Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 12:20

It’s as silly as that idiot Labour MP’s black Labrador gaffe.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 12:19

Shrigley · 02/10/2026 12:14

I agree with @guinnessguzzler - the original article was interesting and didn't actually say that women with bare nails are white supremacists. It was more about how perceptions of particular trends relate to race and class.

Someone quoted used the term “white supremacist” to describe fingernail trends, which is very silly even if the article did make any good points.

onedayillmoveon · 02/10/2026 12:17

Nightmanagerfan · 02/10/2026 10:08

I read that article and found it so bizarre that I couldn’t even really process what it was trying to say. I am not surprised it got pulled

What kind of journalist is that woman? How does she even keep her job? Does she not have anything better to write about?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 12:17

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 02/10/2026 12:11

I do also think (and possibly it needs its own thread), but a lot of the fashion trends for young women leaning heavily into “natural” could be a quiet protest at the idea pushed by many trans rights activists that effectively “woman is a costume”. The way the trends are going, the “costume” is going to be bloody hard for anyone born male to achieve if they go widespread. (Won’t someone think of the poor men who want to quickly signify they are in girl mode! ) in that context, perhaps it’s not surprising the bbc are picking up on this trend as a problem .

That’s an interesting point. I remember the TRAs and their friends getting annoyed about a decade ago because Will Smith’s son chose to wear a skirt to an event and it was confusing. They very much framed it as he was being unhelpful to TIMs.

Shrigley · 02/10/2026 12:14

I agree with @guinnessguzzler - the original article was interesting and didn't actually say that women with bare nails are white supremacists. It was more about how perceptions of particular trends relate to race and class.

SeedsOfReason · 02/10/2026 12:12

I'm glad the BBC article was pulled.

I feel quite angry at the idea the default state for a woman's nails should be decorated, or else she's sending out some message.

I don't do anything with mine bar clipping them once a week - I hate my nails being messed about with.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 02/10/2026 12:11

I do also think (and possibly it needs its own thread), but a lot of the fashion trends for young women leaning heavily into “natural” could be a quiet protest at the idea pushed by many trans rights activists that effectively “woman is a costume”. The way the trends are going, the “costume” is going to be bloody hard for anyone born male to achieve if they go widespread. (Won’t someone think of the poor men who want to quickly signify they are in girl mode! ) in that context, perhaps it’s not surprising the bbc are picking up on this trend as a problem .

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 02/10/2026 12:09

Mapletree1985 · 02/10/2026 11:12

I have a strong negative visceral reaction to fake nails. Seeing people with those huge plastic nails glued to their hands give me the newbie-jeebies.I can't let myself be touched by anyone wearing fake nails.

I worked with a colleague (white, as it happens) who had long fake nails. Quite apart from the logistics of using a keyboard, I couldn't help wondering what lurked underneath.

thesealion · 02/10/2026 12:09

Echobelly · 02/10/2026 12:02

Seems a bit silly and rather an overreach to me but bear in mind this was just one person's view in a longer article - some places were touting it as BBC SAYS BARE NAILS ARE RACIST which it wasn't.

This. Is media literacy really this poor that people can’t distinguish a person being quoted in an article from an opinion piece or endorsement?

Beauty choices are contextual to class, race and cultural norms, and this was a piece about a current online trend that also looked at wider cultural nuances. Whether or not you think the opinion about white supremacy was silly, the fact that someone with this opinion was quoted in an article does not = endorsement of the opinion or “the BBC saying” it.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 02/10/2026 12:04

ApplebyArrows · 02/10/2026 10:28

For this type of person, it seems, copying black people is cultural appropriation, and not copying black people is white supremacy.

Correct. And white people can't win whatever they do. It's quite a neat setup.

Echobelly · 02/10/2026 12:02

Seems a bit silly and rather an overreach to me but bear in mind this was just one person's view in a longer article - some places were touting it as BBC SAYS BARE NAILS ARE RACIST which it wasn't.

ArabellaScott · 02/10/2026 12:00

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 02/10/2026 11:57

This is in the feminism section- are you all just pretending that women’s fashion and beauty trends are not often political?!

it was a badly written article (I did read it when they published it) but there is clearly a trend in fashion away from all black-coded fashion and beauty. It’s not wrong to suggest there might be a political aspect to this, although they did a bad job in that article.

the article wasn’t about the sort of women who have never painted their nails, it was about women who do go for manicures deciding the flashy nail art look is no longer fashionable or desirable. This is not about caring how your hands look, but caring greatly and deciding the nail art look is no longer something you want, and a bare nail look is something you’d spend money on.

Bare long nails are very hard to achieve, you can’t do a lot of housework, you can’t have a manual job. You need a good diet and good health.

Anyone with a spare £50 can go get gels put on, there are nail bars all over the UK, this is easy to achieve now. But bare, long, healthy nails are more exclusive. This is a class signifier.

