Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women's Rights and Rejoining the EU

108 replies

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 01/10/2026 18:34

(I posted this earlier on my Burnham and women's rights thread, but I think it's going to get buried there, so started a new thread)

Following Andy Burnham's speech, someone started a thread about what the re-entry to the EU should be called:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/eu_referendum_2016_/5584173-what-shall-we-call-the-return

Let's not rehash the pros and cons of Brexit here (there are plenty of other threads for that). There might be some economic benefits to rejoining the EU, but if women's rights get lost in the shuffle (and you know they would!), I don't want any part of rejoining.

I think it's unlikely, but, in case it does happen...

What I'm wondering is what would be the ramifications for women's rights in Great Britain and NI if (and that's a very big if) we were to rejoin?

Would there be any? Could anybody with legal expertise enlighten us, please?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 02/10/2026 07:47

GrumpyPanda · 01/10/2026 23:48

It's a bit more complex. The new Self-ID law does indeed permit fines, but exclusively as an anti-doxxing provision. It's never been tested in practice and It's hard to see how it could even work for somebody who's not entirely stealth, perfectly passing and solely a private citizen rather than public figure.

There have been a couple of legal cases involving "misgendering". All of these were argued as perceived insults on the basis of libel law; none involved fines and i believe none of them got beyond the preliminary injunction level to full-blown court proceedings.

There have been court cases in France for similar. We had an appeal on the forum not long ago from a victim convicted felon for help publicising it.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 02/10/2026 06:31

I think every country that has Self ID also has a 'Conversion' therapy ban, the reason why the left in this country are pushing for one so hard is because everyone else has one, we want one too.
The EU is a sinking ship, by chance we left before it started to go under, only the Brits would be stupid enough to want to leap back on board, so we can sink to, everyone else is, us too, us too.
We'd have to take the Euro, we wouldn't get the rebate back, we'd have to take more immigrants, our economy is in dire straits but even we're doing better than France and Germany at the moment, all of the advantages we currently have over the Blob will go.
There is no benefit for women or children in rejoining the EU.

Hoardasurass · 02/10/2026 01:07

moto748e · 02/10/2026 00:14

This is a big topic, Like a lot of MN posters, I suspect, I wish we never left the EU, and would be interested in rejoining if feasible. BUT, there a big problems ahead. Would we be forced to take the euro? I don't have a strong view on that, but I suspect the British public would not be keen. You can't help thinking that Burnham is only considering economic benefits. And yes, the gender issue is massive, especially considering how things are in Germany, as PP have said. My best hope is that we hold off for a few years, until Terf Island has shown the Europeans the way!

Yes we would need the euro and we would no longer have our veto

alcovecupboards · 02/10/2026 00:49

Toffeefudgecaramel · 02/10/2026 00:32

I wonder how many crimes have been committed by transwomen, but reported as committed by women. When the news outlets routinely lie, we have no way of knowing what is actually happening.

Just ask anyone here. They can apparently tell at a hundred paces who's trans and who isn't. And given the singular obsession of many, you can bet whatever you've got that there would be multiple threads on each and every instance.

Toffeefudgecaramel · 02/10/2026 00:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I wonder how many crimes have been committed by transwomen, but reported as committed by women. When the news outlets routinely lie, we have no way of knowing what is actually happening.

moto748e · 02/10/2026 00:14

This is a big topic, Like a lot of MN posters, I suspect, I wish we never left the EU, and would be interested in rejoining if feasible. BUT, there a big problems ahead. Would we be forced to take the euro? I don't have a strong view on that, but I suspect the British public would not be keen. You can't help thinking that Burnham is only considering economic benefits. And yes, the gender issue is massive, especially considering how things are in Germany, as PP have said. My best hope is that we hold off for a few years, until Terf Island has shown the Europeans the way!

GrumpyPanda · 01/10/2026 23:48

Imdunfer · 01/10/2026 19:06

Germany fines women for referring to men as "he".

I want no part in a law making body where one of the strongest members does this.

It's a bit more complex. The new Self-ID law does indeed permit fines, but exclusively as an anti-doxxing provision. It's never been tested in practice and It's hard to see how it could even work for somebody who's not entirely stealth, perfectly passing and solely a private citizen rather than public figure.

There have been a couple of legal cases involving "misgendering". All of these were argued as perceived insults on the basis of libel law; none involved fines and i believe none of them got beyond the preliminary injunction level to full-blown court proceedings.

GrumpyPanda · 01/10/2026 23:32

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:08

Then so did men. Clearly you're talking nonsense.

Men aren't in need of targeted affirmative action to redress discrimination directed against them as a group. They're already the default in society; making them unrecognizable as a social category would simply perpetuate that status quo. Astonishing you as a self-proclsimed feminist can't recognize the difference.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 01/10/2026 23:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You keep putting transactivists' wild claims into women's mouths, and it just doesn't work.

It's transactivists who shriek that any disagreement is literally killing them and that feminists want to stop them existing. I've never heard any feminist make those claims, despite the plethora of death threats hurled at women by transactivists.
See https://terfisaslur.com for more transactivist images of violence against women than any sane person would believe.

Similarly, feminists do not claim that people are dying as a result of self-ID -- although trans-identifying men have killed quite a few people>
See https://transcrimeuk.com for court reports and convictions.

Also, self-ID gives any man the right to intrude in any women-only space, which obviously increases the opportunity to stalk and kill women who are trying to hide from them.

Trans Crime UK – Documenting crimes committed by transgender individuals in the UK

https://transcrimeuk.com

Cailleach1 · 01/10/2026 22:22

MarieDeGournay · 01/10/2026 20:27

Actually, 'women' as a recognised social group did cease to exist in Ireland, as equality legislation etc is based on 'gender' not sex, and sex is not a protected characteristic.
There was nowhere near enough 'scaremongering' before the GRA was passed in Ireland in 2015, it was waved through in the wake of the Marriage Equality referendum with inadequate scrutiny as if it was all part of the same process.
It pretty much boiled down to the trans lobby saying 'This is what must be done' and it was done. Not the legislature's finest hour.

I'm guessing that it's because of the very small numbers concerned that there haven't been issues - it is an interesting situation on the island of Ireland.

The sooner the GRA2015 is repealed, the better.

Absolutely agree with this. Any woman adversely affected is one too many. Paddy O’Gorman has been quite good on this. He did an podcast of interviews with women who are at sharp end, so to speak. Women who have been locked up in prison with these men. There are women who self exclude from women’s refuges too, because of violent men being allowed to use them. I suspect there may be quite a lot more going on but the MSM don’t, or won’t’ report on it.

The rate of incidents will trickle through eventually, and again even 1 woman or girl affected is one too many. Irrespective of how many girls and women suffer a detriment because of this legislation, others have absolutely no right to decide this is acceptable. Every single girl or woman who has been put in the position of being stressed, made vulnerable, abused, open to injury, or self-excluding from something has been made a victim because the state legislated for it to happen. Our TD’s voted for a new line of abuse against women and girls.

The Ladies Gaelic Football Association have a policy to allow males to play against girls, from 12-15 years old. That is crazy. Remember the under 15 boys teams who beat the National women’s soccer team in the US. For boys over 16 and men, there is some bs about the testosterone level and who have a ‘gender certificate’. A level of testosterone no woman would have (we know also that this system can be ‘played’ with as well), and it doesn’t alter their male bodies in any way.

I see there is a lot being spoken about ‘gender’ balance. There would be no way you could trust the figures of female representation as it could be a complete lie. If men say they are women and have their certificate, they could be counted as women, in place of women. You could have a 100% male representation on a board in Ireland (some men with their little certificates stating they are women), and they could call it ‘gender’ balanced. It is a level of gaslighting really.

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:08

MarieDeGournay · 01/10/2026 20:27

Actually, 'women' as a recognised social group did cease to exist in Ireland, as equality legislation etc is based on 'gender' not sex, and sex is not a protected characteristic.
There was nowhere near enough 'scaremongering' before the GRA was passed in Ireland in 2015, it was waved through in the wake of the Marriage Equality referendum with inadequate scrutiny as if it was all part of the same process.
It pretty much boiled down to the trans lobby saying 'This is what must be done' and it was done. Not the legislature's finest hour.

I'm guessing that it's because of the very small numbers concerned that there haven't been issues - it is an interesting situation on the island of Ireland.

The sooner the GRA2015 is repealed, the better.

Then so did men. Clearly you're talking nonsense.

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:06

ArabellaScott · 01/10/2026 20:13

The world did not implode.

Who died as a result of Self-ID in Ireland? There must be hundreds, surely?

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 01/10/2026 21:51

Thanks! lots of comments - I suppose self-ID is just the first and most obvious issue, because it affects "women" as a distinct class (as @MarieDeGournay has said) but I'm wondering if Burnham has even considered any of the legal ramifications of rejoining yet. Probably not.

Honestly, I doubt Labour will get that far, but I wonder how far they would get before anyone even considered the impact on women in GB and NI.

I am still hoping there might be a few international legal bods on here who might have some pointers?? Anything really worrying about a possible rejoining of the EU?

(I'll take a look at the CJEU ruling thanks @fanOfBen and bear in mind what @FrippEnos has posted)

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 01/10/2026 21:06

ArabellaScott · 01/10/2026 20:13

The world did not implode.

Spot on!

happydappy2 · 01/10/2026 20:29

unless the EU change their stance on self Id, it would be very detrimental to women if the UK re join. Our tiny island actually has shown some common sense in this area (thanks to the women bringing legal action)-we're not called terf island for nothing

MarieDeGournay · 01/10/2026 20:27

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

Actually, 'women' as a recognised social group did cease to exist in Ireland, as equality legislation etc is based on 'gender' not sex, and sex is not a protected characteristic.
There was nowhere near enough 'scaremongering' before the GRA was passed in Ireland in 2015, it was waved through in the wake of the Marriage Equality referendum with inadequate scrutiny as if it was all part of the same process.
It pretty much boiled down to the trans lobby saying 'This is what must be done' and it was done. Not the legislature's finest hour.

I'm guessing that it's because of the very small numbers concerned that there haven't been issues - it is an interesting situation on the island of Ireland.

The sooner the GRA2015 is repealed, the better.

ArabellaScott · 01/10/2026 20:13

The world did not implode.

Some Of You May Die Lord Farquaad GIF by slicedbread
Imdunfer · 01/10/2026 20:00

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

That's not true.

You just don't give a shit about any or the women for whom it didn't come to nought.

The Muslim and Jewish women denied access to women only swimming. The victims of sexual violence too scared to use mixed changing facilities. The women left off shortlists because a man got the place they would have got. The goal who don't get to go to Guide camp because their parents don't want them sharing sleeping spaces with a teenage boy. And the rest

LeftieRightsHoarder · 01/10/2026 19:59

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

What patronising nonsense. No one is saying the world would implode.
Single-sex spaces and facilities exist to allow women privacy and safety from exactly the sort of men who want to get into those spaces. Self-ID allows every man to use those spaces as he wishes. One of women's most basic human rights wiped out at a stroke.
And before any male supremacist supporter says they just want to urinate in peace (because they are frightened of the non-existent threat of violence by other men in the men's toilets) -- UK Ministry of Justice stats show that trans-identifying men commit sexual assaults more often than other men.
To get an idea how dangerous these men are, see the Transcrime site, which lists hundreds of convictions in UK courts.
https://transcrimeuk.com

Trans Crime UK – Documenting crimes committed by transgender individuals in the UK

https://transcrimeuk.com

Hoardasurass · 01/10/2026 19:48

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

Barbie Kardashian is a perfect example of how fucked up Ireland is with self-id

Shedmistress · 01/10/2026 19:47

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

From the country that brings the world 'Barbie Kardashian'. Sheesh.

Hoardasurass · 01/10/2026 19:46

Imdunfer · 01/10/2026 19:06

Germany fines women for referring to men as "he".

I want no part in a law making body where one of the strongest members does this.

And you can be fined for complaining about men in your changing facilities and refusing to change with them at work

Soundsok · 01/10/2026 19:44

Imdunfer · 01/10/2026 19:06

Germany fines women for referring to men as "he".

I want no part in a law making body where one of the strongest members does this.

I believe a woman in Spain has been imprisoned for similar.

EasternStandard · 01/10/2026 19:40

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 19:35

It's not an issue. Ireland has self-ID. And we have unrestricted access. The world did not implode. Women did not cease to exist. The scaremongering came to nought.

I’m glad we don’t have self ID.

Swipe left for the next trending thread