Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Views on androgen insensitivity and women’s sport participation

296 replies

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 06:41

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOugAoGDbo6/?hl=en

It's about androgen insensitivity.

Okay, so I come across this person on my reels during the night. Probably due to discussions here and the algorithm and Big Brother.

I also tried to do a search here but nothing come up about previous discussions. Might be the imperfect search functions.

Now unusually for me, I will give my actual position on what I'm about to say and ask.

I don't think trans women should compete with women in the majority of single sex sports events past a childhood grassroots level. Where it really doesn't matter, we should probably have those sports be mixed at a professional level to increase participation but that's another subject entirely.

When it comes to DSDs and the like, I think things like normal or average hormonal levels need to play a part in determining their participation. The athletes most discussed in here, I agree (somewhat reluctantly) they shouldn't compete with women. Reluctantly just because I think they are good athletes/people and haven't acted maliciously.

The person in the clip I have shown above, however, I don't think they are quite the same. I wouldn't begrudge them a space on a women's sports team, though from the sounds of it, they might not be very good, anyway.

I'm actually not sure if this is the clip of them I've watched as I watched them on Facebook. They talk about several of their aunts having the same disorder so they had some idea they would vs most people who have it not knowing until they get older.

So I guess I'm asking for people's opinions on this person and disorder when it comes to single sex spaces and sports.

Jackie Blankenship • Intersex 101 on Instagram: "✨ Born with XY chromosomes, but my body never listened to testosterone. My testes became my natural estrogen factory - Here is the scientific way it all worked! 💛💜 #IntersexProud #Intersex #CAIS #Inte...

4,999 likes, 206 comments - mrsjackieblanks on September 17, 2025: "✨ Born with XY chromosomes, but my body never listened to testosterone. My testes became my natural estrogen factory - Here is the scientific way it all worked! 💛💜 #IntersexProud #I...

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOugAoGDbo6?hl=en

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
borntobequiet · 27/09/2026 14:58

These threads are useful because they clarify matters that otherwise confuse. As for other posters, this one has brought me down firmly on the side of women’s sport for XX only.

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 14:42

renovationchoas · 27/09/2026 13:22

@Multibarpacki think that it’s a version of inclusion - it’s motivated by a desire to include people who don’t fit that comfortably into sex based categories. I personally don’t agree with it for fairness reasons though - I think fairness wins in sport every time. Though obviously up to puberty individuals with CAIS won’t know they have it and will compete with females probably - I think this is unlikely to be unsafe prior to puberty and will be picked up for fairness purposes later, so it doesn’t worry me overly.

It is exclusion - it excludes women from teams, from podiums, from heats, from games.

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 13:28

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:21

Seems like these tests may be something you have just found about, perhaps as a result of further research as tooics come up on this thread.

Can you provide references showing these tests are actually being used in sports rather than the judgement call others have referred to?

In vitro tests for androgen receptor expression, binding, and activation are old hat. These days, CAIS is diagnosed by looking for the mutations known to cause total lack of androgen signalling. The mutations causing PAIS are different.

Sporting regulators won't publicise what tests they do, because of competitor privacy. Semenya's results were published because of the litigation. Many CAIS competitors will have been previously diagnosed, and regulators may simply accept documentary evidence of that.

renovationchoas · 27/09/2026 13:22

@Multibarpacki think that it’s a version of inclusion - it’s motivated by a desire to include people who don’t fit that comfortably into sex based categories. I personally don’t agree with it for fairness reasons though - I think fairness wins in sport every time. Though obviously up to puberty individuals with CAIS won’t know they have it and will compete with females probably - I think this is unlikely to be unsafe prior to puberty and will be picked up for fairness purposes later, so it doesn’t worry me overly.

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 13:14

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:21

Seems like these tests may be something you have just found about, perhaps as a result of further research as tooics come up on this thread.

Can you provide references showing these tests are actually being used in sports rather than the judgement call others have referred to?

