Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions

259 replies

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:33

Stephen King was asked a simple question - are trans women women? - and when he said yes, one of the most wealthy writers in the world turned on him.

J.K. Rowling had just publicly showered him with praise. Within hours of his answer, she deleted it and, in King's words, "sorta blocked" him.

King is one of the most famous novelists alive, and he didn't walk it back or cast himself as the victim. He said plainly that nobody had cancelled Rowling - he just thought she was wrong. He turns 79 today, still saying it.

He could have kept the friend and stayed quiet. He said yes instead.

Stephen King's response to Rowling on sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
EmmyFr · 04/10/2026 06:55

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

EmmyFr · 04/10/2026 06:53

@Daygloboo Since you ask what my post means... It means "you are a random human or possibly not asserting something negative which seems wildly at odds with both the accused and the Zeitgeist, do provide a source if you hope to be believed"

And with respect to Stephen Fry, it means SF publicly described her as a former friend who he found "radicalized " (By her sex realism), and she responded by clarifying they had never been more than acquaintances. It doesn't have the same meaning when a public criticism, especially one that you have changed beyond recognition, comes from a real friend or from someone who could not claim to know you deeply in the first place. OP mentioned a friendship between Rowling and King, so should source it as well.

JamesKirkupReviewWritersFund · 04/10/2026 06:49

Did I miss a Howse incarnation with a Gretel name? What a lucky gal I am. I have noticed though his arguments (such as they are) are increasingly dialled in, his heart’s not in it and it’s all a bit flaccid

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 04/10/2026 06:45

gamerchick · 03/10/2026 22:42

That's not what happened. Don't fucking rewrite history.
HE poked the hornets nest out of the blue supporting her and got his arse handed to him by the masses. She thought for a moment that he had her back until he was forced to say trans women are women and then she got a load of hate for it.

There was absolutely no need to stir up the hive like that for no reason. He's a fucking coward. I watched it in real time, it was ages go and no idea why it's being brought up now.

He's disgusting,

Thanks for posting the real details, in light of it I would say the OP has been busted for spreading dis-information, just regurgitating a warped version of old news in an attempted to prop up some warped point about JKR.

So nothing new then, same old, same old.

maxslice · 04/10/2026 06:36

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 04/10/2026 06:18

What do you not agree with?

I’m still wrangling with the whole thing. Being a woman, having a daughter and also a nephew who says (and the parents agree) is now my “niece”.

Igneococcus · 04/10/2026 06:18

MyAmpleSheep · 04/10/2026 02:14

When you started this thread, were you aware this happened more than six years ago?

And his birthday (according to Wiki, so might not be true) is the 21st September not today.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 04/10/2026 06:18

maxslice · 04/10/2026 03:52

Because they believe it IS their place. While a significant number of women disagree. But not all women. It’s a mess.

What do you not agree with?

Rollingpinofdoom · 04/10/2026 05:13

Tears0fTheMushroom · 04/10/2026 01:30

Don't take it personally. ChoppingNorthernIcelandicBaileyGoodnewsGretel is only here for the scolding.

I always skim past their coma inducing posts these days. Life's too short.

I thought I recognised the tone 😀

maxslice · 04/10/2026 03:52

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 00:59

Funny question to ask on a predominately GC forum. It's as though you don't want to know why or want to be told all the reasons why they shouldn't. Why not do the research yourself or just ask trans people?

Because they believe it IS their place. While a significant number of women disagree. But not all women. It’s a mess.

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 04/10/2026 03:31

Heres an MN thread from June 2020, not sure why OP is dragging all this up now.

The TL:DR of the thread

On June 28, 2020, J.K. Rowling tweeted a quote from Andrea Dworkin. Stephen King retweeted it without additional commentary. JK Rowling subsequently tweeted a public note of praise to King, thanking him for standing up for women's concerns.

Shortly after, someone on T asked S King to clarify his position on TW, and he replied "Yes. Trans women are women."
In response, JK Rowling unfollowed him, deleted her tweet of praise, and then I think blocked him.

King behaved like an arse hat.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3952448-Stephen-King-retweets-JKR?reply=97869042

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3952448-Stephen-King-retweets-JKR?reply=97866256&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share

Page 3 | Stephen King retweets JKR | Mumsnet

[grin] A Dworkin quote.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3952448-Stephen-King-retweets-JKR?reply=97866256

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 02:30

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 02:27

A ' bias source'. ?? What's that. Do you perhsps mean a ' biased source''. Mind you, it's a bit hard to see if you've used the right letters , isn't it, coz it's quite dark half a mile up your own arse.

For some one who protests "unpleasantness" you sure seem fine engaging in it.

Why won't you answer the question I wonder?

Doth protest too much…

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 02:27

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:37

Don't shoot the messenger. I'm simply querying why you would expect to to get an answer that accurately reflected the truth from a bias source. That you would consider such a neutral question offensive perhaps is more a reflection of your fragility than anything else.

Edited

A ' bias source'. ?? What's that. Do you perhsps mean a ' biased source''. Mind you, it's a bit hard to see if you've used the right letters , isn't it, coz it's quite dark half a mile up your own arse.

MyAmpleSheep · 04/10/2026 02:14

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:33

Stephen King was asked a simple question - are trans women women? - and when he said yes, one of the most wealthy writers in the world turned on him.

