Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Views on androgen insensitivity and women’s sport participation

296 replies

Lexibletheflexible · 25/09/2026 06:41

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOugAoGDbo6/?hl=en

It's about androgen insensitivity.

Okay, so I come across this person on my reels during the night. Probably due to discussions here and the algorithm and Big Brother.

I also tried to do a search here but nothing come up about previous discussions. Might be the imperfect search functions.

Now unusually for me, I will give my actual position on what I'm about to say and ask.

I don't think trans women should compete with women in the majority of single sex sports events past a childhood grassroots level. Where it really doesn't matter, we should probably have those sports be mixed at a professional level to increase participation but that's another subject entirely.

When it comes to DSDs and the like, I think things like normal or average hormonal levels need to play a part in determining their participation. The athletes most discussed in here, I agree (somewhat reluctantly) they shouldn't compete with women. Reluctantly just because I think they are good athletes/people and haven't acted maliciously.

The person in the clip I have shown above, however, I don't think they are quite the same. I wouldn't begrudge them a space on a women's sports team, though from the sounds of it, they might not be very good, anyway.

I'm actually not sure if this is the clip of them I've watched as I watched them on Facebook. They talk about several of their aunts having the same disorder so they had some idea they would vs most people who have it not knowing until they get older.

So I guess I'm asking for people's opinions on this person and disorder when it comes to single sex spaces and sports.

Jackie Blankenship • Intersex 101 on Instagram: "✨ Born with XY chromosomes, but my body never listened to testosterone. My testes became my natural estrogen factory - Here is the scientific way it all worked! 💛💜 #IntersexProud #Intersex #CAIS #Inte...

4,999 likes, 206 comments - mrsjackieblanks on September 17, 2025: "✨ Born with XY chromosomes, but my body never listened to testosterone. My testes became my natural estrogen factory - Here is the scientific way it all worked! 💛💜 #IntersexProud #I...

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOugAoGDbo6?hl=en

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
GriseldaandMike · 29/09/2026 12:25

I'm usually pretty hard line and absolutely in favour of grass roots sport being protected, not just top level but I am inclined to think with CAIS there is probably a case for inclusion at recreational level but exclusion for competition level unless there is definitive evidence of absolutely no advantage.

Imdunfer · 29/09/2026 11:32

renovationchoas · 29/09/2026 11:19

@Imdunfer

I also don’t have an issue with these kids being raised as girls. I don’t think that means that they necessarily get to compete against natal women in the Olympics, though. You can still have a more robust position on what the female category looks like, based on what we understand to provide clarity and fairness at this point and only expand the female category from XX if and only if we have concrete scientific evidence that is capable of resolving any individual case.

This exactly. I have no problem with this person using women's loos (I know others might and that is their right) and I think it would be pretty awful to force them into using the men's. But sport should be a complete absence of a Y chromosome to compete as a women, imo.

renovationchoas · 29/09/2026 11:19

@Imdunfer

I also don’t have an issue with these kids being raised as girls. I don’t think that means that they necessarily get to compete against natal women in the Olympics, though. You can still have a more robust position on what the female category looks like, based on what we understand to provide clarity and fairness at this point and only expand the female category from XX if and only if we have concrete scientific evidence that is capable of resolving any individual case.

Imdunfer · 29/09/2026 09:21

Lexibletheflexible · 28/09/2026 23:56

If you watch the video, you'll find that their aunts were diagnosed as teens when they didn't start their periods. That is how her mother had some idea that her own children could inherit the condition, so she was checked at the age of 4.

If you actually use the sources provided instead of just trying to attack this woman, you'll not look so hateful.

The reason why nothing was suspected at birth is because they have typical female external genitalia, so they knew that they likely have CAIS vs PAIS and nothing needs to be done until they are older.

Why would you raise someone who needs to pee sitting down because they were born with a vulva and urethra as a boy? Why would you raise someone who is going to receive sexual pleasure from a typical clitoris as a boy? Why would you raise someone who is going to grow breasts in puberty alongside their natal vulva and vagina as a boy?

That would be very confusing for them. Even if they are attracted to women, the women will have to be women who are attracted to natal female bodies on the "men" they date. If they're attracted to men, it would have to be men who are gay or bi and don't mind their female bodied partner identifying as male.

