Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
kxeil · 29/09/2026 14:41

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 13:50

Sorry, but they have pain relief even for a fetus in the womb and I live with chronic pain myself so I don’t believe the unending unendurable pain with no break and no hope is a reality of today.

Just because you don’t experience unending unendurable pain doesn’t mean other people don’t suffer from it.

In severe cases chronic pain becomes "intractable," meaning it does not respond well to standard medical treatments.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 14:31

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 13:50

Sorry, but they have pain relief even for a fetus in the womb and I live with chronic pain myself so I don’t believe the unending unendurable pain with no break and no hope is a reality of today.

You're wrong.

"It works for me so it works for everyone" isnt the way things are.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 14:24

NotrialNodeal · 29/09/2026 14:09

How you define humane will be different to how I define humane; this is why there is huge debate over whether euthanasia is actually 'humane'. Critics and supporters hold fundamentally different views on what constitutes moral and compassionate care at the end of life.

I would define humane as showing kindness care and sympathy especially when people are suffering. I would see euthanasia as a kindness in this case. It is a merciful way to stop severe, untreatable pain and suffering.

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 14:14

I am sorry for all you went through, ptsd is awful. I’m glad your son is doing well.

This isn’t a feminist issue. It’s a human issue.
I think this is both a feminist issue and a human issue.

NotrialNodeal · 29/09/2026 14:09

kxeil · 29/09/2026 13:56

@AlonsoMosley “I am very uncomfortable with the profound shift where now, doctors can kill.”

If it ends severe suffering isn’t it humane?

How you define humane will be different to how I define humane; this is why there is huge debate over whether euthanasia is actually 'humane'. Critics and supporters hold fundamentally different views on what constitutes moral and compassionate care at the end of life.

backformoreofthesame · 29/09/2026 14:03

You mean treat people like animals ?

kxeil · 29/09/2026 13:56

@AlonsoMosley “I am very uncomfortable with the profound shift where now, doctors can kill.”

If it ends severe suffering isn’t it humane?

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 13:51

MarieDeGournay · 29/09/2026 10:27

This is an important point, but it's also worth pointing out that quality of life [self-assessed by a mentally competent person] is about more than pain.
Its important to say that because the anti-choice side often quote good hospice care [which everyone supports] and pain control as an argument against the need for assisted dying.

There are uncontrollable symptoms other than pain which, after decades of suffering, can make life unbearable to a mentally competent person, especially when combined with other conditions which worsen with age.

A person who is not terminally ill may reach a point after decades of endurance of suffering from an accumulation of conditions, and facing failing general health, where they say
'Enough. I can't go on. I've fought the good fight and made the best of my life. No more endurance left.'

Hospice care, when they may in fact stay alive for a long time, and pain control, when pain is not the deciding factor, are not useful or relevant to people in this situation.

I can see your argument here @MarieDeGournay.

In this case though, I think that drugs should be self administered.

I am very uncomfortable with the profound shift where now, doctors can kill.

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 13:50

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 13:25

There's a very big difference between a child in an iron lung who is otherwise compos mentis and not in pain, and a child with a severe extremely painful condition that can't be cured @NullaEffugium
"We might one day possibly find something to help" is cold comfort to someone in unending pain and discomfort. When you are in intense physical pain, subjectively the future doesnt exist. All that exists is there here and now, lurching from one moment to the next, in agony. If there is objectively medically no hope of surcease it is an extreme cruelty of the worst sort to force someone to keep living.

Sorry, but they have pain relief even for a fetus in the womb and I live with chronic pain myself so I don’t believe the unending unendurable pain with no break and no hope is a reality of today.

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 13:44

In this case though, at 26 weeks, survival is 70-90%, only 10% end up with a severe disability (which includes deafness or blindness, which are severe but you can have a good life with).

This little one was very unlucky, but 26 weeks isn't on the edges of viability any more.

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 13:31

Dollymylove · 29/09/2026 13:15

Surely its unlikely for a 22 week foetus to survive?

In a good unit 25-35% survive to discharge. Obviously many (though not all) will have lifelong consequences.

But bear in mind there's a huge difference between 22+0 and 22+6.

Survival at 21 weeks is rare, but possible (earliest survivor is 21 weeks exactly, and he's doing well, though not without impact). The other side at 23 weeks, survival shoots to 55%.

Nincompoo · 29/09/2026 13:27

Weirdpig · 28/09/2026 20:30

I think this case absolutely raises feminist issues - both around the medical care provided for extremely premature babies and euthanasia of young children with a very poor prognosis.

