Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Two-year-old euthanised in Netherlands in first assisted dying case of its kind

561 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/09/2026 19:01

I'm not going to select any part of the article but just post the link for those who want to read
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/netherlands-infant-2-euthanised-assisted-37709218

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
17
NullaEffugium · 05/10/2026 07:19

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 16:33

I have never come across anyone in the disability movement as determined as yourself to remove the agency of free choice from another adult.

Is this directed at me? I thought we were jointly providing pros and cons. I am not a member of any movement. I am a disabled woman though and assisted dying terrifies me. It does no good to tell me no one is going to euthanise me against my will when it has happened and is happening where it is legal.

As for this- remove the agency of free choice from another adult.

This is a fallacy. The opposition to this bill is not removing any agency or free choice. Everyone has the freedom to die whenever they want to by their own hand. If a friend or relative helps them along, these days this is hardly ever prosecuted, and the person only goes to prison if the courts prove it was really murder not assisting a suicide.

Assisted suicide compels another person to help them. This removes free choice by adding an element of economic duress and social stigma on healthcare providers being turned into death providers.

Euthanasia takes away free choice and gives 3rd parties like doctors and family the right to request another adult (or child)is killed, for their own good but we have seen that despite the good intentions, this is not only open to abuse it has been abused resulting in murders that are being swept under the rug.

The entire bill is to paid for by the State, and as this is being billed as healthcare, the NHS which is gasping for funds and staff will now be responsible for dispensing death. It is not affordable or necessary.

We know innocent people (mostly women) are being murdered, but apparently it is not enough to scrap it. We abolished the death penalty because a handful of innocent people (mostly men) were being executed and it is inhumane. So murderers, rapists and really evil people (mostly men) are protected from euthanasia and we as society accept the extra costs of housing, feeding, healthcare for life for them, but when it comes to shielding the aged, the disabled people (mostly women) from being killed against their will and we protest this, that is apparently being selfish and forcing others to suffer.
No one is forcing anyone to suffer.

But the whole way this campaign is being presented says a lot about society is on the path of valuing the lives of criminal men more than the lives of disabled women.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 16:34

well, that's not true. but that individual believed that the world revolved around them and their desires.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 16:33

I have never come across anyone in the disability movement as determined as yourself to remove the agency of free choice from another adult.

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 15:57

An interviewer, Reid Davenport, whose documentary Life After on Ms Bouzia tracked down her sisters and found that
The interviews, plus home-video footage supplied by the family, paint a picture of a woman who benefited from technological advances and better support, was a voracious reader and seemed content, even happy. Rather than in a hospital, she was living in her own apartment, with a live-in nurse.
“Everybody wants to know, did she change her mind?” her sister, Teresa Castner, says in Life After. She sighs and throws out her hands. “Who the fuck knows? I don’t think she changed her mind per se. I think she accepted her fate. I think she came to the realization that this was not how she wanted to die.”
Bouvia’s sisters say that she was happiest when she had the most autonomy. She was crushed when she was discouraged from pursuing her dream of being a social worker, despite her college education – one of the incidents that seems to have precipitated her original request to die.
“I think there are a lot of parallels between Elizabeth Bouvia and the arguments disabled people are making about [Maid],” Davenport says. In the documentary, he travels to Canada. Although the overwhelming number of Maid deaths there are related to terminal illnesses, activists and reporters have identified cases and practices that call the system’s guardrails into question.

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2025/jan/27/film-assisted-suicide-sundance

Is assisted dying a ‘clear and present danger’ to people with disabilities? New US film asks tough questions

Reid Davenport, whose documentary Life After is at Sundance, thinks euthanasia has ‘a lot to do with cost savings’

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2025/jan/27/film-assisted-suicide-sundance

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 15:50

When she was mentally competent, she chose to resume eating and continued her life outside the hospital.

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 15:46

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 14:07

For a story from the other side:

Elizabeth Bouvia (United States): In 1983, Bouvia—a 26-year-old woman with severe cerebral palsy who was completely paralyzed and suffering from degenerative arthritis—checked into a California hospital, stating she no longer wished to live and asking for assistance to starve herself to death painlessly. While a court eventually affirmed her right to refuse forced tube-feeding, pain management limitations and legal hurdles meant she could not obtain an active, peaceful assisted death. She remained alive decades later as a "reluctant survivor," navigating severe, chronic bodily distress

Can you imagine, desperately wanting to die for decades?

There are plenty more.

The point here is that other people are taking away the individual's right to make a reasoned, long held decision to die.

