Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gang rape at Cornell Uni + If car theft was treated like rape...

102 replies

Toffeefudgecaramel · 30/09/2026 22:57

In the US they have university police who investigate crimes. In the case of this gang rape in a fraternity house, very serious allegations were only investigated internally, and punishments handed down included "writing essays".
It seems that the actual police only became involved much later.
In the UK, universities are under pressure to deal with incidents of sexual assault "in-house", but arguably they should only be handled by experts within the criminal justice system.

Facebook

Details emerge in case of former Cornell student alleging gang rape by fraternity members - CBS News

2.8M views · 70K reactions | The Cornell situation has been sitting heavy with me. I’ll let my satire speak for itself. 👊🏼 #satire #cornell #fyppage #socialcommentary #victimblaming | Michael Pavano

The Cornell situation has been sitting heavy with me. I’ll let my satire speak for itself. 👊🏼 #satire #cornell #fyppage #socialcommentary #victimblaming

https://www.facebook.com/reel/1356725869604678

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Walkden · 03/10/2026 08:11

"The case reminds me of the Ched Evans case over a decade ago"

There does seem to be parallels. The girl and the men in question all drunk and on ketamin. Willing consent for the initial threesome then others joining in later. As a pp said By the New York state law consent high on drugs and alcohol is still consent but it's a deplorable behaviour conduct.

BettyFilous · 03/10/2026 16:09

Cherrycoko · 02/10/2026 09:43

I have an unrelated question, one which I haven't seen raised elsewhere. If Jane Doe is now 20, she must have been 18 when this happened. AFAIK there is no US State where drinking is legal before 21. I wonder if the University are liable for allowing underage drinking on their premises.

I was listening to a podcast earlier where this aspect was discussed. When the drinking age was raised from 18 to 21 it apparently drove the drinking culture on campuses out of bars, where there were witnesses and opportunities to intervene, into dorms and fraternity houses. They also mentioned the shift to co-ed dorms vs more strictly segregated student housing. Both have contributed to the issue by creating more opportunities for predators.

PinkishPanther · 03/10/2026 20:02

Very much worth listening to the BARpod episode on this (not paywalled). Seems that there are many versions of her story (including at least 3 from Jane Doe herself) and as PP said, her original police statement (one of the versions) does not indicate any laws were broken. Grim whichever way you look at it, but also complicated, and very sad.

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Not all men, but always a man

ThisWildDreamer · 03/10/2026 21:47

Well...

Gang rape at Cornell Uni + If car theft was treated like rape...
AlonsoMosley · 04/10/2026 05:00

2021x · 01/10/2026 00:29

I haven't seen anything other than widespread condemnation of how the men and the university handled the appauling assualt, especially with the evidence available.

I recently finished the book "Know My Name" by Chanel Miller, and I highly recommend it as compulsory reading for all young men going to college, especially in the US.

There is a very, very clear reason why the man who attacked Chanel did it, and we need to help young men feel comfortable pushing back on the harmful narratives they are provided as kids.

Edited

There is a very, very clear reason why the man who attacked Chanel did it, and we need to help young men feel comfortable pushing back on the harmful narratives they are provided as kids.

What is the very, very clear reason?

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 13:05

AudHvamm · 01/10/2026 06:52

US military also don't involve police in crimes of sexual violence https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/jun/26/male-jury-woman-strangled-by-us-pilot-britain-airbase-trial

The pattern is male-centred systems protecting each other and themselves.

Yes, I went to the Japanese Women Photographers exhibition in Soho this year and there was one lady, I'll check her name, who took photos of the Okinawa US military bases in the 50s and the issues they caused. Brothels were one- another was the assaults committeed by US soldiers on local women , partly why the bases are still controversial today.
The US military seems to not have improved re covering up attacks on civilian women, judging by what happened in the UK recently.

Re frat culture : legally most sororities don't allow drinking on campus. So if sororities want to have alcohol parties, they have to host them at frat houses, increasing vulnerability. The sorority law dates back to Victorian times, now it puts women in more danger not less.

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 13:08

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/10/2026 09:31

The case reminds me of the Ched Evans case over a decade ago. I thought this was a good piece from Meghan Murphy. She’s not saying this wasn’t criminal, she’s saying that there’s a problem with how people think about sex.

https://www.dailywire.com/news/the-question-nobody-wants-to-ask-about-the-cornell-seven

Thanks for this. I don't subscribe to the Daily Wire though- is there a way to bypass the pay wall?

U53rName · 04/10/2026 13:26

Sororities either have joint parities with fraternities at the fraternity’s house, or have their own parties at party venues that they rent out.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 16:37

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 13:08

Thanks for this. I don't subscribe to the Daily Wire though- is there a way to bypass the pay wall?

Nor do I, I didn’t have a paywall? I did read it linked on Facebook by Meghan herself though.

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 17:21

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/10/2026 16:37

Nor do I, I didn’t have a paywall? I did read it linked on Facebook by Meghan herself though.

Hmm...that's odd, it showed one for me- but it's ok, I read it via the Wayback Machine.

I don't agree with Murphy and I'm disappointed she made this argument. If I'm interpreting correctly, and if I'm not I am sorry, she seems to be saying that Jane Doe did consent but that she was badly mistreated, it just wasn't rape.

But she was not only heavily drunk, she was on ketamine. That negates her ability to consent imo.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/02/cornell-rape-assault-ketamine-laws

Cornell case raises questions about rise of ketamine in sexual assaults: ‘You might not realize you’re being touched’

After a Jane Doe claimed she was encouraged to take ketamine in an alleged gang rape, advocates are urging for tighter laws around the dissociative

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/02/cornell-rape-assault-ketamine-laws

viques · 04/10/2026 19:17

U53rName · 02/10/2026 10:33

To add further stickiness to this case is New York State law on consent. In New York, if you get drugged against your will, you cannot give legal consent. However, if you intoxicate yourself with alcohol or drugs, you CAN legally consent to sex (which is outdated by decades). So the fact that she got drunk by her own free will earlier in the evening will be doing some serious heavy lifting in this case, unfortunately.

By that reasoning if someone serves you alcoholic drinks telling you they are alcohol free and you then drive your car and kill someone , do you walk free from court?

U53rName · 04/10/2026 19:33

viques · 04/10/2026 19:17

By that reasoning if someone serves you alcoholic drinks telling you they are alcohol free and you then drive your car and kill someone , do you walk free from court?

I don’t know. We’ll see what happens. Considering she got herself drunk (she can consent to sex), then the men drugged her (she cannot consent to sex), I’m confused about where this fits in with NY state law.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/10/2026 19:47

LoftyCoralBird · 01/10/2026 03:06

Bloody outrageous! So basically rapists have free rein while at college with only minor sanctions, expulsion or suspension if anything. No criminal record, no prison time, no suspended sentence, no community pay back, no tagging/electronic monitoring.

And if they are really lucky they might end up on the Supreme Court of the US.

PinkishPanther · 04/10/2026 20:20

U53rName · 04/10/2026 19:33

I don’t know. We’ll see what happens. Considering she got herself drunk (she can consent to sex), then the men drugged her (she cannot consent to sex), I’m confused about where this fits in with NY state law.

The men did not drug her. She was drunk and had already done ketamine when she consented to a threesome, along with more ketamine. But it looks like those two then invited others, two of whom then had sex with her/raped her. She did not report immediately, but only after talking to friends (understandable) and after being refused an invitation to a Halloween party at the same frat house where the previous events took place (less understandable). It is all very murky and I don't envy any of the investigators trying to unpick it (although according to BARpod there is some concern with that process too).

Ugh. Just ugh. I have two DDs this age and just pray that they have the sense not to get themselves into such a grim situation where they are so vulnerable.

Ketamine is a completely horrible drug and causes hideous uropathy (particularly in women it seems) - have seen multiple young women with chronic pain, urological dysfunction and sometimes stomas as a result. I think my describing this may at least have put my DDs off this aspect!

PinkishPanther · 04/10/2026 20:25

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 17:21

Hmm...that's odd, it showed one for me- but it's ok, I read it via the Wayback Machine.

I don't agree with Murphy and I'm disappointed she made this argument. If I'm interpreting correctly, and if I'm not I am sorry, she seems to be saying that Jane Doe did consent but that she was badly mistreated, it just wasn't rape.

But she was not only heavily drunk, she was on ketamine. That negates her ability to consent imo.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/02/cornell-rape-assault-ketamine-laws

Edited

This article does not address that the issue that her police statement is different to both the police transcript from the time, and the civil lawsuit statement. The simplistic story about frat boys making a young woman drunk and drugged and then gang raping her does not seem to stand up scrutiny, and the guilt by social media should wait until they are actually found guilty.

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 23:58

PinkishPanther · 04/10/2026 20:20

The men did not drug her. She was drunk and had already done ketamine when she consented to a threesome, along with more ketamine. But it looks like those two then invited others, two of whom then had sex with her/raped her. She did not report immediately, but only after talking to friends (understandable) and after being refused an invitation to a Halloween party at the same frat house where the previous events took place (less understandable). It is all very murky and I don't envy any of the investigators trying to unpick it (although according to BARpod there is some concern with that process too).

Ugh. Just ugh. I have two DDs this age and just pray that they have the sense not to get themselves into such a grim situation where they are so vulnerable.

Ketamine is a completely horrible drug and causes hideous uropathy (particularly in women it seems) - have seen multiple young women with chronic pain, urological dysfunction and sometimes stomas as a result. I think my describing this may at least have put my DDs off this aspect!

'She was drunk and had already done ketamine when she consented to a threesome, along with more ketamine. But it looks like those two then invited others, two of whom then had sex with her/raped her'

  • surely in moral terms (setting aside for a moment that NY law has a loophole that our does not), it doesn't matter whether she was given the ketamine or chose to take it herself?

The question is what impact the ketamine had on her ability to consent.

My understanding is that someone in a K-hole experiences profound physical paralysis and severe cognitive detachment from reality.

That sounds like it would have a significant effect on their ability to give consent.

Jane3212 · 05/10/2026 00:02

PinkishPanther · 04/10/2026 20:25

This article does not address that the issue that her police statement is different to both the police transcript from the time, and the civil lawsuit statement. The simplistic story about frat boys making a young woman drunk and drugged and then gang raping her does not seem to stand up scrutiny, and the guilt by social media should wait until they are actually found guilty.

Surely, in moral terms, it doesn't matter whether they got her drunk/drugged or whether she got herself drunk/drugged.

What matters is whether being drunk and/or drugged affected her ability to consent.

Ketamine certainly sounds like it would, her alcohol consumption also sounds high.

No one can know for certain what happened.

But surely the main question we should be asking here is whether she was mentally capable of consenting after ingesting the drink & drugs. Not who was responsible for her being in that state, although that should also be asked.

Jane3212 · 05/10/2026 00:04

PinkishPanther · 04/10/2026 20:25

This article does not address that the issue that her police statement is different to both the police transcript from the time, and the civil lawsuit statement. The simplistic story about frat boys making a young woman drunk and drugged and then gang raping her does not seem to stand up scrutiny, and the guilt by social media should wait until they are actually found guilty.

'This article does not address that the issue that her police statement is different to both the police transcript from the time, and the civil lawsuit statement'

  • this is an important point, I agree
Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/10/2026 00:25

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 17:21

Hmm...that's odd, it showed one for me- but it's ok, I read it via the Wayback Machine.