The time that worried me most in my pregnancies was after 23 weeks, gradually easing off as the prognosis for a premature baby improves. I know there are many other ways that people end up with severely disabled children and not everyone feels the same about the possibility of a severely disabled child. For me, it was horrible to know that I would probably not have any say in whether medical treatment was offered and the outcome could completely change the course of my life. As unfair as it is, it would almost certainly have been my career that ended to become a carer, because I am a woman. I'd have been on mat leave and it quickly becomes the default to be the carer.

My son was very premature with a very poor prognosis and his medical team and DH and I very much had conversations about the level of intervention we should offer and we’re all in agreement that if he could have a good quality of life then we should try, if not we’d let him die peacefully. There was no pressure and the decision intimately sat with us as his parents.

He’s an adult now, and absolutely fine but the stress of that situation gave me PTSD and I was ill for a long time. It’s cruel to imagine that anyone, a parent especially, is making these decisions on a whim.

I don’t believe in life at any cost. Some people are kept alive long after it is the right thing to do. Some people have disabilities that are unimaginably awful and would be better off dead.

This isn’t a feminist issue. It’s a human issue.

NotrialNodeal · 29/09/2026 13:26

Dollymylove · 29/09/2026 13:15

Surely its unlikely for a 22 week foetus to survive?

A 22 week infant cannot breathe, feed, or regulate their body temperature outside the womb without immediate, advanced life support.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 13:25

There's a very big difference between a child in an iron lung who is otherwise compos mentis and not in pain, and a child with a severe extremely painful condition that can't be cured @NullaEffugium
"We might one day possibly find something to help" is cold comfort to someone in unending pain and discomfort. When you are in intense physical pain, subjectively the future doesnt exist. All that exists is there here and now, lurching from one moment to the next, in agony. If there is objectively medically no hope of surcease it is an extreme cruelty of the worst sort to force someone to keep living.

Dollymylove · 29/09/2026 13:15

Somethinggg · 29/09/2026 13:12

The variation between 22 weeks and 27 weeks 6 days is so colossal that I can't imagine anyone genuinely thinks they should be considered in exactly the same way when it comes to viability decisions. And indeed they're not.

Surely its unlikely for a 22 week foetus to survive?

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 13:14

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 13:01

I’ll just shelve my clinical experience…

Trying to avoid the question then.

Did you have clinical experience that makes the 100% fatal now survivable?

What you actually have to say about the illness I mentioned, for example?

What about CJD or other similar prion diseases with a 100% fatality rate. What would you say to parents with each child in the end stages of this?

If there are weeks away from death do you think this suddenly going to turn around heal?

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 13:14

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 12:57

You're deluded here.

If you've got a toddler with advanced cancer for example, they've run out of options for treatment, and their measuring survival in weeks, for example.

Lets take the example of DIPG for example. Around 4,000 kids a year (worldwide) are diagnosed with it, and around 4,000 kids die from it, because it's considered terminal on diagnosis. And yes there are outliers. One single outlier.

You've got a much higher chance of surviving rabies than this disease, and rabies is considered 'invariably fatal'.

It's also often pretty obvious whether your child is likely to be the one in a million outlier or not. I don't think anyone suggesting euthanasia on diagnosis for even inevitably terminal conditions, but at a point where the end is in sight and continued survival is torture.

If there is some clinical trial that offers hope, it's not going to be offered to the ones so ill their bodies wouldn't be able to cope with the treatment. There comes a time where death is an inevitability within a relatively short period of time.

Edited

I agree when death is weeks away, but that would be considered shortening palliative care. This toddler wasn’t terminally ill or approaching death, so it was euthanasia.

Somethinggg · 29/09/2026 13:12

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 12:42

As a separate point I don't think we can equate prem babies with all their potential with existing children with a severe disability, or with terminally ill adults. These are all different groups.

Prematurity is not particularly rare. Even just considering extremely premature babies (born from 22-28 weeks, rather than all before 37 weeks), there were over 3000 born in the UK in 2022 alone. These would have all needed special care. But only 1 in 10 of these would have a severe disability.

Should we have left them all to die when the majority could be saved and go on to live a good life?

https://www.tommys.org/pregnancy-information/premature-birth/premature-birth-statistics

The variation between 22 weeks and 27 weeks 6 days is so colossal that I can't imagine anyone genuinely thinks they should be considered in exactly the same way when it comes to viability decisions. And indeed they're not.

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 13:11

I don’t think modern medicine has gone too far, I think it hasn’t gone far enough yet.