You speak as if this family acted manipulatively and maliciously to "trick" the world instead of just being a family who have a inherited condition. It's so strange.

I agree completely LTF, there's no reason whatsoever why that particular person shouldn't have been raised as a girl and it's odd to think otherwise.

Lexibletheflexible · 28/09/2026 23:56

Soontobe60 · 28/09/2026 21:53

So his uncles also had a DSD, leading to testing at 4? Are you really gullible enough to think that none of these male relatives particular DSDs were ever noticed until he was 4? What is far more plausible is that the parents already were aware of potential chances of any son they had being born with the same DSD, chose to ignore it until at 4 years old a doctor or nurse advised getting him screened. As his parents had treated him as female since birth they chose to continue to do so. They have an awful lot to answer for.

If you watch the video, you'll find that their aunts were diagnosed as teens when they didn't start their periods. That is how her mother had some idea that her own children could inherit the condition, so she was checked at the age of 4.

If you actually use the sources provided instead of just trying to attack this woman, you'll not look so hateful.

The reason why nothing was suspected at birth is because they have typical female external genitalia, so they knew that they likely have CAIS vs PAIS and nothing needs to be done until they are older.

Why would you raise someone who needs to pee sitting down because they were born with a vulva and urethra as a boy? Why would you raise someone who is going to receive sexual pleasure from a typical clitoris as a boy? Why would you raise someone who is going to grow breasts in puberty alongside their natal vulva and vagina as a boy?

That would be very confusing for them. Even if they are attracted to women, the women will have to be women who are attracted to natal female bodies on the "men" they date. If they're attracted to men, it would have to be men who are gay or bi and don't mind their female bodied partner identifying as male.

You speak as if this family acted manipulatively and maliciously to "trick" the world instead of just being a family who have a inherited condition. It's so strange.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 28/09/2026 21:53

Lexibletheflexible · 26/09/2026 04:56

No, they knew she might be because several of her mother's sisters have CAIS and her mum wanted her to be checked out early. It is explained in the second video I posted.

It also says online that ambiguous external genitalia is a feature in PAIS not CAIS.

So his uncles also had a DSD, leading to testing at 4? Are you really gullible enough to think that none of these male relatives particular DSDs were ever noticed until he was 4? What is far more plausible is that the parents already were aware of potential chances of any son they had being born with the same DSD, chose to ignore it until at 4 years old a doctor or nurse advised getting him screened. As his parents had treated him as female since birth they chose to continue to do so. They have an awful lot to answer for.

DrBlackbird · 28/09/2026 21:20

Interesting thread.

I have every sympathy for the woman in the op as an individual. She does indeed look quite female unless you looking for differences. It also looks like she races frequently, presumably at the amateur level and in the female category. It would be hard for her, as an individual who feels herself female in every way and lives her life as a female to be told no more racing in the female category.

However, at the societal level, I’d be deeply concerned if we stopped using xx as our differentiator. It doesn’t make sense to treat the NHS or Prof Winston as the final and unchallengeable arbitrator. Medical knowledge is imperfect and subject to human bias and the limits of human understanding and scientific research. Just consider the way the DSM-5 changes in each iteration.

There’s every possibility that claiming those with CAIS are female, do so for social reasons.

oldtiredcyclist · 28/09/2026 13:49

Multibarpack · 28/09/2026 13:17

Girls do not have CAIS.

Apologies, I worded it incorrectly.

Multibarpack · 28/09/2026 13:17

oldtiredcyclist · 28/09/2026 10:55

Girls with CAIS do not have a uterus or ovaries.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/androgen-insensitivity-syndrome/symptoms/

Girls do not have CAIS.

Imdunfer · 28/09/2026 09:26

MoistVonL · 28/09/2026 08:30

Thank you, @Imdunfer , that was all fascinating.

I've been looking a bit more and in humans CAIS is associated with more body fat, not less.

But the mouse model shows that androgens are definitely not the only thing that makes males different from females and other effects were already known in humans which stem directly from having or not having a Y chromosome.

Imo, the only fair and safe measure for female sport is the complete absence of a Y chromosome.