I don't agree with Murphy and I'm disappointed she made this argument. If I'm interpreting correctly, and if I'm not I am sorry, she seems to be saying that Jane Doe did consent but that she was badly mistreated, it just wasn't rape.

But she was not only heavily drunk, she was on ketamine. That negates her ability to consent imo.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/02/cornell-rape-assault-ketamine-laws

Edited

I think she wasn’t actually expressing her opinion on that incident primarily, she was talking about all situations of this nature which were legally grey. She’s arguing that it’s not about some sex positive definition of “consent was obtained so any degree of depravity is ok”. I think it’s an interesting point. As I said I am reminded of the Ched Evans case, which was awful.

OtterlyAstounding · 05/10/2026 00:30

I haven't read in depth about this particular case (I haven't felt capable of reading the details, but I may have to, to be informed) but this discussion around ketamine and alcohol does make me wonder just how drunk and mentally affected the men involved were?

Were they, like in the Pelicot case, deliberately raping a woman incapable of consent while in full grasp of their sensibilities, or were they nearly as 'fucked up', so to speak? To be clear, that doesn't mean they shouldn't be considered morally or legally guilty, and punished to the full extent of the law – after all, being drunk doesn't excuse you if you commit a crime.

But it does really highlight the continuing issues around alcohol and mind altering drugs, and the way they both make women more vulnerable, and seem to exacerbate the worst of men's behaviour and potentially make them do things they wouldn't otherwise do if sober.

If I could go back in time, I know for sure that I wouldn't touch alcohol when young.

PutItInTheFridge · 05/10/2026 05:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PinkishPanther · 05/10/2026 08:40

Jane3212 · 04/10/2026 23:58

'She was drunk and had already done ketamine when she consented to a threesome, along with more ketamine. But it looks like those two then invited others, two of whom then had sex with her/raped her'

  • surely in moral terms (setting aside for a moment that NY law has a loophole that our does not), it doesn't matter whether she was given the ketamine or chose to take it herself?

The question is what impact the ketamine had on her ability to consent.

My understanding is that someone in a K-hole experiences profound physical paralysis and severe cognitive detachment from reality.

That sounds like it would have a significant effect on their ability to give consent.

I agree, she did not sound like she was in a position to consent (at least after agreeing to the original threesome - and she did apparently make her own way to the frat house seeking sex so presumably was capable of consent at that point). But the men involved don't sound like they were in a position to make sound moral judgements on that either - according to the BARpod reporting, they couldn't actually perform. So consent as a concept seems pretty slippery - she consented to something, at a point when she was able, with people who were as fed up as her, then perhaps was in a state where she could no longer consent, but was that clear to the other fed up parties? I don't know, and I think morally its a mess, with possibly different culpability amongst different parties. Inviting others to join the 'free pussy' strikes me as very wrong, and as one of the boys who turned up was sufficiently disgusted that he wanted to shut it down, it does suggest that (a) some of them with it enough to make sound judgements and (b) there was something very wrong happening. Suggestive enough that there was a mixture of some consent, and some not. Very difficult to investigate/judge!

It reminds me a bit of that Swingers podcast, where the lady involved agreed to a whole lot of activity (and initiated some) but later reported this as coercive control. I was left feeling very uncomfortable about the implication that she had absolutely no agency in the business. Whereas it felt to me that she had gotten involved (been encouraged/groomed, but not forced) in some extremely unpleasant sexual activity that she later regretted, and apportioned the blame to the man who encouraged it. Bad sex happens and it makes you feel grim. But it isn't always abuse. I am absolutely not saying there was no abuse here - who knows and it needs to see the light of day - but the girl had some agency in her initial choices at least, and maybe some of this was bad, regretted, unpleasant sex. Consent, not consent - combined with alcohol and mind-altering drugs - not simple.

PinkishPanther · 05/10/2026 08:41

Apologies - I used asterisks for fucked up and it has interpreted it as bold. You know what I mean!

PutItInTheFridge · 05/10/2026 08:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread