Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
NotrialNodeal · 29/09/2026 19:43

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 19:30

This is the report from the committee btw.
Poor little one

Click at the end for an English translation

https://www.lzalpkcommissie.nl/publicaties/oordelen/lk/2026/lk-2026-001

A very difficult read. May you rest in peace now dear child 🙏

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 19:40

Ah, thanks @Somuchgoo

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 19:30

This is the report from the committee btw.
Poor little one

Click at the end for an English translation

https://www.lzalpkcommissie.nl/publicaties/oordelen/lk/2026/lk-2026-001

Kirbert2 · 29/09/2026 19:17

monymonymony · 29/09/2026 18:44

Calling euthanasia is a bit misleading, from what I read the two year old was on life support from birth so actually they just decided to stop that

I believe the child had a tracheostomy which supports breathing but is also quite different to a standard ventilator.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 19:00

the actual translation is "actively ended" the life of the child. In Dutch, "euthanasia" is used only if you're over 12. Below that the phrase used is "actively ended"

The general meaning at one point in the article is that pediatric professor Eduard Verhagen says that stopping food / water can have negative side effects for the child, where you can worsen their suffering. And palliative care isn't so easy as it sounds in children, according to him.

They don't say exactly how the active ending of life was carried out. If it's like the people I knew who went for euthanasia (adults) it's done by drug infusion.

monymonymony · 29/09/2026 18:44

Calling euthanasia is a bit misleading, from what I read the two year old was on life support from birth so actually they just decided to stop that

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 18:27

Hospital pharmacists used to quietly up and up the doses to bring death faster in those end-stage situations sometimes. Don't know if they still do. And the problem was that it depended on the doctor, pharmacist and situation.

fuschiaproudparrot · 29/09/2026 17:54

Some people here obviously have never witnessed a death where someone is just " left to die" . They basically die from dehydration. It is horrific . They don't go peacefully. Yes they can be given pain relief and sometimes the " side effect" of that is death. Thank god for those doctors.

fuschiaproudparrot · 29/09/2026 17:50

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 16:10

And you think this is ok?

Doctors have to make decisions everyday based on availability and prognosis. One of the things they consider is giving a liver to someone who is an alcoholic - does that make sense when there are limited donations ? The doctor I heard pointed out to the patient that they as a team will make a decision about resuscitation as the likelihood of brain damage would be enormous. I imagine that was shocking to hear as the patient was in denial about her alcoholism.

Kirbert2 · 29/09/2026 17:47

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 16:35

💐
I have been there. Its fucking dreadful.

Me too.

Though slightly different as my son wasn't premature but had a serious illness when he was 8 and is now disabled due to some complications and wasn't initially expected to survive.

Which is something else to consider, not all children are born very poorly and/or medically complex. My son was healthy and then he wasn't, in the blink of an eye.

PencilsInSpace · 29/09/2026 17:35

C152 · 29/09/2026 09:41

My experience is that withdrawal of support did most certainly directly cause harm. The support was not allowing the mother to see her child and staff in the hospital being told not to feed the baby. They assumed it would take a day to die. It took two weeks. Two long weeks of suffering.

That sounds horrific, where did it happen? I can't imagine that would be lawful in the UK.

But I'm not talking about withdrawal of food or mum cuddles, I'm talking about withdrawal of treatment - drugs, breathing support etc. Sorry if I was unclear.

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 17:35

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 17:03

Have you been following the UK assisted dying Bill in the news?

Some similar safeguards were proposed but the details didn't really work.

Its really difficult for doctors to predict how long someone has left and they frequently get it wrong.

Judges do not have any specialist knowledge in this area. In areas where they have no specialist knowledge they defer to experts (eg family courts and CAFCASS). Therefore the judge would just be rubber stamping the doctors decision. Many judges are unlikely to be happy at having to make decisions about ending someone'slife - that's outwith their current job spec. UK courts are in crisis with delays of months even years. This would add to that burden and likely lead to a delay of many months.

Why 3 months (6 months was proposed in the uk Bill)? That's not much time to get all the admin and checks in place for the procedure to take place, and not enough time to get the decision in front of a judge. Hardly seems worth it?

The proposal for ensuring the person is not being coerced was basically someone asking 'are you being coerced?' (tell me you know nothing about coercive control without telling me?)

I agree with the need for tight safeguards but pinning down exactly what they should be so that they are workable is going to be very difficult.

Absolutely I've been following the bill.

I think you're being unfair when assuming judges would rubber stamp this. Yes their decision will be based on evidence in the form of reports, but that's no different from other decisions judges will make. Judges make decisions on which they're not experts all the time, that's the entire point as an impartial judge.

Bear in mind that it's our judges who currently decide on disputes on treatment for those without capacity, including children, often for life and death decisions. It's not much of a stretch for a judge with experience in analyzing medical evidence as to whether a child's life support should be withdrawn, to whether a terminally ill young child should be euthanized. It's effectively the same decision albeit under a different legal framework.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 17:28

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 16:51

Do those facts about her husband matter though?

