flavour of trans identity that he hasn't put one in a book.

I know JKR had a rather sympathetically written TiM in one of her Strike novels.

GrumpyPanda · 04/10/2026 00:25

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 03/10/2026 22:33

It’s, ironically, a very cargo cult kind of insult, isn’t it?

A few years ago TRAs (I think Katy Montgomerie was one: remember him?) noticed GCs pointing out the similarities between genderism & cults - a position that GCs maintained by knowing the characteristics of cults & seeing how the same characteristics appear in genderism.

They realised being a cult was a BAD THING, but couldn't be arsed to address the actual content of the comparison.

Instead - like building a symbolic landing strip out of flowers & hoping it will produce cargo - they just went for the form.

Call knowing what sex is a “cult”!

It has gone out of fashion: like the OP it’s very retro.

But crap ideas don't seem to die, do they?

It's very DARVO. Also reminiscent of Trump's appropriation of "fake news"," which was coined as a bona fide term to describe Russian hybrid warfare (a.k.a. "flooding the zone with shit"), to instead describe actual news unwelcome to the MAGA world.

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 00:14

EmmyFr · 03/10/2026 21:35

Source (including for their being friends, thank you mate, Stephen Fry's tried it already) or it didn't happen.

What? I dont understand what this means

CassOle · 04/10/2026 00:13

ErrolTheDragon · 04/10/2026 00:10

Some trains which identify as ‘transpennine’ are surely cispennine Confused

Do you think that walking is safe? I don't want to be surprised by where/when I end up each time I travel?

Rollingpinofdoom · 04/10/2026 00:12

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:26

Nope. You don’t understand the law.

There is no situation where a legitimate aim would be answered by a group based on ‘gender identity.’

You can have single sex provision or unisex provision. Those are the options.

Have we not just had this argument on another thread by one of the other GI posters. 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄 almost word for word….

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 00:11

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:53

In the Middle Ages, there was a social contagion where people believed that they were made of glass. Humans believe in all kinds of shit.

Biological sex, however, is demonstrably true and remains true whether it is believed in or not.

Like people who obsess all day about 0.5% of the population & their genitals?
yeah I hear you.

ErrolTheDragon · 04/10/2026 00:10

PachacutisBadAuntie · 03/10/2026 23:41

I'm taking a transatlantic flight soon, I hope the plane doesn't identify as a bicycle.

Some trains which identify as ‘transpennine’ are surely cispennine Confused

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
theilltemperedmonster · 04/10/2026 00:09

King retweeted one of Rowling's TERFy tweets, and she thanked him fulsomely. Then he backpedalled, so she unthanked him.

Seems like a pretty low stakes exchange, particularly as they still appear to be on perfectly cordial terms. Why is someone going on about it six years later?

CassOle · 04/10/2026 00:08

Travelling is pretty dicey these days...

PachacutisBadAuntie · 04/10/2026 00:05

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:55

Maybe take the Trans-Siberian Railway instead, you could end up somewhere warm?

If I get the Blue Train I might end up in a Golden Age detective novel which could be a fun fortnight 🤔

alcovecupboards · 04/10/2026 00:00

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:37

I really cannot imagine how it possible to be so worked up about someone deleting a tweet, but you do you.

I do enjoy your gaslighting ways. Ingrid Bergman would've had a cracking time.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:58

What are you talking about? Gender reassignment is a protected group from discrimination under the EA just like sex is.

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:55

PachacutisBadAuntie · 03/10/2026 23:51

Gosh I hadn't thought of that... I'll pack an extra jumper.

Maybe take the Trans-Siberian Railway instead, you could end up somewhere warm?

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 03/10/2026 23:54

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:49

Gender identification is primarily experienced as an internal psychological & personal sense of self but the conceptual models defining it & the counter arguments against them operate as philosophical and metaphysical positions.

That’s neither the PC of sex, nor of gender reassignment, so not relevant to what is protected in law.

Another fail in Grainger, too.

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:53

In the Middle Ages, there was a social contagion where people believed that they were made of glass. Humans believe in all kinds of shit.

Biological sex, however, is demonstrably true and remains true whether it is believed in or not.

PachacutisBadAuntie · 03/10/2026 23:51

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:42

Well, the transatlantic might actually be the Pacific... lord knows where you could end up!

Gosh I hadn't thought of that... I'll pack an extra jumper.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:49

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 03/10/2026 23:46

Show me where “gender” is a PC.

it isn’t.

Sex is, & is clearly & biologically accurately defined.

Something called “gender reassignment” is. The Act which introduced it into law is extremely contradictory in what it means.

But no gender.

And you were claiming just now that belief men are women if they say so is a belief. What’s that: religious? Philosophical?

Gender identification is primarily experienced as an internal psychological & personal sense of self but the conceptual models defining it & the counter arguments against them operate as philosophical and metaphysical positions.

TheKeatingFive · 03/10/2026 23:46

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:43

Compared to what? Understanding the difference between reproductive traits & sex traits that most of gender critical people who obsess over TP don't even understand? About 65% of the UK population understands what trans is according to surveys which is impressive since trans people aren't relevant to most peoples lives.

So 65% understand transwoman to mean pretend women.

Awesome progress

Humans still can’t change sex

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 03/10/2026 23:46

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:38

Grainger criteria applies exclusively to philosophical or religious beliefs. Under the UK EA gender/sex is already protected as its own standalone characteristic ("sex" or "gender reassignment") and does not need to satisfy these criteria.

Show me where “gender” is a PC.

it isn’t.

Sex is, & is clearly & biologically accurately defined.

Something called “gender reassignment” is. The Act which introduced it into law is extremely contradictory in what it means.

But no gender.

And you were claiming just now that belief men are women if they say so is a belief. What’s that: religious? Philosophical?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 03/10/2026 23:46

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:38

It's best understood as thinking of 'Trans' as a modifier that works the same way as 'Fake' or 'Pretend'.

Most people would interpret trans as a belief just like religion, politics or sex realism is a belief.