MoistVonL · 28/09/2026 08:30

Thank you, @Imdunfer , that was all fascinating.

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 23:15

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 22:39

No, they are often small or underdeveloped in Swyee Syndrome until treated with hormones. Which matches the supposed treatment given here.

Well, they normally just remain child-sized rather than almost impossible to detect. But it sounds like her doctors really let her down. She should have been having at least œstrogen from about age sixteen, and why on earth did they tell her she was really male? Women with SS don't have a functional SRY gene or testes: they are not male. And before the hormone therapy she would not have matured physically - for example no breast development, which must have been devastating for her. What were her doctors thinking?

BackToLurk · 27/09/2026 22:41

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 22:25

That seems much more likely. Though is they are claiming different DSDs to different media locations then I am sceptical about the whole thing. There have been a number of activists on SM that have claimed one DSD then switched to another when it has been pointed out their story is flawed,

Edited

I’ve no idea whether it’s accurate. It’s a bit of an odd site. It’d be interesting to see if they appear in the medical press anywhere.

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 22:39

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 22:30

Well, that's confusing! Don't women with Swyer Syndrome have a normal uterus and fallopian tubes (and no gonads)? What caused hers to regress, if not AMH?

No, they are often small or underdeveloped in Swyee Syndrome until treated with hormones. Which matches the supposed treatment given here.

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 22:30

BackToLurk · 27/09/2026 22:16

This site says Haynes has Swyer Syndrome

https://secondtypewoman.info/swyer.htm

Well, that's confusing! Don't women with Swyer Syndrome have a normal uterus and fallopian tubes (and no gonads)? What caused hers to regress, if not AMH?

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 22:25

BackToLurk · 27/09/2026 22:16

This site says Haynes has Swyer Syndrome

https://secondtypewoman.info/swyer.htm

That seems much more likely. Though is they are claiming different DSDs to different media locations then I am sceptical about the whole thing. There have been a number of activists on SM that have claimed one DSD then switched to another when it has been pointed out their story is flawed,

BackToLurk · 27/09/2026 22:16

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 22:09

The article states that she has CAIS. If she only had PMDS she would be an otherwise normal man with normal male genitalia. It was my speculation that she also has a degree of PMDS, to explain the retained rudimentary uterus.

This site says Haynes has Swyer Syndrome

https://secondtypewoman.info/swyer.htm

Second Type Woman - Swyer Syndrome

Swyer Syndrome

https://secondtypewoman.info/swyer.htm

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 22:09

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 21:58

That is not CAIS - Antimüllerian Hormone is not an androgen so people with CAIS are impacted by it. I’ve seen enough false reports on social media, and mainstream reports of ‘men’ being pregnant.

The article states that she has CAIS. If she only had PMDS she would be an otherwise normal man with normal male genitalia. It was my speculation that she also has a degree of PMDS, to explain the retained rudimentary uterus.

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 21:58

theilltemperedmonster · 27/09/2026 21:34

An interesting report on a 46XY CAIS woman who gave birth to twins with the aid of hormone therapy and a donor egg:

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-2933979/amp/I-born-no-womb-ve-given-birth-twins-says-mother-feared-no-man-want-me.html

It seems as if she also had some AMH-related malfunction causing her to retain a rudimentary uterus: such cases will be very rare!

She does look tall.

That is not CAIS - Antimüllerian Hormone is not an androgen so people with CAIS are impacted by it. I’ve seen enough false reports on social media, and mainstream reports of ‘men’ being pregnant.

Imdunfer · 27/09/2026 19:58

OK, I've been digging into whether only hormones are responsible for male/female differences of whether the presence and absence of a Y gene itself has an effect independent of hormones.

Forgive me the AI quote but I don't see the necessity to paraphrase it.

The answer makes it perfectly clear to me that there is

a) absolutely no way that CAIS people are women

b) that it is categorically unfair for CAIS people to complete as women as they definitely do have physical advantages and, provided this AI response is all correct and mouse models transfer into humans, I cannot understand how this has been allowed.

Even if Lin Yu-ting is completely androgen insensitive there is a natural propensity to lower body fat which a woman would have to train much harder to achieve.