I've done a bit more digging on the tests and I can't find any totally definitive test. The level of corruption of the androgen sensitivity gene is a pretty reliable indicator but Google AI still returned this answer to one of my questions.

"a person can carry an AR gene mutation that is widely documented to cause complete androgen insensitivity syndrome (CAIS), yet they themselves only present with partial androgen insensitivity syndrome (PAIS)"

So the whole thing is a judgment call on whether any one individual has complete or partial insensitivity and such judgements are inappropriate for fair sport for women, imo.

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 13:13

You’ve chosen inclusion where others want proven fairness.

It is not inclusion when men are allowed to take spaces from women in their own sports.

renovationchoas · 27/09/2026 13:08

Hi OP, I don’t think that people with CAIS operate fully as female, even though they might look that way.

obviously in females, the oestrogen input comes at the level of the ovaries and is circulated as part of a cyclical process (which is even observed in many HRT or contraceptive processes), whereas in CAIS you have a continual, constant, conversion of testosterone to oestrogen at a cellular level. CAIS is not well understood, in terms of the need to remove gonads or to manage bone density - there are a range of strategies and treatments. I think that, whilst harsh, we don’t know enough to mitigate any benefits right now.

When you look at the impact of contraceptives that prevent periods in young women, even the science behind female hormones is not totally there in terms of bone density/heart health/athletic performance - obviously, contraceptives are studied in terms of them being actively harmful as against specific risk metrics, but that’s not the same as optimising female performance.

right now, I agree with other PP’s that the reality of the science of “complete” androgen insensitivity does likely contain an element of judgement. It’s not as clear cut as you might think.

i think that, if you’d be happy with someone racing with a prosthetic leg that no one really knew if it performed better than a human leg, then this is similar. You’ve chosen inclusion where others want proven fairness.

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 12:56

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:20

No it wouldn't, because from ither aspects of their outward body, people would assume they have a vagina and treat them as such. That girl would experience life as a female from birth (because she is and everyone can see she is). She proves what I am saying.

You make no allowances at all for women who don't look feminine, do you?

Your version of female is entirely tied up with a female stereotype.

FlatCatYellowMat · 27/09/2026 12:43

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:20

No it wouldn't, because from ither aspects of their outward body, people would assume they have a vagina and treat them as such. That girl would experience life as a female from birth (because she is and everyone can see she is). She proves what I am saying.

How other people view and treat you isn't the whole story of why someone is female though.

Robert Winston may feel that a male with CAIS is basically female, but I think that's pretty misogynistic - relegating anyone who isn't 100% what a man should be to the 'must be a woman' box. Women aren't women because of how they look. A bloke without a penis isn't a woman, any more than a woman without a uterus is a man.

A person with CAIS wouldn't have periods, concern about pregnancy, or pregnancy itself - things which absolutely shaped my life.

XX is the only fair way to determine participation in female sports.

SecretSquirrelLoo · 27/09/2026 12:41

CAIS interrupts and misdirects male sexual development. Not female.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 12:21

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:52

There arw definitive laboratory tests that show where there is no response to androgen by cells. I don't know why people keep insisting there aren't tests. There are a range of tests they use, one of which determines the cells cannot respond to androgen.

Seems like these tests may be something you have just found about, perhaps as a result of further research as tooics come up on this thread.

Can you provide references showing these tests are actually being used in sports rather than the judgement call others have referred to?

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 12:18

Women are not men with insensitivity to testosterone

Women are not men who suppress their testosterone levels

Women are not men without a penis

Women are not men who
like dresses

Women are not men with developmental conditions

Women are not men who look superficially feminine

Women are not men with long hair

Women are not men who like pretending they are submissive

Women are not men who have had their testes removed

Women are not men the patriarchy thinks don’t conform to certain standards of masculinity

Women are not men who fantasise about being women

Women are not non-men

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:52

There arw definitive laboratory tests that show where there is no response to androgen by cells. I don't know why people keep insisting there aren't tests. There are a range of tests they use, one of which determines the cells cannot respond to androgen.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:44

MoistVonL · 27/09/2026 11:39

Someone keeps insisting on including trans people in the discussion

As I understand it, your argument about CAIS is that the category of XX for women's sport is too narrow and should be broadened. Isn't it inevitable that other justifications to dismantle the XX category to include XY will be part of that conversation?

