Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:35

The EU companies do not want to supply to the US because they know this particular drug is used in executions.

The US manufacturers are reluctant to supply for executions too. It's a known problem.

How drugs are administered also makes a difference. In voluntary end of life situations in some countries if the self-adminstration fails (and it does, sometimes) then the physical steps in to administer the lethal dose. How Dignitas handle it I'm not sure (although I'm a member, and if I choose to go there then I'll be sure to ask that question since the medical personnel are not allowed to actual administer the drugs themselves, unlike in the NL).

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:32

The execution drugs are also not administered by trained medical staff who know what they are doing, they are administered by untrained prison staff on the whole.

In the US, execution by lethal injection are administered by nurses under the supervision of a doctor, not by prison staff. The catheter is placed by a phlebotomist nurse. The issues they have had is in finding suitable veins.

As for pre-existing conditions, you’re right, but the protocol for assisted dying also doesn’t take that into account. For one prisoner, the lethal injection failed because of his advanced cancer and he underwent immense physical pain abs psychological torture before they called off the execution and a few years later, he died of the cancer. That is relevant to assisted dying is it not?

Do you know that the UK assisted dying bill doesn’t require any health care qualification at all administer the drugs?

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:27

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:21

Actually yes it does help that you acknowledge them because many, many people don't. If someone knows the absolute reality of forcing someone else to continuing living against their deepest will, and still holds to that, it at least has some integrity. I think there are other words than can be used to describe it as well, but there -is- some integrity there.

The drugs used for executions are not, on the ground and in the syringe, the same ones used in assisted dying. The name is the same but ... well, here goes

The pharma companies will not allow their products to be used to kill unwilling people, so they refuse to supply the States. The states that have execution by lethal injection therefore get the pentobarbitol from underground sources or from specialist pharmacies that will mix drugs to order, but have no quality control. Therefore the drugs are very often not what they claim to be or old, and the potency is poor (would you want your medications from these companies?)

The execution drugs are also not administered by trained medical staff who know what they are doing, they are administered by untrained prison staff on the whole. Nor are known individual illnesses taken into account (as in the recent appalling case).

So as so often, while anti-euthansia campaigners will say it's the same drugs and procedures - it's not.

The scientific paper says differently, may be have a read of it?

Yes while EU and UK pharmaceutical companies are banned from selling these drugs to the US, you are incorrect to claim US pharmaceutical companies that produce and sell the same drugs in the US are somehow doing it underground with no quality control.

EU and UK law doesn’t apply to the US. The US pharmaceutical industry is just as good as the EU and UK’s. So is the Chinese pharmaceutical industry dare I say.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:24

The issue of good drug quality is one that goes much beyond this particular topic actually. Aurobindo is one major drug manufacturer that has huge problems in this area, and it's actually regulated. The independent pharmacies that produce the execution drugs aren't.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:21

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:10

Ok, I acknowledge them. That help?

I was answering Scrolling Leaves question regarding the drugs used for lethal injection executions versus assisted dying drugs quoting a paper that had two illustrative examples to demonstrate a larger issue with the drugs available for both that is more common than most people think.

I didn’t think I needed to make a series of long posts even longer by pulling in all forms of death, dying, and suffering without assisted dying as well when the question was about whether or not convicts being executed would have a more humane death if assisted dying drugs were used.

The answer is no, because they already use the same drug families on both, sometimes the exact same drugs and the problems of them failing or causing a death with suffering and pain still exist at fairly high rates for both executions and assisted suicides or euthanasias.

The most important thing to realise is that the Hollywood death marketed by assisted dying proponents is not even not guaranteed, but many clinicians are in doubt that even a majority are dying with no pain or suffering.

Actually yes it does help that you acknowledge them because many, many people don't. If someone knows the absolute reality of forcing someone else to continuing living against their deepest will, and still holds to that, it at least has some integrity. I think there are other words than can be used to describe it as well, but there -is- some integrity there.

The drugs used for executions are not, on the ground and in the syringe, the same ones used in assisted dying. The name is the same but ... well, here goes

The pharma companies will not allow their products to be used to kill unwilling people, so they refuse to supply the States. The states that have execution by lethal injection therefore get the pentobarbitol from underground sources or from specialist pharmacies that will mix drugs to order, but have no quality control. Therefore the drugs are very often not what they claim to be or old, and the potency is poor (would you want your medications from these companies?)

The execution drugs are also not administered by trained medical staff who know what they are doing, they are administered by untrained prison staff on the whole. Nor are known individual illnesses taken into account (as in the recent appalling case).

So as so often, while anti-euthansia campaigners will say it's the same drugs and procedures - it's not.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:10

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:11

@NullaEffugium · Today 10:53

I have to say that the problem with posting the disasters of euthanasia - and there are a few - is that you are not acknowledging the disasters of not allowing assisted suicide / euthanasia. Of which there are, unfortunately, many. Where people have died, or lived and carried on living, in extreme distress.

There is, frankly, a great deal more dignity in the excerpt you posted than in the unscreaming agony that some people have to endure for far longer than half an hour or even four hours.

Very easy research allows some heartrending stories of people who have been desperate to die and not given the support.

One of the men I knew who went for assisted suicide was in the end stages of leukemia, was a dignified, fiercely intelligent man who had given a great deal to society and enjoyed his life. His wife told me of his last days and I don't want to write them down because he was a friend. But euthanasia gave him the means to step out of life without a terribly distressing (for him, as well as his family) last passage of time.

Ok, I acknowledge them. That help?

I was answering Scrolling Leaves question regarding the drugs used for lethal injection executions versus assisted dying drugs quoting a paper that had two illustrative examples to demonstrate a larger issue with the drugs available for both that is more common than most people think.

I didn’t think I needed to make a series of long posts even longer by pulling in all forms of death, dying, and suffering without assisted dying as well when the question was about whether or not convicts being executed would have a more humane death if assisted dying drugs were used.

The answer is no, because they already use the same drug families on both, sometimes the exact same drugs and the problems of them failing or causing a death with suffering and pain still exist at fairly high rates for both executions and assisted suicides or euthanasias.

The most important thing to realise is that the Hollywood death marketed by assisted dying proponents is not even not guaranteed, but many clinicians are in doubt that even a majority are dying with no pain or suffering.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 12:08

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:57

@PencilsInSpace The problem is that while services ought to be well funded and good levels of care ought to be available for everyone, they aren't. And they aren't, realistically, going to be.

@kxeil 's position is a step too far for me, but they are at least being practical. Nice ethical considerations tend to fade into unimportance when you're cold, hungry and in pain with no realistic chance of improvement.

It's easy to say that we shouldn't allow people in that position the option to die easily, but we are not in that position ourself and we are, by our inaction, allowing this suffering to go on from our position of privilige.

I think it is a valid pov to say that we are arrogantly refusing people in that situation the way to die when they don't want to go on, while we are content enough with our own lives to want to live. We are taking a great deal on ourselves to remove that possibility from others, when it exists.

(again, I personally cannot go as far as @kxeil here too).

“I think it is a valid pov to say that we are arrogantly refusing people in that situation the way to die when they don't want to go on, while we are content enough with our own lives to want to live. We are taking a great deal on ourselves to remove that possibility from others, when it exists.”

I agree. Just because some people want to
live other people don’t. Our endurance for life differs.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 11:43

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar “The problem is that while services ought to be well funded and good levels of care ought to be available for everyone, they aren't. And they aren't, realistically, going to be”

Thank you! People don’t want to face reality. It’s all well and good saying we need to tax people more to pay for adult social care, but this isn’t happening, it would take years to improve and there are no guarantees it will get better in our lifetime.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 11:16

@PencilsInSpace

There is no universal moral rule stating that a person has an obligation to stay alive regardless of their level of distress. This is why people want assisted dying and euthanasia. It would give people bodily autonomy. It lets them decide when they want to die.

LadIsInPain · 02/10/2026 11:08

Care homes are full of old women with dementia, with only a smattering of men. This is a heart rending case which could be used to justify a slippery slope I do not want the UK to go down.

I want to be euthanized when/if I have severe dementia. I'm amazed there are people who would wish to be kept going.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 11:01

@PencilsInSpace I’m arguing for assisted dying and euthanasia for any option. If someone is competent, but are physically or mentally suffering, and no longer want to live it would be good to have it as a CHOICE.

