Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:49

@ScrollingLeaves again, this is an area that is extremely sensitive so it would come to light fast if there were problems.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:48

@ScrollingLeaves there are concerns with the drugs, there is no doubt that in some case but don't forget that there are protocols for what happens if they're not effective within a time limit in the NL, and that the overwhelming vast majority of cases are completed well

"The Regional Euthanasia Review Committees (RTE) in the Netherlands found that fewer than 0.1% of reported cases fail to meet due care criteria—recording just 7 problematic cases out of 10,341 procedures (about 0.06%) in the most recent annual reporting cycle. 1] in the most recent annual reporting cycle."

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 13:41

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:37

It says it all that you will so very quickly invalidate the intellectual and professional integrity of people who have direct personal experience of the topic so fast, when it counters your point.

But I haven’t invalidated their professional opinion or integrity, I am saying that the opinion of one tech support worker at one clinic is insufficient to make any kind of judgement on all of assisted dying in the Netherlands. It’s just common sense. It’s like taking the opinion of one Ryanair aircrew worker on Ryanair safety as sufficient judgement for a safety rating for the entire airline.

Or taking one of the examples I quoted in the paper of assisted dying events that went wrong and claiming all assisted dying gets botched. I haven’t done that, those were just examples to show it can go wrong.

Sure,y you aren’t trying to do the mirror image with your friend’s partner’s tech worker in euthanasia opinion either? To argue it often goes perfectly? They aren’t in a position to be able to know.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:37

It says it all that you will so very quickly invalidate the intellectual and professional integrity of people who have direct personal experience of the topic so fast, when it counters your point.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 13:35

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:21

(I am sure you understand that a friend’s partner’s opinion of how well they do their job isn’t technically impartial oversight.)

My friend had more observational and intellectual integrity than you will ever comprehend.

Yes, I am sure they do. I wasn’t questioning them, merely saying that you must know that impartial oversight would involve teams of 3rd party evaluators inspecting all clinics and no matter how observant and ethical one tech support worker is, they cannot possibly see everything that goes on even in their one clinic, much less all the clinics in the NLs.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 13:25

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:19

I am sorry you have friends who have had to make this difficult choice and I can see why you’d need to believe they died with minimal suffering and pain. That the NLs process is free of complications and abuses. I am sorry for your loss.

(I am sure you understand that a friend’s partner’s opinion of how well they do their job isn’t technically impartial oversight.)

Christ almighty, there are no levels to which you will not sink are there?

You are, I think, the single most patronizing and yes, I come back to the word, dishonest poster I have met here because you will distort information, conflate different situations to serve your own agenda and denigrate other people's experiences in order to push your own agenda.

I'm out.

I am sorry you feel that way. I was acknowledging your loss in a genuine fashion. I truly meant no disrespect.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 13:22

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:57

We have no data showing that it’s being done any more humanely at the assisted dying clinics other than a few glowing loved one of client testimonials plus loads of marketing material depicting a Hollywood death.

No data means just that. No data. You can't judge.

And in this area more than any other if there are problems, it is highlighted - as in Canada. WHich is why it's clear that Canada's model is bad.

But these complaints do not exist in the same level in the NL and Belgium and other countries - which incidently (regarding NL and Belgium and Switzerland have a far greater respect for adults' ability to choose for themselves than the UK).

"a few glowing loved ones of client testimonials" is absolutely inaccurate. Try talking to the families and doctors of people who have gone for euthanasia. None, and I mean none, that I have talked to have complaints. They have either been relieved for their family members, or neutral - taken the view that "it was their choice". Respected that choice.

You are consistently cherry picking data and phrasing things in the way to cast the worst possible light on euthanasia, which can be a well run and very, actually, positive way to end a life. Every single point you make is unbalanced and unnuanced.

As for therapy and PTSD, have the decency to look up the stories of people who have had to watch their loved ones live or die in agony. Even on this thread there are some.

Hang on, I’m not judging, you’re the one saying Canada’s system is bad.

Saying there is no data isn’t a judgement, it’s a fact.

Of course companies don’t exist on the same scale in the NL as in Canada, Canada has more than twice the population.