I will freely admit that I could not give less of a fuck about nail polish or manicures. So yes, I am not the target demographic.

Thanks for extra context. All of this possibly bears discussion; the conflation with 'white supremacism' is the problem, imo.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 02/10/2026 11:58

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 11:02

Thats hilarious- surprised the Guardian isn’t defending it!

TBH that was partly what made me raise my eyebrow.

This is a relevant blog, from the woman quoted.

'I will not be falling for the bare nail propaganda. And, I think it’s harmful to conflate the naked nail look with better “taste” or “class,” or “understated elegance,” all of which are often just euphemisms for white supremacist beauty standards. '

https://archive.ph/wip/vAItp

Babe, your lack of intersectionality is showing 💅

Bare nail propaganda has got to stop!

https://kristinarodulfo.substack.com/p/bare-nails-trend

OP posts:
FancyBiscuitsLevel · 02/10/2026 11:57

This is in the feminism section- are you all just pretending that women’s fashion and beauty trends are not often political?!

it was a badly written article (I did read it when they published it) but there is clearly a trend in fashion away from all black-coded fashion and beauty. It’s not wrong to suggest there might be a political aspect to this, although they did a bad job in that article.

the article wasn’t about the sort of women who have never painted their nails, it was about women who do go for manicures deciding the flashy nail art look is no longer fashionable or desirable. This is not about caring how your hands look, but caring greatly and deciding the nail art look is no longer something you want, and a bare nail look is something you’d spend money on.

Bare long nails are very hard to achieve, you can’t do a lot of housework, you can’t have a manual job. You need a good diet and good health.

Anyone with a spare £50 can go get gels put on, there are nail bars all over the UK, this is easy to achieve now. But bare, long, healthy nails are more exclusive. This is a class signifier.

TorturedParentsDepartment · 02/10/2026 11:56

As an aside - my nail bar is owned and staffed completely by white British middle-aged women who I wouldn't fucking dare exploit cos they'd collectively deck anyone who gave them any shite. Costs me about £30 a month to get them done but without them I'd have bleeding shredded cuticles and nails chewed down to the bed within a week (I have no willpower to stop the damned habit).

UnaPersson · 02/10/2026 11:50

PlantainArama · 02/10/2026 11:29

How fucking dare they pick women's appearances apart like this.

Utterly misogynist

As if women don't have enough actual barriers to being allowed to exist with equity in this world, some twat creates some extra bullshit

Surprised the Guardian aren't in agreement, fairly sure they tried to tell my tits make me right wing a few months ago because Sidney Sweeney.

I kind of like Sydney Sweeney. She is having a high old time winding up the virtue signallers, whilst doubtless making lots of money in what's likely a short career.

As for the nails, I like short painted nails but can't be bothered to do something which is a faff and lasts 2 days max.

It's given us all a good laugh, this article. I hope the BBC doesn't go under as I'm really enjoying The Sky at Night at the moment.

guinnessguzzler · 02/10/2026 11:48

Tbf, as @EllieQ suggested, it didn't really cover class issues at all. It could have been much more interesting and relevant, especially given the clear people exploitation going on in nail bars up and down the country as others have pointed out.

MarieDeGournay · 02/10/2026 11:46

guinnessguzzler · 02/10/2026 11:41

I read this article when it came out and genuinely found it quite interesting. Beauty standards are very closely linked with class, place, ethnicity, and other such factors. The beauty industry relies on cultural norms and people wanting to conform to these. I wouldn't particularly argue with the below (although just saying white rather than white supremacist would have been fairer):

"They (blank nails) are often called elegant or tasteful and these (terms) are often usually euphemisms that perpetuate white supremacist standards of beauty.”

Although I would broaden the concept somewhat, beyond nails and to encompass class. Elegant, tasteful, classy, understated; these are often aspirations for the rich and powerful, who don't need or want to show off their wealth in such an obvious way. Adding in the various higher paid professions who won't have painted nails (mainly thinking of Drs but there will be others) and that's another factor. When I think about people I know, certainly it is women from more working class backgrounds, often, but not always, in lower paid jobs, who have bold nails, lip fillers, obviously dyed hair etc. I have always assumed a combination of feeling like you have something to prove and having limited control over other aspects of your life eg housing and so spending on what you can make a difference on have fed into and supported an overall culture leading to different priorities.

Sorry if this is clumsily worded and I know class can be a really contentious issue but I think it's hugely relevant when it comes to beauty standards and cultural norms.

Ultimately though, blank nails means not spending my hard earned cash on something I find entirely unnecessary so I'll continue putting my plain-nailed two fingers up to the capitalist patriarchy 🤣

That's very interesting, guinnessguzzler, I can relate it to interior design where 'minimalism' is only minimalism if you can actually afford a lot more 'stuff' than you chose to display, whereas the 'minimalism' of my childhood homes was because we didn't have 'stuff'Smile
edited for grammar

ArabellaScott · 02/10/2026 11:43

guinnessguzzler · 02/10/2026 11:41

I read this article when it came out and genuinely found it quite interesting. Beauty standards are very closely linked with class, place, ethnicity, and other such factors. The beauty industry relies on cultural norms and people wanting to conform to these. I wouldn't particularly argue with the below (although just saying white rather than white supremacist would have been fairer):

"They (blank nails) are often called elegant or tasteful and these (terms) are often usually euphemisms that perpetuate white supremacist standards of beauty.”