J.K. Rowling had just publicly showered him with praise. Within hours of his answer, she deleted it and, in King's words, "sorta blocked" him.

King is one of the most famous novelists alive, and he didn't walk it back or cast himself as the victim. He said plainly that nobody had cancelled Rowling - he just thought she was wrong. He turns 79 today, still saying it.

He could have kept the friend and stayed quiet. He said yes instead.

When you started this thread, were you aware this happened more than six years ago?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:37

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:31

So who died and made you the policeman of a thread . What an arrogant thing to say. I didnt ask you to jump on my question and answer it. If you've got nothing useful to say to me regarding what I wrote , then dont say anything. I think you are the sort of person who'd cause a row in an empty house, so I'll leave you to dit squatting inside your own unnecessarily created little drama. Gooodnight.

Don't shoot the messenger. I'm simply querying why you would expect to to get an answer that accurately reflected the truth from a bias source. That you would consider such a neutral question offensive perhaps is more a reflection of your fragility than anything else.

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:31

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:23

You don't understand that this is a predominantly GC forum? Seriously?

So who died and made you the policeman of a thread . What an arrogant thing to say. I didnt ask you to jump on my question and answer it. If you've got nothing useful to say to me regarding what I wrote , then dont say anything. I think you are the sort of person who'd cause a row in an empty house, so I'll leave you to dit squatting inside your own unnecessarily created little drama. Gooodnight.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 04/10/2026 01:30

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:09

Why do you have to be like that. It was a genuine qyestion. Why the need to be unpleasant.Yes, I can read up on it but I'm not sure of the answer and thought someone could tell me. .why are you suggesting I have motivations I dont have. Why dont you step back from yoursrlf for a moment and stop bring nasty and unhelpful..If you dont want to answer my question, just ignore it.

Don't take it personally. ChoppingNorthernIcelandicBaileyGoodnewsGretel is only here for the scolding.

I always skim past their coma inducing posts these days. Life's too short.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:23

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:22

No. I dont understand what you are saying. I think you are pretentious.

You don't understand that this is a predominantly GC forum? Seriously?

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:22

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:16

That you interpret logical conclusions as unpleasantness is on you. Its simply a 'strange' place as in irrevocably biased to ask what trans people think about an issue. Surely you understand this?

No. I dont understand what you are saying. I think you are pretentious.

NotBadConsidering · 04/10/2026 01:19

The absolute desperation of starting a thread about something that happened years ago just to have a pop at JKR 🤣🤣🤣

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:16

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:09

Why do you have to be like that. It was a genuine qyestion. Why the need to be unpleasant.Yes, I can read up on it but I'm not sure of the answer and thought someone could tell me. .why are you suggesting I have motivations I dont have. Why dont you step back from yoursrlf for a moment and stop bring nasty and unhelpful..If you dont want to answer my question, just ignore it.

That you interpret logical conclusions as unpleasantness is on you. Its simply a 'strange' place as in irrevocably biased to ask what trans people think about an issue. Surely you understand this?

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 01:09

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 00:59

Funny question to ask on a predominately GC forum. It's as though you don't want to know why or want to be told all the reasons why they shouldn't. Why not do the research yourself or just ask trans people?

Why do you have to be like that. It was a genuine qyestion. Why the need to be unpleasant.Yes, I can read up on it but I'm not sure of the answer and thought someone could tell me. .why are you suggesting I have motivations I dont have. Why dont you step back from yoursrlf for a moment and stop bring nasty and unhelpful..If you dont want to answer my question, just ignore it.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 01:04

maxslice · 04/10/2026 00:42

She has her opinion, he has his. Mature people are able to disagree and remain friends. Especially about issues that do not directly affect them. And people can also not give a toss about famous writers’ views on topics that have nothing to do with writing.

Remain civil? Sure. Friends? Depends what type of friend. An intimate friend? Depends on the disagreement if its just a trivial issue sure but whether human rights are optional or its ok to frame arguments in dehumanising & demonising language? No. How can someone truly be a friend if they are fundamentally incapable of understanding equality & empathy?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 04/10/2026 00:59

Daygloboo · 04/10/2026 00:38

I want to ask something. It's a genuine question. Why does a transgender woman want to claim female space. Some transgender eomen I presume have nice lives and and are living the life they want, so why is there the need to claim female space. I'm not being facetious. Why not have spaces for them.i cant see why there wouldnt be enough power in claiming a space for themselves. Why dont they want to be accepted as themselves and equal in their own space. Why isnt it enough to be who they actually are.

Funny question to ask on a predominately GC forum. It's as though you don't want to know why or want to be told all the reasons why they shouldn't. Why not do the research yourself or just ask trans people?

GrumpyPanda · 04/10/2026 00:58

CassOle · 03/10/2026 23:55

Maybe take the Trans-Siberian Railway instead, you could end up somewhere warm?

But with a gazillion mosquitoes, the Sibirian summer is infamous for them.

PachacutisBadAuntie · 04/10/2026 00:57

CassOle · 04/10/2026 00:51

Is a replacement bus service a trans-train or a cis-train, then?

I think that's actually a kind of fish with a big red nose and a hooter. But IANAbiologist so I could be wrong.