Look, this is how a debate goes. I make a point in favour of my view, you make a point in favour of your view. I don’t need to be making points in favour of your view for you, that’s for you to do. Yes my posts are against assisted dying and euthanasia because that is my opinion. Your posts are for assisted dying and euthanasia because that is your opinion.

Cherry picking doesn’t apply in a debate, it applies in scientific research to get to a truth or consensus of facts.

In short, neither of us is being balanced or making equal points for and against. We are expressing our opinions and why. I have acknowledged some of your points as you have mine.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:22

@ScrollingLeaves I don't know. Not in that field any more for a long time.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:21

(I am sure you understand that a friend’s partner’s opinion of how well they do their job isn’t technically impartial oversight.)

My friend had more observational and intellectual integrity than you will ever comprehend.

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 13:20

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 09:56

@ScrollingLeaves

That is good but stairs end up needing a stair lift so there also needs to be an extra room downstairs so an elderly/ill person can use that for sleeping in, and the rest of the family still has a sitting room, kitchen and place to eat

Yes, but try getting the house building associations to go with that.

When the new standards were coming in the disability movement fought hard against a number of measures that would have meant this sort of thing but the Housebuilding lobby is big, powerful and didn't want to do it. A lot of watering down Part M of the building regs went on (the accessibility part).

This country is short sighted, unholistic, and almost anti-family . Better building regulations and other factors would save huge amounts of money that will otherwise have to be spent anyway.

I wonder if there has been any comparative research done with different countries?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:19

I am sorry you have friends who have had to make this difficult choice and I can see why you’d need to believe they died with minimal suffering and pain. That the NLs process is free of complications and abuses. I am sorry for your loss.

(I am sure you understand that a friend’s partner’s opinion of how well they do their job isn’t technically impartial oversight.)

Christ almighty, there are no levels to which you will not sink are there?

You are, I think, the single most patronizing and yes, I come back to the word, dishonest poster I have met here because you will distort information, conflate different situations to serve your own agenda and denigrate other people's experiences in order to push your own agenda.

I'm out.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 13:09

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:59

Because I live here, I knew people who went for euthanasia, and because a friend's partner works as tech support on one of the teams administering euthanasia.

For god's sake, is all this theoretical to you? It's not to me.

[editted: lost touch the last few years with the friend, but she was a high powered and very direct Rotterdammer whose own husband had gone for euthanasia and she'd been present]

Edited

No it’s not theoretical to me, as I have family living where it’s legal- NL, Oregon, France, and I am genuinely concerned by the rhetoric around disability benefits in the UK that the abuses in Canada could all to easily happen in the UK.

I am sorry you have friends who have had to make this difficult choice and I can see why you’d need to believe they died with minimal suffering and pain. That the NLs process is free of complications and abuses. I am sorry for your loss.

(I am sure you understand that a friend’s partner’s opinion of how well they do their job isn’t technically impartial oversight.)

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 13:09

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 09:43

There are different methods and drug protocols for assisted dying by country and for execution by state and country.

This paper gives a good overview of the different drugs combinations, but the take away is that all the drugs used for either assisted dying or execution can or have been used for both and can or have complications(suffering, pains or fail to work.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9270985/

I have not finished reading but will do so later.
I cannot express how shocked I am. I would guess almost no one discussing this subject would have the first idea of the truth as described here.

Anyone considering assisted dying for themselves or a relative should read this and get armed with information. It needs a thread of its own I think @NullaEffugium

Likewise read the Liverpool Pathway reports from this same pp if you have very ill, or dying, relatives or friends in hospital.

Do not just trust. Get to know the facts and speak to the doctors first even if these are protocols you think are right for you.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:59

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:50

? Canada and NL have the exact same plan, the difference is we have data from Canada on how often it’s needed but no data from the NL. Why do you assume that what is hidden behind the curtain in the NL is any better than what is being honestly recorded in Canada?

Because I live here, I knew people who went for euthanasia, and because a friend's partner works as tech support on one of the teams administering euthanasia.

For god's sake, is all this theoretical to you? It's not to me.

[editted: lost touch the last few years with the friend, but she was a high powered and very direct Rotterdammer whose own husband had gone for euthanasia and she'd been present]

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:57

We have no data showing that it’s being done any more humanely at the assisted dying clinics other than a few glowing loved one of client testimonials plus loads of marketing material depicting a Hollywood death.

