Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
LBFseBrom · 29/09/2026 01:55

I find it frightening, see it as the thin end of the wedge. The boundaries will change.

That poor child could surely have been kept comfortable without effort to keep alive, then died naturally. There was no need to have the little one 'put down'. What next, disabled, mentally incompetent?

Jane3212 · 29/09/2026 01:53

BansheeOfTheSouth · 29/09/2026 01:29

In many countries you can in fact sell a child. Some are sold into marriage. There are people in this country who have bought children. Surrogacy is another issue not for this thread but it is precisely selling/buying babies to order.

I know that, but my point is , at least here, that's widely understood to not be ethical...unless it's surrogacy. I agree with you about that...surrogacy should not happen, it's wrong in so many ways. However, at least paid surrogacy is illegal here.

SidewaysOtter · 29/09/2026 01:50

ClaudettedeBeauvoir · 28/09/2026 23:22

I can completely understand that there are multiple feminist perspectives on assisted dying, but specifically GC? I can't see how this is an issue linked to being GC.

We discuss all sorts of things in here. Nothing is stopping anyone else coming in and joining the conversation but when FWR became the “naughty step” (ie feminists who wanted to discuss gender issues found ourselves unpopular with feminists who didn’t, so this board was hived off separately) it became a sub-community in itself. So yes, we discuss things here that possibly overlap with other sub-boards, partly because there is a feminist angle and partly because a lot of us like the nuanced discussions that happen here rather than, say, AIBU.

OP can post what she likes, there isn’t a rule which says a topic on subject X has to go in X sub-board. No one has to justify a post being here rather than anywhere else.

BansheeOfTheSouth · 29/09/2026 01:29

Jane3212 · 29/09/2026 00:25

But children are humans, not pets. We sell puppies and kittens, you can't sell a child, among other differences.

I'm not sure what I think about this- but I do think the euthanasia of a young human should not be compared to euthanising a pet.

In many countries you can in fact sell a child. Some are sold into marriage. There are people in this country who have bought children. Surrogacy is another issue not for this thread but it is precisely selling/buying babies to order.

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 01:02

Justbrieme · 28/09/2026 20:35

All of this. There is a sense in modern medicine that preserving life no matter the quality of life in extremely medically invasive ways is the ethical thing to do. I don’t see how we arrived at this place.

Edited

But most medical people themselves would not like the same level of intervention. At least, the ones I know.

PowerRangerGoGo · 29/09/2026 00:40

Heartbreaking for the parents the child and all involved, I certainly wouldn't judge

Lexibletheflexible · 29/09/2026 00:36

Jane3212 · 29/09/2026 00:25

But children are humans, not pets. We sell puppies and kittens, you can't sell a child, among other differences.

I'm not sure what I think about this- but I do think the euthanasia of a young human should not be compared to euthanising a pet.

What is showing is that we offer that compassion to a suffering animal, even though we buy and sell them as property. So it makes no sense that we don't offer that same compassion to humans who have personhood. We let them have horrific but natural deaths.

Mistyglade · 29/09/2026 00:35

Koalapalm · 28/09/2026 23:53

Should we stop all intervention that could go wrong? That could result in pain and suffering? Because sometimes they result in that?

Lots of people are alive - and well - today solely because of invasive intervention, at any age. Not all of it was painless or complication-free at the time.

should we have guidelines that say X age, Y diagnosis, Z complications should all be assumed to have the same outcome? And no intervention needed in case they suffer?

To be honest I’m not sure blanket statements are helpful in this situation, my comment was on this particular case. DS was a v high risk pregnancy as I have complex health issues and lost a previous baby in labour or mc.

I remain eternally grateful for every physician who helped us and I was fortunate to be under the care of one of the countries leading obstetrics expert in my rare condition. She was and is our God, she literally made the impossible possible.

My ex’s GM commented that she didn’t think people should have babies unless it’s straightforward or words to that effect which I thought was almost evil at the time.

Individual types of cases deserve their own unique treatment or judgement I guess.

Jane3212 · 29/09/2026 00:26

Koalapalm · 28/09/2026 23:53

Should we stop all intervention that could go wrong? That could result in pain and suffering? Because sometimes they result in that?

Lots of people are alive - and well - today solely because of invasive intervention, at any age. Not all of it was painless or complication-free at the time.

should we have guidelines that say X age, Y diagnosis, Z complications should all be assumed to have the same outcome? And no intervention needed in case they suffer?

This

Jane3212 · 29/09/2026 00:25

Booboobagins · 28/09/2026 23:16

How sad.

That poor child and their family.

I cant comment on if it was right or not, but we euthanise our pets if they are in pain, have poor quality of life etc, so if feels right to be as kind to a young child.

But children are humans, not pets. We sell puppies and kittens, you can't sell a child, among other differences.

I'm not sure what I think about this- but I do think the euthanasia of a young human should not be compared to euthanising a pet.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 29/09/2026 00:04

I was born three months prematurely at 28 weeks in 1981, weaned off heroin and given world class NICU care with the last available bed in King's College hospital. I've been incredibly lucky to survive, and was called a "miracle of modern paediatric care " by the leading paediatric consultant at that time, Harold Gamsu.

I'm fully aware of the fsct my high frequency hearing loss from all my prematurity meant I got off lightly. That poor littld soul whose life was so hard wasn't so fortunate was perhaps spared a lifetime of suffering.

I have to say, very often, (and obviously I'm quite biased!), tiny babies deserve a fighting chance, but not at the expense of their quality of life forever. Those are things that I believe matter most.

dutchyoriginal · 29/09/2026 00:00

SpidersAreShitheads · 28/09/2026 22:38

I'm extremely wary of the implementation of assisted dying for all the reasons that PP have mentioned, with vulnerable people being disproportionately conditioned/coerced into accepting it as the best option.

Obviously this is a different situation as we're talking about a toddler but I think there needs to be extreme care in deciding to end another person's life. I'm not quite sure who gets to decide what quality of life is good enough, and what isn't.

In this case it would seem that there was an element of doctor shopping. From what I understand, the first doctor and the parents thought euthanasia was the right option, but the independent doctor who was asked to review the case didn't agree. They concluded that "reasonable alternatives" for treatment hadn't yet been exhausted and believed that the condition could be brought under control. As the second doctor didn't agree, an opinion from another doctor was sought and they agreed with the first, so euthanasia was signed off.

I really do understand the need for compassion when we're talking about the limit of another person's suffering, but to end the life of a young child I think there needs to be absolutely no doubts and even then it makes me feel uncomfortable because as above, who gets to decide when suffering is too much? And when a doctor is giving examples of treatments that haven't yet been tried, is it OK just to ignore that because it doesn't suit when you want?

I think it's an incredibly slippery slope when we're deciding whether another person's life has value, and even more so when you're talking about a child with a non-terminal diagnosis. It's veering uncomfortably close to eugenics for me.

As I've seen the point about the different opinion of the second doctor multiple times in this thread, I've checked some of the Dutch coverage. If you paste the link below in google translate, you can find more details of what the doctors did. The first set of second opinion drs. had suggested different anti epilepsy drugs, but apparently taking these caused the child more suffering due to side effects than the original drugs. The child had multiple attacks per day, in addition to its other symptoms and disabilities.
Additionally, they consulted a professor of childrens palliative care, who says in this article that both starvation and palliative sedation can fail in children, leading to increased suffering.

Comparing the Mirror article and the Dutch article from NOS/Nieuwsuur (reputable "Dutch BBC" current affairs programme), some nuances seemingly were lost in translation.

https://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2630308-arts-handelde-zorgvuldig-bij-actieve-levensbeeindiging-peuter

'Arts handelde zorgvuldig bij actieve levensbeëindiging peuter'

Sinds 2024 bestaat er een regeling om het leven van een kind tussen de 1 en 12 jaar, dat ondraaglijk en uitzichtloos lijdt, actief te beëindigen.

https://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2630308-arts-handelde-zorgvuldig-bij-actieve-levensbeeindiging-peuter

Koalapalm · 28/09/2026 23:53

Mistyglade · 28/09/2026 23:11

indeed, I wish more people think like you.

Should we stop all intervention that could go wrong? That could result in pain and suffering? Because sometimes they result in that?

Lots of people are alive - and well - today solely because of invasive intervention, at any age. Not all of it was painless or complication-free at the time.

should we have guidelines that say X age, Y diagnosis, Z complications should all be assumed to have the same outcome? And no intervention needed in case they suffer?

OtterlyAstounding · 28/09/2026 23:53

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:07

Modern medicine has gone too far in some cases. Pushing the boundaries of viability can sometimes result in prolonged suffering or severe complications. Extremely premature babies must undergo highly invasive procedures which cause pain and suffering.

I agree. It really has gone much too far.

NameChange0101010101 · 28/09/2026 23:53

Constantrunner · 28/09/2026 22:08

If there is no hope of recovery that would be reasonable.

Reasonable to kill someone who can't consent?

shuggles · 28/09/2026 23:45

Assisted dying might be the trickiest ethical issue I can think of. When it involves children, that's a level beyond even that.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 28/09/2026 23:32

BobbleBear · 28/09/2026 19:52

Is there a feminist perspective on assisted dying?

Yes. Of course there is.

mybiggreenfrog · 28/09/2026 23:31

EntirelyUnnecessary · 28/09/2026 20:08

OP has a long history of plopping random articles here with no obvious connection to feminism, offering no feminist angle or insight herself and then being rather aggressive in tone to anyone who questions why the thread has been put here.

I wouldn't mind if OP was providing any kind of angle or opener for a discussion, but the plopping of random articles without more is very unhelpful.

I think she just wants to discuss interesting articles with feminists rather than women in general

LivelyGreyShark · 28/09/2026 23:30

I witnessed a horrible, prolonged and painful death of a close relative so I don't say this lightly but how do we know, how on earth can the doctors in the Netherland possibly know that this child's quality of life would never ever improve - there are clinical trials and scientific breakthroughs happening all the time. Millions if not billions worldwide are being poured into using AI to help us discover things faster from existing research. I personally think there should be a wider decision making process - possibly a European medical council or court.

fuschiaproudparrot · 28/09/2026 23:22

Pollyanna87 · 28/09/2026 22:07

Some people seem to forget there’s a difference between allowing someone to die, and actively killing them. Euthanasia for a two year old is monstrous and Final Solution-esque.

Have you witnessed someone being allowed to die?

ClaudettedeBeauvoir · 28/09/2026 23:22

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 20:04

I dont have any answer. The whole point of a forum is to be able to discuss issues, news or whatever with a group of people, in this instance GC feminists.

I have already informed you that because there were a number of threads about euthanasia on FWR with many commenting from the perspective of women, feminism, I thought there would be the same interest in this case.

If you dont believe that, or share that point of view I cant make you.

More importantly why would you take the time to try and stop a discussion because you dont agree with it being discussed.

I can completely understand that there are multiple feminist perspectives on assisted dying, but specifically GC? I can't see how this is an issue linked to being GC.

Booboobagins · 28/09/2026 23:16

How sad.

That poor child and their family.

I cant comment on if it was right or not, but we euthanise our pets if they are in pain, have poor quality of life etc, so if feels right to be as kind to a young child.

Mistyglade · 28/09/2026 23:11

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:07

Modern medicine has gone too far in some cases. Pushing the boundaries of viability can sometimes result in prolonged suffering or severe complications. Extremely premature babies must undergo highly invasive procedures which cause pain and suffering.

indeed, I wish more people think like you.

BluebellsRoses · 28/09/2026 23:09

kxeil · 28/09/2026 20:35

The cut off for treating very premature babies has dropped significantly over recent decades. Perhaps this wasn’t a good idea?

Did you read the post you responded to? I think your response is so tactless, so maybe you misread it. She said her child was born very early, would've died without intervention, and that he is fine. And @kxeil you said effectively "well doctors shouldn't have intervened". 🤦🏼‍♀️

I'm so glad that your son is okay @thisismeithinkorisit 💐♥️.

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 23:04

C152 · 28/09/2026 21:04

That may be a fair point. But 'unlikely' is not something I'd want to risk when it comes to my child's suffering. How is extending suffering and directly causing harm through the withdrawal of support (or forced support when it will clearly have little if any positive outcome) better than immediately ending the suffering?

Withdrawal of life support is not directly causing harm.

If a child is being kept alive by heroic medical effort then withdrawing support is simply letting them go.

'immediately ending the suffering' is something else. It's actively killing a child. As I said previously, it's easy to make a case that for this particular child that was a good thing to do, but what we are discussing here really is whether we should change the law in the UK and any change in the law will affect all of us.

The recent failed bill would have legalised AD for adults with capacity to consent who had less than 6 months to live. Many of us have been warning about a slippery slope of widening criteria and we are continually presented with handwavy arguments that of course there will be lots of safeguards and there's no reason to think we'll end up like Canada or the Netherlands or Belgium.

But the threads are full of people arguing for AD for people who do not have a terminal illness or who do not have capacity to consent, or people with MH issues, or people who don't want to be a burden, or people who don't want their children's inheritance eaten up by care home fees.

This thread has presented a new one to me - AD for people without capacity to consent whose relatives do not want to be carers.

The more of these arguments I read, the harder my 'No' becomes.