I wonder if it would have turned out differently if Ms Bouvia had not checked herself into a psychiatric hospital while suicidal from mental illness and therefore perhaps didn’t really want to die in a compos mentis sense. She was the California equivalent of sectioned as a mentally ill person after psychiatric assessment.

I note too, that she would not have qualified under the UK assisted dying bill nor the California assisted dying law (EOLA) that came into force a year after she passed away as she was not terminally ill nor was her death reasonably foreseeable within six months.

So I take it you are in favour of expanding assisted dying to include a disabled person with chronic pain that is not terminally ill but mentally ill? As she fit that bill to a tee. If you think she should have got her wish, that would mean also euthanising patients in psychiatric hospitals that are actively suicidal. Is that really what we want psychiatrists and psychologists to start doing instead of treating depression?

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 14:13

Again, the reports that give a balanced view of the overall successes, failures, worrying points and constructive points from the Netherlands.

https://english.euthanasiecommissie.nl/the-committees/annual-reports-and-judgments

Will mistakes/failures never happen? No.

But to dismiss the vast majority of successful applications for and processes of euthansia in countries where it works well for people who want it is like taking away an entire meal from a starving person because one potato had a spot of rot.

Annual reports and judgments | Regional Euthanasia Review Committees

https://english.euthanasiecommissie.nl/the-committees/annual-reports-and-judgments

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 14:07

For a story from the other side:

Elizabeth Bouvia (United States): In 1983, Bouvia—a 26-year-old woman with severe cerebral palsy who was completely paralyzed and suffering from degenerative arthritis—checked into a California hospital, stating she no longer wished to live and asking for assistance to starve herself to death painlessly. While a court eventually affirmed her right to refuse forced tube-feeding, pain management limitations and legal hurdles meant she could not obtain an active, peaceful assisted death. She remained alive decades later as a "reluctant survivor," navigating severe, chronic bodily distress

Can you imagine, desperately wanting to die for decades?

There are plenty more.

The point here is that other people are taking away the individual's right to make a reasoned, long held decision to die.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 13:59

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 13:52

No independent oversight leads to this…excerpts because it’s long full text at

https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/euthanasia-dispute-belgium-dementia-1.4538785

Euthanasia — when doctors kill patients at their request — can be granted in Belgium to people with both physical and mental health illnesses. The condition does not need to be fatal, but suffering must be "unbearable and untreatable." It can only be performed if specific criteria are fulfilled, including a "voluntary, well-considered and repeated" request from the person.

But Belgium's euthanasia commission routinely violates the law, according to a September letter of resignation written by Dr. Ludo Vanopdenbosch, a neurologist, to senior party leaders in the Belgian Parliament who appoint members of the group.

"It's not euthanasia because the patient didn't ask, so it's the voluntary taking of a life," said Dr. An Haekens, psychiatric director at the Alexianen Psychiatric Hospital in Tienen, Belgium. "I don't know another word other than murder to describe this."

Kristof Van Assche, a professor of health law at the University of Antwerp, wrote in an email the commission itself wasn't breaking the law because the group is not required to refer a case unless two-thirds of the group agree — even if the case "blatantly disregards" criteria for euthanasia.…

But without a request from the patient, the case "would normally constitute manslaughter or murder," he wrote. "The main question is why this case was not deemed sufficiently problematic" to prompt the commission to refer the case to prosecutors.

Commission acts with 'impunity,' critic says
Vanopdenbosch, who in the letter called himself a "big believer" in euthanasia, cited other problems with the commission. He said that when he expressed concerns about potentially problematic cases, he was immediately "silenced" by others. And he added that because many of the doctors on the commission are leading euthanasia practitioners, they can protect each other from scrutiny, and act with "impunity."

Vanopdenbosch wrote that when cases of euthanasia are identified that don't meet the legal criteria, they are not forwarded to the public prosecutor's office as is required by law, but that the commission itself acts as the court.

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 13:32

A 2019 study in the medical journal, "Anaesthesia," found that long, painful deaths from assisted suicide and euthanasia are common, with a third of patients taking 30 hours to die. Four percent took seven days to die.

https://associationofanaesthetists-publications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/anae.14532

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 13:24

In the case of one murderer, Joseph Wood, "the procedure took almost two hours and resulted in him being injected 15 times". (this does not happen with assisted dying in well run countries!)

Does not happen….

