Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 12:25

MarieDeGournay · 29/09/2026 10:27

This is an important point, but it's also worth pointing out that quality of life [self-assessed by a mentally competent person] is about more than pain.
Its important to say that because the anti-choice side often quote good hospice care [which everyone supports] and pain control as an argument against the need for assisted dying.

There are uncontrollable symptoms other than pain which, after decades of suffering, can make life unbearable to a mentally competent person, especially when combined with other conditions which worsen with age.

A person who is not terminally ill may reach a point after decades of endurance of suffering from an accumulation of conditions, and facing failing general health, where they say
'Enough. I can't go on. I've fought the good fight and made the best of my life. No more endurance left.'

Hospice care, when they may in fact stay alive for a long time, and pain control, when pain is not the deciding factor, are not useful or relevant to people in this situation.

This is a really good point, and one which I admit I hadn't previously considered. Pain isn't the only factor.

However I stand by my previous point that inevitable death doesn't necessarily mean inevitable suffering. Even though pain medication sometimes isn't enough, its important I think to appreciate the nuance. Its not either/or - either excellent hospice care where you can have a happy and pain free end to your days, or a drawn out agonising death.

Its important to consider the multitude of experiences in the middle, and to legislate carefully (if only it were that easy!)

Bobbymoore123 · 29/09/2026 12:24

Lomonald · 28/09/2026 19:44

I don't see how euthanasia of a toddler is a feminist issue I am not being goady i just would like to understand, it sounds like the child had a terrible prognosis and no real quality of life, i can't imagine being the parents who.decided to do this.

am I being a cynic in supposing that it's posted here because this board is a political seclusion and supports a certain kind of approach to political debate and validation?

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 12:02

ThreadGuardDog · 28/09/2026 21:04

Why would you look at things differently via feminism? Surely the only question here is whether this child is suffering and whether anything other than euthanasia is a viable alternative to end his suffering.

Edited

Because what is applied to children often gets expanded to women in our patriarchal society. Coercion into assisted dying as well as husbands or sons or mostly male doctors deciding to euthanise a vulnerable woman without consent is a real concern. It has already happened in Canada- there is at least one documented case with concerns being raised by scientists about the existence of other cases.

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 11:33

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 11:24

In much older people, I broadly agree. But death is never inevitable, however likely - and for children and younger/middle-aged people I think that’s the point.

If people can genuinely make the decision for themselves then I support that all the way. But making decisions about inevitability for others is a very slippery slope - the extreme outliers shouldn’t be caught up in assumptions.

Of course death can be inevitable for some children.

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 11:24

PollyNomial · 29/09/2026 10:08

"rather than making it easier to decide that death is the answer to the suffering around them."

When death is inevitably happening within a matter of weeks/days, no matter what interventions are attempted, it's not clear why prolonging the suffering is preferable and that it should be forced upon someone.

In much older people, I broadly agree. But death is never inevitable, however likely - and for children and younger/middle-aged people I think that’s the point.

If people can genuinely make the decision for themselves then I support that all the way. But making decisions about inevitability for others is a very slippery slope - the extreme outliers shouldn’t be caught up in assumptions.

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 11:18

thisismeithinkorisit · 29/09/2026 10:06

"keeping people alive when they're going to suffer horribly"

what's your threshold for suffering tho? this is why it's so hard. DS was ventilated at birth, filled with lines to keep him alive, ressused twice, fed via tubes until after an op at 2 weeks old, more weeks in hospital on high flow O2 and tube feeds. Is that too much suffering to have a now 11 yo who is doing well? or is it justified because we knows the outcome?

if a baby is born alive, then isn't it right to take reasonable steps to help them? and it's not just about gestation. plenty of parents have been refused help when their baby has been born because of a genetic issue.

or is it justified because we knows the outcome?

This is a really good point. We feel that keeping tiny babies alive and intervening when they are sadly very ill even after treatment was a mistake, that we shouldn’t have made that choice. But no one has a time machine, we cannot possibly know in the point of emergency which babies will die eventually, and which will survive and live their lives. And sometimes that treatment and intervention will take months or years, and may be pretty gruelling in places - yes. But if you ask those people if it was worth it you’ll find some (many? A portion? I don’t know) will say yes.

We can’t ethically refuse to treat all babies at a certain age/presentation because sometimes the outcome will be awful.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 10:43

@Error404FucksNotFound “make it easier to care for people with profound disabilities, rather than making it easier to decide that death is the answer to the suffering around them.”

There are some things that are worse than death. Extreme suffering is one of them.

MarieDeGournay · 29/09/2026 10:27

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 08:33

It doesn't always work though. You talk to any hospital pharmacist and they'll tell you that.

It's one of the moral dishonesties of some anti-euthanasia people. (Not all). People can have incredible amounts of painkillers and they still aren't enough.

This is an important point, but it's also worth pointing out that quality of life [self-assessed by a mentally competent person] is about more than pain.
Its important to say that because the anti-choice side often quote good hospice care [which everyone supports] and pain control as an argument against the need for assisted dying.

There are uncontrollable symptoms other than pain which, after decades of suffering, can make life unbearable to a mentally competent person, especially when combined with other conditions which worsen with age.

A person who is not terminally ill may reach a point after decades of endurance of suffering from an accumulation of conditions, and facing failing general health, where they say
'Enough. I can't go on. I've fought the good fight and made the best of my life. No more endurance left.'

Hospice care, when they may in fact stay alive for a long time, and pain control, when pain is not the deciding factor, are not useful or relevant to people in this situation.

PollyNomial · 29/09/2026 10:08

Error404FucksNotFound · 29/09/2026 09:51

If you are looking for a feminist perspective, here's one.

"I think there’s a specifically feminist issue here that gets missed when people boil it down to “compassion versus cruelty.”
Feminism has always asked us to look at power: who gets to make the decisions, whose needs get met, whose dependence is seen as worth supporting, and whose existence gets treated like an unbearable burden.
That’s why I’m really uncomfortable with euthanasia being extended to a child who can’t meaningfully consent. A two-year-old can’t say, “I want to die.” The decision has to be made by adults — the parents, the doctors and, ultimately, the legal and medical system. I’m not saying those adults are acting maliciously. If anything, they may be acting out of deep love and desperation. But good intentions don’t make the power imbalance disappear.
There’s also a gendered side to this. Women have historically been expected to do most of the unpaid caring for children and disabled family members. Feminism shouldn’t just accept a situation where the answer to impossible caring circumstances becomes, openly or not, ending the dependent person’s life.
The really uncomfortable question is: what would a genuinely feminist society give this family instead?
Would it offer enough respite care? Specialist nursing? Financial security? Suitable housing? Mental health support? Help around the clock? Proper disability services? Could the mother say, “I can’t do this anymore,” without that being turned into an argument that her child’s life itself is unbearable?
Those questions matter because there’s a massive difference between saying “this child is suffering and deserves exceptional palliative care” and saying “this child’s suffering means death is an acceptable medical solution.”
I’m also wary of the phrase “quality of life.” Disabled people have spent decades pushing back against the idea that a life with profound impairment must automatically be worth less. That doesn’t mean pretending severe suffering isn’t real — this child’s medical problems sound horrific. It just means we have to be very careful not to turn a judgement about someone’s suffering into a judgement about whether their life is worth continuing.
And you don’t have to think the parents were selfish or the doctor was cruel to have a feminist objection to the system. Feminism is partly about recognising that people can be loving and well-intentioned while still operating inside structures that protect and value some lives more than others.
For me, the strongest feminist principle here is: make it easier to care for people with profound disabilities, rather than making it easier to decide that death is the answer to the suffering around them.
That matters even more when the person at the centre of it is a child with no independent voice in the decision."
credit to co-pilot.