XX is a nice clear line in the sand. It's fair and applies equally to everyone.

Life is not nice, not clear and absolutely not fair. We aren't children, we all know and accept this.

No, because the androgen insensitivity is key, as is their natal external body.

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 27/09/2026 11:44

MoistVonL · 27/09/2026 11:39

Someone keeps insisting on including trans people in the discussion

As I understand it, your argument about CAIS is that the category of XX for women's sport is too narrow and should be broadened. Isn't it inevitable that other justifications to dismantle the XX category to include XY will be part of that conversation?

XX is a nice clear line in the sand. It's fair and applies equally to everyone.

Life is not nice, not clear and absolutely not fair. We aren't children, we all know and accept this.

Having read the whole thread, and some of the additional research, I now agree with you regarding XX as a clear line. The consensus on CAIS is too unclear. I’m back to Female (with a clear accepted definition) and Open as categories.

And yes, it’s naive (faux or otherwise) not to recognise why this debate is linked to the discussion surrounding transgender people in sport.

MoistVonL · 27/09/2026 11:39

Someone keeps insisting on including trans people in the discussion

As I understand it, your argument about CAIS is that the category of XX for women's sport is too narrow and should be broadened. Isn't it inevitable that other justifications to dismantle the XX category to include XY will be part of that conversation?

XX is a nice clear line in the sand. It's fair and applies equally to everyone.

Life is not nice, not clear and absolutely not fair. We aren't children, we all know and accept this.

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:34

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 11:22

Sure, but if that's to be the only criterion let's just be transparent, ditch "men's" and "women's" sports and have Androgenised and Non-Androgenised categories instead.

I'm so sick of all the little ways various groups are trying to chip away at the concept of "woman" and "female".

Whatever the putative reason given, it all eventually boils down to the belief that these words are more valuable as some sort of hint or metaphor about something else than the value they have as simple labels for the half of humanity that is female. Something else always matters more than boring old women and girls.

I think people born with a typical looking vulva, complete androgen insensitivity and experiencing many of the aspects of a typical female puberty (breasts, other effects of oestrogen on the body) are women.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:29

MoistVonL · 27/09/2026 11:27

Trans people have changed their bodies in order to have the same external body parts as I do

I may have a bridge to sell you...

Incidentally, my understanding of the current definition means it's transphobic of you to assume transwomen have medically transitioned.

I think it needs to be proven beyond reasonable doubt that people with CAIS have absolutely no advantage by virtue of XY before they can be considered safe and fair competitors in women's competitive or professional sport.

Being born with a condition can suck, be it CAIS or a cleft palate. But that's life. It doesn't mean we stop worrying about fairness for women.

In this thread, we are talking about people with CAIS who do have the same natal external body parts as I do. Someone keeps insisting on including trans people in the discussion. Trans women do not have the same natal body parts as I do. That is the point. That is why there is no comparison.

OP posts:
MoistVonL · 27/09/2026 11:27

Trans people have changed their bodies in order to have the same external body parts as I do

I may have a bridge to sell you...

Incidentally, my understanding of the current definition means it's transphobic of you to assume transwomen have medically transitioned.

I think it needs to be proven beyond reasonable doubt that people with CAIS have absolutely no advantage by virtue of XY before they can be considered safe and fair competitors in women's competitive or professional sport.

Being born with a condition can suck, be it CAIS or a cleft palate. But that's life. It doesn't mean we stop worrying about fairness for women.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 27/09/2026 11:22

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 09:06

The ability to use the testosterone is pretty central to whether it gives any sporting advantage. It's like having lots of water in a sealed container that cannot be opened and then arguing that there is no way you could become dehydrated because you have water. Even though you cannot actually access it to drink.

That testosterone becomes oestrogen and leads to things like breast development in puberty.

