Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 15:16

There's also the question that would a really civilised society allow people to endure in agony when they don't wish to?

kxeil · 30/09/2026 15:10

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:52

That is a hypothetical question. Feelings don't work in that way. Who knows how one would feel or what one might consider in any given situation. Feelings shift and change in response to the environment, to circumstances or to the time of day.I don't think this is a question of personal feelings anyway. As I've suggested..I think there are deeper ethical questions about boundaries that anyone in a civilised society must ponder. I don't think individual desires trump everything else.

Edited

We need to face facts. If there is no money and no care available, an alternative like MAID would give people a choice. This is the society we live in right now. I’ve mentioned it before but Adult Social Care is collapsing fast.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 15:09

It isn't a hypothetical question for some people, @Shortshriftandlethal

The numbers of homeless people on the streets of the UK are increasing. Since they are a block of people, they count as part of society.

Actually, euthanasia really IS, centrally, about the individual's desire to live or not. There is a societal aspect to it, but euthanasia is absolutely about each individual.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:52

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:48

If you found yourself in a position where you needed care, but you had no family or friends to help and you couldn’t find carers or couldn’t afford care, would you want to die alone suffering or have the option of being killed?

That is a hypothetical question. Feelings don't work in that way. Who knows how one would feel or what one might consider in any given situation. Feelings shift and change in response to the environment, to circumstances or to the time of day.I don't think this is a question of personal feelings anyway. As I've suggested..I think there are deeper ethical questions about boundaries that anyone in a civilised society must ponder. I don't think individual desires trump everything else.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:52

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:46

Some controversial cases from the Netherlands

1. The 2016 Dementia / Sedated Patient Trial

  • The Case: A 74-year-old woman with severe Alzheimer’s disease had previously written an advance euthanasia directive (AED) stating she wanted to die "when I want to," but also wrote that she could not decide at that moment. When the doctor proceeded with euthanasia, he slipped a sedative into her coffee because she was agitated, and her family had to hold her down as she resisted the injection.
  • The Controversy: This marked the first time a criminal investigation was opened against a doctor under the 2002 law. In 2019, the court [The Hague] acquitted the doctor of all charges, ruling he acted lawfully and honored a valid prior written request, noting that severe dementia removes the capacity to re-verify consent. Critics, however, raised alarms about overriding active resistance from a dementia patient.

2. Psychiatric Suffering and Young Adults (Aurelia Brouwers and Zoraya ter Beek)

  • Aurelia Brouwers (2018): The 29-year-old died via doctor-administered lethal medication after a long history of severe depression, borderline personality disorder, and chronic suicidality, despite having no terminal physical illness.
  • Zoraya ter Beek (2024): The 29-year-old received approval for assisted dying after a multi-year evaluation process for chronic depression, autism, trauma, and anxiety.
  • The Controversy: These cases sparked fierce international debate over whether psychological suffering should qualify for euthanasia. Critics argue that severe mental distress can be treatable or improve over time, and that granting euthanasia risks normalizing or encouraging suicide for psychiatric patients. Proponents maintain that mental suffering can be just as hopeless and unbearable as physical disease, which the Dutch Supreme Court acknowledged in the landmark 1994 Chabot case

I remember reading Zoraya ter Beek (2024)
I actually didn’t have a problem with her choosing to die, living was causing her immense suffering. If someone wants to die, that is their choice. Death is inevitable for all of us.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:51

Yes. Those are controversial cases.

In both cases the patients had, clearly, stated their wishes. In one case when in her right mind. In one case when suffering severe long term psychological distress, and she stated over the ling term she wished to die.

Particularly the first case is uncomfortable, agreed. So is the situation where there is extreme unendurable pain.

There aren't easy answers to everything, and whether euthanasia is legal used or not -some- situations will be highly uncomfortable. I dont think that can be escaped.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:48

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:35

Yes, some States have, but that doesn't necessarily mean that there are no longer any ethical issues to be debated or considered, nor any breaching of safeguards and boundaries in those territories.. Inevitably there will be.

If you found yourself in a position where you needed care, but you had no family or friends to help and you couldn’t find carers or couldn’t afford care, would you want to die alone suffering or have the option of being killed?

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:46

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:41

You're asking questions that highly intelligent trained ethecists have thrashed out for years to find a working system in the NL.

I think there would need to be a set of guidelines created in the UK. It would be sensible to take Dutch and other functioning societies' modus operandi into account.

