Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:06

Koalapalm · 28/09/2026 22:04

I don’t think that’s true actually. People aren’t so one-dimensional. I am very conflicted about abortion for various reasons - but pretty pro-euthanasia.

For that reason I agree with your second paragraph. I think, if we trust the second doctor’s opinion, that this was certainly a heartbreaking act of compassion and the option to end that suffering was a mercy.

I think the main reason I feel conflicted is that the toddler couldn't consent . Could this then mean other people who lack capacity could be euthanised if they are judged to be in sufficient pain?

Koalapalm · 28/09/2026 22:04

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 21:49

The feminist perspective is those who think toddlers should be kept alive no matter what tend to believe in life above everything else and be very anti abortion.

The rest of us recognise life is far more complex. If course euthanasia fir toddlers should be very tightly controlled and at the extreme end. Children can be very disabled and live a happy life. But it's when life is simply pain to be kept alive that this is a kindness.

I don’t think that’s true actually. People aren’t so one-dimensional. I am very conflicted about abortion for various reasons - but pretty pro-euthanasia.

For that reason I agree with your second paragraph. I think, if we trust the second doctor’s opinion, that this was certainly a heartbreaking act of compassion and the option to end that suffering was a mercy.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:01

I don't want to derail, so I'm going to start a new thread, but this Dutch case re Iris Dekker seems very disturbing to me.

https://www.thefp.com/p/the-parents-who-let-their-daughter

How can we be sure her depression couldn't have been improved? She was only 19. On Reddit, some people are picking up on the mention of tranquillisers and thinking she was addicted. We don't have enough info but tranquillisers are known to affect mood.

https://www.reddit.com/r/DeepStateCentrism/comments/1tp8rwh/theparentswholettheirdaughterdiefreepress/

More info: https://news.sky.com/video/the-teenager-who-wanted-to-end-her-life-under-dutch-euthanasia-laws-13561925

The Parents Who Let Their Daughter Die

‘I don’t want my little girl to die,’ Cissy Dekker said about her 19-year-old daughter, Iris. ‘But out of love,’ Cissy told Rupa Subramanya, ‘I also don’t want this life for her.’

https://www.thefp.com/p/the-parents-who-let-their-daughter

Forgotthebins · 28/09/2026 21:59

People are assuming the child was in unbearable suffering but different doctors seem to have had different points of view about that. I’m also very surprised that assisted dying is available for children in the Netherlands from the age of 12. Given they let a depressed women in her 20s choose assisted dying, that seems risky.

NameChange0101010101 · 28/09/2026 21:59

DaisyDooley · 28/09/2026 21:44

There are fewer than you think who go on to lead ‘happy lives’.
Many will die, many will have limited lives, many will have terrible disabilities .

But we don't know which ones, do we?

Are you saying we shouldn't treat any prem babies because some go on to need a lot of care? Its a bit presumptuous for you to decide that all of those disabled babies lives are not worth living.

My 26 weeker is 17 and doing A levels. He had a brain bleed at 2 days old and could have been disabled - but happily, he is not. We couldn't have known the outcome in advance though.

A PP said prem babies have to go through painful and distressing interventions. That does not sound like informed opinion. Mostly they need breathing support. As with adults, if they are mechanically ventilated, they are sedated and know nothing about it.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:58

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 21:49

The feminist perspective is those who think toddlers should be kept alive no matter what tend to believe in life above everything else and be very anti abortion.

The rest of us recognise life is far more complex. If course euthanasia fir toddlers should be very tightly controlled and at the extreme end. Children can be very disabled and live a happy life. But it's when life is simply pain to be kept alive that this is a kindness.

I'm a strong feminist and I don't fully agree with this.

Abortion is fundamentally different to me because the child is still in the mother's womb. Once the child is out of the womb, in the world, helping them stay alive does not conflict with the mother's bodily autonomy. Moreover, I don't agree with abortion after 6 months. The foetus develops throughout the pregnancy, of course - a 2 week old foetus, say, is very different from a foetus about to be born- and even more so from a baby who HAS been born.

This was a very hard case but ultimately I don't agree with parents having the authority to end their children's lives. Maybe in very restricted circumstances...but I'm uneasy about this case. I wish there were more info..

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:55

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:46

Surely it's different primarily because pets are not human and don't have human rights.

You can sell a pet, for one thing, you can't do that to a child. You can neuter a pet, you can't do that to a human without consent. Children, unlike pets, are human beings.

But at the age of two how much understanding is there of the suffering they endure. That’s my point. If there is no hope of recovery what is the point of prolonging that suffering ? Who does it benefit ?

