Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
ITMA2000 · 28/09/2026 22:58

runnerducky · 28/09/2026 19:47

Sounds like a very difficult situation. I think we will increasingly see these situations because in years gone by, children with this level of needs would just have died in infancy as the medical care wasn’t there to prolong life. Now we have the knowledge and skills to keep children like this alive, but there’s the ethical issue of whether just because we can, we necessarily should. We do have to be realistic about the quality of life some children with very severe disabilities have - just because they are living doesn’t mean they have a life.

I don’t understand what it is to do with feminism either though but look forward to the discussion.

Edited

Very difficult. I believe that doctors do a sort of informal triage even today.

NameChange0101010101 · 28/09/2026 22:54

Junglejune · 28/09/2026 22:18

I think it’s actually letting them die rather than artificially keeping them alive with no quality of life. But instead of them dying in discomfort and pain they ensure it happens in a controlled and humane way.

There comes a point where existence does not really meet the definition of life. This sounds like one of those cases.

Its really important for these discussions that we are clear about what we are discussing as there are a lot of similar terms.

As I think a pp posted, letting someone die is withdrawal of care. Its passive.

Its very different to this case, which was euthanasia, ie active killing.

Assisted dying is also active killing, but specifically with consent/ choice of the patient.

DNAR has also been mentioned upthread - do not attempt resuscitation. This is different again, it means that treatment will be given but if they have a cardiac arrest CPR will not be given (ie no attempt to 'bring them back'). This is pretty standard in the UK for elderly or very sick people who likely wouldn't survive resuscitation or for long after/ would likely sustain injuries from it. CPR can be brutal.

FourGreenElephants · 28/09/2026 22:42

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 21:39

'That is being under artificial time-based pressure to decide before the baby turns 1 (as was in Netherlands before) or decide immediately when the premature baby is born (DNR choice).'

Why did the Netherlands have these rules? What were the underlying ideas behind them, and does it link to why they've adopted legal euthanasia?

I don't know why Netherlands has it this way, but I generally like their setup.

I know that in my country we have a few sharp cut offs (24 weeks for abortion for morphological issues, a grey zone around 23-26 weeks with unofficial DNR window), and I know that people who fall into them find the time-pressured decision making very difficult.

What is the responsible decision for my baby?Would I have the guts to give DNR at 24 weeks, or would I be selfish, "give it a try" and risk causing the baby long term suffering?

Some posters argue that we sometimes try too hard to prolong/save the life. I partially agree, but with premature babies and children with heavy neurological issues we just don't know enough to say who will be ok and who won't without letting it unroll.

The Netherland's way is very appealing. Allows deciding based on the real prognosis of the individual, not general statistics and parental desperation.

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:39

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:37

Their mothers must be helped, support for carers is really poor.

There is often some financial allocation for carers. But it can be almost impossible in some cases to get anyone to do the job.

SpidersAreShitheads · 28/09/2026 22:38

I'm extremely wary of the implementation of assisted dying for all the reasons that PP have mentioned, with vulnerable people being disproportionately conditioned/coerced into accepting it as the best option.

Obviously this is a different situation as we're talking about a toddler but I think there needs to be extreme care in deciding to end another person's life. I'm not quite sure who gets to decide what quality of life is good enough, and what isn't.

In this case it would seem that there was an element of doctor shopping. From what I understand, the first doctor and the parents thought euthanasia was the right option, but the independent doctor who was asked to review the case didn't agree. They concluded that "reasonable alternatives" for treatment hadn't yet been exhausted and believed that the condition could be brought under control. As the second doctor didn't agree, an opinion from another doctor was sought and they agreed with the first, so euthanasia was signed off.

I really do understand the need for compassion when we're talking about the limit of another person's suffering, but to end the life of a young child I think there needs to be absolutely no doubts and even then it makes me feel uncomfortable because as above, who gets to decide when suffering is too much? And when a doctor is giving examples of treatments that haven't yet been tried, is it OK just to ignore that because it doesn't suit when you want?

I think it's an incredibly slippery slope when we're deciding whether another person's life has value, and even more so when you're talking about a child with a non-terminal diagnosis. It's veering uncomfortably close to eugenics for me.

Somethinggg · 28/09/2026 22:38

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 22:29

Your argument is that AD is feminist because it saves women from being shoved into caring roles.

This is a terrible argument. Any AD we make legal must never ever ever be to do with the needs or wishes of anyone else other than the person who will be killed. Knowing that there are people who think like this is something that makes me think any AD law is dangerous.

The unpaid care that is expected of women as a default is most definitely a feminist issue but I live in hope that we can solve this without having to kill people.

Nope.

My argument is what I actually wrote. That care labour falls disproportionately on women and that I imagine expectations of who should avail themselves of AD could too. There's a reason I didn't identify either as more feminist. Rather, a feminist approach would acknowledge both.

You're allowed to hope whatever you want, but should and is do not mean the same thing.

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:37

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:34

I agree with your conclusion.
But I have cared for various profoundly disabled teenagers who live a happy life, but are developmentally still like a baby. It is very tough on the mothers.

Their mothers must be helped, support for carers is really poor.

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:34

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 22:29

Your argument is that AD is feminist because it saves women from being shoved into caring roles.

This is a terrible argument. Any AD we make legal must never ever ever be to do with the needs or wishes of anyone else other than the person who will be killed. Knowing that there are people who think like this is something that makes me think any AD law is dangerous.

The unpaid care that is expected of women as a default is most definitely a feminist issue but I live in hope that we can solve this without having to kill people.

I agree with your conclusion.
But I have cared for various profoundly disabled teenagers who live a happy life, but are developmentally still like a baby. It is very tough on the mothers.

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 22:29

Somethinggg · 28/09/2026 20:39

I don't think you can say this particular case doesn't raise feminist issues when it relates to a child who needed such substantial care. Without more specific information on the family, at minimum we can say that the caring expectations on a societal level are different for mothers than fathers, and the Netherlands isn't immune to that by any means.

Which doesn't mean the points about euthanasia and women as lower value than men are wrong either. I think it's quite possible that whatever policy options we pursue, they're all worse for women than they are for men, but in different ways.

Your argument is that AD is feminist because it saves women from being shoved into caring roles.

This is a terrible argument. Any AD we make legal must never ever ever be to do with the needs or wishes of anyone else other than the person who will be killed. Knowing that there are people who think like this is something that makes me think any AD law is dangerous.

The unpaid care that is expected of women as a default is most definitely a feminist issue but I live in hope that we can solve this without having to kill people.

Somuchgoo · 28/09/2026 22:27

That's a huge difference between 'this child is very sick, may not/unlikely to pull through, might be very disabled from it/we don't know what the future holds and condition that would equal certain death.

There are conditions that have a 100% mortality rate, those are the only ones personally that I'd be ok with child euthanasia for. Where there's hope, let's take it. But where there's none, let's choose mercy.

ThePM · 28/09/2026 22:26

kxeil · 28/09/2026 19:53

No!

I think there are multiple!

seahorsessky · 28/09/2026 22:24

Lomonald · 28/09/2026 19:44

I don't see how euthanasia of a toddler is a feminist issue I am not being goady i just would like to understand, it sounds like the child had a terrible prognosis and no real quality of life, i can't imagine being the parents who.decided to do this.

Yes, it would apply to a male or female parent, which makes it different from abortion, as obviously only the mother is carrying the child.

Kirbert2 · 28/09/2026 22:21

NameChange0101010101 · 28/09/2026 21:59

But we don't know which ones, do we?

Are you saying we shouldn't treat any prem babies because some go on to need a lot of care? Its a bit presumptuous for you to decide that all of those disabled babies lives are not worth living.

My 26 weeker is 17 and doing A levels. He had a brain bleed at 2 days old and could have been disabled - but happily, he is not. We couldn't have known the outcome in advance though.

A PP said prem babies have to go through painful and distressing interventions. That does not sound like informed opinion. Mostly they need breathing support. As with adults, if they are mechanically ventilated, they are sedated and know nothing about it.

Yep.

Doctors also don't always know which ones. Especially right away.

My son had a 17 minute cardiac arrest. I was told that if he did survive, he'd have severe brain damage. He is disabled but not in the way the doctor predicted, far from it.

I'm glad they didn't just give up on him and assume his life wasn't worth saving.

Lomonald · 28/09/2026 22:20

SockPlant · 28/09/2026 20:10

scolding again i see.

It's not a feminist issue.

I am not scolding I was honestly trying to work out what the op is wanting to talk about but Instead of clarity i just get waffle and accusations of "scolding" I was interested in the Ops stance. Like I said no wonder women steer clear of this section of mumsnet, there only is soundbites and word salad from some posters.

whywaitallnight · 28/09/2026 22:18

Pollyanna87 · 28/09/2026 22:07

Some people seem to forget there’s a difference between allowing someone to die, and actively killing them. Euthanasia for a two year old is monstrous and Final Solution-esque.

The alternative was allowing the child to suffer for years, with no quality of life, just to sustain the parent’s wants.

Junglejune · 28/09/2026 22:18

Pollyanna87 · 28/09/2026 22:07

Some people seem to forget there’s a difference between allowing someone to die, and actively killing them. Euthanasia for a two year old is monstrous and Final Solution-esque.

I think it’s actually letting them die rather than artificially keeping them alive with no quality of life. But instead of them dying in discomfort and pain they ensure it happens in a controlled and humane way.

There comes a point where existence does not really meet the definition of life. This sounds like one of those cases.

Somuchgoo · 28/09/2026 22:16

Pollyanna87 · 28/09/2026 22:07

Some people seem to forget there’s a difference between allowing someone to die, and actively killing them. Euthanasia for a two year old is monstrous and Final Solution-esque.

Monstrous is watching a child die in pain from brain cancer, fully aware that parts of their body are no longer working, until either they have a fatal seizure or stroke, or their brain stops telling their brain to breathe.

Monstrous is knowing there is no treatment that can help them, and very little done to slow it, and that the outcome is inevitable.

Their deaths cannot be avoided. Their deaths being monstrous can be.

AlonsoMosley · 28/09/2026 22:16

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:07

Modern medicine has gone too far in some cases. Pushing the boundaries of viability can sometimes result in prolonged suffering or severe complications. Extremely premature babies must undergo highly invasive procedures which cause pain and suffering.

My friend.

The doctors were heroic and modern medicine a triumph when they "saved" her baby.

But the parents were then left with seven years of absolute hell, in and out of hospital, many near death experiences, and a subtle but definite pressure to follow the "miracle" and allow it. Her child, my goddaughter spent seven years of pure torture on planet earth punctuated by small, irregular moments of relief. And for seven years, her heart and that of her husband was broken, battered and bruised.

I wondered often if the wonders of modern medicine in that case would have been better to let her go on any of the many occasions when her body and mind were clearly ready.

Rather than keeping them alive in order to kill them a few months later, should we not revisit our philosophy around intervention in the first instance?

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:11

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:08

If there is no hope of recovery that would be reasonable.

But how do you judge if the person lacks capacity to speak for themselves? How can am external person judge whether someone's life is painful enough to be ended?

What would the criteria and controls be? This sounds dangerous to me.

likelysuspect · 28/09/2026 22:09

ScrollingLeaves · 28/09/2026 21:36

Imagine you have an ill dog. You could leave it in its bed. It may have stopped eating. You don’t try to feed it. You don’t try to get it to drink. You might give it some dog pain relief. Over a monthsl
to six weeks, it will eventually die. That is palliative care.

Now, imagine the alternative: you take the dog to the vet who that same day gives it a huge injection of some sort of drug that stops its heart beating. In a few minutes it is dead. That is euthanasia.

Ok so when it sort of presented that the doctors disagreed, it appears that they simply disagree about the right way to progress the death of the child. Its not that the other doctor was saying the child would live.

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 22:09

NotrialNodeal · 28/09/2026 21:19

The pet analogy sounds compelling because both situations involve suffering and compassion, but it smuggles in the conclusion it is supposed to prove. We euthanise animals because humans have to make decisions on their behalf and because, in veterinary ethics, euthanasia can be considered an appropriate response to otherwise unmanageable suffering.
But that doesn't establish that a human child's death is in their interests. A child isn't merely an animal whose suffering we can eliminate; they are a person with interests and rights, and the people making the decision have to justify why death, rather than palliation and comfort, is in that child's interests. “There is no chance of recovery” establishes that treatment may be futile; it does not establish that the person's life has become futile. And “ending suffering” is not synonymous with “ending the sufferer."

Very compelling and food for further reflection. Especially in light of my own life experience. Thank you.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 28/09/2026 22:09

bababamama · 28/09/2026 20:07

The Netherlands used to have a 26 week cut off for resuscitation for preemies too, they have a different attitude to most countries. I’m pretty uncomfortable with the term euthanasia for a child however dnr and withdrawal of support somehow seems more humane

Has it changed now, @bababamama ?

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:08

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:06

I think the main reason I feel conflicted is that the toddler couldn't consent . Could this then mean other people who lack capacity could be euthanised if they are judged to be in sufficient pain?

If there is no hope of recovery that would be reasonable.

Pollyanna87 · 28/09/2026 22:07

Some people seem to forget there’s a difference between allowing someone to die, and actively killing them. Euthanasia for a two year old is monstrous and Final Solution-esque.

NameChange0101010101 · 28/09/2026 22:07

I don't underrated the insistence that you can't have a feminist perspective on euthanasia/assisted dying.

You can have a feminist perspective on anything ( just like a socialist perspective, or conservative perspective etc).

I don't know why people who don't like it can't just read a different thread, without all the scolding.