In a way this child's case was relatively clearcut (relatively) because the cognitive development was so poor.

More uncertain and marginal cases are where it becomes harder. All I can say is that I think doctors' assessments and the parents' wishes should be taken into account, but that euthanasia is not out of the question. Nor should it be standard. There could be guidelines where there are enough of a type of case, but even so decisions would need to be made individually.

Some controversial cases from the Netherlands

1. The 2016 Dementia / Sedated Patient Trial

  • The Case: A 74-year-old woman with severe Alzheimer’s disease had previously written an advance euthanasia directive (AED) stating she wanted to die "when I want to," but also wrote that she could not decide at that moment. When the doctor proceeded with euthanasia, he slipped a sedative into her coffee because she was agitated, and her family had to hold her down as she resisted the injection.
  • The Controversy: This marked the first time a criminal investigation was opened against a doctor under the 2002 law. In 2019, the court [The Hague] acquitted the doctor of all charges, ruling he acted lawfully and honored a valid prior written request, noting that severe dementia removes the capacity to re-verify consent. Critics, however, raised alarms about overriding active resistance from a dementia patient.

2. Psychiatric Suffering and Young Adults (Aurelia Brouwers and Zoraya ter Beek)

  • Aurelia Brouwers (2018): The 29-year-old died via doctor-administered lethal medication after a long history of severe depression, borderline personality disorder, and chronic suicidality, despite having no terminal physical illness.
  • Zoraya ter Beek (2024): The 29-year-old received approval for assisted dying after a multi-year evaluation process for chronic depression, autism, trauma, and anxiety.
  • The Controversy: These cases sparked fierce international debate over whether psychological suffering should qualify for euthanasia. Critics argue that severe mental distress can be treatable or improve over time, and that granting euthanasia risks normalizing or encouraging suicide for psychiatric patients. Proponents maintain that mental suffering can be just as hopeless and unbearable as physical disease, which the Dutch Supreme Court acknowledged in the landmark 1994 Chabot case
ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:46

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:40

I imagine there could be some doctors, like Harold Shipman or nurses Beverley Allit or Lucy Letby who may be quite motivated. And besides when it is normalised for some doctors to breach previous ethical boundaries about 'doing no harm' it casts serious questions over the whole medical profession and its role and its responsibilities.

Edited

This is a concern, but other countries do manage it.

Perhaps there could be a time limit on how long medics could serve on a euthanasia team.

..... if you really want to think outside the box, perhaps actually this would have been the perfect job for Shipman. After all, the patients in question are asking for euthanasia. dry humour

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:41

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:23

..and what of those that don't have the maturity or cognitive capacity to engage with what consitutes 'unbearable' and the wider ethical implications?

Withdrawing food and water goes beyond the remit of DNR - as that would represent more of an active intention to kill.

Edited

You're asking questions that highly intelligent trained ethecists have thrashed out for years to find a working system in the NL.

I think there would need to be a set of guidelines created in the UK. It would be sensible to take Dutch and other functioning societies' modus operandi into account.

In a way this child's case was relatively clearcut (relatively) because the cognitive development was so poor.

More uncertain and marginal cases are where it becomes harder. All I can say is that I think doctors' assessments and the parents' wishes should be taken into account, but that euthanasia is not out of the question. Nor should it be standard. There could be guidelines where there are enough of a type of case, but even so decisions would need to be made individually.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:40

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:31

The State chose to legalise assisted dying / euthanasia. Doctors freely choose if they want to participate.

I imagine there could be some doctors, like Harold Shipman or nurses Beverley Allit or Lucy Letby who may be quite motivated. And besides when it is normalised for some doctors to breach previous ethical boundaries about 'doing no harm' it casts serious questions over the whole medical profession and its role and its responsibilities.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:35

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:31

The State chose to legalise assisted dying / euthanasia. Doctors freely choose if they want to participate.

Yes, some States have, but that doesn't necessarily mean that there are no longer any ethical issues to be debated or considered, nor any breaching of safeguards and boundaries in those territories.. Inevitably there will be.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:31

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:14

Many people would say that ethics is not so much about individual desires and wants as about the moral boundaries of the entire community. None of us exists in a vacuum. If you want to commit suicide that is your decision, but involving others and the State is a different matter.

Edited

The State chose to legalise assisted dying / euthanasia. Doctors freely choose if they want to participate.