Sure, but if that's to be the only criterion let's just be transparent, ditch "men's" and "women's" sports and have Androgenised and Non-Androgenised categories instead.

I'm so sick of all the little ways various groups are trying to chip away at the concept of "woman" and "female".

Whatever the putative reason given, it all eventually boils down to the belief that these words are more valuable as some sort of hint or metaphor about something else than the value they have as simple labels for the half of humanity that is female. Something else always matters more than boring old women and girls.

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:20

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 09:47

You define yourself as a woman because you look like a woman and it wasn't achieved surgically and men hit on you. That would leave out 1 in 5000 girls born without a vagina, for a start.

I'm afraid it isn't your or my decision whether a discussion of CAIS women in sport goes into trans activist territory. It is firmly there.

And until CAIS/PAIS become a matter of a definitive scientific measurement instead of a judgement call, it's going to remain there.

No it wouldn't, because from ither aspects of their outward body, people would assume they have a vagina and treat them as such. That girl would experience life as a female from birth (because she is and everyone can see she is). She proves what I am saying.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 27/09/2026 11:09

Lin Yu Ting is clearly a man 🤣. We are in cuckoo land territory if anyone thinks otherwise. The entire reason he was identified as having XY chromosomes and being a man is because someone said “she looks like a man, we should check her chromosomes”. If he looked like a woman no one would have thought to check.

Which is was true genuine CAIS looks like. Which is why sex screening is important. To pick those with advantage that isn’t just testosterone driven. What will happen with this remains to be seen.

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 09:47

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 09:25

No I don't have a DSD, but if course as a woman I also have external female body parts like the woman in the video I sent. So we would have had many similarities growing up as people with vaginas and breasts ie growing up.into women from a girl. When I was 9 and a man made kissing noises to me in the street, he didnt stop to confirm I was XX, or had ovaries, he made a solid guess that I have a vagina by the way I looked and thought I was a good target for his sexual attention. The same thing would have happened to her.

And no, you aren't in trans territory when talking about CAIS unless you are unable to understand the difference between "born with a vulva and other female external body parts" and "surgically created a vagina from their natal penis as part of their transition". Or you cannot comprehend "totally insensitive to testosterone so unable to even process the levels that I, a natal woman, benefits from".

You define yourself as a woman because you look like a woman and it wasn't achieved surgically and men hit on you. That would leave out 1 in 5000 girls born without a vagina, for a start.

I'm afraid it isn't your or my decision whether a discussion of CAIS women in sport goes into trans activist territory. It is firmly there.

And until CAIS/PAIS become a matter of a definitive scientific measurement instead of a judgement call, it's going to remain there.

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 09:33

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 09:06

The ability to use the testosterone is pretty central to whether it gives any sporting advantage. It's like having lots of water in a sealed container that cannot be opened and then arguing that there is no way you could become dehydrated because you have water. Even though you cannot actually access it to drink.

That testosterone becomes oestrogen and leads to things like breast development in puberty.

That argument only works if it is only androgen use that causes every difference between men and women and I'm not certain that has been established.

The statistical over representation of people with CAIS at elite levels of sport would suggest not.

I can see how some people would argue that the height advantage, for example, is because of the lack of ability to use testosterone and that women can be born with similar height advantages through hormone irregularities. But that isn't, for me, a valid argument because in the case of CAIS people the height advantage arises directly because they have male genes.

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 09:29

"Do you think Lin Yu-ting's androgen insensitivity is complete? He is taller than the average Taiwanese man of his age and a full 7 inches taller than the average Taiwanese woman."

I wouldn't have thought so by looking but people can be taller than average. Women can also be as muscular as she is. I'd trust the science that categorises CAIS vs PAIS. If they've ruled out some people they previously admitted then there is no reason to think they'd make allowances for one.

I dont think the eyes of layman like us is at all relevant to the truth. And as she is permitted to compete in the female category, i think you're being offensive and hostile by labelling her a man. I think it speaks poorly of your character.

OP posts: