Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Somuchgoo · 30/09/2026 13:43

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 13:32

Maybe, but not everyone agrees with that assessment...and as we have seen in countries which offer this 'route', the boundaries shift and people end up being 'assisted to die' who wouldn't have met the original criteria. Once you have crossed the Rubicon it is a slippery slope.

We've been on the slippery slope for a very long time.

In the UK a little boy like this would probably also be allowed to die, but rather than drifting off into a drug-induced coma and then dying, nutrition would be withdrawn and he'd starve, or next time he has an infection he wouldn't be given antibiotics. The end is the same, but they'd be more suffering.

I think I would like to allow full euthanasia, whilst allowing nutrition to be withdrawn, and potentially assisted suicide, is more about our own squeamishness about death rather than best interest of the patient.

We are fine with causing death, but we make artificial distinctions so that we don't feel like we are to blame. Withdrawing nutrition is fine because we aren't actively killing them. Removal of life support is fine, because although we hit the off switch, we tell ourselves we're not killing them we just aren't artificially keeping them alive any more. Then we've got the 'double effect' of morphine at the end where it's given for pain relief, but knowing it also might suppress breathing and hasten death.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 13:32

kxeil · 30/09/2026 10:29

In countries where euthanasia and assisted dying are legal, the State and third parties have chosen this route because they deem it ethical.

Edited

Maybe, but not everyone agrees with that assessment...and as we have seen in countries which offer this 'route', the boundaries shift and people end up being 'assisted to die' who wouldn't have met the original criteria. Once you have crossed the Rubicon it is a slippery slope.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 13:29

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2026 10:28

That relies on the patient having the capacity to request a DNR in the first place. This baby couldn’t have done that, and neither could someone with advanced dementia.

That is what 'Lasting Power of Attorney' is about - for when someone no longer has capacity to make decisions for themselves.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 13:26

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2026 10:28

That relies on the patient having the capacity to request a DNR in the first place. This baby couldn’t have done that, and neither could someone with advanced dementia.

No, it doesn't! I was recently asked about permission for a 'DNR' for my father who has dementia and is in a care home. He also has COPD, asthma and now repeated infections. Furtermore he is also immobile and dependent on assistance with dressing, toileting, and sometimes eating.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 13:12

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar “So much depends on the care situation or care home then. Some are appalling.”

This is why I think the Canadian model is better. In an ‘ideal world’ I would agree with you about having a model like the Dutch, but in the world we actually live in people need options. If people can’t get the care, housing and financial help they need, what do they do? Isn’t it better to at least have the choice to die by assisted dying or euthanasia?

Somuchgoo · 30/09/2026 12:55

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:49

Sorry, but you are describing assisted suicide, not euthanasia. All euthanasia is involuntary as it is a mercy killing and one of the exceptions to murder like killing in self defence.

No. You've got your definitions muddled up. If you don't believe me look it up.

The Netherlands has euthanasia, not assisted suicide, and had done so for a long time. Consent is an integral part of this. Around 120,000 people have died in the Netherlands via euthanasia, current rates are about 6% of deaths. Are you telling me the doctors are killing that number of people without their consent in the Netherlands?

Assisted suicide requires the person dying to perform the act. Whether that means swallowing pills, or drugs that will kill them, or pressing a button to allow drugs via a cannula to start. With assisted suicide, these drugs are provided by medical professionals and the person taking them is usually under medical supervision until their death.

With euthanasia, it's the medical professional that administers the drugs. It is always voluntary, with a couple of very well defined exceptions. The law we are discussing in this thread, is one g of those exceptions - a change to the law in the Netherlands to allow parents to make that decision on behalf of their suffering child.

In most cases assisted suicide is sufficient to allow those who want to die, to die. For people with locked in syndrome, for those with paralysis, those with most motor neurone disease, and other degenerative conditions, allowing assisted suicide but not euthanasia means they can either not be allowed to die, all would need to exercise their right to die earlier than they would otherwise do so because they would lose the ability to administer the drugs later.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 12:54

@SiberFox the problem is we don't have a crystal ball and can't know for sure which children will end up as adults with enough quality of life to count as satisfactory and which children won't.

We also don't know how matters will be for the severely disabled person once their parents pass. So much depends on the care situation or care home then. Some are appalling.

I think if euthanasia is brought in, all that can be done in this sort of situation is for the parents to make the best decision they can at the time and then to go on.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 12:46

@kxeil I think so on balance too .... but Im also in the crowd that has profound reservations about the way it would be carried out in the UK.

In the NL there is a functioning, though certainly not flawless, health system. (You struggle here to get an appointment in 3 days' time when it suits you because they want to see you the same day instead, I kid you not. Minor issue, m'leg wasn't hanging off or anything).