ScrollingLeaves · 30/09/2026 14:24

fuschiaproudparrot · 29/09/2026 17:54

Some people here obviously have never witnessed a death where someone is just " left to die" . They basically die from dehydration. It is horrific . They don't go peacefully. Yes they can be given pain relief and sometimes the " side effect" of that is death. Thank god for those doctors.

@fuschiaproudparrot is this called the Liverpool Pathway?

I feel muddled because when I have expressed my horror at people dying from dehydration, more medical people than I have said that if you give liquids that is horrific because they are not eliminated by the (dying) kidneys and so the lungs get full of water and it is like slow drowning. So I am confused about which of these horrors is worse.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:24

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:14

Many people would say that ethics is not so much about individual desires and wants as about the moral boundaries of the entire community. None of us exists in a vacuum. If you want to commit suicide that is your decision, but involving others and the State is a different matter.

Edited

Euthanasia by definition is a community/society matter I suppose, yes.

Equally, so is the tolerance of unbearable suffering.

Suicide is a messy and often unsuccessful business and attempts have a nasty trail of severely disabled people after them. Which also becomes a society matter.

I guess it comes down to the nature and how well run the society in question is, and where you (the generic you) stand when those three (or four, taking into account the state of the welfare system) are balanced.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:23

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:18

@Shortshriftandlethal in that particular case the doctors have more of an idea than us what constitutes unbearable suffering than us. The Professor was (according to the article) clear that withdrawing nutrition and water can work differently in children than adults though and the implication was, lead to unnecessary suffering.

As to competent people's definition of unbearable suffering, shouldn't that come down to their own decision? (Long term)

..and what of those that don't have the maturity or cognitive capacity to engage with what consitutes 'unbearable' and the wider ethical implications?

Withdrawing food and water goes beyond the remit of DNR - as that would represent more of an active intention to kill.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:18

@Shortshriftandlethal in that particular case the doctors have more of an idea than us what constitutes unbearable suffering than us. The Professor was (according to the article) clear that withdrawing nutrition and water can work differently in children than adults though and the implication was, lead to unnecessary suffering.

As to competent people's definition of unbearable suffering, shouldn't that come down to their own decision? (Long term)

kxeil · 30/09/2026 14:16

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:02

I do see what you're saying and think it's a valid argument, but I run into a quagmire here and can't find a way forward.

In a world with an increasing right wing creep, I'd be afraid that this option would be seen as desirable by some flavours of government and used to cut services further. And shelter and medical centres for long term homeless people where every time you go, you're asked if you'd like for this situation to come to an end via a specialised service - just no. I don't have faith that a government like that won't be elected.

And in practise with the Canadian model people have been pressured into assisted dying.

Honestly, personally in the UK's case I'm closer to the fence than I give the impression, because of the nature of the healthcare system. But the cruelty of forcing a loving partner to being a longed- for release to their spouse, or the cruelty of not allowing a safe death for someone who genuinely wants to die, tips the balance. Although I'll fight to the bitter end the utterly controlling and selfish "I can live with my pain so no one else should have the option for eithanasia" or "I'm afraid someone will tell me I should go for euthanasia so I'm going to vote that no one can.

I agree with you. NO ONE should be coerced into dying. If people find there is no help for them when they need it most what happens? Suicide has always been an option but some people won’t be able to do it. I would want there to be an alternative if I couldn’t kill myself. I realise this probably won’t happen in my lifetime. This is another sign of society beginning to collapse.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:14

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:12

The flip side of objecting to euthanasia because a tiny minority of people might be pushed into it, is that you are truly just as controlling because you are removing a competent adult's ability to make their own free choices (assuming there is a medical team willing to assist).

Either way, if you force a mentally competent unwilling person into euthanasia or if you refuse them euthanasia, you are not listening to their stated and reasoned desires. This is the core of the matter.

A competent adult who is clear and consistent in their desire should be respected, if there are people willing to help them carry their wish out.

I don't believe anyone should have the right to override a competent adult's sincere desire just because they are afraid that sometime, someone in the future might apply it to them, maybe. Or someone like them. In the presence of extreme intractible suffering it's psychological self indulgence of the highest order.

Many people would say that ethics is not so much about individual desires and wants as about the moral boundaries of the entire community. None of us exists in a vacuum. If you want to commit suicide that is your decision, but involving others and the State is a different matter.

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 14:12

Somuchgoo · 30/09/2026 13:43

We've been on the slippery slope for a very long time.

In the UK a little boy like this would probably also be allowed to die, but rather than drifting off into a drug-induced coma and then dying, nutrition would be withdrawn and he'd starve, or next time he has an infection he wouldn't be given antibiotics. The end is the same, but they'd be more suffering.

