Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Constantrunner · 01/10/2026 07:32

fuschiaproudparrot · 30/09/2026 19:16

Have you seen a person with dementia living at home on their own ? Yes there are different types, stages. It may be ok initially but it doesn't last.

Edited

My father lived at home with dementia for a few years. His dementia was very slow progressing and he died before it advanced of something else. Outsiders would have no idea he had dementia.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 07:15

Fair point, but no one in any sort of reasoned argument would say that continence alone is reason to consider euthanasia or assisted suicide.

What you're talking about there is other peoples' perceptions of someone else's life (and consequent assumptions) and euthanasia/assisted suicide should depend on the individual's own stated wishes when competent, except in the terribly sad tiny minority of cases like this child's.

HomericEpithet · 01/10/2026 00:47

Yep. I am not a brain surgeon or neurologist, but it is my understanding that the bit(s) of the brain that controls the bladder and bowels and interprets signals of 'fullness' from either bladder/bowel is a different bit from the parts that mean you can, for example, enjoy doing puzzles/watching TV/singing along to the Rolling Stones.

It's simply not correct to assume that continence is the last thing to go.

Kirbert2 · 01/10/2026 00:25

HomericEpithet · 01/10/2026 00:22

I work in adult social care. In my opinion, people can enjoy a good quality of life even when doubly incontinent. I understand previous posters' concerns about the distress that dementia can cause, but I cannot agree that continence (or lack of it) can be used as a benchmark for quality of life, as I have seen people retain the capacity for joy for years after they became doubly incontinent.

Human aging doesn't run on a strict timetable, and the symptoms of these conditions don't necessarily follow a set order.

I agree.

My son is incontinent and it doesn't stop him from enjoying life.

HomericEpithet · 01/10/2026 00:22

I work in adult social care. In my opinion, people can enjoy a good quality of life even when doubly incontinent. I understand previous posters' concerns about the distress that dementia can cause, but I cannot agree that continence (or lack of it) can be used as a benchmark for quality of life, as I have seen people retain the capacity for joy for years after they became doubly incontinent.

Human aging doesn't run on a strict timetable, and the symptoms of these conditions don't necessarily follow a set order.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 22:18

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 21:31

Because of the long term affect this will have on how society values life.

Which will result in things like euthanasia being seem as a way to reduce costs.

That's not even a hypothetical.

There have been many societies which valued life less. We know what they look like.

There is also the point that by refusing to support a capable adult in their choice, the society is saying that's it's fine for people to live in agony far beyond their wished-for lifespan. Respect for life really should include respect for the quality of life.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 22:16

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 21:31

Because of the long term affect this will have on how society values life.

Which will result in things like euthanasia being seem as a way to reduce costs.

That's not even a hypothetical.

There have been many societies which valued life less. We know what they look like.

I realise you have reasoned arguments for your position, but it seems to me that the value of life has to be partially measured by the respect for individuals' choice.

In other cultures where euthanasia is treated with respect (not canada) then the value of life is not lessened.

It could be that that the parameters for euthanasia will widen in those cultures, but it seems likely that a final balance will be reached. It's not a question of either nothing, or everything; there is in those cultures balance, and the choice of euthanasia is a valid and respected choice seen as part of someone's life and death. A good death is part of the entire sum of someone's life.

Admittedly in the parlous state of the UK's welfare system, that might not always be the case and while on balance I still think it's better to treat people as adults capable of making their own decisions and to support them in that, the concerns you state are very valid.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 21:38

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 21:31

Because of the long term affect this will have on how society values life.

Which will result in things like euthanasia being seem as a way to reduce costs.

That's not even a hypothetical.

There have been many societies which valued life less. We know what they look like.

A society's true measure is not economic growth or power, but its capacity and choice to minimise avoidable human pain.

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 21:31

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 18:37

Turn this around @TempestTost

Why do you think it's alright that people are living in pain and not wanting to live, and we could help and don't?

Because of the long term affect this will have on how society values life.

Which will result in things like euthanasia being seem as a way to reduce costs.

That's not even a hypothetical.

There have been many societies which valued life less. We know what they look like.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 20:12

I believe that people who work with very advanced dementia sufferers say that most of them are not happy, at all. Apparently it's clear that there is considerable distress, often (according to the leader of an award winning advanced dementia acquaintance)

Which doesn't mean that in that case euthanasia is justified. It's justified when the individual requests it, being of clear mind.

abracadabra1980 · 30/09/2026 19:47

BirdLandedonmyHead · 28/09/2026 19:52

Just because we can prolong life, doesnt always mean we should.

Agree wholeheartedly.

nearlylovemyusername · 30/09/2026 19:42

XelaM · 30/09/2026 18:17

What quality of life does for example a double-incontinent dementia sufferer really have? Why would you want to continue living like that?

Edited

I assume double incontinent dementia sufferer you have in your mind doesn't have capacity to decide when they reach this stage. So without their direct request this would be considered murder.
Besides, you just don't know what's going on in their minds, they might be fine with their state, even though it seems vegetated life to the rest of the world.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 19:38

elgreco · 30/09/2026 19:29

So if the child is a girl, then along with the 2 young women and 1 elderly woman who have been controversialy euthanized, it would make all 4 of those controversially euthanized female.

More women than men choose assisted dying. Men are more likely to choose violent unassisted suicide.

fuschiaproudparrot · 30/09/2026 19:37

kxeil · 30/09/2026 19:20

We are in the minority here!

I understand it is a contentious issue. There are of course different issues here - a person being able to consent to this and the one in the OP which it is where a child . It is so individual and the people who have had disabled children are obviously outraged by this. This is the thing - each case IS individual and would not to be considered in that light ! By not having this as an option though people are being denied this self determination.

elgreco · 30/09/2026 19:29

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:46

Some controversial cases from the Netherlands

1. The 2016 Dementia / Sedated Patient Trial

  • The Case: A 74-year-old woman with severe Alzheimer’s disease had previously written an advance euthanasia directive (AED) stating she wanted to die "when I want to," but also wrote that she could not decide at that moment. When the doctor proceeded with euthanasia, he slipped a sedative into her coffee because she was agitated, and her family had to hold her down as she resisted the injection.
  • The Controversy: This marked the first time a criminal investigation was opened against a doctor under the 2002 law. In 2019, the court [The Hague] acquitted the doctor of all charges, ruling he acted lawfully and honored a valid prior written request, noting that severe dementia removes the capacity to re-verify consent. Critics, however, raised alarms about overriding active resistance from a dementia patient.

2. Psychiatric Suffering and Young Adults (Aurelia Brouwers and Zoraya ter Beek)

  • Aurelia Brouwers (2018): The 29-year-old died via doctor-administered lethal medication after a long history of severe depression, borderline personality disorder, and chronic suicidality, despite having no terminal physical illness.
  • Zoraya ter Beek (2024): The 29-year-old received approval for assisted dying after a multi-year evaluation process for chronic depression, autism, trauma, and anxiety.
  • The Controversy: These cases sparked fierce international debate over whether psychological suffering should qualify for euthanasia. Critics argue that severe mental distress can be treatable or improve over time, and that granting euthanasia risks normalizing or encouraging suicide for psychiatric patients. Proponents maintain that mental suffering can be just as hopeless and unbearable as physical disease, which the Dutch Supreme Court acknowledged in the landmark 1994 Chabot case

So if the child is a girl, then along with the 2 young women and 1 elderly woman who have been controversialy euthanized, it would make all 4 of those controversially euthanized female.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 19:20

fuschiaproudparrot · 30/09/2026 19:17

100%

We are in the minority here!

fuschiaproudparrot · 30/09/2026 19:17

kxeil · 30/09/2026 18:57

There is a vital need for assisted dying and euthanasia to end severe suffering,

People deserve bodily autonomy and the right to die on their own terms.

100%

fuschiaproudparrot · 30/09/2026 19:16

Constantrunner · 30/09/2026 18:20

Lots of disabled people are doubly incontinent. It doesn't make someone's life worthless.
Dementia varies. It can mean you can still live at home alone with someone helping with things like bills, right to needing 24 hour care.

Have you seen a person with dementia living at home on their own ? Yes there are different types, stages. It may be ok initially but it doesn't last.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 18:57

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 18:37

Turn this around @TempestTost

Why do you think it's alright that people are living in pain and not wanting to live, and we could help and don't?

There is a vital need for assisted dying and euthanasia to end severe suffering,

People deserve bodily autonomy and the right to die on their own terms.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 18:37

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 18:14

I wish I was shocked that you think this is an argument.

How about children that cost the education system too much money next?

Turn this around @TempestTost

Why do you think it's alright that people are living in pain and not wanting to live, and we could help and don't?

kxeil · 30/09/2026 18:24

TempestTost · 30/09/2026 18:14

I wish I was shocked that you think this is an argument.

How about children that cost the education system too much money next?

If there is no funding and not enough people willing to care for vulnerable people, what do you suggest?

It’s the government of the day that decides how the money is spent. Not enough people are paying taxes and Rachel Reeves damaged the job market.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 18:22

Constantrunner · 30/09/2026 18:20

Lots of disabled people are doubly incontinent. It doesn't make someone's life worthless.
Dementia varies. It can mean you can still live at home alone with someone helping with things like bills, right to needing 24 hour care.

That isn't the point.

The point is, what if the person themselves wants to die because they feel they don't want to live like that? Neither you nor I can speak for them.

XelaM · 30/09/2026 18:22

Constantrunner · 30/09/2026 18:20

Lots of disabled people are doubly incontinent. It doesn't make someone's life worthless.
Dementia varies. It can mean you can still live at home alone with someone helping with things like bills, right to needing 24 hour care.

Obviously I'm talking late stages of dementia when some people even forget how to eat. Why would anyone want to continue living having lost everything that made him a person and all dignity? What's the point?

Constantrunner · 30/09/2026 18:20

XelaM · 30/09/2026 18:17

What quality of life does for example a double-incontinent dementia sufferer really have? Why would you want to continue living like that?

Edited

Lots of disabled people are doubly incontinent. It doesn't make someone's life worthless.
Dementia varies. It can mean you can still live at home alone with someone helping with things like bills, right to needing 24 hour care.

XelaM · 30/09/2026 18:17

What quality of life does for example a double-incontinent dementia sufferer really have? Why would you want to continue living like that?