Just because you don’t agree with it doesn’t mean there isn’t a need for it.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:57

PencilsInSpace · 02/10/2026 10:45

You have repeatedly argued for AS for people who can't afford care. That's what we were discussing.

@PencilsInSpace The problem is that while services ought to be well funded and good levels of care ought to be available for everyone, they aren't. And they aren't, realistically, going to be.

@kxeil 's position is a step too far for me, but they are at least being practical. Nice ethical considerations tend to fade into unimportance when you're cold, hungry and in pain with no realistic chance of improvement.

It's easy to say that we shouldn't allow people in that position the option to die easily, but we are not in that position ourself and we are, by our inaction, allowing this suffering to go on from our position of privilige.

I think it is a valid pov to say that we are arrogantly refusing people in that situation the way to die when they don't want to go on, while we are content enough with our own lives to want to live. We are taking a great deal on ourselves to remove that possibility from others, when it exists.

(again, I personally cannot go as far as @kxeil here too).

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:56

PencilsInSpace · 02/10/2026 10:45

You have repeatedly argued for AS for people who can't afford care. That's what we were discussing.

No I haven’t! I do want it as an option if I’m suffering and I’m unable to kill myself. I also want it as an option if there’s no care available if I end up needing it.

If I became a quadriplegic (with no use of hands and arms) and there was no care available I would want it as an option.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:50

@PencilsInSpace “to live out your natural lifespan”

Modern medicine often prolongs life way past ‘your natural lifespan’.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:50

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:41

@PencilsInSpace “Nobody goes to Switzerland because they can't afford care.”

I never said they do. I said there was a need for assisted dying and euthanasia, which is why people go to countries where it’s legal.

as a note, you have to be a resident of the NL and have a dutch healthcare insurance before you can use the 'endoflifeclinic' services here, although you don't have to be Dutch. It's not like Dignitas where if you can pay and travel to Switzerland and self-administer the drugs, anyone can go.

PencilsInSpace · 02/10/2026 10:45

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:41

@PencilsInSpace “Nobody goes to Switzerland because they can't afford care.”

I never said they do. I said there was a need for assisted dying and euthanasia, which is why people go to countries where it’s legal.

You have repeatedly argued for AS for people who can't afford care. That's what we were discussing.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:43

@PencilsInSpace” If there is no money and no care available then how is such an offer a 'choice' exactly?”

It would be a choice of dying naturally (which could involve immense suffering) with no care, or having the option to end your life by assisted dying or euthanasia.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 10:41

@PencilsInSpace “Nobody goes to Switzerland because they can't afford care.”

I never said they do. I said there was a need for assisted dying and euthanasia, which is why people go to countries where it’s legal.

PencilsInSpace · 02/10/2026 10:40

@kxeil you didn't answer my questions -

If there is no money and no care available then how is such an offer a 'choice' exactly?

If you got your way, how long before not taking up an offer of AS, preferring to live out your natural lifespan with all its attendant costs, came to be seen as a selfish thing to do?

How long before the state stopped funding care altogether so a natural lifespan became a luxury only the wealthy could afford?

PencilsInSpace · 02/10/2026 10:37

kxeil · 02/10/2026 07:21

@PencilsInSpace “I can envision a not-ideal world where we pay more tax and have reasonable quality social care and nobody feels they ought to die because they don't have the money to pay for it.”

There is a limit to taxing others.
The idea that the UK can endlessly fund public services by simply taxing "other people" (like high earners or corporations) faces a shrinking pool of untapped wealth.

Higher rate taxpayers are now normal workers, meaning taxes affect ordinary household budgets directly. People are already struggling with the cost of living.

Just to be clear, I’m not advocating for people to be ‘killed off’. I’m saying there is a need for assisted dying and euthanasia. That’s why people choose to go to countries like Switzerland where it’s legal

“I agree that adult social care is in a terrible state. The thing to do is to fix it”

And if it can’t be fixed (or takes decades) and keeps getting worse, what then? What happens if not enough people want to work as carers, nurses, social workers etc? We have a massive shortage already because they are very demanding jobs. It’s not just about low wages. Look at teaching.

Society often undervalues the work in caring professionals.

Another chilling post.

Nobody goes to Switzerland because they can't afford care.

Do you think we should just give up on all public services then?