Awkwardisfunny · 28/09/2026 21:49

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:49

Well I would ask why you wouldn't think if you are a feminist that you might look at events in life differently than someone who isn't. And want to do that with those who share that view point.

And as i said there have already been more that a couple of threads about assisted dying on this forum, which many participated in. And this is an extension of that.

Are you suggesting they shouldn't have been able to do that.

So, is this forum/board for any and all topics but through the lens of a feminist, or is it meant for topics relating to women's issues... Does that question make sense?

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 21:49

The feminist perspective is those who think toddlers should be kept alive no matter what tend to believe in life above everything else and be very anti abortion.

The rest of us recognise life is far more complex. If course euthanasia fir toddlers should be very tightly controlled and at the extreme end. Children can be very disabled and live a happy life. But it's when life is simply pain to be kept alive that this is a kindness.

JennyChawleigh · 28/09/2026 21:46

Older people might remember this case. He was apparently very much liked and many parents testified about his caring and compassion at the trial.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:46

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:07

Exactly this. Apologies because I know in advance that this is trite and a cliche but we end the suffering of pets because they don’t understand pain and it’s thought of as cruel to extend a life of suffering. How is the life of a child any different ? If there is no chance of recovery and there is pain and suffering surely ending it is the kindest option ?

Surely it's different primarily because pets are not human and don't have human rights.

You can sell a pet, for one thing, you can't do that to a child. You can neuter a pet, you can't do that to a human without consent. Children, unlike pets, are human beings.

Itsthewoluff · 28/09/2026 21:45

I don’t think this is a feminist issue if you look at it from the perspective of a child with no chance of any quality of life with a definite death prognosis anyway. It’s a human kindness, mercy issue only.

DaisyDooley · 28/09/2026 21:44

thisismeithinkorisit · 28/09/2026 21:41

the parents of the baby who go on to survive and live happy lives would likely disagree. you don't stop texting all babies with X or born at X because some don't survive or do well.

There are fewer than you think who go on to lead ‘happy lives’.
Many will die, many will have limited lives, many will have terrible disabilities .

DaisyDooley · 28/09/2026 21:43

Dollymylove · 28/09/2026 21:15

Sadly this is true.
Its also true at the other end of the spectrum, keeping very elderly frail people alive with no good reason. Sometimes letting nature take over is the right thing to do

I couldn’t agree with you more.
Im sick of hearing people begging ‘save mum, I can’t live without her’ when mum hasn’t recognised anyone for two years, doesn’t know where or when she is and is doubly incontinent.
Why would you want somone you love to live like that?? Why? It’s so so selfish.
There’s also a huge financial burden on the state keeping people alive who should have just been allowed to slip away.
And, as you say, it’s at both ends.
I’ve been personally involved at both ends and I firmly believe in euthanasia.
It should be a human right to be able to choose the time and place of your own death.
I am pleased the parents of the little Dutch girl made that choice for her.They did the hardest, kindest thing possible.
Her soul can now fly free.

thisismeithinkorisit · 28/09/2026 21:41

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:35

The cut off for treating very premature babies has dropped significantly over recent decades. Perhaps this wasn’t a good idea?

the parents of the baby who go on to survive and live happy lives would likely disagree. you don't stop texting all babies with X or born at X because some don't survive or do well.

Minasama · 28/09/2026 21:41

How very distressing. I imagine the poor child was chronically ill and in pain with no quality of life. How dreadful to have to make this decision though.

TheGardenPond · 28/09/2026 21:41

BobbleBear · 28/09/2026 19:52

Is there a feminist perspective on assisted dying?

I suppose there is because the ones who care for babies, children and the sick and disabled are much more likely to be women. Whether that’s in the home or in caring professions like medicine, nursing, social care and SEND education. So if society is or isn’t offering assisted dying hugely affects women more than men.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:39

FourGreenElephants · 28/09/2026 21:29

I see one thing which is worse than signing euthanazia request for a 2 yo. That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice).

Some babies born at 26 weeks will survive, catch up and lead a healthy life. Giving the baby and parents a chance and decide a bit later depending on how it goes sounds like the kindest option. And, in a sense, the most pro-life. I wouldn't dare to become pregnant if I didn't have a guarantee that medical intervention (abortion) is available in case of a significant risk to me (ectopic) or significantly damaged baby (morfological damage at 20w scan).

Similarly, being able to terminate the effort later is the best base for giving a heavily premature baby a chance.

'That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice).'

Why did the Netherlands have these rules? What were the underlying ideas behind them, and does it link to why they've adopted legal euthanasia?

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:38

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:20

How wonderful of your parents. How wonderful you are alive and well. Thank you for coming on to this thread to let people know your own experience. It is not derailing.

Yes, this reminds me of what my grandmother's said about her long term next door neighbours. Their son was born with a condition which meant he had intellectual disabilities and limited walking ability, the doctors told his parents it would be better to abort. She didn't want to, and although he had health problems and couldn't live independently, he found happiness collecting rock records and playing the drums and was close to his parents and siblings. Sadly he only lived into his mid-40s but that doesn't mean the life he did have wasn't worth living.

Presumably the doctor thought his prognosis was much worse, but like pp's anecdote, it shows how these things can't always be predicted. I'm a carer for a 94yo relative who last year the doctors predicted was 'in the last phase of life' and put on palliative care when she began refusing food and drink during a UTI. It took some time to clear up but she's now better and happy, fortunately.

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 21:37

FourGreenElephants · 28/09/2026 21:29

I see one thing which is worse than signing euthanazia request for a 2 yo. That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice).

Some babies born at 26 weeks will survive, catch up and lead a healthy life. Giving the baby and parents a chance and decide a bit later depending on how it goes sounds like the kindest option. And, in a sense, the most pro-life. I wouldn't dare to become pregnant if I didn't have a guarantee that medical intervention (abortion) is available in case of a significant risk to me (ectopic) or significantly damaged baby (morfological damage at 20w scan).

Similarly, being able to terminate the effort later is the best base for giving a heavily premature baby a chance.

That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice)

Thanks for explaining that. I dont this this point was made in the article.

But maybe does explain how the decision was reached, ie it is an extension of an existing practice(?).

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:36

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 21:28

What exactly would the difference be though, I thought palliative care was end of life comfort.

Imagine you have an ill dog. You could leave it in its bed. It may have stopped eating. You don’t try to feed it. You don’t try to get it to drink. You might give it some dog pain relief. Over a monthsl
to six weeks, it will eventually die. That is palliative care.

Now, imagine the alternative: you take the dog to the vet who that same day gives it a huge injection of some sort of drug that stops its heart beating. In a few minutes it is dead. That is euthanasia.

Kirbert2 · 28/09/2026 21:31

It definitely makes me feel uneasy as the mother of a disabled child who likely wouldn't have survived as late as the 70's/80's. He has surpassed the majority of expectations and has a good life.

My main concern would be misuse such as complex disabled children can cost the state a lot of money and also as I said, doctors don't always get it right when it comes to the future of a disabled child.

FourGreenElephants · 28/09/2026 21:29

I see one thing which is worse than signing euthanazia request for a 2 yo. That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice).

Some babies born at 26 weeks will survive, catch up and lead a healthy life. Giving the baby and parents a chance and decide a bit later depending on how it goes sounds like the kindest option. And, in a sense, the most pro-life. I wouldn't dare to become pregnant if I didn't have a guarantee that medical intervention (abortion) is available in case of a significant risk to me (ectopic) or significantly damaged baby (morfological damage at 20w scan).

Similarly, being able to terminate the effort later is the best base for giving a heavily premature baby a chance.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 21:28

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:25

I don't think it's right to call it 'assisted dying' for such a young child, or for anyone without capacity to consent'

  • This.

I definitely also read that another doctor said palliative care could have helped, or possibly it was another treatment, I need to check.

What exactly would the difference be though, I thought palliative care was end of life comfort.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:28

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 21:19

The pet analogy sounds compelling because both situations involve suffering and compassion, but it smuggles in the conclusion it is supposed to prove. We euthanise animals because humans have to make decisions on their behalf and because, in veterinary ethics, euthanasia can be considered an appropriate response to otherwise unmanageable suffering.
But that doesn't establish that a human child's death is in their interests. A child isn't merely an animal whose suffering we can eliminate; they are a person with interests and rights, and the people making the decision have to justify why death, rather than palliation and comfort, is in that child's interests. “There is no chance of recovery” establishes that treatment may be futile; it does not establish that the person's life has become futile. And “ending suffering” is not synonymous with “ending the sufferer."

This.

Personally I find the pet analogy wrong in that context. I did a thread on this earlier.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5579309-to-think-people-should-not-use-we-put-pets-to-sleep-as-an-argument-to-allow-assisted-dying

To think people should not use 'we put pets to sleep' as an argument to allow assisted dying? | Mumsnet

I love animals but they aren't legally the same as people. If somebody sold a person, or controlled who they could have children with, we would be hor...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5579309-to-think-people-should-not-use-we-put-pets-to-sleep-as-an-argument-to-allow-assisted-dying