No data means just that. No data. You can't judge.

And in this area more than any other if there are problems, it is highlighted - as in Canada. WHich is why it's clear that Canada's model is bad.

But these complaints do not exist in the same level in the NL and Belgium and other countries - which incidently (regarding NL and Belgium and Switzerland have a far greater respect for adults' ability to choose for themselves than the UK).

"a few glowing loved ones of client testimonials" is absolutely inaccurate. Try talking to the families and doctors of people who have gone for euthanasia. None, and I mean none, that I have talked to have complaints. They have either been relieved for their family members, or neutral - taken the view that "it was their choice". Respected that choice.

You are consistently cherry picking data and phrasing things in the way to cast the worst possible light on euthanasia, which can be a well run and very, actually, positive way to end a life. Every single point you make is unbalanced and unnuanced.

As for therapy and PTSD, have the decency to look up the stories of people who have had to watch their loved ones live or die in agony. Even on this thread there are some.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:53

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar
No, and this alone means that this bill is unacceptable. If it's legalized, it needs to be done properly and that means medically trained staff. There's a really easy solution to the UK bill not requiring health care professionals to be involved at this point, isn't there.

Yes and it’s too bad the Leadbetter committee rejected that HoL amendment too to have trained, qualified medical staff administer the assisted dying drugs. Perhaps because they had promised assisted dying wouldn’t cost a lot?

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:50

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:43

As I've said, repeatedly, Canada is no model for euthanasia.

But just because Russia carries out democracy really badly doesn't mean that every other country in the world should reject the system.

It's actually reassuring that in the Dutch system they do actually plan what to do in the case of it taking too long. Given that this is what the individuals want for themelves.

Edited

? Canada and NL have the exact same plan, the difference is we have data from Canada on how often it’s needed but no data from the NL. Why do you assume that what is hidden behind the curtain in the NL is any better than what is being honestly recorded in Canada?

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:48

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:42

As for pre-existing conditions, you’re right, but the protocol for assisted dying also doesn’t take that into account. For one prisoner, the lethal injection failed because of his advanced cancer and he underwent immense physical pain abs psychological torture before they called off the execution and a few months later, he died of the cancer. That is relevant to assisted dying is it not?

Not if the doctor is able to get help, quickly, to resolve the situation. I'd also like to point out that this prisoner did not choose voluntarily to die. And if you really believe the US prison system including the execution system is well planned, effective, practical and decent, I have a bridge to sell you .... https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/executions/botched-executions

Do you know that the UK assisted dying bill doesn’t require any health care qualification at all administer the drugs?

No, and this alone means that this bill is unacceptable. If it's legalized, it needs to be done properly and that means medically trained staff.

There's a really easy solution to the UK bill not requiring health care professionals to be involved at this point, isn't there.

Thanks, but I have already posted a quote from the death penalty botched executions webpage.

We have no data showing that it’s being done any more humanely at the assisted dying clinics other than a few glowing loved one of client testimonials plus loads of marketing material depicting a Hollywood death.

And yet, people getting PTSD diagnoses and therapy after witnessing a relative having assisted dying is a growing subset of psychological trauma.

There isn’t much oversight and I for one have zero faith it’s as good as it says on the tin.

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 12:46

kxeil · 02/10/2026 09:08

@ScrollingLeaves “I was speaking of better, more adaptable housing stock.”

New builds are generally getting smaller in the UK.

“There can be many years of being old though where simply living with your family can be care in itself which can prevent some illnesses.”

Plenty of families won’t be willing or unable to have an elderly parent live with them.

The houses getting smaller and less adaptable is a bad idea. That is the point.

Some people don’t want elderly relatives, some people, and definitely some cultures do.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 12:46

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 12:38

I absolutely agree with you about the choice but feel almost certain this would become a pressure not a choice. So that is the dilemma imo.

I agree with you, but if adult social care collapsed leaving many more people who need daily care to suffer and die alone, wouldn’t it be good to have a choice if you wanted it?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:43

As I've said, repeatedly, Canada is no model for euthanasia.

But just because Russia carries out democracy really badly doesn't mean that every other country in the world should reject the system.

