Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
PencilsInSpace · 01/10/2026 22:13

ScrollingLeaves · 30/09/2026 14:24

@fuschiaproudparrot is this called the Liverpool Pathway?

I feel muddled because when I have expressed my horror at people dying from dehydration, more medical people than I have said that if you give liquids that is horrific because they are not eliminated by the (dying) kidneys and so the lungs get full of water and it is like slow drowning. So I am confused about which of these horrors is worse.

This is discussed quite a bit in the Liverpool Care Pathway review

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/review-of-liverpool-care-pathway-for-dying-patients

Very often as someone approaches death the desire to eat and drink goes away. Giving liquid in this situation can lead to fluid on the lungs as their body can no longer process it. But sometimes people do want something to eat or drink and in those cases it should not be denied. The patient's comfort is paramount and thirst especially can be extremely distressing.

The LCP on paper recommended that staff do not continue to push food and drink when the patient does not want it and do not use assisted hydration if there is no benefit to the patient.

The LCP in practice, delivered by poorly trained, overworked and undersupported staff, became a tick box exercise and too many relatives were told 'Your Mum's on the LCP now so we've withdrawn food and drink.'

The whole report is worth reading as a cautionary tale - what was an attempt to deliver gold standard hospice-style palliative care in hospitals failed horribly for all the usual reasons - not enough staff, not enough money, not enough training, too much focus on the system (the 'pathway') instead of the patient.

If we legalised AS I see no reason why it wouldn't be at least as much of a shitshow as LCP.

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 21:16

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 18:02

You can’t change sex. HTH

Well doh I know that and said that . Read the thread. HTH

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 18:34

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 17:59

I am certain because the slippery slope exists. Every country that has legalised assisted dying has expanded it to include people who aren’t anywhere near dying or death. They have also documented abuses that would normally be considered murder or an execution.

I call these victims vulnerable because they usually are vulnerable in a clinical and social sense- disabled, poor, female are the key characteristics showing up in the studies. I call these victims innocent because the only other people killed in this fashion are convicted murderers on death row in countries like the US that still have the death penalty.

In my opinion it is as inhumane as execution. We can do better at helping suffering. If we funded care for conditions that cause chronic pain and palliative care like we fund cancer research, we would not have people so afraid of pain that they are willing to shorten their lives the same way a convict is executed.

I apologise for the emotive language, but we are all using it because death, suffering, pain, are all emotive subjects.

Edited

I think that you and I, however hard we tried unfortunately, would not be able to meet and agree on this subject and our fundamental approaches are so different that we can't 'find each other' as they say in Dutch.

Your approach gives me grave concerns, as no doubt mine does to you.

But I appreciate you answering this in good faith.

Shortshriftandlethal · 01/10/2026 18:19

Lexibletheflexible · 01/10/2026 16:43

"Since then it gained notoerity and started to be targeted by trans activists, 'allies' and disruptors - who sought to report posts and get women banned."

You mean members of the public joined the forum to also talk about S+G and those members may have had a range of views, some of which oppose GC views.

As people repeat many times, nobody can really get anyone banned. If you report a post and it is against the site's rules of conduct, then it will be deleted and you may have further reprimands.

"the moderation eased up"

Do you mean they changed guidelines so some things were now not against the rules and so fewer people who said those things were moderated?

"and now we have quite a few people, such as yourself, who come here to argue in favour of 'genderism'"

Or do you mean that some people have views that aren't at one end of the extreme or the other and you label all of those people as "genderists" or "TRAs"? Because I'm fairly sure I've made my views clear several times on where I stand on say whether TWAW and I didn't say they are.

Yet you still call me a genderist. So it seems like unless anyone nods emphatically at all your opinions, you assume they must be One Of Them and then you categorise them with these terms.

"People who don't want to have discussions about the negative impact of trans ideology tend not to post here;"

I think that is more about what happens when they do. I suspect things are changing though in the sense that moderators are starting to become aware of the tactics that create an echo chamber.

"and those that do know that and post anyway know they will be in a minority."

That can change any time. If an influx of "genderist" posters come in who respect site policy and overwhelm the GC posters in number, then they will be the majority.

This is what I mean about it not being any sort of protected space for GC people. If they are outnumbered and therefore have the minority opinion in these threads, then that will be fine with staff here. As long as you get to comment your thoughts. That's my impression of what they want to work towards if they aren't there already.

I think you are now looking for offence, so I'm not going to respond to you further on this topic. I've explained the history of this forum and how it has evolved.
I'm more interested in interesting and thoughtful posts than this type of to and fro.

kxeil · 01/10/2026 18:12

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 18:04

I see it as a moral failing of society to help mentally ill people before they are actively suicidal.

There is a chronic global shortage of trained mental health professionals, including psychiatrists, psychologists, and psychiatric nurses.

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 18:04

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:15

I do. Having been suicidal myself and attempted it, I still hold that opinion.

I see it as a moral failing of society to help mentally ill people before they are actively suicidal.

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 18:02

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 15:59

I don't know if this has been touched on but it seems to be ok for doctors to change the sex of a person based on that person's thoughts but it's not ok for a doctor to end someone's life based on that person's thoughts PLUS an identifiable disease. The latter has been described as not moral on here but what about the first ? No doubt I will be told I'm in the wrong pub but to me it's certainly relevant. I'm not looking to muddy the waters.

You can’t change sex. HTH

NullaEffugium · 01/10/2026 17:59

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 14:59

Goodness, how certain you are. Very sentimental language you're using there, 'innocent vulnerable'.

Do you usually disempower people who clearly state their own wishes like this?

Reminds me very much of the days when non-disabled people made decisions for disabled people "because the vulnerable can't be trusted to know their own minds".

I am certain because the slippery slope exists. Every country that has legalised assisted dying has expanded it to include people who aren’t anywhere near dying or death. They have also documented abuses that would normally be considered murder or an execution.

I call these victims vulnerable because they usually are vulnerable in a clinical and social sense- disabled, poor, female are the key characteristics showing up in the studies. I call these victims innocent because the only other people killed in this fashion are convicted murderers on death row in countries like the US that still have the death penalty.

In my opinion it is as inhumane as execution. We can do better at helping suffering. If we funded care for conditions that cause chronic pain and palliative care like we fund cancer research, we would not have people so afraid of pain that they are willing to shorten their lives the same way a convict is executed.

I apologise for the emotive language, but we are all using it because death, suffering, pain, are all emotive subjects.

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 17:59

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:38

I feel very strongly about euthanasia for many reasons, not least because I have been in a place where I didn't want to be alive anymore.

I know what it is like for pain to become so overwhelming that you cannot imagine feeling differently. At the time, it can feel as though nothing will ever change and that death is the only way for the suffering to end. But I also know something now that I couldn't see then: feelings can change. Circumstances can change. Pain can ease. Hope can return.

I am incredibly grateful that my darkest moments did not become an irreversible decision. If they had, I would never have experienced the life, relationships, love, and moments that came afterwards.
That is partly why I struggle with the idea of euthanasia. I understand that people facing terminal or unbearable illness can experience suffering that is very different from what I went through, and I don't judge anyone for the complexity of those circumstances. But my own experience makes me believe passionately that when someone is suffering and wants to die, we should do everything we can to understand their pain, surround them with compassion, and give them every possible opportunity for that pain to change. I am here today because my worst moment wasn't my last moment.

But you don't want to give them every chance for that pain to change...

kxeil · 01/10/2026 16:58

@NotrialNodeal Thank you for sharing that. I’m glad you had the love and support to get better.

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:58

Thanks. I appreciate your post 🫂 @ReleaseTheDucksOfWar

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 16:50

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:38

I feel very strongly about euthanasia for many reasons, not least because I have been in a place where I didn't want to be alive anymore.

I know what it is like for pain to become so overwhelming that you cannot imagine feeling differently. At the time, it can feel as though nothing will ever change and that death is the only way for the suffering to end. But I also know something now that I couldn't see then: feelings can change. Circumstances can change. Pain can ease. Hope can return.

I am incredibly grateful that my darkest moments did not become an irreversible decision. If they had, I would never have experienced the life, relationships, love, and moments that came afterwards.
That is partly why I struggle with the idea of euthanasia. I understand that people facing terminal or unbearable illness can experience suffering that is very different from what I went through, and I don't judge anyone for the complexity of those circumstances. But my own experience makes me believe passionately that when someone is suffering and wants to die, we should do everything we can to understand their pain, surround them with compassion, and give them every possible opportunity for that pain to change. I am here today because my worst moment wasn't my last moment.

@NotrialNodeal The circumstances or events that led you to that darkest of places must have been severe, and clearly they went on for some time. I'm glad that you received the support, and the love of people around you, that kept you going long enough for the darkness to fade and for your life to become worthwhile for yourself again.

It can't have been easy to write that or post it.

Lexibletheflexible · 01/10/2026 16:48

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 16:38

One of the most difficult things about this debate is that some people, and sometimes the ones who shout loudest, will cherrypick the facts or downright lie.

On the BBC some years ago in a debate on this the anti-assisted dying side fielded a man who claimed that the Dutch sent vans round estates advertising for assisted-death business. This was just an outright lie.

Equally it's false to claim that no one would ever be pressured, ever, into taking that step, or that there is no danger of creep.

But very few of the anti-euthanasia movement will honestly acknowledge the suffering that their stance allows to go on.

I think other religions and cultures are better at doing that acknowledgement. Buddhists for example.

I think in this part of the world, people can be loathe to admit or simply ignorant of how much the Abrahamaic religions influence their values and beliefs. The idea that handling our suffering down here with grace somehow makes us more righteous through either hard work or paying back for sins or whatever. There is a mix of that kind of thought in the major 3.

Lexibletheflexible · 01/10/2026 16:43

Shortshriftandlethal · 01/10/2026 13:46

How long have you been viewing and/or posting here?

It started out as a meeting place for women who were not allowed to freely discuss the issue in any other forum; and when questions were still not permitted even in parliament. The Labour party was still chanting 'No Debate' and there was no coverage in mainstream media. It acted as a lifeline in those times. That is the origin story.

Since then it gained notoerity and started to be targeted by trans activists, 'allies' and disruptors - who sought to report posts and get women banned. Many women were banned even from here. Over the years as the issue started to gain more traction with the public, the moderation eased up - and now we have quite a few people, such as yourself, who come here to argue in favour of 'genderism', or others simply to troll.

Edited

"Since then it gained notoerity and started to be targeted by trans activists, 'allies' and disruptors - who sought to report posts and get women banned."

You mean members of the public joined the forum to also talk about S+G and those members may have had a range of views, some of which oppose GC views.

As people repeat many times, nobody can really get anyone banned. If you report a post and it is against the site's rules of conduct, then it will be deleted and you may have further reprimands.

"the moderation eased up"

Do you mean they changed guidelines so some things were now not against the rules and so fewer people who said those things were moderated?

"and now we have quite a few people, such as yourself, who come here to argue in favour of 'genderism'"

Or do you mean that some people have views that aren't at one end of the extreme or the other and you label all of those people as "genderists" or "TRAs"? Because I'm fairly sure I've made my views clear several times on where I stand on say whether TWAW and I didn't say they are.

Yet you still call me a genderist. So it seems like unless anyone nods emphatically at all your opinions, you assume they must be One Of Them and then you categorise them with these terms.

"People who don't want to have discussions about the negative impact of trans ideology tend not to post here;"

I think that is more about what happens when they do. I suspect things are changing though in the sense that moderators are starting to become aware of the tactics that create an echo chamber.

"and those that do know that and post anyway know they will be in a minority."

That can change any time. If an influx of "genderist" posters come in who respect site policy and overwhelm the GC posters in number, then they will be the majority.

This is what I mean about it not being any sort of protected space for GC people. If they are outnumbered and therefore have the minority opinion in these threads, then that will be fine with staff here. As long as you get to comment your thoughts. That's my impression of what they want to work towards if they aren't there already.

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:38

I feel very strongly about euthanasia for many reasons, not least because I have been in a place where I didn't want to be alive anymore.

I know what it is like for pain to become so overwhelming that you cannot imagine feeling differently. At the time, it can feel as though nothing will ever change and that death is the only way for the suffering to end. But I also know something now that I couldn't see then: feelings can change. Circumstances can change. Pain can ease. Hope can return.

I am incredibly grateful that my darkest moments did not become an irreversible decision. If they had, I would never have experienced the life, relationships, love, and moments that came afterwards.
That is partly why I struggle with the idea of euthanasia. I understand that people facing terminal or unbearable illness can experience suffering that is very different from what I went through, and I don't judge anyone for the complexity of those circumstances. But my own experience makes me believe passionately that when someone is suffering and wants to die, we should do everything we can to understand their pain, surround them with compassion, and give them every possible opportunity for that pain to change. I am here today because my worst moment wasn't my last moment.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 16:38

One of the most difficult things about this debate is that some people, and sometimes the ones who shout loudest, will cherrypick the facts or downright lie.

On the BBC some years ago in a debate on this the anti-assisted dying side fielded a man who claimed that the Dutch sent vans round estates advertising for assisted-death business. This was just an outright lie.

Equally it's false to claim that no one would ever be pressured, ever, into taking that step, or that there is no danger of creep.

But very few of the anti-euthanasia movement will honestly acknowledge the suffering that their stance allows to go on.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 16:29

ScrollingLeaves · 01/10/2026 15:17

I have heard that some ill people in certain countries have been told that their health insurance will not cover X treatment but it will cover assisted dying.

I would say such people are vulnerable; and though the offered path is not directly murder, it does not seem to leave much choice for life.

edited for typo

Edited

I think this needs looking into further. It could be as it seems on the surface. It could also be that the treatments are cutting edge, high risk with low success rate and therefore not generally covered.

In this case, surely it's not a case of 'we won't fund this but we'll fund your assisted dying instead' but 'we won't fund this but will fund palliative care until you die'. (If it is the former, it'd be absolutely appalling but surely that would have hit the news - no health company would get away with not funding palliative treatment?)

In the situation where absolute miracles can be achieved, sometimes, but at a gigantic cost, not all treatments are affordable without making everyone's premiums unaffordable.

Would you happen to know any more?

kxeil · 01/10/2026 16:25

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:15

I do. Having been suicidal myself and attempted it, I still hold that opinion.

Thank you for your honesty.

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:15

kxeil · 01/10/2026 16:13

Out of curiosity, do you think unassisted suicide is morally unacceptable?

I do. Having been suicidal myself and attempted it, I still hold that opinion.

kxeil · 01/10/2026 16:13

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:01

I think they are both morally unacceptable.

Out of curiosity, do you think unassisted suicide is morally unacceptable?

Shortshriftandlethal · 01/10/2026 16:12

Lexibletheflexible · 01/10/2026 14:34

I think you're mistaking "you can argue your point here" or "you can wear any shirt here" with "this view is the default" or "this pub is for Spurs fans".

I agree many places wouldn't even let you argue your GC points. This place does allow you to argue your GC points. It doesn't mean the sex and gender board is GC. It isnt anything. It is for people to debate and discuss their views on S+G. That's if I understand the staff correctly.

So again, i think youve mistaken "share your opinions" with "this is your safe space where everyone who isnt intruding will agree".

How long is it you've been viewing and posting here?

I've explained the origins and the history of this forum. Though it is, of course, an open forum and anyone can contribute or post providing they respect the posting rules.

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 16:10

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:02

Also no matter how hard a doctor tries, they cannot change a person's sex.

Agree

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:06

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 16:05

That is your opinion which you are entitled to but opinions are like a holes. We all have them hence why these things are so difficult.

Agree.

fuschiaproudparrot · 01/10/2026 16:05

NotrialNodeal · 01/10/2026 16:01

I think they are both morally unacceptable.

That is your opinion which you are entitled to but opinions are like a holes. We all have them hence why these things are so difficult.

Shortshriftandlethal · 01/10/2026 16:04

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 01/10/2026 14:51

@Shortshriftandlethal Thank you. Some articles that look to be analytical there that Ill follow up, though Julie Bindel's article is highly slanted in a way.

Interesting:

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/lalnDoC0xTI

Swipe left for the next trending thread