Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

This isn't working - Trans Identified Men in the workplace

62 replies

Niminy · 01/10/2026 09:49

Not sure if anyone else has flagged this, but the latest edition of This Isn't Working podcast has an absolutely brilliant interview with psychologist 'Dr P', which absolutely nails why cross-dressing men are so disturbed and disturbing. She goes right to the heart of the matter and is absolutely fearless in her (in my view totally convincing) analysis. Youtube linked but audio version also available on podcast platforms.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HermioneWeasley · 06/10/2026 07:41

I love how clear and unapologetic Prof P is.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 05/10/2026 09:36

UtopiaPlanitia · 02/10/2026 00:14

What I took from the interview was that she was against people in active psychosis (with the added complications involved from cross sex hormones interaction with the brain) in the workplace because they can be dangerous to themselves and others.

As for her comments about clothing: 5 years ago I was much more easy going about men in women's clothing but I've since learned an awful lot more about the motivations behind transvestism, and AGP, and now I don't trust men who cross dress not to be doing it as a boundary violation or being in the early 'frog boiling' stages of fetishism. Which is a pity because I've grew up during a time where men were gender non-conforming and it really worked - I loved the creative expression that Glam, New Romantics and Grunge allowed men.

I grew up during a time where men were gender non-conforming and it really worked - I loved the creative expression that Glam, New Romantics and Grunge allowed men.

Same here. I thought that was fun, and liberating for men in a harmless way. Totally different from the present situation.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 05/10/2026 09:24

Niminy · 01/10/2026 13:08

The bit where she talked about how having to deal with a TiM (and actually I think TiF as well) slows down your cognitive processing. That's so recognisable. It's a similar mental load to having to translate from another language you don't speak fluently. Also the insight that whatever concessions you make will never be enough; and that women's discomfort is a feature not a bug. Actually, all of it.

having to deal with a TiM (and actually I think TiF as well) slows down your cognitive processing. That's so recognisable. It's a similar mental load to having to translate from another language you don't speak fluently.

That’s a very interesting observation. It makes sense, I suppose, because your brain is having to deal with something it knows isn’t true. And our survival instinct makes us naturally wary of anything in disguise.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 04/10/2026 17:07

hastenotwaste · 02/10/2026 08:53

I think her point about pilots, air traffic controllers etc was very important and also worrying. We really don't know what mental effects taking these large doses of hormones have and, perhaps more importantly, research and enquiry is actively discouraged.

This is such an important point. We wouldn't allow people in these positions to stay employed if taking any other drug without appropriate medical evidence of need and that it doesn't make you unstable / unsuitable for the demands of the job.

I'd also add in doctors and other HCPs. I want my air traffic controller, pilots and HCPs to have some understanding of material reality, even if that material reality upsets them. I don't want them self identifying that the approach to land / surgical incision is low risk I want it to be low risk in material reality.

luy · 04/10/2026 10:48

Helen Joyce explains the influence parents have and the catastrophic outcome when parents ultimately become activists themselves and allow themselves to become entrenched in the misinformation online, eg the deliberate falsification of suicide statistics, leading to permission for their child to become a lifelong victim and medical patient.

EdithStourton · 03/10/2026 15:08

Thanks op - one to listen to.

heatdome · 03/10/2026 13:36

hastenotwaste · 02/10/2026 08:53

I think her point about pilots, air traffic controllers etc was very important and also worrying. We really don't know what mental effects taking these large doses of hormones have and, perhaps more importantly, research and enquiry is actively discouraged.

Yes I’d never thought about that.

illuminada · 03/10/2026 07:20

2021x · 02/10/2026 09:24

I agree.

I think, as a society, we have moved past the whole "gendered soul" and are reverting back to gender non conforming gay men and cross-dressing men as the two archetypes.

Stepping back, we are treating transwomen the way we have treated mentally unwell men. We try to be accepting, either through care or through fear, but as Dr P says, it's never enough.

Once they got the go-ahead to enter female spaces, that wasn't enough because the distress comes from inside. This change has now made it a lot easier for dominant perverts (Dr Beth Upton) to access women's spaces, knowing there is nothing that women can do about it in the moment.

It's the same with sexual assault: until a man tells them no, they just carry on- and I agree it's time for the men to start speaking up now.

