Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
BirdLandedonmyHead · 28/09/2026 20:54

Womens medical issues are also moore likely to be dismissed by medical professionals. So it could well be they are more likely to be suffering.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:50

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 28/09/2026 20:49

It concerns me that more women die as a result of euthanasia- either formal or informal- and more men ‘assist’.
It concerns me that every country that has legitimised euthanasia, has gradually widened the acceptable boundaries.

It is a feminist issue for many reasons.

Canada is a particular problem with this I think.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:49

NullaEffugium · 28/09/2026 20:47

That’s impossible to do because quality of life is a subjective assessment that is entirely dependent on the emotions and biases of the observer.

Exactly and even in this case it seems the doctors didnt necessarily agree.

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 28/09/2026 20:49

It concerns me that more women die as a result of euthanasia- either formal or informal- and more men ‘assist’.
It concerns me that every country that has legitimised euthanasia, has gradually widened the acceptable boundaries.

It is a feminist issue for many reasons.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:47

Ive read the article now

I dont know why this is termed assisted dying, its not assisted dying.

It sounds heartbreaking. I cant quite make out if the child was actually euthanised or whether treatment was withdrawn? Is that the same thing?

NullaEffugium · 28/09/2026 20:47

D0gMum26 · 28/09/2026 20:44

This ^^ all too often sadly people want intervention at all costs and to save lives. Understandable when that’s your baby or indeed your elderly mum getting cancer treatment at 85 years old.
But Drs should be making clinically sound decisions based on quality of life and facts. Not emotions.

That’s impossible to do because quality of life is a subjective assessment that is entirely dependent on the emotions and biases of the observer.

D0gMum26 · 28/09/2026 20:44

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 19:56

If the doctors left the baby without intervention when he/she was born at 26 weeks they wouldn't be dealing with euthanasia now.

This ^^ all too often sadly people want intervention at all costs and to save lives. Understandable when that’s your baby or indeed your elderly mum getting cancer treatment at 85 years old.
But Drs should be making clinically sound decisions based on quality of life and facts. Not emotions.

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 20:41

C152 · 28/09/2026 20:10

@bababamama On the face of it, I don't disagree with the parents and Dr's decision. It's much more humane to end someone's suffering immediately than starve them to death (which is what 'withdrawal of support' means). It's not a quick or easy death, even for a sickly premature newborn.

'Withdrawal of support' does not always mean starving to death.

This child had breathing difficulties and frequent seizures. It's unlikely they would have survived long enough to starve if treatment was withdrawn.

NullaEffugium · 28/09/2026 20:40

Lexibletheflexible · 28/09/2026 20:18

I have reported it. Let's see what happens.

What have you reported? There is nothing wrong with an OP starting a thread to do a feminist analysis of one of the most important ethical questions of today without presenting a fait accompli of her own. Forums are for discussion, they aren’t just for defence of a thesis.

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:40

Justbrieme · 28/09/2026 20:35

All of this. There is a sense in modern medicine that preserving life no matter the quality of life in extremely medically invasive ways is the ethical thing to do. I don’t see how we arrived at this place.

Edited

It is cruel. Preserving life at all costs can prolong severe suffering.

Somethinggg · 28/09/2026 20:39

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 20:22

There is, although this particular case does not directly raise feminist issues.

In a new review of more than 100 UK cases, we find that despite claims: ‘mercy killings’ are not the wanted, ‘hastened’ deaths that need assisted dying. They are overwhelmingly violent domestic homicides of women, by men: and show that our society is still poor at detecting and responding to domestic abuse. How will these men who kill behave when the state offers lawful death ?

https://theotherhalf.uk/safeguarding-women-in-assisted-dying

I don't think it's right to call it 'assisted dying' for such a young child, or for anyone without capacity to consent. This was not a child who wanted to die but needed assistance. This was a child who was euthanised because the parents and doctors considered their suffering to be unbearable with no hope of improvement. The child was PTS.

It's easy to make a case that for this child it was the right thing to do, although according to the article, the second opinion doctor said palliative care would be effective.