In the case of this 48yr old woman with cancer, assisted dying was an ordeal involving the initial injection, a second injection, calling paramedics and eventually doing a fourth dose in her neck. It took her over four hours and traumatised not only her, her family but also the doctor used to performing euthanasias (the dr used the word traumatised in his testimony, that’s not me making it emotive)

This article has a good history of assisted dying and euthanasia in the Netherlands and a discussion on the drug cocktails being used off label to do them. It goes over the fact around half a dozen cases a year fail the due care criteria which are meant to document the person euthanised really consented. It also points out that data isn’t collected to know just how peaceful it is or isn’t, how often botches happen or don’t happen.
https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/assisted-death-always-peaceful-lack-data-means-we-simply-2026a10003d7?form=fpf

Is Assisted Death Always Peaceful? We Simply Don’t Know

Euthanasia protocols rely on off-label drugs. With little data and no oversight on complications, how do we know the death is truly painless?

https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/assisted-death-always-peaceful-lack-data-means-we-simply-2026a10003d7?form=fpf

NullaEffugium · 04/10/2026 13:08

The drugs fail in euthanasia as well from time to time. In this case, a pillow was employee to complete the ‘dignified’ death of a young mother with terminal cancer.

https://www.alliancevita.org/en/2023/09/the-shocking-fiasco-of-a-euthanasia-in-belgium/

Le fiasco choquant d’une euthanasie en Belgique femme belge étouffée dans un coussin suite à une euthanasie ratée

The Shocking Fiasco of a Euthanasia in Belgium - %%sitetitle%%

https://www.alliancevita.org/en/2023/09/the-shocking-fiasco-of-a-euthanasia-in-belgium

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 11:38

@ScrollingLeaves did I quote this article above? it's about the US hunt for drugs for executions. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67150566

I did like the line that when one state execution team managed to cadge some from another team, they sent a thank you saying "you're a lifesafer".

Essentially because of the use the drugs are put to, the supply of reliable drugs died up and they scrabble around and sometimes try nice interesting experimental concoctions of drugs.

In the case of one murderer, Joseph Wood, "the procedure took almost two hours and resulted in him being injected 15 times". (this does not happen with assisted dying in well run countries!)

I can't find the proper BBC article about the problems with the firing squad but did find this : https://www.npr.org/2025/05/08/nx-s1-5389846/firing-squad-south-carolina-death-penalty-execution

Admittedly 2 minutes is a lot lot faster death than either Joseph Wood or Pike, but it's a pretty bad two minutes and the chances of trained marksmen missing a highlighted target at that distance are pretty small.

Protest against the death penalty

Death row: The secret hunt for lethal drugs used in US executions

When drugs used in executions stopped being produced in the US, prisons turned to the UK to find a new supply.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67150566

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 04/10/2026 10:50

Not sure actually.

The death squad is also highly problematic. The prisoner is meant to be blindfolded and have a target pinned over the left ventricle of the heart. But there seem to be a number of reasonably reliable stories where all three of the shots (from a fairly close range by trained people, mind you) have unaccountably missed leading to prolonged and agonizing deaths. Ill try to find the BBC article later.

The implication has been that 1) some of the sharp shooters have simply not wanted to kill another person. And 2) sometimes there's been a revenge factor, eg in the case of a black man who shot a white police officer.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/10/2026 00:48

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 03/10/2026 11:45

About getting hold of the drugs for executions in the US as opposed to drugs for euthanasia.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67150566

The situation hasn't improved for the US.

The drugs used in euthanasia on the other hand are well sourced, good quality and in date (as well as more effectively administered)

Thank you. That is interesting but horrible. I’d prefer a firing squad. The sight of that bed with so many straps is the creation of a nightmare. Maybe with some of the concocted, untried drugs, the person being killed if fully conscious but paralysed. No one would know.

America looks sick from this.

What exactly is the euthanasia used on animals? If they have the drugs for an animal as big as a horse or a big dog why not for a human? Maybe those drugs are not as benign as we’d like to think either.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 03/10/2026 11:45

About getting hold of the drugs for executions in the US as opposed to drugs for euthanasia.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67150566

The situation hasn't improved for the US.

The drugs used in euthanasia on the other hand are well sourced, good quality and in date (as well as more effectively administered)

Protest against the death penalty

Death row: The secret hunt for lethal drugs used in US executions

When drugs used in executions stopped being produced in the US, prisons turned to the UK to find a new supply.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67150566

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 18:50

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:52

this could be a useful report to read, in English @ScrollingLeaves
https://english.euthanasiecommissie.nl/the-committees/annual-reports-and-judgments

Edited

Thank you very much @ReleaseTheDucksOfWar
I shall copy that to read later.

Kirbert2 · 02/10/2026 14:47

CoatiCutie · 02/10/2026 14:33

I agree with the view that people should have a choice - I just worry about a system where that isn't the reality. How long before people get a terminal diagnosis, or bad prognosis, for their child, and there is pressure to euthanise them before things get bad, or to free up bed space, to not cost the NHS money that is ultimately 'pointless' financially as the patient will still die. What about when those treatment options are no longer available as there's deemed not enough of a chance at the patient living, or living long enough. Who can put value on a persons life, or remaining time of it?

The idea in itself I agree with, but I struggle to see how it would ever be more than an ideal, and the thought of how it could be utilised terrifies me.

Yep.

I've been in the position of having a doctor with kind, sad eyes telling me that my child likely isn't going to survive and even if he did, he'd probably have brain damage and not be the same 8 year old as he was before.

It was the worst experience of my life but I felt comfort in knowing that the medical professionals were truly doing everything they could do to save his life and in the end, they did save his life.

If assisted dying was an option, would they have tried as hard? Would they have instead suggested assisted dying? Even pressured me if it was the norm knowing it would save money? Honestly, that would've likely finished me off at the time.

His prognosis was poor and in the end, they were wrong about him in multiple ways. How many people, especially those not able to decide for themselves such as children would die that they were wrong about?

kxeil · 02/10/2026 14:47

@CoatiCutie “I agree with the view that people should have a choice”

That’s good! I do understand your concerns. They don’t make me not want to have assisted dying and euthanasia.

A person owns their body and life, so they should control how and when it ends.

CoatiCutie · 02/10/2026 14:33

I agree with the view that people should have a choice - I just worry about a system where that isn't the reality. How long before people get a terminal diagnosis, or bad prognosis, for their child, and there is pressure to euthanise them before things get bad, or to free up bed space, to not cost the NHS money that is ultimately 'pointless' financially as the patient will still die. What about when those treatment options are no longer available as there's deemed not enough of a chance at the patient living, or living long enough. Who can put value on a persons life, or remaining time of it?

The idea in itself I agree with, but I struggle to see how it would ever be more than an ideal, and the thought of how it could be utilised terrifies me.

kxeil · 02/10/2026 14:19

@CoatiCutie “I was inconsolable from pain, fatigue and not able to think clearly at points, just spending my time rocking and crying from pain -“

That sounds absolutely awful and I’m sorry for your suffering.

Some people would choose to die instead of living in those circumstances. Not everyone has a partner or family willing to help them. Even if they did have someone, it might not be enough to want to keep on living.

It’s about giving people a choice and autonomy on when they want to end their life.

CoatiCutie · 02/10/2026 13:54

NullaEffugium · 29/09/2026 15:18

Please don’t put in quotations anything I did not write.
I am aware of how things are, I actually live with chronic pain. You however are assuming that chronic pain means it would be kinder to kill people like me, even children. Perhaps you should be listening and not assuming, because you were the one saying that unending pain for other than someone in the end stages of a terminal disease exists is unendurable and there is nothing that can be done. Both aren’t true, there is pain reliever medications and CBT where you can train your mind to ignore certain nerve ending signals so the pain becomes background noise.

Do you have an example of someone in pure agony 24/7 where medication doesn’t touch the pain, and they are not terminally ill and in the end stages but only chronically ill and their expected life span is many more years?

I have been in pure agony 24/7 for the best part of a year a few years ago, and I still deal with chronic pain now, though I have found ways to manage it. I truly was suicidal and was struggling to get through each hour. However this story terrifies me, as like previous poster have said, if provisions for pain management are less available, more expensive, it could easily push people to assisted dying.

I was inconsolable from pain, fatigue and not able to think clearly at points, just spending my time rocking and crying from pain - the thought that my husband could have signed of on ending my life at that point, it's terrifying.

Or parents who are abusive, have MBP, it opens up an awful possible reality at the bottom of the slippery slope. We already have an issue with women coerced and forced into abortions they don't want...

ScrollingLeaves · 02/10/2026 13:52

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/10/2026 13:37

It says it all that you will so very quickly invalidate the intellectual and professional integrity of people who have direct personal experience of the topic so fast, when it counters your point.

I respectfully disagree that in a general way, as I see it from the outside, this poster
has intended disrespect. And if the pp’s posts are one sided, that is for a reader to mull over. Everyone knows to listen to various views.

I for one am grateful for the additional information about the research on The Liverpool Pathway, and other various research on assisted dying/euthanasia/ capital punishment drugs. I shall look up more.

I am also very grateful to your counter weighting arguments. This thread has been very helpful.

My personal experience is of care of relatives who were terminally ill but not with the very worst illnesses entailing years of incapacity and terrible suffering. They died unpleasantly, without assistance, but possibly finally helped at the last hour with morphine.