This

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 17:54

TempestTost · 02/10/2026 02:18

I think the thing is, there are already lots of "dresses" for men.

There are kilts, sarongs, various kinds of robes and things. They might be less usual, but people can usually see these are men's clothing that men wear, made for men.

Men who wear dresses made for women are doing so because they are women's dresses. Even David Bowie or Kurt Cobain. It wasn't intended to make them men's clothes. It was intended to be a statement and noticeable and create a sexual frisson.

Thank you, you have explained what I think too.

UtopiaPlanitia · 02/10/2026 15:24

hastenotwaste · 02/10/2026 08:53

I think her point about pilots, air traffic controllers etc was very important and also worrying. We really don't know what mental effects taking these large doses of hormones have and, perhaps more importantly, research and enquiry is actively discouraged.

The original Dutch study (from which the protocol of giving PBs to teenagers arises) stated that it would perform brain scans/studies to check the effect of cross sex hormones on brain function/health. This was in the 90s and those scans were never performed. Dr P mentioned this in the interview as well.

From my reading on this subject, no medical scans are being performed to check the brain health and long-term brain function of people (of any age) taking cross-sex hormones. So, as you say, we have no proper studies into what these hormones are doing to people's cognitive function and mental health. So much of this area of medical treatment is based on anecdata and off-label prescribing.

This could well be a future time-bomb for the NHS as well as for society - lots of patients in decades to come suffering the ill effects of long-term cross sex hormone usage.

AudHvamm · 02/10/2026 14:52

MagpiePi · 02/10/2026 14:17

I bet no one would have said anything if you were wearing a skirt or dress of the same length.

Well quite! And yes you're right -two female colleagues wearing dress/skirt that were same length as my shorts and no, of course no one said anything!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 14:20

GreyskySexRealistsky · 02/10/2026 11:57

Did you actually watch/listen to the podcast @TransParentlyAnnoyed ? She explains her reasoning extensively there.

I think there might be some sort of spontaneous combustion event, probably better not to.

MagpiePi · 02/10/2026 14:17

AudHvamm · 02/10/2026 13:12

I really appreciate you pointing out that workplaces are not the setting for pushing boundaries around cultural norms. I'd been stuck on that element of what Dr P was saying as broadly agree with @Heggettypeg's perspective.

But yeah, of course workplaces are more conservative! Look at the attention Hillary Clinton's "pant suits" got only a decade ago!

I wore a pair of shorts into my very casual workplace on one of the very hot days in the summer (mostly because the 2 very hot weather work wear dresses I own were in the wash). They were a couple of inches above knee and not revealing, but people looked and commented and I was very aware that what I was wearing was not quite appropriate for the setting. Male colleagues were wearing shorts, this was not commented on because it is a norm in our sector.

I bet no one would have said anything if you were wearing a skirt or dress of the same length.

Notonmyland · 02/10/2026 13:13

Asymetry of risk. (Women know what men are, survival and reproduction)

The trans truth effect section is worth watching from 14mins in there abouts.

AudHvamm · 02/10/2026 13:12

Pingponghavoc · 02/10/2026 09:06

She's talking about the workplace.

If we want to remove the idea of separate men and womens clothes we have to change social norms and the workplace isnt where that happens. It took years of women wearing trousers in their private life before it became acceptable at work.

Also Derek from accounts wearing a short skirt and a padded bra isnt going to normalise men wearing dresses in society.

Women wearing trousers and flat shoes at work is motivated by practicality. Thats not 'Derek' motivation. He's wearing them because they are womens clothes and he wants everyone to see that. Its convenient to pretend thats not the case, or it might not be true, or another man may wear a hoodie from the womens section and we cant draw a line.

I really appreciate you pointing out that workplaces are not the setting for pushing boundaries around cultural norms. I'd been stuck on that element of what Dr P was saying as broadly agree with @Heggettypeg's perspective.

But yeah, of course workplaces are more conservative! Look at the attention Hillary Clinton's "pant suits" got only a decade ago!

I wore a pair of shorts into my very casual workplace on one of the very hot days in the summer (mostly because the 2 very hot weather work wear dresses I own were in the wash). They were a couple of inches above knee and not revealing, but people looked and commented and I was very aware that what I was wearing was not quite appropriate for the setting. Male colleagues were wearing shorts, this was not commented on because it is a norm in our sector.

Pingponghavoc · 02/10/2026 13:11

As a society, we accept, and probably wouldnt notice, men wearing basically unisex clothes from the womens department. But it isnt normal for men to wear low cut blouses. The workplace isnt where we push these boundaries. I think that's what she means by cultural norms.

luy · 02/10/2026 13:04

2021x · 02/10/2026 09:24

I agree.

I think, as a society, we have moved past the whole "gendered soul" and are reverting back to gender non conforming gay men and cross-dressing men as the two archetypes.

Stepping back, we are treating transwomen the way we have treated mentally unwell men. We try to be accepting, either through care or through fear, but as Dr P says, it's never enough.

Once they got the go-ahead to enter female spaces, that wasn't enough because the distress comes from inside. This change has now made it a lot easier for dominant perverts (Dr Beth Upton) to access women's spaces, knowing there is nothing that women can do about it in the moment.

It's the same with sexual assault: until a man tells them no, they just carry on- and I agree it's time for the men to start speaking up now.

oh gosh, I really hope so

luy · 02/10/2026 13:01

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 01/10/2026 16:09

Slur in title + podcast asks why anyone would hire someone with zero violent convictions = appearance-based bigotry. Nah cheers.

where’s the slur? And it’s not appearance based. It’s about working with someone who is mentally less
than well, ie want to remove healthy body parts and the impact that pretending your eyes can’t see what they can see, ie pretending that a man is a woman or that a woman is a man, when clearly they’re not.

Notonmyland · 02/10/2026 12:51

Someone's said it before.. 5 year olds often want to be mermaids. We don't surgically apply a tail to them.

It's excellent.
It needs sharing widely.

MoistVonL · 02/10/2026 12:47

Where I disagreed with her was in her rigidity about gendered clothing.

I think Harry Styles looks great in his gender fluid outfits, and I'm all for "total clothing rights" as Izzard used to say before he lost his marbles and decided he could be a lesbian.

My male hairdresser buys his jumpers from the women's section on M& S because they are better colours. I don't have a problem with a guy in a blouse. I don't think anyone should, as long as it's suitable clothing for the occasion (like DrP's beachwear being inappropriate for a wedding example)

I do have an enormous problem with a man cosplaying as his version of a woman, along blackface lines. And I have a problem with being coerced by my employer or society to pretend a bloke is a woman.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 02/10/2026 11:57

Did you actually watch/listen to the podcast @TransParentlyAnnoyed ? She explains her reasoning extensively there.

MoistVonL · 02/10/2026 11:56

Interesting to hear a professional psychologist make the Blackface comparison.

Soontobe60 · 02/10/2026 11:51

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 01/10/2026 16:09

Slur in title + podcast asks why anyone would hire someone with zero violent convictions = appearance-based bigotry. Nah cheers.

There are myriad reasons why someone may not be hired - zero violent convictions isn’t the only criteria for employment. I’d say the essential criteria should include honesty, truthfulness, the willingness to accept other people’s viewpoints that are legally considered WORIADS and an ability to live within the Law. Oh, and I’d also include the ability to keep any fetishes or paraphilia out of the workplace.

borntobequiet · 02/10/2026 11:30

borntobequiet · 02/10/2026 07:53

I found this refreshing because it aligns with the position I have arrived at over the last few years.

Quoting myself to add that I arrived at this position as a result of seeing the behaviour of so many trans identified people and their allies, and the resulting detriments to women and girls. Like many others, I decided to “educate myself”, and here I am.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 10:21

2021x · 02/10/2026 09:24

I agree.

I think, as a society, we have moved past the whole "gendered soul" and are reverting back to gender non conforming gay men and cross-dressing men as the two archetypes.

Stepping back, we are treating transwomen the way we have treated mentally unwell men. We try to be accepting, either through care or through fear, but as Dr P says, it's never enough.

Once they got the go-ahead to enter female spaces, that wasn't enough because the distress comes from inside. This change has now made it a lot easier for dominant perverts (Dr Beth Upton) to access women's spaces, knowing there is nothing that women can do about it in the moment.

It's the same with sexual assault: until a man tells them no, they just carry on- and I agree it's time for the men to start speaking up now.

💯

Swipe left for the next trending thread