Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Transgender person elected as Deputy Mayor in Sydney

169 replies

Catcentral · 24/09/2026 04:53

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1HxkfR1VCB/

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 08:25

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 08:16

I doubt that is an aim as ‘Olly’ wasn’t claiming to be a woman when elected. However, there was already an issue with corruption of data. That is compounded by LLMs and other forms of AI using online sources to ‘build knowledge’. This ‘Sydney had a ‘gender-balanced’ council’ ‘fact’ becomes baked in and no one ever interrogates it.

I’m not especially interested in a specific man, who may or may not be any good as a councillor. I’m more interested in the wider issues at play here. What makes this person now a woman? Where should this ‘woman’ be included when looking at the sex of elected representatives in relation to ‘gender balance’?

Yes I see that wider implication and would have supported a thread that led with that and not that Australia is going to the dogs because Sydney has appointed a trans person as deputy mayor. That reaction, imo, gives fuel to trans arguments against gender critical women.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 08:16

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:54

I agree with you there if there is a stated objective to have a 50:50 split on sex in that Council. The article doesn't mention that.

I doubt that is an aim as ‘Olly’ wasn’t claiming to be a woman when elected. However, there was already an issue with corruption of data. That is compounded by LLMs and other forms of AI using online sources to ‘build knowledge’. This ‘Sydney had a ‘gender-balanced’ council’ ‘fact’ becomes baked in and no one ever interrogates it.

I’m not especially interested in a specific man, who may or may not be any good as a councillor. I’m more interested in the wider issues at play here. What makes this person now a woman? Where should this ‘woman’ be included when looking at the sex of elected representatives in relation to ‘gender balance’?

DialSquare · 24/09/2026 08:15

My issue would be regarding the policies he promotes. Is he a full blown TRA (likely) or one of the few transwomen who do not use female single sex spaces? I doubt it’s the latter.

Missey85 · 24/09/2026 07:55

So what's your point if their qualified to do the job that's all that matters 😊

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:54

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 07:49

He can absolutely dress as he likes. However, a current search looking for the gender split of Sydney City Council describes it as having a 50/50 split. 5 women, 5 men. With Olly being one of the women. That, imo, is a problem.

I agree with you there if there is a stated objective to have a 50:50 split on sex in that Council. The article doesn't mention that.

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 07:49

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:42

I'm sorry but it's this kind of reaction that will give ammunition to trans claims that "terfs" want them eradicated. It damages women's arguments for safe spaces and fair sport.

He's perfectly entitled to dress and present however he wants, just as we are as women.

He has huge experience for the role and was elected unanimously.

Judge the man on his policies and achievements.

He can absolutely dress as he likes. However, a current search looking for the gender split of Sydney City Council describes it as having a 50/50 split. 5 women, 5 men. With Olly being one of the women. That, imo, is a problem.

dizzydizzydizzy · 24/09/2026 07:46

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

I agree too. I can understand issues with toilets and sport but not this.

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 07:46

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:42

I'm sorry but it's this kind of reaction that will give ammunition to trans claims that "terfs" want them eradicated. It damages women's arguments for safe spaces and fair sport.

He's perfectly entitled to dress and present however he wants, just as we are as women.

He has huge experience for the role and was elected unanimously.

Judge the man on his policies and achievements.

He can dress how he wants for sure, but it’s his claim to be a woman that is the issue.

Imdunfer · 24/09/2026 07:42

I'm sorry but it's this kind of reaction that will give ammunition to trans claims that "terfs" want them eradicated. It damages women's arguments for safe spaces and fair sport.

He's perfectly entitled to dress and present however he wants, just as we are as women.

He has huge experience for the role and was elected unanimously.

Judge the man on his policies and achievements.

roseyposey · 24/09/2026 07:39

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 06:05

@sanluca humans discriminate on all sorts of things every single day, big and small - it's called decision making.

I'd suggest a candidate being unable to differentiate truth from fiction does make them unsuited to public office.

Your second paragraph nails it

BackToLurk · 24/09/2026 07:38

Two years ago, when elected, Olly was non-binary Mitch. If anyone wants to explain in what way Olly is now a woman, that would be dandy.

PeachyDaisy · 24/09/2026 07:24

I don't think being trans necessarily makes them unsuited, for me it depends entirely on their policies. For example, I'm more likely to vote for Kaitlyn Jenner over AOC as they can at least recognise that a woman is an adult human female.

BEAchDays2 · 24/09/2026 06:45

Hard agree with @sanluca

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 06:22

mysticbob · 24/09/2026 06:20

Agree.

True. But when one of your main policies is ‘finding a home for a radio station”…. I don’t think he was chosen on merit 😀

mysticbob · 24/09/2026 06:20

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

Agree.

Rollingpinofdoom · 24/09/2026 06:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ingenieur · 24/09/2026 06:05

@sanluca humans discriminate on all sorts of things every single day, big and small - it's called decision making.

I'd suggest a candidate being unable to differentiate truth from fiction does make them unsuited to public office.

sanluca · 24/09/2026 05:55

Is it the person being transgender that makes you think he is unsuited to office? Because that is discrimination. There are nice transgender people out there too, you know?

What are his policies? Is he going to actively work against women? If that is the case yes, he would be the wrong person for the job. Otherwise, give him a chance. It is not like being deputy mayor is a role reserved for women.

Manyanamanyana · 24/09/2026 05:05

A man in woman-face. Because he's stunning and brave, and will represent men and womens interests with equal passion and vigor no doubt. Australia is still heading south on this issue. I just wonder how low it can actually go.