I think I would like to allow full euthanasia, whilst allowing nutrition to be withdrawn, and potentially assisted suicide, is more about our own squeamishness about death rather than best interest of the patient.

We are fine with causing death, but we make artificial distinctions so that we don't feel like we are to blame. Withdrawing nutrition is fine because we aren't actively killing them. Removal of life support is fine, because although we hit the off switch, we tell ourselves we're not killing them we just aren't artificially keeping them alive any more. Then we've got the 'double effect' of morphine at the end where it's given for pain relief, but knowing it also might suppress breathing and hasten death.

I have more of an issue with people's squeamishness towards suffering than I do with death itself, to be honest.

How is suffering measured? How is it defined? Who decides? And when a person no longer has mental capacity, or in the case of a child that doesn't yet have capacity, or never will, how is intolerable suffering to be judged. Is there a measurable or universal standard?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:12

The flip side of objecting to euthanasia because a tiny minority of people might be pushed into it, is that you are truly just as controlling because you are removing a competent adult's ability to make their own free choices (assuming there is a medical team willing to assist).

Either way, if you force a mentally competent unwilling person into euthanasia or if you refuse them euthanasia, you are not listening to their stated and reasoned desires. This is the core of the matter.

A competent adult who is clear and consistent in their desire should be respected, if there are people willing to help them carry their wish out.

I don't believe anyone should have the right to override a competent adult's sincere desire just because they are afraid that sometime, someone in the future might apply it to them, maybe. Or someone like them. In the presence of extreme intractible suffering it's psychological self indulgence of the highest order.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 30/09/2026 14:02

kxeil · 30/09/2026 13:12

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar “So much depends on the care situation or care home then. Some are appalling.”

This is why I think the Canadian model is better. In an ‘ideal world’ I would agree with you about having a model like the Dutch, but in the world we actually live in people need options. If people can’t get the care, housing and financial help they need, what do they do? Isn’t it better to at least have the choice to die by assisted dying or euthanasia?

I do see what you're saying and think it's a valid argument, but I run into a quagmire here and can't find a way forward.

In a world with an increasing right wing creep, I'd be afraid that this option would be seen as desirable by some flavours of government and used to cut services further. And shelter and medical centres for long term homeless people where every time you go, you're asked if you'd like for this situation to come to an end via a specialised service - just no. I don't have faith that a government like that won't be elected.

And in practise with the Canadian model people have been pressured into assisted dying.

Honestly, personally in the UK's case I'm closer to the fence than I give the impression, because of the nature of the healthcare system. But the cruelty of forcing a loving partner to being a longed- for release to their spouse, or the cruelty of not allowing a safe death for someone who genuinely wants to die, tips the balance. Although I'll fight to the bitter end the utterly controlling and selfish "I can live with my pain so no one else should have the option for eithanasia" or "I'm afraid someone will tell me I should go for euthanasia so I'm going to vote that no one can.

kxeil · 30/09/2026 13:56

ScrollingLeaves · 30/09/2026 13:45

A concern is though that this encourages the convenient route taken by governments/people/families to not make care and palliative care a priority. It is much easier if people just die.

I mentioned this earlier, we already have a massive shortage of carers and people are increasingly living longer with more health problems. What is the alternative right now if you need care but can’t get it?

kxeil · 30/09/2026 13:53

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/09/2026 13:32

Maybe, but not everyone agrees with that assessment...and as we have seen in countries which offer this 'route', the boundaries shift and people end up being 'assisted to die' who wouldn't have met the original criteria. Once you have crossed the Rubicon it is a slippery slope.

What will happen if people can’t find carers, don’t have anyone willing to care for them and are financially unable to pay for care?

If I was in that position I would want some options. Obviously suicide is always one if you’re able to do it by yourself.

ScrollingLeaves · 30/09/2026 13:45

kxeil · 30/09/2026 13:12

@ReleaseTheDucksOfWar “So much depends on the care situation or care home then. Some are appalling.”

This is why I think the Canadian model is better. In an ‘ideal world’ I would agree with you about having a model like the Dutch, but in the world we actually live in people need options. If people can’t get the care, housing and financial help they need, what do they do? Isn’t it better to at least have the choice to die by assisted dying or euthanasia?

A concern is though that this encourages the convenient route taken by governments/people/families to not make care and palliative care a priority. It is much easier if people just die.