Stepping back from the facts of this particular case, this does indirectly relate to feminist concerns around assisted dying because it's killing a person who cannot consent. Care homes are full of old women with dementia, with only a smattering of men. This is a heart rending case which could be used to justify a slippery slope I do not want the UK to go down.

I don't think you can say this particular case doesn't raise feminist issues when it relates to a child who needed such substantial care. Without more specific information on the family, at minimum we can say that the caring expectations on a societal level are different for mothers than fathers, and the Netherlands isn't immune to that by any means.

Which doesn't mean the points about euthanasia and women as lower value than men are wrong either. I think it's quite possible that whatever policy options we pursue, they're all worse for women than they are for men, but in different ways.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:36

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:07

Modern medicine has gone too far in some cases. Pushing the boundaries of viability can sometimes result in prolonged suffering or severe complications. Extremely premature babies must undergo highly invasive procedures which cause pain and suffering.

Absolutely, can you imagine the work and resources, blood sweat and tears that went into sustaining the childs life, ensuring that they lived and now the agony of mkaing a decision to take the life away.

No one wants to hear this though, that sometimes nature should take its course.

Justbrieme · 28/09/2026 20:35

runnerducky · 28/09/2026 19:47

Sounds like a very difficult situation. I think we will increasingly see these situations because in years gone by, children with this level of needs would just have died in infancy as the medical care wasn’t there to prolong life. Now we have the knowledge and skills to keep children like this alive, but there’s the ethical issue of whether just because we can, we necessarily should. We do have to be realistic about the quality of life some children with very severe disabilities have - just because they are living doesn’t mean they have a life.

I don’t understand what it is to do with feminism either though but look forward to the discussion.

Edited

All of this. There is a sense in modern medicine that preserving life no matter the quality of life in extremely medically invasive ways is the ethical thing to do. I don’t see how we arrived at this place.

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:35

thisismeithinkorisit · 28/09/2026 20:28

if the doctors left my baby without intervention when he was born he wouldn't be here now either, they didn't know the outcome with him until they did intervene, same for this baby. thankfully DS is now well. you can't let every poorly baby die because some won't recover.

The cut off for treating very premature babies has dropped significantly over recent decades. Perhaps this wasn’t a good idea?

spannasaurus · 28/09/2026 20:34

BerryTwister · 28/09/2026 20:23

What is FWR?

Feminism and womens rights. Its the old name for this board

LumpkinPumpkin · 28/09/2026 20:34

Somuchgoo · 28/09/2026 20:03

We had a sudden very serious diagnosis for our then toddler. It was 50-50 whether she'd have a variant that was effectively terminal on diagnosis, or one where she'd be very likely ok (which is thankfully the one she had).

She had emergency surgery and I prayed that if it was the nasty one, that she'd die in surgery, rather than recover, have months of treatment and then inevitably die a distressing death.

This was me praying that the daughter I loved with all my heart would for in surgery if terminal. She's lying beside me in bed now, and for that I'm so grateful.

I know of others with the nasty variant and how futile treatment is for it, and the horror of the end. I am not horrified by the idea of tightly controlled toddler euthanasia where the alternative is intolerable suffering with an inevitable death. It's what I would have wanted for my child and would have been a mercy.

God, I’m sorry you had to go through that. Even the thought is heart wrenching. I have a friend with a young child with a seriously life limiting condition. He’s presently got, what seems to be, a very good quality of life. But at some point in the next decade of so he will deteriorate significantly, and this will inevitably lead to a painful and undignified death. I know of my friend had the choice to make this quick and comfortable, she would do it in a heartbeat.

Heggettypeg · 28/09/2026 20:33

Assisted dying has the potential to become an equality issue for several protected characteristics, especially if legislation is poorly drafted. Sex, race, disability, age... Anything where there are people with the view that some members of society are of higher value than others or that some people are a useless burden.

It's not only a matter of legal loopholes that allow outside coercion: people can internalise views like that and hold them about themselves.

And with regard to this particular case: whether or not you feel that ending the life of a hopelessly impaired infant is justified in itself, it needs to be recognised as a significant breach in the principle that an assisted death should be voluntary only.

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 20:33

thisismeithinkorisit · 28/09/2026 20:28

if the doctors left my baby without intervention when he was born he wouldn't be here now either, they didn't know the outcome with him until they did intervene, same for this baby. thankfully DS is now well. you can't let every poorly baby die because some won't recover.

Truly happy to learn that your baby is alive and well. But respectfully you have no idea about the particular circumstances around this childs birth/life.

Morecoffeeneedef · 28/09/2026 20:32

Summerhillsquare · 28/09/2026 19:57

Of course.

When there is competition for resources women and children lose out, and are seen as less valuable than men. There will be more pressure on women to agree, as they are already seen as less deserving than men.

But this poor child was not losing out, she was being spared a terrible life with no hope of improvement.

Weirdpig · 28/09/2026 20:30

I think this case absolutely raises feminist issues - both around the medical care provided for extremely premature babies and euthanasia of young children with a very poor prognosis.

The time that worried me most in my pregnancies was after 23 weeks, gradually easing off as the prognosis for a premature baby improves. I know there are many other ways that people end up with severely disabled children and not everyone feels the same about the possibility of a severely disabled child. For me, it was horrible to know that I would probably not have any say in whether medical treatment was offered and the outcome could completely change the course of my life. As unfair as it is, it would almost certainly have been my career that ended to become a carer, because I am a woman. I'd have been on mat leave and it quickly becomes the default to be the carer.

holkhamhighkicks · 28/09/2026 20:29

The thread is really interesting but the arguing is tiresome! Move on if you don’t want to discuss it.

Lomonald · 28/09/2026 20:29

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 20:04

I dont have any answer. The whole point of a forum is to be able to discuss issues, news or whatever with a group of people, in this instance GC feminists.

I have already informed you that because there were a number of threads about euthanasia on FWR with many commenting from the perspective of women, feminism, I thought there would be the same interest in this case.

If you dont believe that, or share that point of view I cant make you.

More importantly why would you take the time to try and stop a discussion because you dont agree with it being discussed.

I don't think I will interact with you any more discussing things is great if you give clarity in what you mean. I asked you a direct question that you refused to answer and was dismissive I was interested in being part of your thread, to.read your Pov which you haven't given. And I don't think i disagreed with anything.

thisismeithinkorisit · 28/09/2026 20:28

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 19:56

If the doctors left the baby without intervention when he/she was born at 26 weeks they wouldn't be dealing with euthanasia now.

if the doctors left my baby without intervention when he was born he wouldn't be here now either, they didn't know the outcome with him until they did intervene, same for this baby. thankfully DS is now well. you can't let every poorly baby die because some won't recover.

BerryTwister · 28/09/2026 20:23

What is FWR?

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 20:22

BobbleBear · 28/09/2026 19:52

Is there a feminist perspective on assisted dying?

There is, although this particular case does not directly raise feminist issues.

In a new review of more than 100 UK cases, we find that despite claims: ‘mercy killings’ are not the wanted, ‘hastened’ deaths that need assisted dying. They are overwhelmingly violent domestic homicides of women, by men: and show that our society is still poor at detecting and responding to domestic abuse. How will these men who kill behave when the state offers lawful death ?

https://theotherhalf.uk/safeguarding-women-in-assisted-dying

I don't think it's right to call it 'assisted dying' for such a young child, or for anyone without capacity to consent. This was not a child who wanted to die but needed assistance. This was a child who was euthanised because the parents and doctors considered their suffering to be unbearable with no hope of improvement. The child was PTS.

It's easy to make a case that for this child it was the right thing to do, although according to the article, the second opinion doctor said palliative care would be effective.

Stepping back from the facts of this particular case, this does indirectly relate to feminist concerns around assisted dying because it's killing a person who cannot consent. Care homes are full of old women with dementia, with only a smattering of men. This is a heart rending case which could be used to justify a slippery slope I do not want the UK to go down.