It's actually reassuring that in the Dutch system they do actually plan what to do in the case of it taking too long. Given that this is what the individuals want for themelves.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 12:42

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:32

The execution drugs are also not administered by trained medical staff who know what they are doing, they are administered by untrained prison staff on the whole.

In the US, execution by lethal injection are administered by nurses under the supervision of a doctor, not by prison staff. The catheter is placed by a phlebotomist nurse. The issues they have had is in finding suitable veins.

As for pre-existing conditions, you’re right, but the protocol for assisted dying also doesn’t take that into account. For one prisoner, the lethal injection failed because of his advanced cancer and he underwent immense physical pain abs psychological torture before they called off the execution and a few years later, he died of the cancer. That is relevant to assisted dying is it not?

Do you know that the UK assisted dying bill doesn’t require any health care qualification at all administer the drugs?

Edited

As for pre-existing conditions, you’re right, but the protocol for assisted dying also doesn’t take that into account. For one prisoner, the lethal injection failed because of his advanced cancer and he underwent immense physical pain abs psychological torture before they called off the execution and a few months later, he died of the cancer. That is relevant to assisted dying is it not?

Not if the doctor is able to get help, quickly, to resolve the situation. I'd also like to point out that this prisoner did not choose voluntarily to die. And if you really believe the US prison system including the execution system is well planned, effective, practical and decent, I have a bridge to sell you .... https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/executions/botched-executions

Do you know that the UK assisted dying bill doesn’t require any health care qualification at all administer the drugs?

No, and this alone means that this bill is unacceptable. If it's legalized, it needs to be done properly and that means medically trained staff.

There's a really easy solution to the UK bill not requiring health care professionals to be involved at this point, isn't there.

DPI

Botched Executions | Death Penalty Information Center

It is estimated that 3% of U.S. executions in the period from 1890 to 2010 were botched. In the 2014 book, Gruesome Spectacles: Botched Executions and…

https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/executions/botched-executions

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:41

How drugs are administered also makes a difference. In voluntary end of life situations in some countries if the self-adminstration fails (and it does, sometimes) then the physical steps in to administer the lethal dose.

Yes I already mentioned this. For both Canada and NL, if death hasn’t occurred within 60 mins, a doctor steps in to inject a lethal dose.

They need to do this in around 50% of cases in Canada. Half is a bit more often than sometimes.

The unpredictable efficacy of assisted suicide drugs is acknowledged by the Royal Dutch Medical and Pharmaceutical Societies and the Canadian Association of MAiD Assessors and Providers, who both recommend that clinicians obtain consent from patients to convert to euthanasia prior to ingestion of the lethal drugs in case the patient takes too long to die.8,25 In 2018, of the MAiD cases in Canada with available data, 50% were unsuccessful by 60 min and the clinician transitioned to euthanasia to complete the ‘assisted’ death.25

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 12:38

kxeil · 02/10/2026 11:01

@PencilsInSpace I’m arguing for assisted dying and euthanasia for any option. If someone is competent, but are physically or mentally suffering, and no longer want to live it would be good to have it as a CHOICE.

Just because you don’t agree with it doesn’t mean there isn’t a need for it.

I absolutely agree with you about the choice but feel almost certain this would become a pressure not a choice. So that is the dilemma imo.

NullaEffugium · 02/10/2026 12:36

Here is the prisoner I mentioned
February 22, 2018. Alabama. Doyle Lee Hamm. Lethal Injection (failed). Despite several warnings from defense counsel that it would be impossible to find a vein in which to insert the catheter (Hamm suffered from advanced lymphatic cancer and carcinoma), the State went forward with the execution. For 2.5 hours, the executioners tried to find a vein, leaving Hamm with a ten-twelve puncture marks, including six in his groin and others that punctured his bladder and penetrated his femoral artery. Finally, approaching a midnight deadline that prohibited further attempts, the execution was called off. Alabama Corrections Commissioner Jeff Dunn later told reporters, “I wouldn’t necessarily characterize what we had tonight as a problem.”[80] [NOTE: On March 5, 2018, attorneys for Doyle Hamm submitted a preliminary report from an anesthesiologist who evaluated Hamm on February 25. WARNING: Report contains graphic images and descriptions.] On November 28, 2021, Mr. Hamm, still in prison, died from his lymphoma and cranial cancer.[81]

Swipe left for the next trending thread