This means there is the funding for an independent, technically modern and well run euthanasia service.

I'd be very concerned if that would be the case in some NHS trusts.

Additionally, and this cuts more to the core of the matter, there is a culture that people know their own mind and their stated wishes should be respected. It is seen as absolutely unacceptable to override a competent someone's stated expressed wishes, if they are reasonable (or they made these wishes in the past when they were competent).

Im afraid to say that cultural mindset is not as clear in the UK. I would be afraid of coercion in some cases. I hope the safeguards would be strong enough, but I doubt it because at the point where someone is being coerced, a team would need to remove that person from the coercive situation and ensure good care for them. And there isnt the money for that.

But that does not alter the fact that some people live in excruciating agony, and on balance, I think that euthanasia / assisted dying should be legalised. But on the Dutch model, not the Canadian.

SiberFox · 30/09/2026 12:43

StellaAndCrow · 30/09/2026 11:50

Yes, I have met people like this as young adults. Severely physically and cognitively disabled, blind, can't sleep, agitated/shouting/screaming much of the time, multiple ongoing seizures, doctors trying their best to help with symptoms, and mums still doing everything they can.

I know there many people like you describe but that doesn’t apply to this child. Things can obviously change but for now he is mostly pain free, sleeps well and is an easy child apart from the psychical challenges of handling him. The important part also is he goes to school with 1:1 support and they get respite too. My friend is largely happy with her life. Could you predict that when he was 2 and constantly seizing? No.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 12:23

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar “The only excuse is simple ignorance, but when people who are against euthanasia consistently choose to ignore the actual reality of some people's lives, there is something deeply dishonest and wrong.”

I agree. Euthanasia should be legal in the UK for this reason. If people are severely suffering and can’t kill themselves, it would be humane to have euthanasia as an option.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 12:08

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:49

Sorry, but you are describing assisted suicide, not euthanasia. All euthanasia is involuntary as it is a mercy killing and one of the exceptions to murder like killing in self defence.

This is becoming laughable. Dear God.

Assisted suicide is where the medical staff provides the drugs and the patient self- administers.

Euthanasia is where the medical staff administer the lethal medicine.

There is voluntary euthanasia and involuntary euthanasia. The former is at the request of the person. The second is where it is forcibly applied.

@Somuchgoo was talking about where a person lacks capacity to judge for themselves. That means that others would be making the decision and administering the death-bringing medications.

So yes, she was talking about euthanasia.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 11:51

As for palliative care it is not the golden answer it is painted. I know personally of people for whom it did not work and they were screaming in agony but were told by the palliative team that nothing more could be done for them. There are many, many documented cases where people were begging to be allowed to die but were forced to die in agony and suffering.

This, and the plight of people who live in agony that is unmanageable, is my concern.

There is cruelty by action and cruelty by inaction.

Both are unforgivable. The only excuse is simple ignorance, but when people who are against euthanasia consistently choose to ignore the actual reality of some people's lives, there is something deeply dishonest and wrong.

StellaAndCrow · 30/09/2026 11:50

SiberFox · 29/09/2026 21:43

I have a friend with a severely disabled child as a result of birth trauma. He suffers from epilepsy that is resistant to medication and had periods of awful, continuous suffering - including his condition being made worse by some of the medication attempted. My friend is a PTSD sufferer because of that. The boy is now 8, over the past years his condition improved quite a lot - nobody knows why- where he goes months sometimes without seizures, and of course there are many other challenges as he is profoundly disabled, but he is one of the happier people I know. Always with a smile, curious and sociable, loves going to school and has friends there, loves ice cream and flowers.

Has it been worth the pain he’s experienced? I don’t know. It was fucking awful for his parents to live through. What if things haven’t changed for the better? But they have, and that’s the thing that bothers me about the NL case.

Saying with confidence that there is no hope for improvement and only endless suffering in the future is so much harder when a child is in question..

Edited

Yes, I have met people like this as young adults. Severely physically and cognitively disabled, blind, can't sleep, agitated/shouting/screaming much of the time, multiple ongoing seizures, doctors trying their best to help with symptoms, and mums still doing everything they can.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 11:45

Like most abled people, who don’t suffer from chronic pain, you are making assumptions about our quality of live and judgements as to whether our lives are worth living without ever walking in our shoes or even bothering to research medical conditions to ascertain the pain level and frequency or the treatments that do help.

and FYI, I receive carer's allowance for decades now because Im disabled. Legacy benefit.