They don't change the facts that he asked doctors to euthanise his wife against her wishes, and 2 of them agreed and did it! It actually makes me feel physically sick that this could happen, and I don't think their sexes are irrelevant either.

Are you arguing that his extenuating circumstances made it ok for him to effectively take her life?

Where do you draw the line? And crucially, who is doing the drawing?

I am very uncomfortable with other people making that decision on another individuals behalf. Especially for their own benefit.

I can understand how the husband could have reached that point. I said in my post that the woman shouldn’t have died against her express wishes.

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 17:06

kxeil · 29/09/2026 16:45

People will consent to being killed. In this case the child’s parents would’ve consented.

‘Do not harm’ can often mean the opposite.

But you argued against yourself here - "people will consent to be killed" followed by the "in this case the child's parents would've consented" means that the child could not have given consent.

Pleas let me be clear though - I cannot imagine the pain of this family, I truly can't. I do not judge them at all.

But - the idea of euthanasia and the practice or implementation of it are very different things. It is rife with problems.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 17:03

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 16:49

That's not the definition of euthanasia, but involuntary euthanasia.

Where a person has capacity (even limited) it's obvious that euthanasia against their will is completely wrong.

Whether in the case of someone who lacks capacity (such as a toddler), someone else should make that decision for them is different. If allowed, then it needs to have the strictest conditions and safeguards possible to ensure that power is never abused.

For example, perhaps allowed if:

  • the person's projected lifespan is less than 3 months and there is no hope for survival. Agreed by 3 separate doctors
  • they are suffering physical or psychological distress which cannot be alleviated in any other way. Agreed by 3 separate doctors
  • they lack capacity to make the decision. Agreed by 3 separate doctors.
  • (in the case of those who lose capacity such as those who become ill or elderly), they have expressed a wish for euthanasia should this situation arise. Obviously doesn't apply to young children.
  • approval needed from a judge

Have you been following the UK assisted dying Bill in the news?

Some similar safeguards were proposed but the details didn't really work.

Its really difficult for doctors to predict how long someone has left and they frequently get it wrong.

Judges do not have any specialist knowledge in this area. In areas where they have no specialist knowledge they defer to experts (eg family courts and CAFCASS). Therefore the judge would just be rubber stamping the doctors decision. Many judges are unlikely to be happy at having to make decisions about ending someone'slife - that's outwith their current job spec. UK courts are in crisis with delays of months even years. This would add to that burden and likely lead to a delay of many months.

Why 3 months (6 months was proposed in the uk Bill)? That's not much time to get all the admin and checks in place for the procedure to take place, and not enough time to get the decision in front of a judge. Hardly seems worth it?

The proposal for ensuring the person is not being coerced was basically someone asking 'are you being coerced?' (tell me you know nothing about coercive control without telling me?)

I agree with the need for tight safeguards but pinning down exactly what they should be so that they are workable is going to be very difficult.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 16:51

kxeil · 29/09/2026 16:14

@NullaEffugium “her husband got tired of caring for her and put in an emergency request for MAiD on the basis of ‘carer fatigue’”

Her husband was very elderly. He did not receive support or professional caregiving relief because local healthcare authorities explicitly denied requests for hospice and palliative care.

Obviously she shouldn’t have died against her express wishes.

Do those facts about her husband matter though?

They don't change the facts that he asked doctors to euthanise his wife against her wishes, and 2 of them agreed and did it! It actually makes me feel physically sick that this could happen, and I don't think their sexes are irrelevant either.

Are you arguing that his extenuating circumstances made it ok for him to effectively take her life?

Where do you draw the line? And crucially, who is doing the drawing?

I am very uncomfortable with other people making that decision on another individuals behalf. Especially for their own benefit.

Somuchgoo · 29/09/2026 16:49

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 16:07

Again that’s not what I said or my attitude. Please do not use quotations when you’re not quoting someone.

You have demonstrated most aptly just how much you know and it’s not enough to ethically advocate for euthanasia of patients with chronic pain who are not terminal or dying. To be clear, euthanasia is when a doctor or relative decides someone else needs to die for their own good.

That's not the definition of euthanasia, but involuntary euthanasia.

Where a person has capacity (even limited) it's obvious that euthanasia against their will is completely wrong.

Whether in the case of someone who lacks capacity (such as a toddler), someone else should make that decision for them is different. If allowed, then it needs to have the strictest conditions and safeguards possible to ensure that power is never abused.

For example, perhaps allowed if:

  • the person's projected lifespan is less than 3 months and there is no hope for survival. Agreed by 3 separate doctors
  • they are suffering physical or psychological distress which cannot be alleviated in any other way. Agreed by 3 separate doctors
  • they lack capacity to make the decision. Agreed by 3 separate doctors.
  • (in the case of those who lose capacity such as those who become ill or elderly), they have expressed a wish for euthanasia should this situation arise. Obviously doesn't apply to young children.
  • approval needed from a judge
kxeil · 29/09/2026 16:45

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 16:35

I understand the dilemma but think that doctors should not be the assassins!