What about prisons? Nobody likes their taxes being spent on criminals. Do you think people should be offered AS instead of a prison sentence?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:37

Apparently he was so good at pleading his cause and so good a communicator that he became rather celebrated and people didn't want to lose him.

Bit rich to be fighting for the right to die for roughly thirty years only for people to say 'you're so good at this we don't want to lose you'.

TheFlyingPenguin · 02/10/2026 10:30

There is a Spanish film, 'The Sea Inside', which is based on the real life story of a man who chose to end his life after being a quadriplegic for 25 years. It gives a whole new perspective on the matter, he fought for the right to die for many years.

Just because we can extend life through advanced medical techniques does not mean we should.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 10:11

@NullaEffugium · Today 10:53

I have to say that the problem with posting the disasters of euthanasia - and there are a few - is that you are not acknowledging the disasters of not allowing assisted suicide / euthanasia. Of which there are, unfortunately, many. Where people have died, or lived and carried on living, in extreme distress.

There is, frankly, a great deal more dignity in the excerpt you posted than in the unscreaming agony that some people have to endure for far longer than half an hour or even four hours.

Very easy research allows some heartrending stories of people who have been desperate to die and not given the support.

One of the men I knew who went for assisted suicide was in the end stages of leukemia, was a dignified, fiercely intelligent man who had given a great deal to society and enjoyed his life. His wife told me of his last days and I don't want to write them down because he was a friend. But euthanasia gave him the means to step out of life without a terribly distressing (for him, as well as his family) last passage of time.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 10:09

ScrollingLeaves · 01/10/2026 23:14

What do people think about the monster State killing attempt in Tennessee?

This has made me curious about what the difference is between that killing method and the assisted dying one? I suppose the assisted one is in the form of a drink. I wonder why those sentenced to death are not given the option of the same? It must surely be more humane.

This bit directly compares lethal injection in some US states to the euthanasia injection used in the Netherlands, what this 2 yr old child would have experienced.

However, euthanasia seems to confront a different kind of challenge, as some clinicians question whether death by lethal injection is as peaceful and painless as it may seem. In 2019, a group of clinicians reviewed methods commonly used for euthanasia and contrasted these with an analysis of capital punishment in the USA. Although some of the specific dugs, doses and monitoring techniques employed vary, they found that methods of US capital punishment closely resemble the Dutch injection technique. Their concern lies in the challenge posed by achieving and ensuring unconsciousness during euthanasia, as evidenced from studies of penal death as well as the medical phenomena known as ‘accidental awareness during general anesthesia’.26
While caution is needed in extrapolating findings from a generally physically healthy population to those with pathology, based on toxicology reports, up to 88% of executed prisoners studied had postmortem blood concentrations of anesthetic in the blood lower than that required for surgery and 43% had concentrations consistent with awareness.27 This means that some prisoners who are subjected to lethal injection do not received a sufficient amount of anesthetic to be fully unaware of the dying process. However, because neuromuscular blocking agents are administered, these prisoners cannot move any muscle even if they remain cognizant and therefore appear to be unconscious.
Sinmyee et al.26 express concern that monitoring consciousness in patients who are undergoing euthanasia and have received paralytic agents is difficult and, unless properly monitored, ‘there is a risk that vulnerable citizens may be killed by suboptimal, or even cruel, means’. This is of particular concern as opponents of lethal injection argue that a majority of executed prisoners show postmortem signs of flash pulmonary oedema, i.e. their lungs are filled with fluid and weigh several times the weight of normal lungs.28 This may be due to toxic drug effects on alveolar basement membrane, allowing rapid fluid ingress. If the person were aware, it has been suggested that the experience of death by lethal injection could be akin to suffocation or drowning.

Efficacy and safety of drugs used for ‘assisted dying’ - PMC

‘Assisted dying’ is practiced in some European countries and US states. Legislation suggests that there exists an easily prescribed drug which consistently brings about death quickly and painlessly. Evidence from jurisdictions where ‘assisted dying’ .....

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9270985/#ref26

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 10:04

The Leadbetter UK Assisted Dying bill as written excludes physician assisted euthanasia as it only allows self administered oral ingestion, but it is a sure thing that it will need to be added after the first dozen or so people die horribly without it. A suggested amendment from the HoL to add it was rejected by her committee as well.