But I dont have the soaring arrogance to assume that because I'm disabled, no one else can have an opinion on the matter or only mine is right.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 11:43

And you may find living with intense complex pain bearable enough to not want euthanasia, but others do not and you refuse to acknowledge or accept that.

Since you impose your position on others without respecting their experience, why, exactly, should they respect yours?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 11:40

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:59

That’s not euthanasia, that is assisted suicide. Stop conflating the two.

Do answer the point.

Junglejune · 30/09/2026 11:31

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:34

Sorry? When did I quote any statistics? I have said this happens and said there was one documented case and scientists are concerned there are others that have been swept under the carpet. This is fact.

What is also fact is that euthanasia is never self chosen because self chosen euthanasia does not exist. What you are calling self chosen euthanasia is actually called assisted suicide. So get your terminology correct.

And why are you so blasé about these murders? We abolished capital punishment because of only a handful of innocents were executed over decades, but you seem fine with abuse of assisted dying that results in what are billed as assisted suicide are actually euthanasia and murder but so far everyone involved in these few cases arent being prosecuted because the life of the person they took isn’t deemed valuable enough and the attitude is it was the humane thing to do even though that person did not want to die like that.

It is not about value. It is about whether life is bearable. It is medical staff that are assessing the level of quality of life which is extremely complex and does not relate to disability. If I was in constant pain AND had no quality of life then I would not want my life to be artificially prolonged. Because I am pretty sure that this child could not live without complex medical treatment. So we are not artificially killing someone we are allowing them to die naturally but the process is hastened to avoid further suffering. We are fed the myth that medicine can fix everything and we comfort ourselves with that but for some people life is simply not worth living.

I certainly don’t believe in pressure being brought to bear on disabled people to end their lives and you talk about ‘cases’ without giving any evidence that this is true. As for palliative care it is not the golden answer it is painted. I know personally of people for whom it did not work and they were screaming in agony but were told by the palliative team that nothing more could be done for them. There are many, many documented cases where people were begging to be allowed to die but were forced to die in agony and suffering.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 10:29

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 10:17

They have the option of suicide if they really want to die. It is quite a different matter involving third parties and the State in this - it brings up serious ethical questions.

Edited

In countries where euthanasia and assisted dying are legal, the State and third parties have chosen this route because they deem it ethical.

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2026 10:28

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 10:20

That is what 'Do Not Resucitate' arrangments are meant to recognise. If someone is in a prolonged or very serious condition and their heart stops then active interventions to resusitate cease. This is permitting an inevitable and natural death - but not actively bringing it about.

Edited

That relies on the patient having the capacity to request a DNR in the first place. This baby couldn’t have done that, and neither could someone with advanced dementia.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 10:20

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2026 10:11

We had exactly this conversation at work yesterday. I feel the same, whatever the age of the sick person.

As a nation we spend a lot of resources,
money, time, space, mental and physical effort looking after people who will never be able to enjoy anything like a reasonable standard of life, often to the detriment of the carers’ own lives and of those around them, and at huge cost that could arguably be better spent elsewhere.

That is what 'Do Not Resucitate' arrangments are meant to recognise. If someone is in a prolonged or very serious condition and their heart stops then active interventions to resusitate cease. This is permitting an inevitable and natural death - but not actively bringing it about.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 10:17

kxeil · 30/09/2026 09:23

Has it ever occurred to you some people might have had enough of living? Just because you have hope, some people want to die.

They have the option of suicide if they really want to die. It is quite a different matter involving third parties and the State in this - it brings up serious ethical questions.

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2026 10:11

BirdLandedonmyHead · 28/09/2026 19:52

Just because we can prolong life, doesnt always mean we should.

We had exactly this conversation at work yesterday. I feel the same, whatever the age of the sick person.

As a nation we spend a lot of resources,
money, time, space, mental and physical effort looking after people who will never be able to enjoy anything like a reasonable standard of life, often to the detriment of the carers’ own lives and of those around them, and at huge cost that could arguably be better spent elsewhere.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 09:23

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:38

There is hope for anyone not terminally ill who suffers from chronic pain. I’m not talking about people in the end stages of fatal diseases.

Has it ever occurred to you some people might have had enough of living? Just because you have hope, some people want to die.

anyolddinosaur · 30/09/2026 09:20

The doctors in this case disagreed about whether the child was suffering badly at that time but there was no doubt the child had suffered a great deal and was going to go on suffering. Children should not have to suffer torture.

NullaEffugium · 30/09/2026 08:59

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 29/09/2026 20:39

Surely in the 99.9% of cases where euthanasia is at the person's wish, their own consistent stated wishes should be respected?

That’s not euthanasia, that is assisted suicide. Stop conflating the two.