For me, the doctors role should end at the diagnostics in these cases, The moral shift in the medical profession is too great, where they can now kill as well as diagnose/treat/cure, and crucially, do no harm.

People will consent to being killed. In this case the child’s parents would’ve consented.

‘Do not harm’ can often mean the opposite.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 16:43

kxeil · 29/09/2026 16:25

Who are you to say that there is hope? Just because there is hope for you and you want to keep living, doesn’t mean other people feel the same way.

This is the problem I have with that poster. They think that because they have an answer for them, it ought to apply to everyone else.

Euthanasia is a very difficult topic, and there are things to weigh on each side. Canada has mishandled euthanasia. The Netherlands (so far) has not. Other countries have mostly not.

It's a dangerous and heavy thing to take responsibility for ending someone's life. If you do it, you've ended someone's life - for the best of reasons, in most cases. If you don't allow euthanasia, you condone the extreme pain and distress that a notable number of people live with, sometimes for decades, and reach the end of their life with. The fact that euthanasia involves someone taking action to end a life does to my mind make a difference, as opposed to passively allowing immense suffering (like that poster) There are no easy answers.

But it is dishonest to pretend that all suffering can be erased with medicine, it is cruel to pretend that hope exists in all cases and it is selfish and self-centred in the extreme to take the view that "because I can live with intense pain, so should everyone".

ClimbTheLadder · 29/09/2026 16:41

I find this a very hard case to comment on. I’m against assisted dying as I don’t think it’s possible to put in sufficient safeguards that people would never be coerced into agreeing.

But my heart goes out to this poor child and their parents and how heart breaking it must have been to see their child in great pain. I don’t think I could have made that same decision if I’d been in their place and I would have preferred not to have had the option but I can’t judge someone who made that decision.

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 16:41

kxeil · 29/09/2026 15:31

@NullaEffugium As a consenting adult, no one is going to kill you against your will. The child in this case couldn’t consent so doctors and family did what they thought was best for him. The child had a severely compromised quality of life.

Everyone on this planet will die one day. Keeping people alive at all costs is cruel.

Edited

As a consenting adult, no one is going to kill you against your will.

Are we sure about that? I mean the horror stories coming out of Canada indicate that it is exactly people like the poster who are now getting targeted, as in - you are too expensive to treat over the long term - how about this solution?

AlonsoMosley · 29/09/2026 16:35

kxeil · 29/09/2026 13:56

@AlonsoMosley “I am very uncomfortable with the profound shift where now, doctors can kill.”

If it ends severe suffering isn’t it humane?

I understand the dilemma but think that doctors should not be the assassins!

For me, the doctors role should end at the diagnostics in these cases, The moral shift in the medical profession is too great, where they can now kill as well as diagnose/treat/cure, and crucially, do no harm.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 16:35

Nincompoo · 29/09/2026 13:27

My son was very premature with a very poor prognosis and his medical team and DH and I very much had conversations about the level of intervention we should offer and we’re all in agreement that if he could have a good quality of life then we should try, if not we’d let him die peacefully. There was no pressure and the decision intimately sat with us as his parents.

He’s an adult now, and absolutely fine but the stress of that situation gave me PTSD and I was ill for a long time. It’s cruel to imagine that anyone, a parent especially, is making these decisions on a whim.

I don’t believe in life at any cost. Some people are kept alive long after it is the right thing to do. Some people have disabilities that are unimaginably awful and would be better off dead.

This isn’t a feminist issue. It’s a human issue.

💐
I have been there. Its fucking dreadful.

NameChange0101010101 · 29/09/2026 16:31

Somethinggg · 29/09/2026 13:12

The variation between 22 weeks and 27 weeks 6 days is so colossal that I can't imagine anyone genuinely thinks they should be considered in exactly the same way when it comes to viability decisions. And indeed they're not.

Well yes, of course. I didn't say they were?

However, statistics tend to only be provided for 3 categories: sub 28 weeks, 28-32 weeks and 33-37 weeks.

28 weeks is not the same as 32 weeks, either. But that's the information that is available.

Feel free to provide more detail if you like.

PPs have argued for not treating preterm babies because some babies don't have good outcomes and they might suffer. No further suggestions have been made for how this might apply in practice.

I do not subscribe to this viewpoint and was attempting to provide a bit more detail and nuance to flesh out my argument, including the number of babies this might actually apply to. Its difficult to form reasonable arguments in the absence of information.

When treatment for prem babies is given, the best interests of the individual child is always considered, its not a blanket blunt rule of 'we do x at 25 weeks but we don't at 24'. Individual babies of the same gestation vary in weight, development and illnesses.

And as we found out during the 3 1/2 months my son spent in special care, doctors rarely agree with each other. Its never clear cut.

kxeil · 29/09/2026 16:25

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 15:20

And there is no hope? No research into other means of pain relief? A friend of mine also has chronic pain and is in a wheelchair, she finds hydro therapy at a heated pool to be really helpful. Who are you to say there is no hope?

Who are you to say that there is hope? Just because there is hope for you and you want to keep living, doesn’t mean other people feel the same way.