Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:25

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 20:22

There is, although this particular case does not directly raise feminist issues.

In a new review of more than 100 UK cases, we find that despite claims: ‘mercy killings’ are not the wanted, ‘hastened’ deaths that need assisted dying. They are overwhelmingly violent domestic homicides of women, by men: and show that our society is still poor at detecting and responding to domestic abuse. How will these men who kill behave when the state offers lawful death ?

https://theotherhalf.uk/safeguarding-women-in-assisted-dying

I don't think it's right to call it 'assisted dying' for such a young child, or for anyone without capacity to consent. This was not a child who wanted to die but needed assistance. This was a child who was euthanised because the parents and doctors considered their suffering to be unbearable with no hope of improvement. The child was PTS.

It's easy to make a case that for this child it was the right thing to do, although according to the article, the second opinion doctor said palliative care would be effective.

Stepping back from the facts of this particular case, this does indirectly relate to feminist concerns around assisted dying because it's killing a person who cannot consent. Care homes are full of old women with dementia, with only a smattering of men. This is a heart rending case which could be used to justify a slippery slope I do not want the UK to go down.

I don't think it's right to call it 'assisted dying' for such a young child, or for anyone without capacity to consent'

  • This.

I definitely also read that another doctor said palliative care could have helped, or possibly it was another treatment, I need to check.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 28/09/2026 21:25

BobbleBear · 28/09/2026 19:52

Is there a feminist perspective on assisted dying?

Google Lens tells me this when I put a screenshot of your question into it - see attached (It also tells me that @NullaEffugium 's response to your question a few posts later is a misinterpretation of specific, narrow subsets of data to make a sweeping generalization)

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind
catspyjamas1 · 28/09/2026 21:25

EntirelyUnnecessary · 28/09/2026 20:08

OP has a long history of plopping random articles here with no obvious connection to feminism, offering no feminist angle or insight herself and then being rather aggressive in tone to anyone who questions why the thread has been put here.

I wouldn't mind if OP was providing any kind of angle or opener for a discussion, but the plopping of random articles without more is very unhelpful.

Can you enlighten the rest of us with the lore?

Imdunfer · 28/09/2026 21:24

Jesus, well I hope the criteria for killing a child don't get stretched the way the ones for killing an adult have.

Poor little bugger, what a life modern medicine gave him.

catspyjamas1 · 28/09/2026 21:23

Imdunfer · 28/09/2026 21:20

There have been no threads about euthanising a two year old and that is way more important imo than the feminist only viewpoint on it.

I too thought you'd posted in the wrong forum by mistake. If you wanted the feminist viewpoint on it you should have explained that in your first post instead of picking arguments with perfectly reasonable posters.

Edited

Picking arguments? How so?

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 21:22

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:02

@likelysuspect I think the word ‘euthanise’ used in the article means they would have administered a drug in a quantity they were certain would end the child’s life. It is an active step with the purpose of killing ( as a mercy).

Whereas ‘assisted dying’ means something more like not taking emergency life-saving actions, not continuing to feed the person, and possibly administering pain relief.

Assisted dying means the person has given consent and wants to die but cant do it themselves, or doesnt want to and the law allows for them to be assisted to die. This doesnt apply here.

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:20

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:16

Just to add balance and not to derail because I broadly agree, but I was born with spina bifida in the late 1950s. Mum was advised that the best thing would be to let me die because I would always be dependent, would have a low IQ and would be unable to walk or participate in life in the same way as someone without the disability.

I’m now early sixties. Had limited walking ability which necessitated elbow crutches and outdoor wheelchair use, which I’m still fine with. IQ of 130, mainstream education and uni, worked full time in a hugely fulfilling career and married for forty years. Broad range of friends - many of whom are lifelong and remain supportive. I wouldn’t change a thing.

Things were far from easy for my parents but they persevered and because of their intelligent approach I had as normal a life as possible. Your unease is the reason I’m still here and I thank you for it.❤️

How wonderful of your parents. How wonderful you are alive and well. Thank you for coming on to this thread to let people know your own experience. It is not derailing.

Imdunfer · 28/09/2026 21:20

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:49

Well I would ask why you wouldn't think if you are a feminist that you might look at events in life differently than someone who isn't. And want to do that with those who share that view point.

And as i said there have already been more that a couple of threads about assisted dying on this forum, which many participated in. And this is an extension of that.

Are you suggesting they shouldn't have been able to do that.

There have been no threads about euthanising a two year old and that is way more important imo than the feminist only viewpoint on it.

I too thought you'd posted in the wrong forum by mistake. If you wanted the feminist viewpoint on it you should have explained that in your first post instead of picking arguments with perfectly reasonable posters.

catspyjamas1 · 28/09/2026 21:20

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:50

Canada is a particular problem with this I think.

THIS

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 21:19

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:07

Exactly this. Apologies because I know in advance that this is trite and a cliche but we end the suffering of pets because they don’t understand pain and it’s thought of as cruel to extend a life of suffering. How is the life of a child any different ? If there is no chance of recovery and there is pain and suffering surely ending it is the kindest option ?

The pet analogy sounds compelling because both situations involve suffering and compassion, but it smuggles in the conclusion it is supposed to prove. We euthanise animals because humans have to make decisions on their behalf and because, in veterinary ethics, euthanasia can be considered an appropriate response to otherwise unmanageable suffering.
But that doesn't establish that a human child's death is in their interests. A child isn't merely an animal whose suffering we can eliminate; they are a person with interests and rights, and the people making the decision have to justify why death, rather than palliation and comfort, is in that child's interests. “There is no chance of recovery” establishes that treatment may be futile; it does not establish that the person's life has become futile. And “ending suffering” is not synonymous with “ending the sufferer."

catspyjamas1 · 28/09/2026 21:18

Thanks for the thread @IwantToRetire good to see it on FWR - interesting so far.

DosPerros · 28/09/2026 21:18

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 19:56

If the doctors left the baby without intervention when he/she was born at 26 weeks they wouldn't be dealing with euthanasia now.

Yes, totally agree with you here.

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:16

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 20:54

I think one aspect is that it relates to a reason for abortion in cases where the child has been identified as having a severe disability which will cause it suffering when it is born. I remember a doctor suggesting that spins bifida could be like this.

Many people who would not otherwise agree with abortion might do so in a case if such a disability were going to severely affect the baby, yet they might not feel at all sure about ending the life of a child once he or she had been born. Logically though it should be the same as abortion.

I am not sure what I personally feel about the euthanasia in the article. On the face of it, the child’s suffering was so bad it was a certainly mercy to end it. It must have been truly terrible for the parents to have to make this choice.

On the other hand, I feel unease that this sort of euthanasia could be abused and used to end the life of a disabled child whose life might nevertheless be worthwhile for them, and have quality and purpose - but be inconvenient.

But balance I agree with the practice a pp mentioned as being relevant in 1970 when the pp was born, which was to have the choice not to take steps to keep a chid alive just after birth if he or she is certainly profoundly disabled. That is similar to the OP article though more passive and less active.

It must be so upsetting for any parents having to consider this.

Just to add balance and not to derail because I broadly agree, but I was born with spina bifida in the late 1950s. Mum was advised that the best thing would be to let me die because I would always be dependent, would have a low IQ and would be unable to walk or participate in life in the same way as someone without the disability.

I’m now early sixties. Had limited walking ability which necessitated elbow crutches and outdoor wheelchair use, which I’m still fine with. IQ of 130, mainstream education and uni, worked full time in a hugely fulfilling career and married for forty years. Broad range of friends - many of whom are lifelong and remain supportive. I wouldn’t change a thing.

Things were far from easy for my parents but they persevered and because of their intelligent approach I had as normal a life as possible. Your unease is the reason I’m still here and I thank you for it.❤️

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:16

BirmaBright · 28/09/2026 21:04

What is the difference between euthanasia and palliating someone ? Did the Doctors involved give the child something to make them die or did they reduce input and increase symptom control , I am not sure the article makes that clear ?

The word euthanasia makes it clear:
Cambridge Dictionary
Noun
the act of killing someone who is very ill or very old so that they do not sufferany more:
Although some people campaign for the right to euthanasia, it is still illegal in most countries.
Synonym
mercy killing

mercy killing

1. the act of killing someone who is very ill or very old so that they do not…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/mercy-killing

Dollymylove · 28/09/2026 21:15

BirdLandedonmyHead · 28/09/2026 19:52

Just because we can prolong life, doesnt always mean we should.

Sadly this is true.
Its also true at the other end of the spectrum, keeping very elderly frail people alive with no good reason. Sometimes letting nature take over is the right thing to do

AllTheToddlers · 28/09/2026 21:13

No different to hospitals here withdrawing treatment for similar children, especially when the parents don’t want it

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 21:10

Lexibletheflexible · 28/09/2026 20:14

"The whole point of a forum is to be able to discuss issues, news or whatever with a group of people, in this instance GC feminists."

Another reference by a regular member about this group being aimed at GC feminists

If I want a 'GC feminist' take on anything this is the first place I come.

The title of this topic is Feminism: Sex and Gender. In practice it is primarily a feminist forum*. You see those 1135 pages of threads, starting from 2010? The vast majority were posted under the topic's old title of Feminism and Women's Rights.

I'm sure most posters here would agree that there is no way of doing feminism without acknowledging sex. If you disagree then start a thread explaining how and why we would do that. What is non-GC feminism? How would that work?

Maybe 'Feminist Chat' would be more your thing. That's the topic that was demanded by people wanting to discuss 'feminism' while pretending sex is not relevant. It's a bit of a ghost town but maybe you can liven it up.

*Ancient threads on site stuff clarified that it's a topic about feminism which means we have to put up with raging misogynists posting why they reckon feminism is shit, as long as they abide by the talk guidelines. We are free to argue back.

AlonsoMosley · 28/09/2026 21:07

Lomonald · 28/09/2026 19:53

I don't know why you are being so aggressive no wonder women stay clear of here , i see you don't intend to give me a clear explanation of what you actually mean.

I can't see the aggression in the posters answer?

Also - any thing to do with children would interest feminists wouldn't it? As would anything to do with life, assisted life, assisted dying etc.

I mean, your confusion over why feminists would be interested in this is ... confusing!

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:07

C152 · 28/09/2026 21:04

That may be a fair point. But 'unlikely' is not something I'd want to risk when it comes to my child's suffering. How is extending suffering and directly causing harm through the withdrawal of support (or forced support when it will clearly have little if any positive outcome) better than immediately ending the suffering?

Exactly this. Apologies because I know in advance that this is trite and a cliche but we end the suffering of pets because they don’t understand pain and it’s thought of as cruel to extend a life of suffering. How is the life of a child any different ? If there is no chance of recovery and there is pain and suffering surely ending it is the kindest option ?

C152 · 28/09/2026 21:04

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 20:41

'Withdrawal of support' does not always mean starving to death.

This child had breathing difficulties and frequent seizures. It's unlikely they would have survived long enough to starve if treatment was withdrawn.

That may be a fair point. But 'unlikely' is not something I'd want to risk when it comes to my child's suffering. How is extending suffering and directly causing harm through the withdrawal of support (or forced support when it will clearly have little if any positive outcome) better than immediately ending the suffering?

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:04

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:49

Well I would ask why you wouldn't think if you are a feminist that you might look at events in life differently than someone who isn't. And want to do that with those who share that view point.

And as i said there have already been more that a couple of threads about assisted dying on this forum, which many participated in. And this is an extension of that.

Are you suggesting they shouldn't have been able to do that.

Why would you look at things differently via feminism? Surely the only question here is whether this child is suffering and whether anything other than euthanasia is a viable alternative to end his suffering.

BirmaBright · 28/09/2026 21:04

What is the difference between euthanasia and palliating someone ? Did the Doctors involved give the child something to make them die or did they reduce input and increase symptom control , I am not sure the article makes that clear ?

catspyjamas1 · 28/09/2026 21:03

kxeil · 28/09/2026 19:53

No!

There should be.

Hasn't Kathleen Stock been involved in this for a while? Could be a starting point.

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:02

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 20:47

Ive read the article now

I dont know why this is termed assisted dying, its not assisted dying.

It sounds heartbreaking. I cant quite make out if the child was actually euthanised or whether treatment was withdrawn? Is that the same thing?

@likelysuspect I think the word ‘euthanise’ used in the article means they would have administered a drug in a quantity they were certain would end the child’s life. It is an active step with the purpose of killing ( as a mercy).

Whereas ‘assisted dying’ means something more like not taking emergency life-saving actions, not continuing to feed the person, and possibly administering pain relief.

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 20:54

Roxela · 28/09/2026 20:08

Yes there is, but I not sure it is relevant in this scenario.

The one that springs to mind is how it is a common trait among women (certainly older women) to tend to put themselves last and not want to be a bother.

I think one aspect is that it relates to a reason for abortion in cases where the child has been identified as having a severe disability which will cause it suffering when it is born. I remember a doctor suggesting that spins bifida could be like this.

Many people who would not otherwise agree with abortion might do so in a case if such a disability were going to severely affect the baby, yet they might not feel at all sure about ending the life of a child once he or she had been born. Logically though it should be the same as abortion.

I am not sure what I personally feel about the euthanasia in the article. On the face of it, the child’s suffering was so bad it was a certainly mercy to end it. It must have been truly terrible for the parents to have to make this choice.

On the other hand, I feel unease that this sort of euthanasia could be abused and used to end the life of a disabled child whose life might nevertheless be worthwhile for them, and have quality and purpose - but be inconvenient.

But balance I agree with the practice a pp mentioned as being relevant in 1970 when the pp was born, which was to have the choice not to take steps to keep a chid alive just after birth if he or she is certainly profoundly disabled. That is similar to the OP article though more passive and less active.

It must be so upsetting for any parents having to consider this.