Although I would broaden the concept somewhat, beyond nails and to encompass class. Elegant, tasteful, classy, understated; these are often aspirations for the rich and powerful, who don't need or want to show off their wealth in such an obvious way. Adding in the various higher paid professions who won't have painted nails (mainly thinking of Drs but there will be others) and that's another factor. When I think about people I know, certainly it is women from more working class backgrounds, often, but not always, in lower paid jobs, who have bold nails, lip fillers, obviously dyed hair etc. I have always assumed a combination of feeling like you have something to prove and having limited control over other aspects of your life eg housing and so spending on what you can make a difference on have fed into and supported an overall culture leading to different priorities.

Sorry if this is clumsily worded and I know class can be a really contentious issue but I think it's hugely relevant when it comes to beauty standards and cultural norms.

Ultimately though, blank nails means not spending my hard earned cash on something I find entirely unnecessary so I'll continue putting my plain-nailed two fingers up to the capitalist patriarchy 🤣

It'd be good to see the original article to see if there's context missing.

The quotes in isolation read as absurd and extreme.

OP posts:
guinnessguzzler · 02/10/2026 11:41

I read this article when it came out and genuinely found it quite interesting. Beauty standards are very closely linked with class, place, ethnicity, and other such factors. The beauty industry relies on cultural norms and people wanting to conform to these. I wouldn't particularly argue with the below (although just saying white rather than white supremacist would have been fairer):

"They (blank nails) are often called elegant or tasteful and these (terms) are often usually euphemisms that perpetuate white supremacist standards of beauty.”

Although I would broaden the concept somewhat, beyond nails and to encompass class. Elegant, tasteful, classy, understated; these are often aspirations for the rich and powerful, who don't need or want to show off their wealth in such an obvious way. Adding in the various higher paid professions who won't have painted nails (mainly thinking of Drs but there will be others) and that's another factor. When I think about people I know, certainly it is women from more working class backgrounds, often, but not always, in lower paid jobs, who have bold nails, lip fillers, obviously dyed hair etc. I have always assumed a combination of feeling like you have something to prove and having limited control over other aspects of your life eg housing and so spending on what you can make a difference on have fed into and supported an overall culture leading to different priorities.

Sorry if this is clumsily worded and I know class can be a really contentious issue but I think it's hugely relevant when it comes to beauty standards and cultural norms.

Ultimately though, blank nails means not spending my hard earned cash on something I find entirely unnecessary so I'll continue putting my plain-nailed two fingers up to the capitalist patriarchy 🤣

MarieDeGournay · 02/10/2026 11:41

HorseandHeron · 02/10/2026 11:15

Thank you for bringing the phrase 'Foucault-addled grievance gerbils' into my life.

You are very welcome!
That's the origin of the gerbils who run the Bluestocking Women's Pub -
'Foucault-addled grievance gerbils' was used by somebody in the context of a PhD student from Aston Uni 'scraping' MN data to prove we are all transphobes or something.
The phrase appeared on t-shirts and mugs, and then obviously the gerbils got organised and decided to seize the means of production and set up factories to make the t-shirts themselves...
Then they went into catering, and won the catering contract for the Bluestocking, and because the gerbils are committed to inclusivity, the workforce grew to include wombats, capybaras, tree kangaroos and red pandas.

I'd hate anybody to think that the Bluestocking gerbils were just cute furry little faces, with strangely humanoid hands, and impeccable customer service.

Many books have been written about their proud entrepreneurial history, as you can see...

[recycled image from an old Bluestocking thread]

BBC removes article that says women who don't wear nail varnish might be white supremacists.
TheDogsMother · 02/10/2026 11:37

This is so fucking bonkers I can barely find the words. Men don’t get this shit do they.

ArcangelaTarabotti · 02/10/2026 11:33

Maybeitllneverhappen · 02/10/2026 11:20

I don't wear nail varnish because I don't have time and I'm hopeless at applying it. Surely I'm not the only one?? Sometimes the simplest explanation is the obvious one?

same!

ArcangelaTarabotti · 02/10/2026 11:32

Thebutterflyslovemybush · 02/10/2026 10:04

I mean there's reaching and then there's this. Utter madness

Howling with laughter at that article.

TheeNotoriousPIG · 02/10/2026 11:30

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 11:17

Do you have a black Labrador though.

No, but I do have a black and white Collie, and another tri-colour dog! They are much more practical for herding than a Lab (lovely though they are!).