"rather than making it easier to decide that death is the answer to the suffering around them."

When death is inevitably happening within a matter of weeks/days, no matter what interventions are attempted, it's not clear why prolonging the suffering is preferable and that it should be forced upon someone.

thisismeithinkorisit · 29/09/2026 10:06

SapphireSeptember · 29/09/2026 04:48

Just read about a baby born at 21 weeks and wonder how far we as humans are going to push our luck keeping increasingly tiny babies alive. DS was born full term and needed oxygen, antibiotics and a feeding tube and it made me feel awful to see him upset. I couldn't imagine him being premature and all the things that go with that.

I don't know how I feel about euthanasia. It makes me uncomfortable, but so does keeping people alive when they're just going to suffer horribly.

"keeping people alive when they're going to suffer horribly"

what's your threshold for suffering tho? this is why it's so hard. DS was ventilated at birth, filled with lines to keep him alive, ressused twice, fed via tubes until after an op at 2 weeks old, more weeks in hospital on high flow O2 and tube feeds. Is that too much suffering to have a now 11 yo who is doing well? or is it justified because we knows the outcome?

if a baby is born alive, then isn't it right to take reasonable steps to help them? and it's not just about gestation. plenty of parents have been refused help when their baby has been born because of a genetic issue.

Sealedbidswoes · 29/09/2026 10:00

Lexibletheflexible · 29/09/2026 00:36

What is showing is that we offer that compassion to a suffering animal, even though we buy and sell them as property. So it makes no sense that we don't offer that same compassion to humans who have personhood. We let them have horrific but natural deaths.

But there is one significant difference - we don’t have anything like the same powers of alleviation in the veterinary world. Euthanasia is the only real end of life care we can offer our pets. For both practical and financial reasons, you can’t send them home with a syringe driver or admit them to a hospice to be cared for by specialist palliative nurses around the clock. I know sometimes this system fails humans, but for pets it’s not even an option.

Error404FucksNotFound · 29/09/2026 09:51

If you are looking for a feminist perspective, here's one.

"I think there’s a specifically feminist issue here that gets missed when people boil it down to “compassion versus cruelty.”
Feminism has always asked us to look at power: who gets to make the decisions, whose needs get met, whose dependence is seen as worth supporting, and whose existence gets treated like an unbearable burden.
That’s why I’m really uncomfortable with euthanasia being extended to a child who can’t meaningfully consent. A two-year-old can’t say, “I want to die.” The decision has to be made by adults — the parents, the doctors and, ultimately, the legal and medical system. I’m not saying those adults are acting maliciously. If anything, they may be acting out of deep love and desperation. But good intentions don’t make the power imbalance disappear.
There’s also a gendered side to this. Women have historically been expected to do most of the unpaid caring for children and disabled family members. Feminism shouldn’t just accept a situation where the answer to impossible caring circumstances becomes, openly or not, ending the dependent person’s life.
The really uncomfortable question is: what would a genuinely feminist society give this family instead?
Would it offer enough respite care? Specialist nursing? Financial security? Suitable housing? Mental health support? Help around the clock? Proper disability services? Could the mother say, “I can’t do this anymore,” without that being turned into an argument that her child’s life itself is unbearable?
Those questions matter because there’s a massive difference between saying “this child is suffering and deserves exceptional palliative care” and saying “this child’s suffering means death is an acceptable medical solution.”
I’m also wary of the phrase “quality of life.” Disabled people have spent decades pushing back against the idea that a life with profound impairment must automatically be worth less. That doesn’t mean pretending severe suffering isn’t real — this child’s medical problems sound horrific. It just means we have to be very careful not to turn a judgement about someone’s suffering into a judgement about whether their life is worth continuing.
And you don’t have to think the parents were selfish or the doctor was cruel to have a feminist objection to the system. Feminism is partly about recognising that people can be loving and well-intentioned while still operating inside structures that protect and value some lives more than others.
For me, the strongest feminist principle here is: make it easier to care for people with profound disabilities, rather than making it easier to decide that death is the answer to the suffering around them.
That matters even more when the person at the centre of it is a child with no independent voice in the decision."
credit to co-pilot.

C152 · 29/09/2026 09:41

PencilsInSpace · 28/09/2026 23:04

Withdrawal of life support is not directly causing harm.

If a child is being kept alive by heroic medical effort then withdrawing support is simply letting them go.

'immediately ending the suffering' is something else. It's actively killing a child. As I said previously, it's easy to make a case that for this particular child that was a good thing to do, but what we are discussing here really is whether we should change the law in the UK and any change in the law will affect all of us.

The recent failed bill would have legalised AD for adults with capacity to consent who had less than 6 months to live. Many of us have been warning about a slippery slope of widening criteria and we are continually presented with handwavy arguments that of course there will be lots of safeguards and there's no reason to think we'll end up like Canada or the Netherlands or Belgium.

But the threads are full of people arguing for AD for people who do not have a terminal illness or who do not have capacity to consent, or people with MH issues, or people who don't want to be a burden, or people who don't want their children's inheritance eaten up by care home fees.

This thread has presented a new one to me - AD for people without capacity to consent whose relatives do not want to be carers.

The more of these arguments I read, the harder my 'No' becomes.

My experience is that withdrawal of support did most certainly directly cause harm. The support was not allowing the mother to see her child and staff in the hospital being told not to feed the baby. They assumed it would take a day to die. It took two weeks. Two long weeks of suffering.

Kitte321 · 29/09/2026 09:30

I think we have to be very very careful here.
My nephew is severely disabled after contracting meningitis at 8 months old - now 3. He has so many challenges (brain damage, epilepsy, sight impairment) but is loved and his family are dedicated to him and giving him moments of joy amongst the hard times. That joy does shine through, tho I know they have times of feeling desperate too.

The thought of euthanasia in anything other than certain death makes me deeply uncomfortable when the person involved doesn’t have the capacity to make that choice. Quality of life is subjective and with early infant hood disabilities it is hard to know what the long term prognosis will be.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 08:33

It doesn't always work though. You talk to any hospital pharmacist and they'll tell you that.

It's one of the moral dishonesties of some anti-euthanasia people. (Not all). People can have incredible amounts of painkillers and they still aren't enough.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 08:29

SapphireSeptember · 29/09/2026 04:48

Just read about a baby born at 21 weeks and wonder how far we as humans are going to push our luck keeping increasingly tiny babies alive. DS was born full term and needed oxygen, antibiotics and a feeding tube and it made me feel awful to see him upset. I couldn't imagine him being premature and all the things that go with that.

I don't know how I feel about euthanasia. It makes me uncomfortable, but so does keeping people alive when they're just going to suffer horribly.

It makes me uncomfortable, but so does keeping people alive when they're just going to suffer horribly.

I think it's worth bearing in mind that 'no hope of recovery' does not necessarily equal 'suffer horribly'

We do have all kinds of palliative medication that can help keep dying people comfortable.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 08:19

I can't believe the belly aching about this original post being on the wrong board, not being a feminist issue, being the wrong tone, not being directional enough is still rumbling on.

Other threads are available!

The only complaints I've seen from the OP 'becoming upset about the direction it is taking' is the ones seemingly a little annoyed that she's being criticised for posting this subject, on this board. Seems a reasonable thing to be annoyed about. Women posting here don't owe anyone 'nice', 'kind' or whatever other tone policing term you want to use, or an in depth justification of why they are posting.

It all comes across as the usual tedious attempts to shut down discussion.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 08:18

Jane3212 · 28/09/2026 22:01

I don't want to derail, so I'm going to start a new thread, but this Dutch case re Iris Dekker seems very disturbing to me.

https://www.thefp.com/p/the-parents-who-let-their-daughter

How can we be sure her depression couldn't have been improved? She was only 19. On Reddit, some people are picking up on the mention of tranquillisers and thinking she was addicted. We don't have enough info but tranquillisers are known to affect mood.

https://www.reddit.com/r/DeepStateCentrism/comments/1tp8rwh/theparentswholettheirdaughterdiefreepress/

More info: https://news.sky.com/video/the-teenager-who-wanted-to-end-her-life-under-dutch-euthanasia-laws-13561925

Edited

There's a view in the Netherlands that people can make their own decisions and if they are well and consistently argued, that decision should be respected, even if it's a controversial or mistaken one.

It leads to a far more adult society imo. There are rules for bloody everything, but peoples' rights to their own pov and decision is far more respected. Even where death is concerned.

ArabellaScott · 29/09/2026 07:51

Feminism isnt a monolith. Any issue that affects women is relevant to feminism.

ArabellaScott · 29/09/2026 07:50

BobbleBear · 28/09/2026 19:52

Is there a feminist perspective on assisted dying?

There are several.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 07:48

BluebellsRoses · 28/09/2026 23:09

Did you read the post you responded to? I think your response is so tactless, so maybe you misread it. She said her child was born very early, would've died without intervention, and that he is fine. And @kxeil you said effectively "well doctors shouldn't have intervened". 🤦🏼‍♀️

I'm so glad that your son is okay @thisismeithinkorisit 💐♥️.

I was replying to @NotrialNodeal

Whether to initiate, withhold, or withdraw medical treatment for critically ill or extremely premature babies is a profound ethical question that weighs the potential for survival against the risk of severe, lifelong suffering and the burden of invasive medical interventions.

SpiderInMyShoe · 29/09/2026 05:51

SidewaysOtter · 29/09/2026 03:45

Why, @SpiderInMyShoe? We’re not a hive mind, a thread doesn’t need a direction assigned to it. Why isn’t it OK just to put something out there and let the discussion take its course, and posters add what they think rather than going with/against the “direction”?

I’m not saying other posters can’t have their own take on an issue. I’m saying that rather than the OP obliquely posting a link and then becoming upset at the direction a thread has taken, that she add some kind of statement about what she thinks at the very least.

SapphireSeptember · 29/09/2026 04:48

Just read about a baby born at 21 weeks and wonder how far we as humans are going to push our luck keeping increasingly tiny babies alive. DS was born full term and needed oxygen, antibiotics and a feeding tube and it made me feel awful to see him upset. I couldn't imagine him being premature and all the things that go with that.

I don't know how I feel about euthanasia. It makes me uncomfortable, but so does keeping people alive when they're just going to suffer horribly.

SidewaysOtter · 29/09/2026 03:45

Why, @SpiderInMyShoe? We’re not a hive mind, a thread doesn’t need a direction assigned to it. Why isn’t it OK just to put something out there and let the discussion take its course, and posters add what they think rather than going with/against the “direction”?

SpiderInMyShoe · 29/09/2026 03:03

SidewaysOtter · 29/09/2026 01:50

We discuss all sorts of things in here. Nothing is stopping anyone else coming in and joining the conversation but when FWR became the “naughty step” (ie feminists who wanted to discuss gender issues found ourselves unpopular with feminists who didn’t, so this board was hived off separately) it became a sub-community in itself. So yes, we discuss things here that possibly overlap with other sub-boards, partly because there is a feminist angle and partly because a lot of us like the nuanced discussions that happen here rather than, say, AIBU.

OP can post what she likes, there isn’t a rule which says a topic on subject X has to go in X sub-board. No one has to justify a post being here rather than anywhere else.

I agree that she can post what she likes, but it would be helpful if @IwantToRetire adds an accompanying statement in her OP that steers the thread in the direction she wishes, rather than becoming annoyed with people who obviously take it elsewhere. This happens so often.