It always starts with life saving and then it develops quality of life improvements over later years. Do you know the last child Polio victim who needed an iron lung to breath just passed away? Martha Lillard contracted polio in 1953 at age 5. She then lived until age 78, passing away this past June.

Initially medicine meant these children had to stay in the iron lung all the time except for a few minutes here and there for hygiene and nappy changes.

Later, they had better medication so these now young adults only needed to sleep in them at night and so their lives started. Then they developed other better, smaller and portable ventilators and ways to wean some off needing them.

Too late for them did we get a vaccine. But isn’t it good we didn’t look at this girl at age 5 and think, hm better to euthanise her. It was the desire to give her a better life that inspired the medical innovations that did in fact give her a chance for a long and full life- she married twice and had pet dogs, she painted and made friends.

If we look at children in similar states where current medicine isn’t there yet- we can well write them off and say god that’s awful how can anyone, much less a child live like that?

I think it’s better to push to have medicine go further and increase quality of life rather than give up, shrug our shoulders and put them to sleep.

If all the children with polio had been euthanised because modern medicine had nothing better to offer, we would never have developed the kind of ventilators that saved the lives of thousands from other lung infections. Even when it looks hopeless, we can’t know what could be done for a child next year or a few years later.

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind
Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind
Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind
ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 13:03

@MarieDeGournay really excellent post. I can think of one or two long term conditions which might become too much to bear after decades ... which ones were you thinking of?

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 13:01

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 12:57

You're deluded here.

If you've got a toddler with advanced cancer for example, they've run out of options for treatment, and their measuring survival in weeks, for example.

Lets take the example of DIPG for example. Around 4,000 kids a year (worldwide) are diagnosed with it, and around 4,000 kids die from it, because it's considered terminal on diagnosis. And yes there are outliers. One single outlier.

You've got a much higher chance of surviving rabies than this disease, and rabies is considered 'invariably fatal'.

It's also often pretty obvious whether your child is likely to be the one in a million outlier or not. I don't think anyone suggesting euthanasia on diagnosis for even inevitably terminal conditions, but at a point where the end is in sight and continued survival is torture.

If there is some clinical trial that offers hope, it's not going to be offered to the ones so ill their bodies wouldn't be able to cope with the treatment. There comes a time where death is an inevitability within a relatively short period of time.

Edited

I’ll just shelve my clinical experience…

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 12:57

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 12:31

Death is inevitable for all of us so in that sense you’re right. But even with the conclusion that they will most likely die, there is much variation on when. And there are always outliers.

You're deluded here.

If you've got a toddler with advanced cancer for example, they've run out of options for treatment, and their measuring survival in weeks, for example.

Lets take the example of DIPG for example. Around 4,000 kids a year (worldwide) are diagnosed with it, and around 4,000 kids die from it, because it's considered terminal on diagnosis. And yes there are outliers. One single outlier.

You've got a much higher chance of surviving rabies than this disease, and rabies is considered 'invariably fatal'.

It's also often pretty obvious whether your child is likely to be the one in a million outlier or not. I don't think anyone suggesting euthanasia on diagnosis for even inevitably terminal conditions, but at a point where the end is in sight and continued survival is torture.

If there is some clinical trial that offers hope, it's not going to be offered to the ones so ill their bodies wouldn't be able to cope with the treatment. There comes a time where death is an inevitability within a relatively short period of time.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 12:43

People nowadays seem afraid of death and often don’t like talking about it.

People in the past experienced death much more frequently in their daily lives. People died at home surrounded by relatives rather than in hospital environments, making the physical reality of dying and corpses a natural part of life.

Modern medicine has gone too far in some cases.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 12:42

As a separate point I don't think we can equate prem babies with all their potential with existing children with a severe disability, or with terminally ill adults. These are all different groups.

Prematurity is not particularly rare. Even just considering extremely premature babies (born from 22-28 weeks, rather than all before 37 weeks), there were over 3000 born in the UK in 2022 alone. These would have all needed special care. But only 1 in 10 of these would have a severe disability.

Should we have left them all to die when the majority could be saved and go on to live a good life?

https://www.tommys.org/pregnancy-information/premature-birth/premature-birth-statistics

Premature birth statistics

A preterm birth is one that happens before 37 weeks of pregnancy. Globally, more than 1 in 10 pregnancies will experience in preterm birth.

https://www.tommys.org/pregnancy-information/premature-birth/premature-birth-statistics

Koalapalm · 29/09/2026 12:31

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 11:33

Of course death can be inevitable for some children.

Death is inevitable for all of us so in that sense you’re right. But even with the conclusion that they will most likely die, there is much variation on when. And there are always outliers.