@Lexibletheflexible please note all this has become known since Professor Winston's comments in 2004 which you set such store by.

Quote.

Hormones are not the only factor; genetics and chromosomes also play a fundamental, direct role in male and female development.

....

Direct Genetic Effects: Beyond just triggering hormone production, genes located on the X and Y chromosomes have independent, direct effects on cell function and tissue differentiation throughout the body before hormones even begin acting.

....

Direct genetic effects (also called cell-autonomous sex effects) refer to biological differences between males and females that are caused directly by the expression of X and Y chromosome genes inside individual cells, completely independent of hormones.

For decades, scientists believed that sex chromosomes only built the gonads (testes or ovaries), and hormones did all the work after that. Modern genomics proves that cells "know" their biological sex and act differently because of it, long before any hormones enter the picture.

  1. The "Dosage" Difference (X-Inactivation Escapees)

Females have two X chromosomes (XX) and males have one (XY). To keep things balanced, female cells shut down one of their X chromosomes in a process called X-inactivation.

However, this shutdown isn't perfect. Around 15% to 23% of genes on the "inactive" X chromosome escape inactivation. Because these genes stay active, female cells naturally produce a higher "dose" of certain regulatory proteins than male cells. This baseline genetic imbalance directly impacts cell metabolism, immune function, and resilience.

  1. Y-Chromosome Genes in Non-Reproductive Organs

The Y chromosome doesn't just hold the SRY gene for making testes; it contains a handful of vital regulatory genes that are expressed in tissues all over the body, including the brain, heart, and lungs.

The Brain: Genes uniquely found on the Y chromosome (like Kdm5d and Uty [my edit , these are tumour suppressing and have a role in reducing inflammation]) are active in male brain cells long before prenatal testosterone is ever produced.

Cell Lifespan: Some of these Y-linked genes are responsible for fundamental cell upkeep. Because men only have one X chromosome, these Y genes serve as a necessary baseline backup to keep male cells healthy.

  1. Direct Effects on the Immune System

The X chromosome houses a massive number of genes related to the immune system. Because females have a higher genetic dosage from X-inactivation escapees, female immune cells are inherently more reactive than male immune cells. This direct genetic difference explains why females generally mount stronger antibody responses to infections, but are also far more susceptible to autoimmune diseases, independent of circulating hormone levels.

[My comment - a more active immune system requires significantly more energy.]

  1. Metabolic Differences at a Cellular Level

Scientists have used unique mouse models (like the "Four Core Genotypes" model) to separate hormones from chromosomes. They bred mice so that an XY mouse could develop ovaries, and an XX mouse could develop testes.

They discovered that even when they removed all hormones, XX cells inherently metabolize fat and store energy differently than XY cells. XX animals naturally accumulate more fat tissue and handle glucose differently purely because of their chromosome count, not their hormones.

End Quote

Multibarpack · 27/09/2026 17:48

renovationchoas · 27/09/2026 17:05

@Multibarpacki think we have the same principles. I prefer to argue substance over semantics, because it all depends on what you think inclusion is. All I was saying is that there is clearly a tension between wanting to be sympathetic to a group of people (ie to include them) and fairness and I prefer fairness.

Fairness is vital in sport but the use of the excuse of ‘inclusion’ is deceptive - if you include men then that means women, for whom the sport exists, are excluded. It isn’t inclusion - it is replacement of women with men. I think it is important to challenge the idea that including men in women’s sport is doing anything other than forcing women out.

renovationchoas · 27/09/2026 17:05

@Multibarpacki think we have the same principles. I prefer to argue substance over semantics, because it all depends on what you think inclusion is. All I was saying is that there is clearly a tension between wanting to be sympathetic to a group of people (ie to include them) and fairness and I prefer fairness.

Shortshriftandlethal · 27/09/2026 16:06

Lexibletheflexible · 27/09/2026 11:34

I think people born with a typical looking vulva, complete androgen insensitivity and experiencing many of the aspects of a typical female puberty (breasts, other effects of oestrogen on the body) are women.

I think they are biologically male people with androgen insensitivity, not female people. This is unfortunate for them, but does not mean that the female category should be compromised on account of it. Even if they 'look' female or 'identify as' female.

Swipe left for the next trending thread